10 Actors Who Turned Down Star Wars
We're taking a look at those actors who foolishly turned down roles in the Star Wars franchise.
In spite of what you may think of the prequels and more recent additions to the saga, there's no denying that franchises just don't come any bigger than Star Wars. When even periphery characters from the film series manage to develop their own fan bases, it's fair to say that acting gigs just don't come any bigger than a Star Wars film.
It therefore comes as a mighty shock when an actor decides, for some crazy reason, to reject an offer to star in the iconic Space Opera. As nonsensical and crazy as such an idea may sound to us legions of fans, for various reasons this has (too) often been the case.
For the purposes of this list, any decision to turn down a role in a Star Wars movie is considered a poor one, and also sacrilegious. Lesser profile actors who have not taken a role that was offered to them were particularly looked down upon in the construction of this list, while rejecting roles in the phenomenal original Star Wars trilogy was also frowned upon.
While we can only pity those poor souls who are forced to live with their dreadful decision, the the first entry on this list deserves no pity at all..
10. Leonardo DiCaprio - Anakin Skywalker
What on Earth was Leo thinking? Sure, turning down roles like Anakin Skywalker allowed for him to not be pigeon holed or typecast into specific roles. And yes, not appearing in the mediocre prequels may have helped him land roles in critically acclaimed films like The Departed, which lead to him being the most sort after actor on the planet. But this is Star Wars we're talking about!
If we're being perfectly honest, the anguish we feel towards Leo has nothing to do with his own regrets, but how much harm his decision did to the franchise. With all respect to Hayden Christensen, his interpretation of the man destined to be Darth Vader was dreadful, leaving us hating the character for all the wrong reasons. There's no doubt Leo would have smashed this role, which makes his decision all the more agonising.
With DiCaprio in the role, the 'I don't like sand' speech would have rivalled the great speeches of film history. Anakin's transition from nice guy to child murderer in the space of five minutes wouldn't have felt jarring at all with Leo in the role. In fact, the legendary actor's mere presence would have elevated all the dodgy CGI of the films to extraordinary heights.
Instead, Leo must live with the fact that his absence single handedly damned the Prequels, and ultimately instigated the beginning of the end for the Star Wars saga. Damn you Leo, damn you to hell!
9. Benicio Del Toro - Darth Maul
Poor old Benicio, the man who foolishly turned down the role of the one cool character from The Phantom Menace. While Del Toro's decision to not play the iconic yet much under utilised Darth Maul in the first prequel was a strange one, the punishment he received for this mistake was mighty harsh- forced to act in The Last Jedi.
Del Toro had been signed up by George Lucas for the role of the super cool looking Sith apprentice Darth Maul, but eventually dropped out after Lucas handed him a redacted script. With just five minutes screen time and only several lines, Del Toro eventually decided to give up the role.
Trying to recapture his last chance at Star Wars fame, Del Toro sadly took the role of arguably the most pointless character in the franchise's history- lock picker DJ. While Del Toro did all he could with the character, DJ just had no relevance to the entire story arc and proved to be a rather forgettable presence. The fact that the character was involved in a subplot that proved pointless to the overall narrative and loathed by many also didn't help Del Toro's legacy on the Star Wars saga.
8. Al Pacino - Han Solo
The first of a trilogy of 'I could have been Han Solo' entries, Al Pacino had perhaps the best excuse for not taking the iconic role. Coming fresh off the mega success of the first two Godfather films and Dog Day Afternoon, Pacino was simply offered too many roles to take them all on.
Actors didn't come any bigger at the time than Pacino, and it's easy to see why Lucas would have wanted such a talent in his film. Pacino however wasn't convinced of this fact, believing Lucas only wanted him in the film for one reason. "I was in The Godfather. They didn’t care if I was right or wrong for the role, if I could act or not act." The half glass empty thoughts of Pacino are only half true, as while Lucas no doubt wanted to cash in on the star's fame, there's no doubt the actor would have been perfect as Han.
