10 Best Pre-MCU Superhero Films
Before the MCU, these were the best of the best in superhero cinema.
The MCU is so ubiquitous on our cinematic horizon that it can sometimes overshadow a number of superhero movies made before that fateful first venture of Iron Man in 2008. And it is a shame to overlook this rich period of the superhero genre's fledgling years, as it contains some incredibly intriguing directions in tone and story that are only being revisited now that the genre is well and truly established.
Despite the occasional misguided release (you just thought of that Affleck Daredevil, didn't you?), there were many truly excellent releases that deserve recognition. Some have remained confirmed fan favourites, while others are crying out for rediscovery. After all, It is difficult enough making a good film, never mind making one in a genre that hadn't quite fully established its cinematic tropes at the time.
For a true connoisseur of the genre, these pre-MCU films are unmissable early successes, with some of the finest moments of superhero cinema to be found amongst these forerunners. From edgy '90s fare to the first full-blooded outings of some of comics' most beloved characters, these are the ten best superhero movies from that pre-MCU era.
10. Blade
Long before the resurgence of R-rated superhero films in the form of Logan and Deadpool, Blade fully indulged in all the gore and action of its comic book origin. Add to that the cool central performance from Wesley Snipes and some excellent supporting work from Kris Kristofferson and N'Bushe Wright.
One of the earliest Marvel licences to find big screen success, Blade focused on the titular Daywalker vampire hybrid and his mentor Abraham Whistler. Dr. Karen Jenson finds herself caught up in their underground war against vampires and particularly the ambitious evil plans of young vamp Deacon Frost.
Blade was a commercial success, and played well to audiences, though the critics were a bit more lukewarm. Suffice to say, they got it wrong and subsequently Blade garnered something of a cult following. It is a stylish blend of action and horror. Its sharp writing and direction and well conceived production design means that Blade still stands up over 20 years later. From its opening rave-turned-bloodbath (obviously a '90s film), Blade will sink its teeth into you and you'll be ever so glad it did.
9. The Phantom
Does Billy Zane look daft in that weird purply suit? Yes. Is The Phantom still really good fun? Absolutely. The critics weren't so sure back in 1996, but since then The Phantom has only risen in the estimation of fans. If you like your superheroes colourful and with a little supernatural touch in the tale, then look no further.
In the late 1930s, Kit Walker - the 21st Phantom, as the superhero moniker is passed from father to son - fails to stop a shadowy group from stealing a supernatural artefact, the Skull of Touganda. Thus begins the sort of pulp romp laced with the supernatural that seldom makes its way to screens these days.
The Phantom is knowingly silly but not in a conceited way; it is absolutely committed to having a good time. And it is that tone that really makes it a fun superhero romp, especially contrasted with later moody attempts to try to legitimise superhero stories by making them brooding and edgy. It should be no surprise to know that The Phantom has a fairly healthy cult following and if you watch it, you'll see why.
8. Superman
Richard Donner's first Superman picture is arguably the best outing the Man of Steel has had in his long cinematic history. It strikes the balance of tone excellently, giving us a truly wholesome and virtuous Superman (and a far cry from the regrettably lacklustre outings Kal-El has had since).
Based on a story writer Mario Puzo developed from the comics (yes, the very same Mario Puzo of The Godfather fame), this blockbuster foray into the superhero genre was at one time the most expensive film ever made. It's all here: the origin story, showing Jor-El (Marlon Brando) send his son Kal-El (played as an adult by Christopher Reeve) to Earth, whereupon he grows up in Kansas and of course ends up with his double life as Clark Kent and Superman, battling Gene Hackman's Lex Luthor as he tries to detonate a missile in the San Andreas Fault.
It's fun, it's big, it's bold. In short, it's everything a Superman film should be. And yes, the 'flying around the world so fast time goes backwards' ending is nonsense, but it's fun nonsense, so it gets a free pass.
7. Spider-Man
All respect to Tom Holland, but to some of us, Tobey Maguire just is Spider-Man and this film is the reason why.
The original (and best) cinematic offering of the Web-slinger's origin story, Sam Raimi's take on Spider-Man gave us, amongst other things, Willem Dafoe's sneering Norman Osborn/Green Goblin, Kirsten Dunst's Mary Jane Watson, and of course Maguire's Peter Parker; all of them believable and sincere renditions, whilst still allowing room for some juicy comic book extravagance (especially thanks to Dafoe). Plus, we got Bruce Campbell and 'Macho Man' Randy Savage cameos - an element sorely missing from other Holland or Garfield's Spidey outings. That and J.K. Simmons' J. Jonah Jameson, which could very well be the standout performance amongst stiff competition.
There are only a few films that have legitimate claims to having changed the industry itself, but Spider-Man is one of them. It is the film responsible for the BBFC's creation of the '12A' certificate, allowing children under 12 to see the film when accompanied by an adult. You can thank your friendly neighbourhood Spider-Man for that.
6. Batman Returns
The second of Tim Burton's Batman films was considerably weirder and darker than the already unusual first outing. The result was one of the most interesting big-screen Batman adventures we have.
For his second outing, Keaton's Batman faces off against Danny DeVito's impeccable Penguin in his plot to kill all of Gotham City's firstborn sons. Add Christopher Walken's dodgy tycoon Max Shreck and Michelle Pfeiffer's unforgettable turn as Catwoman, and you have the makings of an exquisite superhero romp.
