10 Actors Whose Career Has BOMBED After Their Biggest Hit

Cursed isn't even the word.

Rosamund Pike Gone Girl Radioactive
New Regency / StudioCanal

Hollywood is an incredibly unpredictable beast at the best of times, and no matter how talented an actor might be, that's no guarantee of success.

Though it's expected that an actor's profile will snowball after appearing in a massive hit movie, in turn allowing them to get cast in a slew of tentpole and prestige films, that's sadly not always the case.

Ironically, these 10 actors all suffered through major setbacks after appearing in the biggest, most successful, and most iconic films of their careers up to that point.

While some of them were lucky enough to rebound eventually - whether in the world of film or TV - most are still feeling the effects of a career that failed to take flight in the wake of a major hit.

From actors who clearly took bad advice from their agents, to those who earned reputations for being difficult to work with, and those who were simply unlucky, these 10 performers all struggled to gain upward momentum after appearing in their biggest movie to date...

10. Val Kilmer - Batman Forever

Batman Forever Val Kilmer
Warner Bros. Pictures

From the mid-1980s through to the mid-1990s, Val Kilmer was one of Hollywood's hottest young properties.

With successful roles in the likes of Top Secret!, Real Genius, Top Gun, Willow, The Doors, Thunderheart, and Tombstone, it seemed like Kilmer was set to be a popular Hollywood mainstay forever more.

Kilmer being cast as the Dark Knight in 1995's Batman Forever seemingly cemented his standing in the industry, and the film's solid commercial performance suggested he'd return for at least a few sequels.

But in actual fact, Kilmer opted not to reprise the role for Batman & Robin, and after appearing in Michael Mann's heat later in 1995, found himself suffering through a brutal run of critical and commercial duds.

In honesty his career never recovered from turning down Batman, with his last 25 years in the business being largely defined by the tawdry likes of The Island of Dr. Moreau, The Saint, Red Planet, Alexander, and in more recent years The Snowman and a slew of straight-to-VOD action duds.

Though Kilmer has certainly appeared in a few great movies since Batman & Robin - namely Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang and Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans - he's never regained that leading man box office appeal, which combined with his reputation for being difficult to work with hasn't served him well.

Kilmer will appear in cameo form, however, in the upcoming Top Gun: Maverick, yet due to a recent bout with throat cancer reducing his voice to a rasp, it's sadly unlikely he'll ever regain his A-lister status.


9. Kate Hudson - Almost Famous

Almost Famous
Dreamworks/Columbia Pictures

Kate Hudson exploded onto the A-list in 2000 with her unforgettable performance as Penny Lane in Almost Famous, for which she received a Best Supporting Actress Oscar nomination.

Though Hudson had all the talent and potential to take the Jennifer Lawrence post-Oscar path - that is, racking up a slew of awards-nominated performances while appearing in occasional blockbusters - she hasn't had a single critically acclaimed leading role in a film in the 20 years since.

Beyond supporting parts in the likes of Kung Fu Panda 3, Deepwater Horizon, and Marshall, Kudson's post-Almost Famous filmography is littered with low-effort romance and comedy duds like How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days, You, Me and Dupree, Fool's Gold, My Best Friend's Girl, Bride Wars, Something Borrowed, A Little Bit Of Heaven, and Mother's Day.

Not every actor is always actively gunning for awards-caliber roles, but Hudson's obvious preference for more lightweight fare ensures she's had to settle for periodic commercial success instead of critical plaudits.

She can still get cast in movies, but her stock as a leading lady has taken an undeniable hit in recent years. Like so many talented artists, she clearly peaked early.


8. Orlando Bloom - The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King

The Lord Of The Rings Return Of The King Legolas Orlando Bloom
Warner Bros.

In the early 2000s, you couldn't not know who Orlando Bloom was: the handsome rising star was part of both the Lord of the Rings and Pirates of the Caribbean franchises, and also played a memorable part in Ridley Scott's Black Hawk Down.

But his career hit the sudden skids after the release of the final Lord of the Rings movie, The Return of the King, which not only grossed $1.14 billion worldwide but also won 11 Oscars, including Best Picture.

With his boyish good looks and solid acting chops, Bloom seemed destined for a prosperous career, and yet he spent the entire next decade appearing in critical flop after critical flop.

