10 Best Actor Replacements In Movies
These actors delivered the goods under trying circumstances.
Though moviegoers often twitch at the word "reshoots," they're nevertheless a totally ordinary part of the filmmaking process, especially where bigger-budgeted fare with innumerable moving parts are concerned.
Reshoots are most commonly conducted to flesh out story or character beats which test audiences found confusing or to fix editing issues, but every so often they'll be the result of actors being dismissed from the project, whether during shooting or once principal photography is completed.
Rare though it is for actors to be replaced once cameras have started rolling, it happens for a multitude of reasons - perhaps the director simply isn't satisfied with the actor's performance, decides they're wrong for the part, or the ever-tricky "creative differences" get in the way.
Whatever the reason, the following ten movies all saw actors replaced during production, and despite the lack of prep time the new actors had to step into the role, they all absolutely knocked it out of the park.
Nobody could blame any actor for being a little off their game when joining a movie shoot last-minute, but these actors all proved themselves certifiable pros through their excellent, in some cases even award-nominated performances...
10. Paul Dano - There Will Be Blood
Paul Dano in Paul Thomas Anderson's epic period drama There Will Be Blood is an especially interesting case given that Dano was already cast in the film in the small role of Paul Sunday.
The part of Paul's preacher brother Eli was originally played by Kel O'Neill, who was fired two weeks into shooting.
Though rumours initially indicated that O'Neill was intimidated by co-star Daniel Day-Lewis' intense method acting, this was ultimately dismissed by O'Neill, Anderson, and Day-Lewis.
All the same, Anderson decided to replace O'Neill with Dano himself, in turn changing Paul and Eli Sunday into twin brothers and massively expanding Dano's presence in the movie, given how much larger Eli's role is.
And to say that Dano stands toe-to-toe with Day-Lewis - by no means an easy feat - is quite the understatement, so perfectly cast he is as the weaselly, insincere preacher who so ill-advisedly crosses Day-Lewis' oil man Daniel Plainview.
Dano should've received a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination for his performance, but all the same, it remains his finest work to date - impressive for a part he jumped into with effectively zero prep time.
9. Ed Harris - The Truman Show
Ed Harris was the sole actor in The Truman Show to receive much awards recognition, scooping a Best Supporting Actor nomination for his terrific performance as the titular reality TV show's God-like creator, Christof.
But the late Dennis Hopper was originally cast in the role, despite some consternation from both director Peter Weir and producer Scott Rudin, who agreed that Hopper would be recast if they didn't feel he was a good fit once shooting started.
Well, all it took was two days of filming for Hopper to be fired, and given that the Christof scenes were all scheduled to be shot at the very end of production, finding a replacement was a majorly pressing matter.
With Paramount growing impatient, Weir ultimately decided to meet with Harris, and after a meeting the same day, hired him for the job.
As a result, Harris had just a weekend to prepare for the role before filming began - including reshooting Hopper's scenes - yet according to Harris himself, he appreciated the lack of time he had to think about the part, forcing him to act on instinct.
All the same, Harris' understated work in the role remains one of his greatest screen performances to date, lending soul and dimension to a fascinatingly complex villain.
8. Scarlett Johansson - Her
Now, it goes without saying that recasting a voice role is significantly less arduous for filmmakers than one that's in front of the camera, but all the same, in the case of Spike Jonze's brilliant sci-fi romance Her, the voiceover role has very special significance.
During principal photography, Samantha Morton was hired to voice protagonist Theodore Twombly's (Joaquin Phoenix) AI love interest Samantha, and rather than merely record her lines during post-production, she was actually present for the shoot, acting on set in a soundproof booth.
However, during editing Jonze decided that Morton's performance wasn't quite the right fit for the character, and so decided to recast, drafting in Scarlett Johansson as her replacement, while Morton received an associate producer credit.
Despite the expectation that Johansson would simply re-record the lines over a weekend, she reportedly spent four months working on the film with Jonze, who also re-shot new material to accommodate the change in actress.
Those months were evidently well spent though, given that beyond the inherent appeal of Johansson's soothing voice, she gives a terrifically nuanced performance as an unexpectedly multi-faceted character, enough that some even believed her worthy of an Oscar nomination despite her lack of visual presence in the film.
7. Donald Pleasence - You Only Live Twice
You Only Live Twice was the James Bond film which finally bestowed a proper, fleshed-out part to villain Ernst Stavro Blofeld, with Czech actor Jan Werich originally cast in the role.
Once Werich made it to set to begin shooting, however, producer Albert R. Broccoli and director Lewis Gilbert both felt that they'd made a mistake, even comparing his look to Father Christmas.
Broccoli and Gilbert nevertheless pressed ahead, hoping that their instincts were wrong, but after a few days of shooting agreed that Werich just wasn't menacing enough to play the supervillain. And so, the great Donald Pleasence was hurriedly drafted in to replace him, reshooting Werich's scenes - save for a few shots of him stroking Blofeld's pet cat - and completing the rest of the role.
Pleasence brought with him many ideas for the character, including Blofeld's now-iconic scarred eye, and though many actors have portrayed the villain over the last 50+ years, Pleasence's rendition remains the easy consensus favourite among fans.
6. Bruce Greenwood - The Fall Of The House Of Usher
A divergence into the world of TV now, with Mike Flanagan's mesmerising recent horror-drama series The Fall of the House of Usher.
The central role of Usher family patriarch Roderick Usher was originally set to be played by Frank Langella, yet mid-way through shooting he was dismissed from the production following an investigation into his alleged misconduct with co-stars and crew members on set.
