10 Best Comic Book Movie Directors

They took the pages of your favourite comics and made your dreams come true.

Comic book movies are huge. Like, really huge. Over the past 15 years or so, movie studios have slowly come around to the idea that comic book movie adaptations are profitable. And now, in 2014, there is no denying the fact that motion pictures and comic books equal a lot of money. What at first must have seemed impossible to achieve has now gifted us with some of the best blockbuster movies of all-time: The Dark Knight, The Avengers... two decades ago, these movies were thought to be mere pipe dreams. Comic books were just silly, weren't they? But everyone loves comic book movies in this modern era. They fill the multiplexes, dominate online discussions, and fuel the imagination. But what about the people responsible for bringing these things to the big screen? What about the directors who are tasked with transforming the pages of a beloved comic book, and rendering them as a certified motion picture experience that pays tribute to its source material whilst giving it enough room to be its own thing? These are the folk who innovate, imagined, create, craft and mold our fantasies into cinematic terms. Join us, then, as take a look at the 10 greatest comic book movie directors of all-time. In most cases (all but one, in fact), the directors featured here have directed two or more comic book adaptations, and have therefore rightfully earned their places in the small canon of directors who deserve to be remembered for doing so. There were no specific qualifications required of a director for them to be considered for a place on this list; just that they successfully managed to bring the pages of a comic book or graphic novel to life on the big screen...

10. Park Chan-wook

The Movies: Oldboy (2003) Korean director Park Chan-wook probably isn't the first person you think of when somebody says "comic book movie director" (or the second or the third or the fourth...), but this guy has proven himself to be one of the best and most creatively impressive comic book directors with just a single film. That's to say, the pieces should fall into place as soon as you realise that Oldboy, one of South Korea's most famous flicks, was actually based on a Japanese manga of the same name, albeit somewhat loosely. Whatever. An adaptation is an adaptation, right? Oldboy is a masterclass in tone and visual stylings, and showcases Park Chan-wook as an extraordinary talent capable of maximising tension and drama at every moment by way of his careful staging and immaculate framing. It might seem strange to hail the man as one of the greatest comic book movie directors of all-time on the strength of a single film, but when your film is this good - and indeed, it transcends the already great material on which it was based - it seems a bit futile to leave him off. Here's hoping Chan-wook adapts another comic soon.

9. Richard Donner

The Movies: Superman (1978), Superman II: The Richard Donner Cut (1980) Richard Donner's name isn't one of the most recognised in Hollywood history, and yet the man has directed some inarguable all-time classics over the course of his long career, the most important and famous of which is probably Superman (though you could argue a case for Lethal Weapon, 'cause Lethal Weapon is freakin' awesome). One of the greatest superhero movies of all-time, Superman starred Christopher Reeve as the titular hero, and blew everyone away with its special effects and brilliant score (courtesy of John Williams) back in '78. Donner has often been labelled as a relatively uninteresting director, given that his movies are fairly explanatory on a technical level - but you have to give credit to the guy pulling the strings on something like Superman, given its potential to go horribly wrong. Interestingly, Donner directed around 75% of Superman II before he was replaced by Richard Lester, which pretty much cements him as the "true" director of the film: indeed, you can buy a legitimate "Richard Donner Cut" of Superman II and check out his original vision for yourself. It's really good.

8. Zack Snyder

The Movies: 300 (2007), Watchmen (2009), Man Of Steel (2013) You have to hand it to Zack Snyder: he may not be the greatest director in the world, but he has definitely developed his own unique style, and - when he manages to rein in the carnage and explosives for a second - has proven himself to be a competent handler of comic book material. So 300, which is still probably his best comic book film (his best film, ironically, isn't a comic book adaptation at all, but the remake of Dawn of the Dead), showcased the director as a talent with great technical capabilities; what's more, it was a total blast. And you've gotta admire anyone who attempts to adapt a comic book as infamous and gargantuan and influential as Watchmen. For all its flaws, it was a respectful take on Alan Moore's seminal graphic novel (too faithful, perhaps). Man Of Steel was overblown and overwritten, sure, but there were shades of greatness in and amongst everything that didn't quite work. Which is to say, Zack Snyder has proven himself time and time again as a bold, especial director; even if you don't like his films, you have to admire the gusto with which they're made.

7. Matthew Vaughn

The Movies: Kick-Ass (2010), X-Men: First Class (2011) Matthew Vaughn's name pretty much guarantees a product of quality, so it's no wonder that the Layer Cake and Stardust director has helmed two of the best comic book movie films of all-time in Kick-Ass and X-Men: First Class, which were both released within a year of one another to rave reviews. Though he started his career as a producer on films like Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, Vaughn soon tried his hand at directing: his style, clean and confident, has earned him positive notes, and he's a deft hand at staging action and casting actors. Kick-Ass showed Vaughn as something of a provocateur - the movie, based on a comic book written by Mark Miller, set out to deconstruct superhero and comic book tropes, and did so through scenes involving relentless violence and swearing children But for anyone who thought that Vaughn's tongue would remain firmly in his cheek for his next venture, X-Men: First Class, not so: his comic book prequel hit all the right notes of sadness and excitement and humour, whilst remaining true - and respectful - of the already established X-Men canon.