From Troy to Kingdom of Heaven, Elizabethtown, the first two Pirates sequels, and The Three Musketeers, Bloom just couldn't seem to find a comfortable niche for himself which satisfied both critics and general audiences.

Though Bloom did return to the blockbuster realm for two of the broadly acclaimed Hobbit sequels, he was really just a small cog in the franchise machine by that point, and his career has never returned to those prior heights.

He did, however, give a solid performance in the recent VOD war movie The Outpost, suggesting he's probably better-suited for a middle-aged career as a stoic character actor in smaller-scale movies rather than a swashbuckling lead.


7. Mickey Rourke - Iron Man 2

Iron Man 2
Marvel Studios

Mickey Rourke has had one of the most fascinatingly topsy-turvy careers of any actor in Hollywood history.

Rourke received consistent acclaim for his evocative performances throughout the '80s in movies such as Diner, Rumble Fish, The Pope of Greenwich Village, 9½ Weeks, Barfly, and Angel Heart.

For several years in the early '90s, however, Rourke stepped back from acting to pursue a career as a boxer, which combined with his reputation for being a difficult actor to work with severely harmed his standing in Hollywood.

Rourke's handsome looks were also impacted by his in-ring injuries, and so it wasn't until he appeared in 2005's Sin City that Hollywood truly began to take notice of him again.

Rourke followed this up with his incredible, Oscar-nominated performance in The Wrestler, which led to him winning the role of villain Whiplash in Iron Man 2.

Though Iron Man 2 was by far the highest-grossing film of Rourke's career and should've ensured he became a tentpole mainstay, in the decade since he's appeared in just a single critically acclaimed film - the 2018 horror anthology Nightmare Cinema.

Sadly he largely appears in low-effort straight-to-VOD fare these days, squandering an immense amount of talent in the process.


6. Rosamund Pike - Gone Girl

Gone Girl Rosamund Pike Amy
20th Century Fox

Though Rosamund Pike was certainly already a well-known and respected actress prior to 2014, it was her starring role in David Fincher's Gone Girl which catapulted her to the A-list, netting her a Best Actress Oscar nomination in the process.

And though Pike has appeared in a number of broadly well-received movies since, not a single project she's been involved with post-Gone Girl has been a box office success.

Despite her solid work in the likes of A United Kingdom, Hostiles, Beirut, A Private War, and Radioactive, all 10 movies she's starred in since her Oscar nomination have tanked commercially.

At least she's just a fortuitous casting decision away from reigniting her movie career, and she's imminently set to star in Amazon's The Wheel of Time TV series.

But if she wants to bolster her cinematic standing, she could use a big hit in the near-future.


5. Cuba Gooding, Jr. - Jerry Maguire

Jerry Maguire Cuba Gooding Jr
TriStar Pictures

Cuba Gooding, Jr.'s career is perhaps the ultimate cautionary tale of how an actor with all the talent in the world can struggle post-Oscar.

Gooding scooped the Best Supporting Actor Oscar in 1997 for his iconic performance in Jerry Maguire, yet following an appearance in As Good as It Gets later that year, his career totally fell off a cliff.

It would be another 18 movies and 11 years before Gooding appeared in a film which succeeded both critically and commercially - Ridley Scott's American Gangster.

In the meantime, his filmography became littered with duds like A Murder of Crows, Instinct, Chill Factor, Boat Trip, Home on the Range, and Shadowboxer, while his financially successful films were also largely panned by critics, including Pearl Harbour, Rat Race, Snow Dogs, Norbit, and Daddy Day Camp.

In the ultimate demonstration of how thoroughly his career flew off the rails, in 2003 he received a Worst Actor Razzie nomination for his combined work in three movies - Boat Trip, The Fighting Temptations, and Radio. Oof.

Though his career upticked briefly in 2016 when he received a Best Actor Emmy nomination for his performance as O.J. Simpson in American Crime Story, his late-career period is largely defined by forgettable dramatic thrillers which typically forego cinemas entirely.


4. Eva Green - Casino Royale

Eva Green Casino Royale
MGM

In another universe, Eva Green's career would've skyrocketed following her coming-out party in 2006, when she played all-timer Bond girl Vesper Lynd in Casino Royale.

