10 Alternative Comics That Would Make Killer Movies

Alternative comics have a freedom that the more mainstream comics don't, and with Hollywood being awash with goody two-shoes superheroes, we could all be in need of a change.

Hollywood knows a good thing when it sees it. Taking the most well-known comic book characters from history and bringing them to life on the big screen has generated billions of dollars in revenue, created a new genre of film and delivered pure cinematic joy to millions of cinema-goers. There are however, a number of alternative graphic novels and comics that don't feature well known characters and crucially that can offer an audience something they've never seen before onscreen. Alternative comics have a freedom that the more mainstream comics don't. The good guy doesn't always win, or even behave honourably. Characters are multifaceted individuals, the themes and stories are complex, the imagery occasionally perverse and the language blue enough to make a sailor blush. In alternative comics Batman would use a certain character's Bowel Disruptor to make enemies poop themselves to death. And in alternative comics Black Widow only got in the Avengers by performing oral sex on Captain America. Two of the most loved alternative comics; Garth Ennis' seminal Preacher and Neil Gaiman's iconic Sandman, are both currently in active development with Seth Rogen and Joseph Gordon Levitt helping them make the leap from page to screen. With Hollywood finally catching on to what else is on offer, join us for a look at ten of the best alternative comics that have flown under the radar of mainstream success that we think will make killer movies.

10. Transmetropolitan

Plot: Warren Ellis' cyber-punk comic charts the trials and tribulations of Spider Jerusalem, an infamous gonzo journalist. Spider dedicates his life to fighting corruption and abuses of power from the many decadent and evil inhabitants of The City; a twisted metropolis of rampant consumerism, sex, drugs and violence as he strives to stop the world becoming even more dystopian than it already is. The Pitch: Fear & Loathing in the 23rd Century. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: In a word; Spider. The protagonist in Transmetropolitan is unlike any other comic book character seen in film before. Paying homage to Hunter S. Thompson, Spider Jerusalem is a sarcastic, drug-addicted, foul-mouthed, troubled and bitter man who also happens to be a brilliant journalist with a deep hatred of authority, political corruption and, err, dogs. Never without his trusty bowel disruptor (it does what it says on the tin) and his 'filthy assistants', Spider takes the fight to The Man, helping him rank as the 12th Greatest Comic Book Character of All Time by Empire Magazine. Transmetropolitan is set in a fully realised world of the future that is scarily familiar but incredibly funny at the same time. This dystopian vision of the future is one reason why no film has yet to be made (Ellis has stated production costs would be too great) but with creator Ellis indicating he would like Tim Roth to play the character of Spider Jerusalem, film goers and comic book aficionados can but dream we'll get to see this on the big screen one day.

9. Powers

Plot: Combining the superhero and police procedural genres, Brian Michael Bendis's comic follows two human homicide detectives who are assigned to investigate crimes involving people with superhuman abilities, known as 'powers', in this suspense-filled read. The Pitch: CSI: Metropolis. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: Juxtaposing the superhero genre and the police procedural genre gives Powers a fresh perspective; seeing the action through the eyes of the cops. The two cops in question; Detectives Walker and Pilgrim, are a veteran and rookie respectively and both have compelling story arcs of their own as they investigate murders involving both superheroes and villains. Powers flips the standard clichés you usually find with this material and has a surprisingly high body count. FX picked up Powers and filmed a pilot episode back in 2011 but after reshoots and re-casting it fizzled out. Brian Michael Bendis stated last year that he was hopeful the show is still alive meaning we could still see this Eisner Award winning comic series on the big (or small) screen sometime soon.

8. Black Hole

Plot: Charles Burns' 1970s set comic follows a group of teenagers who, over the course of one summer, contract a mysterious sexually transmitted disease. Before they can pat themselves on the back for scoring some summer lovin', the STD causes grotesque physical mutations. As they are ostracised from society and all have to come to terms with themselves, each other and a series of murders going on. The Pitch: Irradiated Stand By Me. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: One of the most original comics ever written, this award winning story has mutations and murder, and is a metaphor for sexual awakening and adolescence, but the loudest message is clear; always wear a condom. This coming-of-age tale is also perfect viewing for those who suffer from body inadequacy issues after watching the usual comic book movies. Many talented people have flirted with adapting Black Hole in the past including French director Alexandre Aja, Neil Gaiman and Pulp Fiction co-writer Roger Avary. However the closest it got to being made was when David Fincher took an interest in it in 2008 but pulled out two years later to focus on The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo. With such an original story and interest from such talented individuals Black Hole could be one of the most interesting comic book adaptations ever.

