10 Best Accidental Horror Movies

Scariest non-horror movies you need to see - Marathon Man, Parasite, Labyrinth & more!

Marathon Man
Universal

Just because the horror genre primarily focusses on freaking out its audience, it does not mean it has a monopoly on it.

In fact, there have been many instances where using the macabre in non-horror movies has been so impressive, that they end up straying far closer to the horror genre than the filmmakers intended.

The genre tends to have a stigma for being tropey thanks to its reliance on violence, gruesomeness and plot twists, so it comes as no surprise that many movies end up employing the same tricks.

After all, there is a universal appeal to fear, as showing something terrifying on a screen can give the viewer a strong sense of catharsis, since audiences love to see characters put through the wringer and overcoming it.

Viewers have been treated to some truly astonishing films that tow the line between horror and non-horror so well, and they have gone on to scare audiences massively, without that being the primary motive.

The following ten are the best of the best when it comes to this, as none of them are horror movies in the conventional sense, but ended up feeling like them anyway.

10. Buried

Buried Ryan Reynolds
Lionsgate

There are some ways to die that are truly unimaginable, but one of the most haunting is the idea of being buried alive, which is a hypothetical many people - especially those with claustrophobia - prefer to push away.

As the title might suggest, Buried takes full advantage of this fear, as it presents you with a compelling and thrilling drama that revolves around one performance and a terrifying set-up.

It follows Paul Conroy, an American truck driver working in Iraq, who is kidnapped and buried in a coffin underground. There, he seeks to stay alive, with nothing but a lighter and a phone.

As if this plot wasn't scary enough, the film fully delves into isolation and claustrophobia, as you stick with Paul - played impeccably by Ryan Reynolds - throughout the whole thing, feeling stuck and doomed as his oxygen slowly runs out, and his time begins to dwindle.

Although it doesn't present itself as a horror movie, audiences felt like they were watching one, thanks to the protagonist's lack of power and hope.


9. Labyrinth

Labyrinth Hands
TriStar Pictures

A charming movie full of puppets, songs and goofy characters, starring David Bowie and crafted by the man who created The Muppets? Surely such a project would be a whimsical delight.

Well, Labyrinth is anything but whimsical; it's a dark, scary and downright creepy flick that throws a tonne of messed-up scenarios your way, thanks to Jim Henson's creative creatures and the wild mind of the writer, Terry Jones.

Labyrinth follows the young and naïve Sarah as she puts up a fuss after being asked to babysit her brother Toby. In a misguided fit of frustration, she asks the Goblin King to take her young sibling away, and he obliges. Then, to get him back, she is tasked with completing a Labyrinth, full of dark puzzles, dangerous games and terrifying creatures.

It almost feels like what would happen if Guillermo del Toro made a kids movie, as the flick's monsters are truly horrifying. Some of the worst include the Helping Hands - pictured above - who cling to Sarah and communicate by forming faces with their fingers. Then, there are also the Goblins, who look truly disturbing and vicious. That's just scratching the surface of this spooky movie.

Even with Bowie's charming presence, this flick still caused plenty of children and adults alike to hide behind a pillow.


8. The Black Cauldron

The Black Cauldron
Disney

Time to move from one traumatising children's film to another. The Black Cauldron is more infamous than anything else, as it has always felt like an outlier in the Disney line-up. It even gained a horrid reputation for almost ruining the studio, and a significant reason for this lack of success was how terrifying it was.

The story follows a young boy named Taran as he, his trusty pet pig, and a collection of other misfits quest to find the titular Cauldron before the evil Horned King uses it to raise an army of the dead and bring the world to bondage.

Despite being a Disney movie aimed at children, the gothic villain, spooky atmosphere and focus on violence took it from a charming animation to downright horror. It's only kept out of the genre entirely thanks to the focus on adventure and fantasy, as the zombie creatures, Horned King and character death would fit right at home on Shudder.