An exceptional actress with striking beauty to match, Green is a total package actress with all the skills necessary to become a towering A-lister, and yet, her post-Bond career has seen her perennially cast as the best thing in a bunch of bad movies.

From 2006 to 2015, Green didn't appear in a single well-reviewed film, though she did nevertheless receive praise for her better-than-the-material-deserves performances in Dark Shadows, 300: Rise of an Empire, and Sin City: A Dame to Kill For.

Though Green has found more success recently in the world of TV - scoring a Best Actress Golden Globe nod for her gonzo work on Penny Dreadful - the standing of her filmography doesn't at all reflect her talent.

While several of her blockbuster projects have been moderately successful at the box office - namely Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children and Dumbo - the one-two punch of critical and audience approval has been curiously lacking since Casino Royale.


3. Billy Zane - Titanic

Titanic Billy Zane Kate Winslet
20th Century Fox

Like basically every single actor involved with James Cameron's Titanic, the Best Picture-winning blockbuster is the most successful film of Billy Zane's career.

Zane, who just three years prior had starred in the atrocious spoof The Silence of the Hams, wasn't exactly going places before Titanic, and the film absolutely should've elevated his stature in Hollywood, especially given that he was quite terrific as the villainous Caledon Hockley.

Despite having his strong work presented on such a massive stage, though, Zane's post-Titanic career has largely been a non-event of commercial bombs and films critics didn't even bother to see.

Less than a decade later he was stuck starring in Uwe Boll movies (BloodRayne) and erotic thrillers (Three), and it wasn't until 2011 that one of his films was again commercially successful - The Roommate, which rocks a cool 4% on the Tomatometer.

These days most of Zane's appearances in major media are ironic as-himself cameos, and there's sadly little indication things are going to uptick anytime soon.

Compare all this to his co-stars Kate Winslet and Leonardo DiCaprio, who between them have received 10 Oscar nominations since Titanic with one win each.


2. Brandon Routh - Superman Returns

Superman Returns Flying Brandon Routh
Warner Bros.

It's a depressing thought that playing Superman can be both the best and worst thing to happen to a rising actor, but that's definitely true in the case of Brandon Routh.

A largely unknown Routh was plucked out of obscurity to play the Man of Steel in Bryan Singer's 2006 reboot-sequel Superman Returns, and despite Routh's strong performance, the film received a lukewarm response from both critics and general audiences.

Despite the immense visibility the role lent to him, Routh's Hollywood trajectory never quite took off in the way most would've expected.

The planned Superman Returns sequel was eventually scrapped, and beyond small supporting roles in Zack and Miri Make a Porno and Scott Pilgrim vs. the World, he has no major or acclaimed films to his name.

Routh has at least enjoyed a recurring role in the Arrowverse as Ray Palmer aka The Atom, and recently reprised the Superman role for the universe's Crisis on Infinite Earths event, yet despite his good looks and sharp comedic timing, he's failed to graduate far beyond the Man of Steel.


1. Lindsay Lohan - Mean Girls

Mean Girls Lindsay Lohan
Paramount Pictures

Though Lindsay Lohan's highest-grossing movie to date is 2003's Freaky Friday, the film which catapulted her into the pop-culture stratosphere was undeniably Mean Girls the very next year.

Its critical and commercial success made Lohan the "It girl" of 2004, and seemed to suggest a bright future for the rising young actress.

And yet, what followed was a number of underwhelming star vehicles like Herbie: Fully Loaded and Just My Luck.

Then there were the critically dismissed forays into more serious acting with Bobby, Chapter 27, and I Know Who Killed Me, the latter of which scored Lohan two Razzie awards for Worst Actress and Worst Screen Couple.

Between 2007 and 2014, Lohan received a total of six Razzie nominations, and despite the modest commercial success of films like Machete and Scary Movie V, the quality leading roles had dried up long before those movies were released.

Lohan made a bold attempt to rejuvenate her career with 2013's erotic thriller The Canyons, yet it ultimately released to little interest from, well, anyone.

And despite Lohan starring in a supernatural horror film last year, Among the Shadows, it has just a single review on the Tomatometer almost 18 months after its release. Oof.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.