10 Annoying Flaws That Stop Great Directors Being Perfect
Someone should buy Christopher Nolan a new sound system.
What makes a brilliant film director?
Is it their knowledge of cinema? Their eye for for a great story? Their technique for getting the best of out of an actor? Or maybe it's that flare of creativity audience's lust for whenever they settle down to watch a film for two hours?
Whatever it is, many movie directors have "it". They have the spark, they have the edge and they certainly have the creative control to carve out a piece of their identity on screen that resonates with audiences. If a movie director has a big enough reputation, they can also start to carve out a signature on screen that we as audience members come to recognise about them.
In the same way you can detect Aaron Sorkin dialogue or Roger Deakins cinematography, some directors have a tradition that is noticeable across the board. And while most brilliant qualities are found in excellent directors, there are some who are just at 99% perfection.
There's that little hump that if they just got over, there would be no bad word to say about them. Taste-makers and nitpickers of the movie world will still find something incredulous to say about them of course, but world peace couldn't please them.
In this list are ten talented filmmakers who have just one tiny gripe that they have to reckon with, then they'll be good as the gold on an Oscar.
10. Zack Snyder - Isn't Aware That Less Is More
Yeah that's right, Zack Snyder is a great director!
For all the digs made at Snyder for what he's created for the DCEU, at least you can tell they're his movies. The earthy tones, slow-motion shots might make some audiences roll their eyes, but if you pause his films at any moment during a fight sequence - the shot on screen looks like a gosh-darned painting! A re-watch of 300, Watchmen and even Sucker Punch prove that he has an eye for spectacle on screen - at least some of the time.
Where Snyder falls down is his inability to rein in the madness. Man Of Steel is actually a great character study for Superman for at least two-thirds of the movie, with its final act turning into Godzilla levels of destruction between two demigods. Batman Vs Superman is just as cataclysmic towards the end, and I pray his revised version of Justice League isn't just going to be another round of unwarranted lights, noise and destruction.
Snyder can set up a film brilliantly, and there's a belief that he genuinely has an appreciation for what he's doing. Perhaps what he needs to do is remember he's making a film that's nearly three hours long, and subtlety is a useful tool in that scenario. Otherwise Snyder might go down the very dark route of becoming nothing more than another Michael Bay.
9. Todd Phillips - Copycatting Other Movies
Todd Phillips is a fascinating filmmaker - his gradual transition away from gross-out comedies into more mature films have been a slow burn, but I got to say it's working. Movie directors that change genres are great because they show their diverse approach to moviemaking, and even in Phillips' later comedies, there are darkly tones within the finished product.
But herein lies a problem with Todd Phillips - he's packaged and repurposed very recognisable movies. Admittedly, recycling ideas is pretty much the nature of Hollywood these days, but Phillips' approach is so blatant it's hard to tell if in some way it's all one big practical joke.
The first two Hangover movies were a less whimsical version of Dude, Where's My Car? The film Due Date was a twenty-first century remake of Planes, Trains and Automobiles, and let's not forget last year's Joker, borrowed extensively from Martin Scorsese's King of Comedy and Taxi Driver.
It's clear Phillips is a good director, but what knocks him down is his blatant mirroring of existing films. With him behind the wheel of a Hulk Hogan biopic, I can't help but think he'll play fast and loose with the truth so he can imitate an already existing Hollywood classic.
8. M. Night Shyamalan - Obligated To Put Twists In His Films
Ever since the infamous twist at the end of The Sixth Sense, M. Night Shyamalan has been heralded as the man who delivers on "gotcha!" movie endings. Expecting the unexpected has become such a staple of his films, that for him to not turn the tables at the end is the twist itself.
Let's be clear, Shyamalan is great filmmaker. Through careful camera positioning, and how he builds up suspense in his pacing, are some of his best qualities. When combined with the interesting plots he does conceive of, Shyamalan should hit home runs each time. The problem is, Shyamalan is addicted to subverting expectations, and the end result doesn't always land on the dismount.