Burton was initially reluctant to return for a Batman sequel, yet the resulting picture displays none of this hesitancy. It is bold, it is striking, and, most importantly, it is fun (despite the tonal shift to dark). Batman Returns was a high water mark for the Caped Crusader, until Christopher Nolan's Bat-pictures debuted.
Criticised for its darker tone upon release, if anything this is precisely the quality that has let the film age well. And, of course, there has probably never been better casting than Danny DeVito as the Penguin.
5. Hellboy
Guillermo del Toro's take on Hellboy remains, for good reason, cherished by fans. Based on Mike Mignola's Hellboy: Seed of Destruction, this is the first Dark Horse Comics property on this list, though there's a great number of pre-MCU film adaptions of their back catalogue out there.
Beginning in 1944, when Rasputin (Karel Rodin) assists the Nazis in a failed attempt to open a demonic portal, the demon thereafter called 'Hellboy' manages to come to our world. 60 years later, Rasputin is back to finish what he started and Ron Perlman's now-grown-up Hellboy must battle his past as well as snarling Hell beasts.
The film is drenched in that del Toro style fans know well: gothic ostentation and satisfyingly well-crafted cinema. The style blends with the story and the many excellent performances (especially Doug Jones' Abe) to create a truly memorable and distinct comic book adventure.
Perlman is the jewel in the crown of Hellboy. Arguably, this is one of the most harmonious casting decisions in comic book cinema, insofar as he looks like he's walked straight off the page and onto the screen.
4. Batman Begins
Nolan's retelling of Batman's origins remains the definite version for this cinematic generation. In the same vein as X-Men, Batman Begins sought to give the comic book genre a bit of gravitas by approaching the subject matter in a more subdued fashion, though took this notion further in its grounded version of the Dark Knight's journey.
Batman Begins rather fittingly shows us how Christian Bale's take on the Caped Crusader gets underway with his crimefighting career - especially his training under Liam Neeson's Ra's al Ghul, his subsequent break from Ra's, and return to crime-besieged Gotham.
The performances are what elevate this picture; that and the reluctance director Christopher Nolan has towards using CGI. The result is a weighty piece of work, one that really packs a punch. It seems difficult to imagine a better version of Bruce and Alfred than the interplay between Christian Bale and Michael Caine. That, and Cillian Murphy's Scarecrow is probably the most underrated and overlooked masterstroke of the subsequent trilogy, though his real time to shine is unarguably in this very first outing.
3. X-Men 2
Leaps and bounds ahead of its first entry, the second of the original X-Men pictures remains a high-water mark for the entire genre. It also features the most visceral and engaging Wolverine action we were to get until Logan many years later. Add to that a complex story and some excellent performances and you have a superhero picture with real heft.
From the opening sequence of Nightcrawler attempting to assassinate the President, to Brian Cox's General Striker launching an assault on Xavier's school, X-Men 2 starts strong and builds towards a tease of the Phoenix (still exciting even if we know this promise was not fulfilled). Add to that some Hannibal Lecter inspired Magneto imprisonment and a whole host of subplots and themes deftly woven together and it seems that X-Men 2 has good claim for being one of the most ambitious and successful comic book films, at least from a conceptual point of view.
Contemporary opinion was positive, but in retrospect, X-Men 2 seems to be even more of an achievement than it did back in 2003.
2. Spider-Man 2
For a while, Spider-Man 2 was the first word in quality when it came to superhero pictures; it was the standard to which other films in the genre would strive to reach. Even nearly two decades on, it's hard to find many examples of a superhero film that can match Raimi's second Spidey picture, superlative MCU fare notwithstanding.
Set two years after the first outing, this sequel follows Macquire's Peter Parker failing to balance his two lives, and doubting whether he should continue to be Spider-Man at all, whilst a new villain appears after Dr. Otto Octavius's experiment in fusion energy goes horribly wrong. It's got it all, to say the least.
This is the second Raimi film on this list. If there was an undisputed pre-MCU auteur, it was him. If the news hadn't excited you before, then the confirmation that Raimi is helming the Doctor Strange sequel should now be music to your ears. And of course, there's a reason why Alfred Molina's Doctor Octopus made a comeback in Tom Holland's third MCU outing as Spidey - you can't replace the best.
1. The Crow
Overshadowed by the onset tragedy of star Brandon Lee, it ought not be forgotten that The Crow was and remains one of the best superhero movies ever made and rightfully deserves to be recognised as such.
Based on the James O'Barr comic of the same name, The Crow tells the tale of edgy rocker Eric Draven. He and his fiancee are brutally murdered, after which Draven is resurrected by a crow to seek vengeance. There follows a film which remains surprisingly committed to the horror-action genre aspects, with some real visual flair in its fight scenes as well as an impressive overall gothic aesthetic.
It is difficult to think about The Crow without dwelling on Brandon Lee's fate. And yet perhaps the best tribute to the late star was that this last film of his was also his best by far. The Crow has style, it has a good plot, and it has a depth which can sometimes be lacking from some similarly edgy genre-inflected superhero pictures. A feat which few other such pictures can claim is that The Crow has also retained its quality, despite the years.