10 Actors Who Should Replace Ben Affleck As Batman
Fan-casting the unthinkable...
Whisper it, but there may be a possibility that Ben Affleck won't be involved in The Batman at all.
He's already scaled back his involvement, dropping his writing credit and vacating the director's chair and now there are some rumblings that he may be compelled to leave the project entirely. Mercifully, right now he says he's committed to playing Bruce Wayne, but the rumour mill seems to suggest that something is amiss and the conspiracy theorists among Bat-fans have leapt on the idea that there's more the situation than meets the eye.
And then this...
Uh-oh. So what now?
There are some incredible choices that are now completely beyond the realms of reality: Jeffrey Dean Morgan has now already played a Wayne, so Bruce is unlikely; Alec Baldwin is too old; Michael Keaton too far gone... But imagine any of them playing an older, wizened Batman for a minute. It's enough to get you Bat-moist.
So who SHOULD Warner Bros turn to if the rumours of Ben Affleck's possible departure turn out to be concrete?
10. Ryan Gosling
He may currently be riding the crest of a wave as Hollywood's newest answer to Gene Kelly, but Ryan Gosling has proved in the past that he's adept at playing characters steeped in symbolism who trade more on their mythology than on dialogue. Sure, so it didn't work quite as well in Only God Forgives as it did in Drive, but in both cases, Gosling's ability to exude a sort of strong, silent cool and power should not be ignored.
He probably doesn't quite have the voice for Batman, but then Michael Keaton didn't either, and it would be a nice change of direction to go from Ben Affleck's hulking brute to a leaner, cleaner Bat who HAS to rely on his ability to instil fear in his enemies rather than just punching them through walls.
And that sort of reduced physicality could also translate into a more demure take on the character, focusing more on detective work than ripping back muscles. Which probably wouldn't be the worst thing.
9. Jon Hamm
As long as Jon Hamm remains an active actor and Batman stays on the big screen, there will be calls for him to play the Dark Knight. There's something about him that seems to suggest he's made for the role.
Perhaps it comes down to his performance as Don Draper, and how well that would translate into a new take on Bruce Wayne? He'd certainly have no trouble playing the public mask Wayne is supposed to maintain, which Affleck hasn't entirely been allowed to play with yet, unfortunately and which Christian Bale did so well with.
Plus, he has the presence and the physical stature to play a brooding Batman who wouldn't look out of place in the muscle-bound world of heroes Zack Snyder has built. And he has the acting chops to add some much needed depth to the performance
8. Joseph Gordon-Levitt
Look, it's unlikely that Warner Bros would actively try and bring Nolan's Batman universe and the DCEU together consciously, because of the difficulties with the timeline and the fact that we've already seen another version of the Joker, but if Fox's approach to the X-Men franchise has proven anything it's that fans will forgive continuity explosions if the results are entertaining enough. And even a hint at a continuation of Nolan's The Dark Knight Rises timeline with Joseph Gordon-Levitt playing Batman would be incredibly exciting.
Again, he would be an entirely different prospect to Affleck's take on the character - which would be a good thing if the film-makers are indeed looking for a "fresh approach" - thanks to how different he'd look as Batman.
Perhaps it's the purist in me, but the idea of Batman in the Michael Keaton mould who couldn't necessarily rely on superhuman strength but had to use ingenuity and guile in combat is far more interesting, and Gordon-Levitt would pull that off with aplomb. And he's already proven himself adept at adapting to some fairly wildly different roles in the past, so stepping into Wayne's shoes would presumably not be a task too far.
7. Josh Brolin
Though he's got the small matter of Marvel's Infinity War on his plate currently, Josh Brolin was at one point extremely close to playing Batman for Warner Bros. In the end, and without a great deal of malice, he was pipped at the post by Ben Affleck amidst rumours that he and Zack Snyder disagreed on how the character should be built.
But reading back through some of Brolin's comments, it's hard not to yearn for him to be considered again if Affleck leaves the role. He didn't want to play Batman "cool", he wanted to follow his usual trend of playing him a "little off", which immediately inspires thoughts of Michael Keaton's quirkier, creepier Batman.
And if you can't get excited about the idea of someone as intense and talented as Brolin playing a more odd-ball Batman, rather than just flexing his muscles and growling at bad guys, there's something very wrong with you.
6. Jake Gyllenhaal
There was a time when the idea of Jake Gyllenhaal tackling Batman would have been downright offensive, but he was in the running for Christopher Nolan's trilogy alongside Christian Bale and a raft of other young actors. It wouldn't have ben right at that stage of his career, but since then he's added a considerable number of impressive notches to his belt that have confirmed he has greater depth and range than he ever showed in his early career.