7. Fables

Plot: The premise of Fables, created by writer Bill Willingham, is a simple one; fairytale characters are exiled from their homeland and living in New York. So far, so 'meh', but what makes Fables stand out are the alternative versions to the creatures you remember from childhood. The series inverts the images of well-known characters from folklore, and the story arcs all take the form of a different genre with caper stories, conspiracy thrillers and murder-mysteries all featuring. The Pitch: Del Toro does Grimm. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: Fables offers viewers a chance to see their favourite childhood characters like never before; Prince Charming is a lying cheat, Snow White is sleeping with the Big Bad Wolf and Goldilocks is a homicidal maniac (to name but a few). The series is surprisingly unflinching in its portrayal of well-known characters and the results are every bit as compelling as any of its fantasy competitors. Hopefully we won't have to wait long before we can get a glimpse of Willingham's creation as its been reported that Warner Bros. have commissioned a live-action film with Danish filmmaker Nikolaj Arcel hired to direct. Arcel directed the Oscar nominated period drama A Royal Affair and wrote the screenplay for The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo, so it appears to have the right credentials to make Fables a hit.

6. Scalped

Plot: After 15 years away Dashiell Bad Horse returns to his reservation and promptly starts working as a ruthless enforcer for the tribal police force. However, Dash Bad Horse is really a FBI agent under orders to investigate the murder of two FBI agents decades earlier in Jason Aaron's action packed comic. The Pitch: Donnie Brasco down on the 'Rez. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: This thrilling series is a perfect example of a comic without superpowers but with plenty of action and depth. The fights are brutal as protagonist Horse smashes meth labs (and their occupants) into pieces trying to undercover the truth behind two old murders. Scalped has great characters and some well-handled social commentary about the Reservoir, and it delivers a tightly-plotted tale that draws inspiration from detective fiction of the past but with the action ramped up to 11. The biggest draw has to be Dashiell Bad Horse though. IGN ranked Dash as the 62nd Greatest Comic Book Hero of All Time, stating he shows us how dark you can go with an anti-hero but still make an audience root for him. Translated; it means he's one bad mother-trucker.

5. The Boys

Plot: In Garth Ennis's extremely violent, highly sexed and utterly hilarious world, superheroes exist but are easily corrupted by their celebrity status and giant egos. The CIA forms its own super-squad, known as The Boys, who are charged with monitoring the superhero community. When the superheroes step out of line the Boys dish out the punishment...with extreme prejudice. The Pitch: Preacher in spandex. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: To those aficionados who have read Preacher, all you need to know about why The Boys would make a great film is the following quote from creator Garth Ennis. Referring to The Boys he said '"It will out-Preacher Preacher". To everyone else The Boys consist of a group of supers that make The Avengers look like girl-scouts. In a morally bankrupt world where famous superheroes are far from wholesome (initiation into The Seven involves forcing the female to perform oral sex on the male members) comes Ennis' heroes in this pitch black, ultra-violent story. Featuring a cast of unforgettable characters, this would be a truly original and adult take on the comic book superhero genre, which would be a welcome breath of fresh air in today's kiddie-friendly market. Recent reports show we might not have to wait too long to see a film version with Paramount Pictures hiring Adam McKay (The Other Guys, Anchorman 2) in April 2013 to write a screenplay.

4. 100 Bullets

Plot: In Brian Azzarello's dark and stylish story the mysterious Agent Graves propositions people who have been victims of a terrible wrong and gives them the opportunity to take revenge. He gives them a gun, 100 bullets, proof the target identified is responsible for their all of their woes, and the promise that law enforcement will turn a blind eye. The Pitch: Indecent Proposal? That's putting it mildly. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: On the surface a film version would pose a thoroughly devilish question to draw audiences in; 'would you kill someone responsible for everything bad in your life if you knew you would get away with it?' As the film would progress, a deeply complex backstory can be revealed involving secret organisations and centuries-old conspiracies in this sprawling crime saga. This compelling morality tale has come close to being made in the past with David S. Goyer (writer of The Dark Knight) in 2011, but following some mass shootings the producers pulled the plug. Given how time heals all, in a few years we could hopefully all be ready for this stylish, violent and clever story.