If films like The Last Airbender and After Earth have proved anything, it's that Shyamalan works at his best with a small budget and a narrow concept. The Visit, Split, Unbreakable and Signs were all small films that highlighted how he can create tension with very little in the room.
Perhaps Shyamalan needs a writing partner, or at the very least a trustworthy individual to provide a second opinion on his narrative choices? If he had one of them in the room a year ago, Glass would have been a brilliant end to the anti-Superhero trilogy we didn't know we wanted.
7. Judd Apatow - Too Much Improv
Judd Apatow has cut a fine wedge in the movie industry as a figure who can harness excellent rising talent, and bring out their best qualities for the world to see. With an eye for talent and an ear for great comedy, you can pretty much rely on Apatow to find the right actor for the right role. But there is a problem...
For years, critics noted how poorly Apatow wrote female, homosexual or POC characters in his movies, and thankfully he has gotten better at it over the years. The one thing he still can't seem to get over is the ability to yell "cut!" when the scene is complete.
With a loose script, and an arsenal of Saturday Night Live comics in his films, the riffing never ends and if you have a spare few hours, have a look at the uncut versions or deleted scenes of his films.
The scenes go on for much longer than they need to, with repeated variations of the same joke spewing out the actors' mouths - yes! it may be more of an issue with the actors, but some of this stuff makes it into the theatrical cuts. The finished product is a joke that dies midway, and audiences start wondering how much time is left in the movie.
Don't believe me? Watch Knocked Up again and see how long it is before you're screaming at the film to just end a scene and move on with the story.
6. Paul Greengrass - Shaky Cameras
Paul Greengrass is an amazing filmmaker; one who has bravely put a camera lens to some very upsetting real-life incidents over the years, and handled their stories with the utmost respect.
He's also made the Matt Damon look the like worst person to pick a fight with in a dark alley, and for that he deserves kudos. But if there's one thing Greengrass has got to start doing, it's putting his cameras on a dolly and give the cameramen's shoulders a break.
I feel that shaky, handheld camerawork in films will never go away and when it is used properly, it adds to the sense of carnage during a skirmish on a boat or a fistfight in a hotel room. And while Greengrass nails that particular angle, his overuse of shaky cameras for scenes that are a lot "calmer" not only feels inappropriate but dizzying.
For the Bourne movies, the disorientation should come from Jason Bourne's inability to figure out who he is, not between two CIA agents having a chat in an office.
While United 93 and Captain Phillips do incorporate shaky camerawork effectively as a means of standing in a rocking vehicle, it couldn't hurt for him to rest the camera on something every now and then and give audiences a chance to take in what's happening on screen, instead of trying to figure out what's happening.
5. Wes Anderson - Too Much Twee
Knocking on Wes Anderson for the very thing that makes his movies seminal feels very petty, but like Zack Snyder in this list, there is such a thing as "too much".
Going as far back as The Royal Tenenbaums, there was an aura to Anderson's films that felt like what many indie directors have aspired to be since.
Whether it's the symmetry, or the adrenaline shot of "quirk" into his movies, there have been times in Anderson's flicks when he could have toned down the twee of his movies and let the scenes speak for themselves. While he has found his voice in films, adding more layers of twee to his movies feels almost like the visual form of a catchphrase or an elaborate trick a child has learnt, and they just won't stop doing it.
Again, Wes Anderson is a phenomenal director and one that really hits the mark with his own style of filmmaking. And I'm not asking him to switch sides and become unrecognisable - but just for once, turn the nozzle down a bit on the twee.
The Grand Budapest Hotel was an incredible film, but it was also so rich with quirkiness it got almost unbearable at the midpoint.
4. J.J Abrams - Lens Flares
Before I begin, let me first address one of the biggest problems with J.J Abrams, which is his inability to have a single original idea. Playing it safe and not subverting expectations is okay for most directors, but when you're bestowed with the honour and responsibility of rebooting both Star Trek and Star Wars, you have to be expected to be a bit daring with the narrative.