Another reason that Pacino stated for turning down the role was his initial confusion as to what the whole story was about. "I remember not understanding (the script) when I read it." This seems a particularly puzzling remark, considering the complexity of the films Pacino had starred in prior to A New Hope.
All hopes of Pacino appearing in a Star Wars film however are not lost, with the actor stating that "Anything's possible" while telling of his love for another Sci-Fi franchise, the Guardians of the Galaxy. Fingers crossed!
7. Sylvester Stallone - Han Solo
The second of the 'I turned down Han Solo trilogy' entries on this list goes to none other than Rocky Balboa himself, Sylvester Stallone. While Sly wasn't exactly offered the part, he makes this list for not even giving himself a chance. Coming off the monster hit Rocky, which Sly wrote and starred in, Stallone managed to get an audition for the role of Han Solo, but withdrew from the race before he even got to show his talents.
As stated in an interview with Jimmy Fallon, Stallone explained how he turned up to the audition, but immediately got the feeling that Director George Lucas was not interested in him. Picking up the vibe of the room, Stallone immediately withdrew, telling Lucas "I would look like crap in spandex leotards and a ray gun. Guys in space don't have this face, I get it."
While the more violent scenes would no doubt have been up Sly's alley, it's hard to imagine him matching Harrison Ford's iconic humour. The love angle between Han and Leia also would also have played out a lot differently, with Stallone unlikely to have nailed the banter with Carrie Fisher in quite the same way as Ford.
Considering Sly's want to revisit older projects, one suspects that Stallone would have revelled starring in recent Star Wars films.. We probably would have seen more of Han, with Sly unlikely to request his character be killed off after one film as per Ford's request.
6. Burt Reynolds - Han Solo
The final of the 'Han Solo' rejected offers trilogy, Burt Reynolds has been one actor who has been very forthcoming in his regret at not taking a Star Wars role. Reynolds was very much an established star upon the release of Star Wars, with the likes of Deliverance and The Longest Yard elevating him to the top tier of Hollywood actors. Lucas offered Reynolds the role of Han, but the actor knocked it back, initially sighting that he was 'too busy'.
While Harrison Ford was obviously superb in the iconic role, there's no doubting that Reynolds would have also been perfect for the role. One gets the feeling that George Lucas wrote the Han Solo character with Reynolds in mind, considering the playboy renegade nature of both character and actor.
Reynolds later acknowledged that he regretted the decision to not appear in Star Wars, while also acknowledging another iconic role he wish he'd taken- James Bond! Reynolds was offered the role when he was still a relative unknown, but turned down the offer because he didn't think that an American could play a British character, something he admitted made little sense in hindsight.
While Reynolds had to live with the regret of not signing up for Star Wars, he shouldn't have felt too bad considering the legacy he left behind. For there was one film that was released in 1977 that did star Mister Reynolds, that just happened to be a classic all on its own- Smokey and the Bandit.
5. Jim Henson - Yoda
The legendary puppeteer Jim Henson will always live on in people's memories as the man who created the beloved Muppets. There was however one role that he should also have been synonymous with. With the staggering success of the first Star Wars movie, George Lucas plans for The Empire Strikes Back soon begun in earnest. One of the Director's first duties was to casting the role of a Master Jedi character by the name of Yoda.
Lucas immediately turned to Henson, hoping that Henson would design and voice the character. As explained by Lucas, Henson let him know that he was too busy at the time working on his own project, but offered Frank Oz's services instead. From this the legendary character and voice of Yoda was born, with Oz quickly becoming part of Star Wars folklore.
Of course the Jim Henson legacy could never be tarnished whatever his decision, with numerous Muppets movies and TV reboots, along with the continued success of Sesame Street letting his legacy live on. Still, it would have been nice to add Star Wars to his CV.
4. Jodie Foster - Princess Leia
It's hard to imagine anyone else in the role of Princess Leia other than the amazing Carrie Fisher, but the fact is that she was not Lucas' first choice. That mantle actually went to another up and coming young actress by the name of Jodie Foster.
