10 Badly Miscast Actors In DC Movies

Characters who were portrayed by completely inappropriate actors.

DC have probably had more movie flops that they've had successes. Green Lantern, Supergirl, Steel, Jonah Hex, Catwoman, Batman Forever and Batman and Robin have all been slammed by critics and audiences alike. In some cases, you can't really blame the casting or the actors for said failure - Halle Berry was actually one of the bright points of the terrible Catwoman movie, in spite of its ridiculous concept, and Josh Brolin could have been a fantastic Jonah Hex had the material he was given to work with not been awful. That said, most of the time it's down to poor casting. DC have given jobs to so many completely inappropriate actors, in terms of the characters that they played, that we've lost count of the number of cases in which it has occurred. Whether it's because the actor in question just wasn't very good, whether it's because they were so impossibly different to the character they were portraying, whether it's because they were taking over from someone who was a hard act to follow or whether it was another reason entirely, some actor-character mixes have simply been wrong and that's what we're going to be looking at here. Here are ten badly miscast actors in DC movies...

10. Ben Affleck As Batman (Batman Vs Superman: Dawn Of Justice)

Normally, this kind of entry would only get an honourable mention but, such was the uproar about Ben Affleck's casting as Batman, it had to make the actual list. It was met with a huge backlash from comic book fans, with some even going to such lengths as creating online petitions calling for the removal of the actor from the project. Fans have claimed he isn't built like Batman, isn't intimidating enough to play Batman, doesn't have the star power to play Batman and simply doesn't have the acting chops to play Bruce Wayne and Batman, while many have pointed towards his failed portrayal of Marvel superhero Daredevil back in 2003 as reason enough not to cast him as a street-prowling vigilante. Regardless of fan opinions, he will portray the Dark Knight in the 2016 Batman Vs Superman movie and, fingers crossed, all this furore will prove to have been misplaced and misjudged.

9. Shaquille O'Neal As Steel (Steel)

In anyone's book, casting Shaquille O'Neal as any character is a bad move - the guy simply isn't an actor. Casting him as a relatively obscure comic book hero in an era before even major comic book movies were popular was simply insane. Even if O'Neal was cast today, in an era where comic book movies are hot property in Hollywood, and even if it was as a major comic book hero like Black Panther, it would still be a bad move. Steel was a recipe for disaster and that's exactly what it turned out to be. O'Neal was wooden, uninteresting and cartoonish and he rightly earned a Razzie Award nomination as Worst Actor for his performance in the film, but he "lost" out to Kevin Costner for his role in The Postman.

8. Tommy Lee Jones As Two-Face (Batman Forever)

The character of Two-Face in Batman Forever was terribly flawed to begin with. He started the movie in the disfigured form that we know from the comic books, which ruined any possibility of seeing what he was like as district attorney Harvey Dent prior to the disfigurement that drove him to villainy in the first place and meant that the character really didn't have any depth. The fact that Tommy Lee Jones was cast as the character really didn't help either. Jones was only three years on from having played embittered ex-CIA operative William "Bill" Strannix in 1992's Under Siege and it was almost as if he was still in character as the mentally unstable Steven Segal foe - he essentially ended up playing the role of Two-Face as a Joker knock-off as a result. He really didn't make any attempt to play the Harvey Dent side of the personality either. Granted, this version of Two-Face was brain-damaged, but it would have been much better to have seen more hints of the man Two-Face once was portrayed in the performance.

7. Robert "Jeep" Swenson As Bane (Batman & Robin)

It's fair to say that this version of Bane didn't exactly require the Daniel Day-Lewis calibre actors of this world to portray the villain, but there really should still have been someone better than a B-list wrestler in the role. It's by no means the late Jeep Swanson's fault that this version of Bane was terrible - he was probably told to camp it up in the terrible way the role was performed - it's just that this isn't how anyone wanted Bane to be portrayed. Swanson performed like a heel wrestler and, as a result, the outcome was less of a comic book villain and more of a 'roid-rage Gobbledy Gooker. Someone with more acting experience would surely have been able to portray the character, even in this mindless form, as more of a physical threat and less of a joke. It was very poor of DC to bring a comic book character of such renown down to this level.

6. Val Kilmer As Batman (Batman Forever)

Val Kilmer was a terrible Batman. There are a select few people who might say otherwise, but he was a terrible Batman. To be fair to Kilmer, he made a decent Bruce Wayne. His looks, his height, his charm and his general smooth and cool persona worked well for the businessman. It came quite natural to him. But Batman he was not. For starters, he wasn't muscular enough. When you think about the shape Christian Bale got in to and compare it to the shirtless scene Val Kilmer did in Batman Forever, it's embarrassing for the latter. Mostly, he just wasn't memorable as the Dark Knight. There was just nothing to him. It's hard to point out anything ridiculous about his performance, but there is simply nothing good to say about it either. He didn't make the role his own at all. On top of the fact that he played a terrible Batman, Joel Schumacher also described Kilmer as "childish and impossible", said that he fought with various crewmen and outright refused to speak to the director for a fortnight after he had told him to stop behaving in a rude way. An all round terrible casting.