But enough about poor narrative choices, let's talk lens flares!
It might be the smallest issue on this list, but it is just as insufferable to witness on screen. The streams that spew from random light sources only happen for a brief second at a time, but when it occurs so frequently in one film audiences are left wondering if there was something wrong with the cameras on the day of shooting.
It might be excusable if the blinding flares served to obscure a secret character's identity or make the audiences feel like a character being blinded by light. But unfortunately not, as the lights bounce off the corner of a table on the bridge of the USS Enterprise, we realise Abrams just likes to put his a needless twist on screen.
Not unlike his need for a mystery box.
3. Quentin Tarantino - The Feet Obsession Is Distracting
Anyone who has read a couple of forums, or just watched enough movies, knows that Quentin Tarantino has a thing with feet.
Whether his characters are discussing them, he's tracking a character's movements, or if in fact they are integral to the plot, a person's (often a woman's) foot has become like an Easter Egg in his films.
Fans have to assume that Tarantino knows this fact about him, and he's leaning into it as a means to stamp a signature into his films. But the problem is, because the awareness is so well known, every time a character props their feet up, the subconscious message pulls focus away from the film.
All of a sudden, investment in the characters is knocked off-kilter because the meta aspect of Tarantino's flair has been discovered. Like Alfred Hitchock's cameos in his own films, it becomes something audiences should look out for.
I know it's a strange gripe to have, but one of the very tense moments in Inglorious Basterds, or the awesome character development scenes in Once Upon A Time In Hollywood... are flattened slightly by the fact that Margaret Qualley, Margot Robbie or Diane Kruger are enacting one of Tarantino's calling cards.
2. Nicolas Winding Refn - Prolonged Dialogue
Films like Drive, The Neon Demon and Only God Forgives are an acquired taste in cinema - and you can be forgiven for not being drawn into the subtle themes of the movies. And while the director, Nicolas Winding Refn might be more known these days for the excessive violence in his projects, there is something more pressing in his work that is unbearable to sit through.
The Amazon series Too Old To Die Young is what happens when Winding Refn is unleashed, and let loose on a ten episode miniseries that is all his machinations put together. It might be one of the most underrated series to binge on any streaming service, and yet one of the reasons why it can be hard to watch is because of how the pacing works.
Much like his movies, there are scenes within the series where Winding Refn has characters pause for almost five seconds before responding to each other. And while Winding Refn is clearly a director who insists on all of a viewer's attention, it can be almost unbearable to watch when characters blankly stare at each other and whisper one-word answers back and forth.
Winding Refn is amazing at creating suspense and bringing the unexpected, but if he could just up his tempo a little bit, his work could feel like it flows much better when you watch it.
1. Christopher Nolan - Terrible Sound Mixing
Having a grievance with Christopher Nolan and his films is almost blasphemous, but some things have to be addressed.
As one of the few filmmakers out there with the clout to command films with a $200 million budget, the movie-making perfectionist has got one giant flaw that couldn't be more apparent than his latest film, Tenet.
Without spoiling too much detail, an early scene in the film that takes place at a train yard is all but ruined by the background noises screaming over the quieter (and explaining) dialogue. The ambient sounds, coupled with a bombastic score immediately grip audience members in their seats, but the moment a character starts talking alongside the preceding sounds, it feels like you're overhearing a conversation in a nightclub.
This example has descended across some of Nolan's other recent films, and sadly there's a realisation that the one thing Nolan has a bad ear for sound. From the original audio of Bane's voice in The Dark Knight Rises, through Dunkirk and landing on Tenet, there's a genuine concern that Nolan might not be aware of how bad his sound mixing capabilities are.
Given how cerebral and complex Nolan's storytelling is, and that most of his dialogue is characters explaining the world in which they inhabit, Nolan needs his films to be as crystal-clear as possible. Something he's lost track of since his Memento and The Prestige days.