3. Planetary

Plot: Warren Ellis' story revolves around super team Planetary; an organisation who investigate the secret history of the world which brings them into contact with alternative versions of figures from popular culture. The self-styled 'Archaeologists of the Impossible' consist of three supers with different powers as they investigate everything from Godzilla to Sherlock Holmes. The Pitch: X-Men vs. The Fantastic Four. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: This story takes everything familiar about the superhero genre and makes it seem fresh and new. As Planetary travel the world investigating strange phenomena for the betterment of mankind, they are opposed by the Four, evil versions of the Fantastic Four, who are intent on using the secrets of the world for personal gain. There are epic storylines, lots of bone-crunching action and even musings of the meaning of life as mathematical equations. Yeah, it gets pretty deep. Planetary would make a visually stunning film as the team get to investigate outer and inner-space, other dimensions, secret islands and the past, but the biggest attraction is actually seeing what would happen when fan favourite characters from both Marvel and DC interact. Superman, Green Lantern and Wonder Woman all come to the attention of the Four (unfortunately for them), and we get to see a tragic but strangely logical death for the Incredible Hulk in this post-modern and enthralling story.

2. Y: The Last Man

Plot: On July 17th 2002, something kills every living male on the planet, plunging the world into chaos. The only exceptions are young escape artist Yorick Brown and his pet monkey Ampersand. They set out across America to reunite with his girlfriend (Yorick's, not the monkeys) and are drawn into a story that is both huge in scope yet very personal. There are creepy scientists, government killers, an Israeli strike team and even a ninja, but it all comes down to one boy and his monkey in Brian K. Vaughn and Pia Guerra's sci-fi odyssey. The Pitch: Children Of Men hit The Road. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: A post-apocalyptic story involving lots of spectacle and action? Check. Larger than life characters? Check. Lots of extreme and unforgettable imagery? Check. If that's not enough to convince you this would make a great film there is also a truly heart-breaking ending to this globe-spanning adventure that takes a lifetime, making it one of the best graphic novels ever written. Y: The Last Man has come close to being made numerous times since it was first published in 2002 with Disturbia pair DJ Caruso and Shia LaBeouf, French director Louis Leterier, David Goyer and most recently Portal director Dan Trachtenberg all coming and going. However in January 2014 Brian K. Vaughn said that the film rights will revert back to him and co-creator Pia Guerra, so if shooting doesn't begin soon which means we may have to wait a little longer before getting a chance to see this Eisner award-winning story on the big screen.

1. Rising Stars

Plot: Spanning 60 years, J. Michael Straczynski's epic saga begins with a meteor strike over a small US town where all the children in utero at the time are born with special powers. Rising Stars charts the lives of the 113 'Specials' as they grow to adulthood and deal with their powers, themselves, each other and the world itself. There are triumphs, tragedies, conspiracies and epic action in this excellent and tightly-plotted comic. The Pitch: Superhero by Spielberg. Why It Would Make A Killer Movie: Rising Stars is the superhero story to end all superhero stories. It has great characters, big action, a gripping storyline, enigmatic protagonists and incredible visuals. This has absolutely everything you could want from a comic book adaptation but with the one thing you'll never get with Marvel or DC cash cows; a complete and flawless ending. Creator J. Michael Straczynski, who wrote the Clint Eastwood directed film The Changeling, penned a script back in 2001 based on Rising Stars first act (Born In Fire) intending it to be a trilogy, but after legal disputes with publisher Top Cow nothing ever came of it. It may just be wishful thinking but with Superhero films now de rigueur in Hollywood, and with a number of great directors ranging from Steven Spielberg to Ridley Scott having never made a Superhero film, this great story could still make the transition to the big screen in the future, made by a filmmaker with the right skills to do it justice.

Contributor
Contributor

Writer from Cardiff. Fan of all rebels, rogues and rascals.