6. Hayao Miyazaki

The Movies: Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (1984), Porco Rosso (1992) Though he is best known for massively original works such as Princess Mononoke, My Neighbor Totoro and Spirited Away, the Japanese Walt Disney has adapted at least half of his works from existing sources - two of which are comic books. Renowned for his obsessive, immaculate attention to detail, and the fact that he draws hundreds of thousands of frames of each of his pictures personally by hand, Miyazaki is arguably the perfect person to adapt an established comic book into an animated feature film. You really couldn't find a trustworthier guy. Miyazaki's first feature film with Studio Ghibli (a studio that would become and remains synonymous with his name all these years later), then, was the beautiful and haunting Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind, which tells the story of a young girl's fight for survival in a post-apocalyptic world, and was based on... well, Miyazaki's own manga of the same name. Almost ten years later, he adapted another one of his comic books, Hiktei Jidai, into the wonderful, soaring, World War I movie, Porco Rosso. So when in doubt, adapt your own work, apparently.

5. Tim Burton

The Movies: Batman (1989), Batman Returns (1992) Nobody seems to take Tim Burton seriously anymore, which is a bit of shame, given that pretty much every single one of his movies throughout the '80s and the '90s showcased a brilliant auteur working at the top of his game. Still, given Burton's recent overindulgence in CGI monstrosities and a questionable love affair with casting Johnny Depp in everything, what did the man expect? But let's think back to better times, when Burton was working certified cinema magic with his brilliantly-rendered Batman movie and its sequel, Batman Returns. It was a risky move, of course, taking Batman into his darkest territories yet - especially so, given Burton's insistence on casting Michael Keaton, who - at the time - was best known as a comedic actor. Burton's Batman has since been overshadowed by the great success of Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight saga, but it's essential to remember that with his own ventures, Burton pretty much set the mould; his movies are dark, visionary, exciting, and hilarious. Most importantly, though, they actually feel like the pages of a comic book have exploded onto the screen.

4. Bryan Singer

The Movies: X-Men (2000), X-Men 2 (2003), Superman Returns (2006), X-Men: Days of Future Past (2014) In light of the recent allegations currently facing Bryan Singer, his otherwise impressive resume has taken something of a beating. Whether or not said allegations are true... well, only time will tell. That said, Singer has proven himself as something of a master when it comes to directing comic book movies, despite the fact that - before X-Men - he admitted to knowing very little about them. So Singer has directed four comic book films since his first gave us X-Men in 2000, a movie that - along with Spider-Man in 2002 - helped to advance the genre. Because X-Men and its sequel, X2, convinced Hollywood that comic book adaptations were creatively viable, technologically possible and - most importantly - marketable. It's a tribute to Singer's talents that the X-Men franchise began to fall apart when he decided to jump ship in favour of directing his own Superman film over at Warner Bros., and although that film wasn't exactly the success we all hoped it would be, it remains interesting on its own terms. And now, he's made what is arguably his best film ever in sequel X-Men: Days of Future Past.

3. Guillermo Del Toro

The Movies: Blade II (2002), Hellboy (2004), Hellboy 2: The Golden Army (2008) Oh, to be inside the mind of Guillermo del Toro. Despite having never been there, of course, the Mexican director has spent a pretty hefty portion of his career showing us exactly what it would be like if we did end up there. So del Toro's name has become well-associated with the likes of comic book movie adaptations - even his movies that aren't directly based on outside sources (Pacific Rim, for example) have the look and feel of a comic book: heighten realities, quirky characters, bold visuals, and - let's face it - awkward, clunky dialogue cues. First, there was the brilliant and compulsive Blade IIl; then Del Toro's second foray into the realms of comic book adaptations came with Hellboy. The results were solid and the movie was greatly entertaining, but it wasn't until Hellboy 2: The Golden Army that del Toro's personal visions seemed to meld with his source material to maximum effect. Indeed, del Toro's comic book films seem to act as playgrounds for his imagination, proving that there really is room for an auteur to work his or her idiosyncratic stylings in and around somebody else's story.

2. Sam Raimi

Sam Raimi still might be best known for his work on The Evil Dead trilogy (and there's absolutely nothing wrong with that), but there's no denying the influence that his mostly excellent Spider-Man trilogy has had upon the realms of comic book movie filmmaking. With the original flick, first released in 2002, Raimi crafted a relentlessly entertaining and - at the time - genuinely remarkable adaptation of a beloved comic character. It could have gone horribly wrong, and yet the director's sense of humour, visual style and deft skill with SFX made it a triumph. With Spider-Man 2, Raimi took what he learned making the first film and unleashed what is quite possibly the greatest comic book movie of all-time. What could have ended up as a severely overblown sequel emerged as one of the most frantically fun and balls to the wall exciting comic book adaptations ever. What Raimi seems to understands better than most is that a comic book movie should feel like a comic book - and with a character as inherently ridiculous as Spider-Man, there's no use trying to pretend otherwise (we'll just ignore Spider-Man 3).

1. Christopher Nolan

The Movies: Batman Begins (2005), The Dark Knight (2008), The Dark Knight Rises (2012) Well, who else was it going to be? Christopher Nolan's name has since become synonymous with that likes of Batman, but the British director started out his career about as far away from comic book adaptations as possible, crafting tight, moody thrillers such as Following, Memento, and Insomnia, before Warner Bros. plucked him up and put him in charge of making the Caped Crusader cool again. Mission successful. Single-handily, Batman Begins breathed new life into an ailing popular cultural icon, and brought the character back into the mainstream. Nolan's approach - to ground Batman in a more realistic world - changed the way that comic book movies were made from then on in, and with his magnus opus, the brilliant, gritty, Michael Mann-like The Dark Knight, showed movie-goers that it was possible to blend comic book aesthetics with a lifelike grittiness. Nolan's skills as a blockbuster technician are near unparalleled - even if he didn't manage to cap off the saga with a great film in The Dark Knight Rises, the man still deserves maximum credit for all his bold and innovative work in the subgenre. Like this list? Agree or disagree with our picks? Anyone we should have included but didn't make the cut? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.