5. Helen Slater As Supergirl (Supergirl)

Putting Helen Slater in to her first ever film role as a character as popular as Supergirl was always going to be a terrible idea. Some people think that the Supergirl movie was a cheap, low-budget spin-off of the Superman movies and therefore getting a minor actress made sense, but this was a $35 million budget movie in 1984 - it was far from being low budget, so such a risk was crazy. Slater was likeable enough - don't think we're saying anything to the contrary - but she just wasn't interesting enough. She lacked the acting chops to live up to the reputation that the mighty Christopher Reeve had brought to Kryptonian movie heroes. She spent the entire movie being wide-eyed and cheery, but lacked depth and substance and ended up just being a bit boring. She was also playing opposite accomplished talent like Faye Dunaway, Mia Farrow and Peter O'Toole and she was simply outshone.

4. Arnold Schwarzenegger As Mr. Freeze (Batman & Robin)

Of all the people Arnold Schwarzenegger could play from the world of comic books, and of all the people who could have played Mr. Freeze, matching the two together really does seem like a baffling idea thought up by an idiot. In the comics, Victor Fries is a genius in various sciences and an expert in cryogenics. After an accident, he puts his previously weak body in to a cryogenic suit in order to survive and it also grants him superhuman strength and durability. In addition to freeze guns and various other ice-based weapons, he becomes a physical threat as well as an intellectual threat to Batman. What he certainly isn't is a muscular European man with no discernible genius and a barrage of cheesy lines to throw around. Schwarzenegger seemed to know this character was a joke and he played it as such, so he can't really be blamed for the casting, but he never should have been given the role in a million years.

3. George Clooney As Batman (Batman & Robin)

George Clooney is, without any shadow of a doubt, the worst man to have ever been cast as Batman. Period. In what was a pretty terrible film overall, Clooney is widely seen as the worst thing about it, having been described as "the big zero of the film" and as someone who "should go down in history as the George Lazenby of the series". Even Clooney himself has spoken out about how poor the whole thing was, saying "I think we might have killed the franchise" and calling the whole thing a waste of money. The ER actor (who simultaneously was allowed to film said drama series whilst shooting for this movie, which can't have helped matters at all) simply isn't dark enough to play the iconic Dark Knight. In fact, Joel Schumacher specifically cast him to provide a lighter and less depressing Batman than previous offerings, which was a stupid idea that went a large fraction of the way towards ensuring its failure. Of course, the Bat-nipples didn't help one bit either, but that's another story...

2. Brandon Routh As Superman (Superman Returns)

Simply put, Brandon Routh completely lacked the charisma required to play Clark Kent AKA Superman. Routh was the first actor to follow Christopher Reeve in the role on the big screen - a hard act to follow, given that Reeve's version is one of Hollywood's truly iconic performances of any character - and he just couldn't live up to the Superman name. It was a very average, very vanilla performance and it led some people to believe that Routh had been cast simply for the fact that he slightly resembled Reeve in terms of his appearance (which sort of made sense, given that the movie was meant to serve as a kind of homage sequel to the Reeve movies) and not because he had the acting chops to take on such a huge role. The film, as a whole, wasn't as bad as a lot of people made out - Kevin Spacey's Lex Luthor was great and the rest of the cast was more than acceptable - it's just that the very raw Routh, who had only appeared in small roles in two films prior to getting the Superman job, simply wasn't ready for it.

1. Ryan Reynolds As Hal Jordan (Green Lantern)

Ryan Reynolds tends to play Ryan Reynolds in every role and that's exactly what he did here. Hence, he was not, is not and never will be suitable to play Hal Jordan. Deadpool? Yes. Hal Jordan? No. Jordan isn't a comedy character. He is certainly quite often unreliable and lazy in the comic books - which is something that was reflected in Reynolds' interpretation - but the man has absolutely no personality and, therefore, a joker with a big personality and the wit and charisma of Reynolds doesn't fit. This isn't an attack of Reynolds - far from it - it's just that he is too interesting and fun to play the Jordan from the comics properly and, as a result, the portrayal was nothing like what comic fans wanted or expected. So there you have it - ten badly miscast actors in DC movies. Did you enjoy this article? Do you agree with the entries on this list? Which other actors were badly miscast in DC movies? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below. And please feel free to follow me on Twitter!

Contributor
Contributor

I'm a Tottenham Hotspur fan who loves comics and comic book movies.