He's had a great run since he missed out on the role, making Brokeback Mountain, Jarhead, Zodiac, Brothers, Source Code, Prisoners, Enemy, Nightcrawler, Southpaw and Nocturnal Animals. And yet somehow he still doesn't seem to have hit the same sort of level as a Christian Bale.
That profile issue shouldn't worry him, as he makes incredibly astute career moves, for the most part, and he is increasingly proving that he can flex his acting muscles in unexpected ways, jumping genres and performance types with apparent ease. And he's blossomed with a sort of off-kilter quirkiness that would definitely suit the not-quite-of-our-world ideal image of Batman too.
5. Keanu Reeves
The idea of anyone suggesting Keanu Reeves seriously as a contender to play Batman a couple of years ago would probably have elicited outright ridicule. Sure, he made some interesting movies in 2013 (Man of Tai Chi and 47 Ronin), but they came after a period mostly defined by inactivity.
But then John Wick happened, and all of a sudden he's fashionable again, landing more interesting parts and the inevitable sequels to his hitman smash. And all of this despite not really having to reinvent himself at all: it's funny how the wheel of fortune spins.
Reeves would be able to pull off the other-worldly, removed sort of spirit you'd want from Bruce Wayne, simply by not really acting all that much. There's definitely something to his casual, dead-eyed demeanour (which seems to have now been reinvented as a sort of tangible coolness), and he's definitely got the kung-fu credentials and the hard-action chops to play Batman too. The more you think about it, the more the idea of John Wick playing Batman should appeal.
4. Colin Farrell
It's probably fair to say that Colin Farrell is an acquired taste. He's made almost as many poor films as he has genuinely good ones, and while he has something of a poor track record in bigger blockbuster movies, he would make a beguiling Dark Knight.
It is precisely Farrell's uneasy charm that would work so well as Bruce Wayne: this is a man who is designed not to be likeable generally, after all, but who requires a certain type of disarming charisma to unlock doors for him at the same time. That description could have been written for Farrell.
He would also offer a refreshing take on Batman, a more manic, more visibly unhinged take, channelling some of his more frantic past roles in a way that hasn't really been explored enough in the past. Batman is supposed to be a wildcard and a dark avenger, not the wholesome flag-bearer of the Justice League (that's what Superman exists for): the dynamic between him and the criminals he locks up is more interesting because of the dangerous similarities in them, and that's a Batman Farrell could absolutely pull off.
3. Armie Hammer
Having said all of that about Farrell, if Warner Bros genuinely do want to continue the image of Batman as a sort of gentleman Dark Knight who you can smell the private school upbringing on, they could do a lot worse than hiring Armie Hammer. Sure, it might involve sabotaging their plans for Green Lantern Corps, but he'd make a far more interesting Batman than he would a ring bearer.
Hammer has of course already been hired as Batman, for the unfortunately scrapped Justice League movie that fell at the final hurdle, so he's obviously done enough to impress Warner Bros in the past. And he would definitely look the part as both Bruce Wayne and Batman, even if he is a little clean cut for what the best image of Batman has traditionally been.
But then maybe it's time for a more aloof Batman? It'd certainly work for Bruce Wayne, and a different direction would be welcome with a fresh creative approach.
2. Matt Damon
Though they're in no way alike as actors (aside from their initial work together on Good Will Hunting), Matt Damon and Ben Affleck go together like cheese and crackers. And it probably wouldn't be unfair to say that, of the two, Damon is the more appreciated acting talent, so having him step into Affleck's shoes would feel almost symbolic.
Of all of the suggestions on this list, Damon is arguably the highest level A-lister and the most dependable box office draw. He's also just proved with the latest Bourne movie that he can do strong, silent action heroes who use their mythology to announce themselves.
And on the flipside, he is an incredibly charismatic lead, who could easily take on the requirements of playing Bruce Wayne (and without having to make him feel particularly unlikeable). The only issue is perhaps that he's too conventionally "nice guy", but he has played with darker roles in the past (in the likes of The Departed), so it's not outside of his wheelhouse.
1. Michael Fassbender
Who wouldn't want to see an actor as gifted and as broad-ranged as Michael Fassbender turning his hand to one of the most complex characters ever committed to film?
Fassbender ticks almost every box for the ideal image of what both Batman and Bruce Wayne should be. He's intriguing, he has a tangible exoticness that comes at least partly from his strange, removed global accent, and he definitely has it in him to be the right kind of weird and ostentatious.
He would easily inhabit the same sort of creative space Michael Keaton did as Bruce Wayne, adding intensity and his trademark bubbling emotional vulnerability, and he'd be an interesting, lithe Dark Knight who would absolutely need to trade of the power of fear. And of course, he's a very talented actor - chameleon-like even - and Warner Bros need a big, big name to replace Ben Affleck if the worst happens.
Who would you like to see step in as Batman if Ben Affleck leaves? Share your picks below in the comments thread.