A few weeks later, legendary character actor Bruce Greenwood was drafted in to take Langella's place, and watching the end product, it's basically impossible to imagine Langella giving as spectacular a performance as Greenwood.
Conduct aside, Langella's an undeniably remarkable actor, yet Greenwood simply feels like a more natural fit for the suave, loquacious, corrupt pharma CEO - not to mention being almost 20 years Langella's junior, making him more plausibly the father of Usher's six adult children.
If there's any justice in the world, Greenwood will receive an Emmy nomination for his deeply felt performance, though given that Flanagan's sublime work in the horror genre has largely been ignored by awards bodies, it's probably not happening.
5. Winona Ryder - Mermaids
Classic 1990 family comedy Mermaids received general acclaim for the performances of its cast but especially Winona Ryder, who plays protagonist Charlotte Flax - the neurotic 15-year-old daughter of free-wheeling single mother Rachel (Cher).
But shooting actually started with another actress, Emily Lloyd, playing the role of Charlotte, only for Cher to complain early during shooting that Lloyd didn't look enough like her to plausibly be her daughter.
And so, Lloyd was dismissed mid-filming, and because she turned down the lead role in Pretty Woman in order to star in Mermaids, she filed a lawsuit against Orion Pictures for breach of contract and consequently received $175,000 in damages.
Lloyd was quickly replaced with Ryder, who Cher approved of after watching her performance in Heathers, and while this was certainly a tough blow for Lloyd, given that Ryder went on to receive a Best Supporting Actress Golden Globe nomination for her turn, it's tough to argue much with the decision.
4. Jeff Daniels - The Purple Rose Of Cairo
Throughout his filmmaking career, Woody Allen has habitually re-cast actors during principal photography after realising they weren't fit for the part, the most notable of which perhaps happened in his Oscar-nominated 1985 fantasy rom-com The Purple Rose of Cairo.
Michael Keaton was initially cast in the dual role of Tom Baxter and Gil Shepherd - one a movie character, the other the actor playing the character - but ten days into filming, Allen decided that Keaton's performance was too modern, and that audiences would struggle to accept it in a period film.
With that, Michael Keaton - who took a pay cut to work with Allen - was sent packing, at which point Jeff Daniels was brought in to play Tom/Gil instead. And watching the final movie, it's tough to argue with Allen's assessment; Daniels does feel like a much better fit for the film's whimsical romance than Keaton, and to back it up, Daniels received a Best Actor nomination at the Golden Globes.
3. Michael J. Fox - Back To The Future
The frantic nature of Back to the Future's production has been extensively written about over the years, namely that the film's first 34 days of shooting saw not Michael J. Fox playing the part of protagonist Marty McFly, but Eric Stoltz.
Stoltz, a terrific actor in his own right, was cast after scheduling issues prevented Fox from playing the role, but more than a month into filming, director Robert Zemeckis confessed that he felt Stoltz was wrong for Marty, playing the part with too much intensity.
As a result Stoltz was dismissed, and by this time it became possible for Fox to replace him as the lead.
This required a month's worth of Stoltz's scenes being re-shot, which combined with Stoltz being paid his full salary, added an estimated $4 million to the budget while putting the shoot hugely behind schedule.
Despite much negativity surrounding the film while it was in production - a tough claim to believe nowadays - Back to the Future of course went on to become a massive success, in large part due to Fox's pitch perfect performance as Marty.
Truly, it's difficult to picture anyone else playing that part - Fox is Marty, no matter that he had to hit the ground running as soon as Stoltz was given his marching orders.
2. Christopher Plummer - All The Money In The World
Ridley Scott's crime drama All the Money in the World originally cast Kevin Spacey in the role of cantankerous oil tycoon J. Paul Getty, but in October 2017, roughly two months before the film's premiere, sexual misconduct accusations levelled against the actor led to him being removed from the film.
Rather than delay its release as most expected, Scott hurriedly recast Christopher Plummer in the role - his original choice before the studio requested a "bigger" name - and swiftly conducted ten days of reshoots less than a month before the film's premiere.
The reshoots, including a rush-order placed on post-production, added $10 million to the film's budget, yet allowed it to quite elegantly sidestep the controversy of Spacey's involvement and still release in time for awards season deadlines.
Perhaps most impressively of all, Plummer's nimble performance as Getty resulted in him receiving an Oscar nomination for Best Supporting Actor - a staggering achievement for a role he had so little time to prepare for.
That you'd never know Plummer's part was hastily inserted into the film mere weeks before release is a testament to both the late actor's tenacity as a performer and Scott's apparently unwavering work ethic.
1. Freddie Stroma - Peacemaker
Another TV example to wrap things up, then, with the part of Adrian Chase, aka Vigilante, in James Gunn's DC series Peacemaker.
In the show, Vigilante is an hilariously awkward wannabe superhero who looks up to Peacemaker (John Cena) and, over the course of the show's first season, categorically won fans' hearts.
However, the part was originally played by Chris Conrad, yet after Conrad had shot five of the show's eight episodes, he exited the production due to unspecified creative differences with Gunn.
At this point Freddie Stroma was drafted in to replace Conrad, and despite Vigilante spending much of the show underneath a mask, all of Conrad's scenes were reshot with Stroma regardless, likely due to Stroma being noticeably smaller in stature.
And while it's impossible to judge Conrad's work we never got to see, Stroma brings such a show-stealing quality and so much unexpected heart to the character, in turn delivering one of the best performances of the entire series.