What's even more terrifying is that the version fans got to see was allegedly toned down from the original cut. If this is what made it to the screen, what horrifying sights didn't? Thankfully, the movie has attained a cult following due to the imaginative world, stunning animation and controversial reputation, allowing it to remain alive, despite the efforts of Disney.


7. The Passion Of The Christ

The Passion Of The Christ
Newmarket Films

Whatever your religious beliefs are, there is always a benefit to watching a movie about Jesus Christ, as at the very least you'll usually get a powerful experience about being good to people, loving your neighbour, and caring about something other than yourself. Of course, that's so long as you're not watching The Passion of the Christ.

It seems like Mel Gibson's mission here wasn't to give viewers something enlightening but rather a horror gore flick disguised as something spiritual. Passion tells the story of the final twelve hours in the life of Jesus, as he is tortured, beaten, broken and finally crucified.

The movie is full of gore, to the extent that even an avid Saw watcher might blush. Seeing the titular character stripped, whipped and abused to a bloody pulp takes up most of the runtime, and it's truly disturbing to witness.

While movies like Hostel and Saw are criticised for focusing on gory shock value, they're at least open about their horror movie stamps. Passion instead tries to present itself as a powerful and emotional tale about the famous icon but instead gives you a final product that's more akin to a splatter flick.


6. The Cable Guy

Jim Carrey Cable Guy
Sony Pictures Releasing

A lonely and unstable cable guy performs a job for a young architect and starts obsessing over him. Soon, he stalks him and attempts to force himself into the client's life, ultimately leading to a dramatic clash filled with home invasion, threat and paranoia.

There's no way you'd know upon reading the description that this isn't a horror flick, but rather a Jim Carrey led comedy movie.

The Cable Guy is notorious for breaking the winning streak that Carrey was on in the mid-90s, as it was a significant commercial disappointment. While it would hardly ruin his career, it certainly did show that not all his movies were winners. A lot of the criticism thrown it's way came down to how dark, depressing and frightening it was.

Despite its status as a comedy, the movie delves into some genuinely terrifying ideas and explores them through a macabre visual style. Heavy shadows, some demonic faces from Carrey and a borderline uncomfortable feeling all come together to make this film more creepy than funny.

It still works great as a comedy, just one that accidentally strayed too far into its dark side.


5. Marathon Man

Marathon Man
Paramount Pictures

Seeing an innocent character becoming immersed in an elaborate plot they know nothing about has led to some incredibly entertaining movies. Films like The Fugitive, The Man Who Knew Too Much and North by Northwest have all presented such an idea well, but Marathon Man took it to another level by adding some strong horror elements.

Marathon Man follows Babe - played by Dustin Hoffman - as he is unwittingly embroiled in a diamond plot thanks to his secret US operative brother. This results in Babe being relentlessly pursued by the terrifying Nazi war criminal Dr Christian Szell, The White Angel of Auschwitz.

The entire runtime is filled to the brim with tension and suspense, as you feel for poor Babe and know that danger lurks around every corner. Still, one specific set of scenes push the film over the edge, those being the infamous dentistry torture segments.

After being captured by the primary antagonist, they seek to get information from him, repeatedly asking, "is it safe?" as they torture him using dentistry tools to expose nerves in his mouth and extracting as much pain as possible. It's truly disgusting to watch and had audiences feeling queasy and too afraid to visit the dentist themselves.


4. Melancholia

Melancholia film
Nordisk Film

It was almost inevitable that the infamous Lars Von Trier would make an appearance on this list. This auteur of disturbing avant-garde cinema is known for generating some of the most unsettling flicks ever created. Many of his titles stray deliberately into horror, such as Antichrist or The House That Jack Built. However, even when trying to make something outside of the genre, there's still a memory of it.

Melancholia is a strange science fiction tale that masterfully pulls between a grounded emotional relationship and a wide reaching cosmic catastrophe. It follows a pair of sisters named Claire and Justine as they go about their lives, attempting to navigate their strained relationship, and remain civil.