Foster had become a major presence as a child actor in the 70's, appearing in five movie roles and multiple TV appearances. At the age of 14, Foster was offered two significant roles, both of which would see her take on far more meaty roles than she had before. The first role on offer was in Martin Scorsese's Taxi Driver, where she would play a young prostitute alongside Robert DeNiro. Then George Lucas came along with what would have been the ultimate starring role, none other than Princess Leia. As we well know, Foster declined Lucas' offer, taking the role in Scorsese's film instead.
It's fair to assume that giving the role of Leia to a 14 year old would have lead to a number of changes to the script and casting, which overall we should be thankful didn't eventuate. The romantic tension between Leia and Han would most likely have been removed, or at least felt a little awkward.
As for Foster herself, well she claims to not regret her decision. “I don’t think I’m going to be on my deathbed going, like, ‘Damn! I didn’t do Star Wars." Actually, we kind of think you might!
3. Hugh Quarshie - Captain Panaka
A mighty odd decision here, especially considering that Hugh Quarshie wasn't exactly a household name. With this in mind, one would have thought Quarshie would have jumped at the opportunity to star in another film, let alone reprise his role in a Star Wars film. Quarshie did a good job of Captain Panaka in The Phantom Menace while receiving decent screen time in his one appearance in the role. It proved to be the potential lack of screen time in sequel Attack of the Clones that lead Quarshie to abandon his role.
As explained by the actor, Quarshie was given the offer to reprise his role, but was never given a script or an indication of how big his role would be. Refusing to go into a film shoot completely blind, Quarshie pulled the plug, with the character subsequently being removed from the movie.
Quarshie appeared in just two movies after this time, moving to the small screen with his lead role of Hugh Griffin in medical drama Dolby City and crossover show Casualty, both which still run today. While it is great that Quarshie found continued success on the small screen, it is still a real head scratcher that he would choose to leave the biggest opportunity offered to him in his career.
2. Denis Lawson - Wedge Antilles
Another case of a low profile actor not returning for a Star Wars role, with the reasoning for this decision particularly baffling. Denis Lawson's character Wedge Antilles become somewhat of a 'cult hero' after his support role in A New Hope, eventually becoming more of a periphery figure in the original trilogy. JJ Abrams invited Lawson to return for the role in a cameo for The Force Awakens, but surprisingly the offer was turned down.
Incredibly Lawson gave one specific reason for not returning- he didn't think it would be any fun! Lawson was still acting at the time, so the decision was more than a little puzzling, especially in regards to the production not being any fun. There hasn't been any clarification if there was any other reason for his decision, but it was one he finally rescinded.
Lawson took up JJ Abram's offer to reprise the character for The Rise of Skywalker. It was only a brief cameo, amongst a number of faces arriving for the final attack on the Empire. Even though it was a blink and you'll miss it moment, it was still a nice gesture from JJ to allow Lawson to honour his character one last time.
1. Toshiro Mifune - Obi-Wan Kenobi + Darth Vader
Of all the actors to turn down the overtures of George Lucas, legendary Japanese actor Toshiro Mifune was the one the Star Wars Director desperately wanted on board. Having largely based the Jedi off the Samurai, Lucas offered the role of Obi Wan Kenobi to Mifune, a star of such classic movies like Seven Samurai. However, as described by his daughter Mika, his father had concerns. "He was concerned about how the film would look and that it would cheapen the image of samurai, on which George Lucas had based a lot of the character and fighting style.”
Not to be deterred with Mifune knocking back this role, Lucas then offered him another significant part- none other than Darth Vader. But as Mika explained, his father still had serious misgivings. “At the time, Sci-Fi movies still looked quite cheap as the effects were not advanced and he had a lot of samurai pride. So then, there was talk about him taking the Darth Vader role as his face would be covered, but in the end he turned that down too.”
It is fascinating to ponder how different the franchise would have been had Mifune agreed to take either of the roles. Darth Vader's lightsaber fight scenes would no doubt have been greatly enhanced, and in hindsight would have been the best use of Mifune's talents. As for Obi-Wan, the character would have taken on a whole new look- seeing him take down the thugs in the cantina would have been really something!