If that wasn't bad enough, a stray and unperceived planet named Melancholia soon appears and is set to collide with Earth. The movie then falls down a rabbit hole of science, fear and anxiety, as the world's fate slowly but surely, becomes sealed with death.

There's nothing more horrifying than the notion that a world-ending collision is coming, and you are powerless to stop it. This horrific sense of dread permeates the film, as the certainty of the character's doom gives the flick this nihilistic outlook and plays honestly and horrifically into cosmic horror.


3. We Need To Talk About Kevin

We Need To Talk About Kevin
Artificial Eye

Sometimes, there is nothing scarier than showing a unique perspective on a subject that everyone knows to be horrifying. This movie is a truly disturbing yet profound dive into the effects that a tragedy can have on a person and their family, and although it's intended to be a drama, it's a pure piece of nightmare fuel.

The movie follows Tilda Swinton's Eva, as she raises a disturbed and troubled young boy named Kevin. As their life together continues, so do his creepy and sociopathic tendencies, leading to a host of unsettling scenes, vicious attacks and a haunting climax that is topical, poignant and traumatising.

Focussing on the mother of a dangerous child turned criminal is such a compelling outlook, as you see how she is scapegoated for the acts her son committed, although she worked hard not to instil this kind of behaviour in him. Swinton does a fantastic job with the role, as she shows how hard it can be to let go of the love she bore for her son, whilst capturing the trauma he left in his wake.

Despite the socially charged message, the film is an absolute nightmare. Ezra Miller's performance in the titular role is full of tension, and the slow pace makes the violent acts seen throughout the flick truly take you by surprise.


2. Parasite

Parasite Movie
Neon

Parasite shook the cinematic world after its release, not only because of the success it had at the Oscars but also thanks to the mainstream popularity it found in English-speaking markets, something that foreign language movies don't often attain. It achieved this success thanks to phenomenal writing, incredible amounts of tension, strong characters and some truly disturbing implications.

The movie follows a young man named Ki Woo, who poses as a university student, and gets hired by the wealthy Park family to tutor their daughter. Eventually, Ki Woo's entire family - the Kims - get in on the deception as they work together to push out the Park's workers and take their places, all while keeping their identity secret.

To further discuss the scariest aspects of this movie, some major spoilers need to be given, so if you haven't watched the flick - which you definitely should - then do not read on.

While the small-scale invasion of the Park family comes with enough tension and creepiness, it turns into downright horror after discovering that a mentally unstable and thoroughly creepy man lives in a hidden bunker underneath the house. This takes the film from tense to terrifying, as he lashes out against the Kim family and is even shown to have traumatised the youngest Park.


1. Requiem For A Dream

Requiem for a Dream
Artisan Entertainment

Electroconvulsive therapy, an evil sentient fridge, amputations, tonnes of bloodshed: is this a powerful exploration of addiction or a twisted horror movie?

The answer to that question isn't so clear, as Requiem for a Dream walks such a fine line between scary and emotional.

Requiem follows the lives of four protagonists, Harry, Marion, Tyrone and Harry's mother Sara, as they all deal with an addiction to narcotics. Everything starts idyllic, as the youngsters plan for their future and Sara finds a new reason to be hopeful, but it all comes crashing down as their addictions become unbearable, and the landscape of their lives become entrenched with crime, desperation and mental instability.

It's not an easy watch, as you quickly fall for the charm of the central cast, only to see them all go through hell. There's such a sublime focus on pacing, making the entire movie feel like a crescendo, leading up to the chaotic finale that throws almost every disturbing concept your way.

It's got grotesque sex, violence, tragedy and all things that make horror what it is, despite this film not being a part of that genre.


Watch Next


The Scariest Horror Movie Quiz You Need To Try!

Hellbound Hellraiser II 20
Cinemarque Entertainment BV

1. Exactly How Many Pins Are There In Pinhead's Head?

Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!