10 Best Roles From The World's Worst Actors

These beacons of hope made their failures all the more painful.

It's never nice to be disappointed by a reliable or well loved actor, but even Hollywood royalty have their bad days. Most viewers cringed at Leo DiCaprio's uniquely ill conceived turn in notorious cult flop The Beach, while many fans will never forgive Charlize Theron for Sweet November. Luckily, this sort of regrettable surprise is rare. After all, a decent hit-maker in Hollywood can usually be depended on to make savvy career choices and to light up screens with their talent. Sometimes an even rarer phenomenon occurs, though, in the form of a much more welcome surprise. A terrible actor, universally panned and relied on to produce material that's trite at best and unwatchable at worst, will pleasantly shock audiences with a memorable and commendable performance. At such a potentially career-defining moment, a flailing actor's future rests tenuously on the brink of greatness. It can go either way. The actor might capitalise on this moment of inspiration, and forge his or her way into the golden streets of Hollywood nobility; Matthew McConaughey is modern cinematic history's best example of this. Or, as unfortunately proved the case with the following ten actors, they'll let the spark of hope flicker and die, only to return to the next misguided script or vapid plot. The following ten roles promised great things of these otherwise maligned actors, and their movies live on in cinematic history as testament to careers that could have been.

10. Jessica Alba - Sin City

Jessica Alba has largely failed to move out of the realm of Hollywood's pretty faces. Sure, the 'pretty faces' realm is a lucrative one, but Alba has spent her career under the malevolent glare of critics who consistently remind her that she could do better. Alba's early career was promising, but it was her turn as the sultry Nancy in 2005's film noir, Sin City, that really made people sit up and pay attention. Nancy was memorable for all the right reasons: Sexy, dark, and mature, movie goers felt Alba's was a standout role in the movie, and not just because of the skimpy outfits. This 2005 role had the potential to transform the stunning Alba into one of Hollywood's star talents, and it came at a time when her resumé was only slightly coloured by limited bad movie choices. Alba, however, went on to become a victim of further bad choices and bad luck. Despite the fact that 2005's Fantastic Four was a critical flop, it got a sequel she was contracted to star in. She then featured in progressively more painful romantic comedies like 2008's The Love Guru, and finally gave up when she decided to appear in Machete and the more recent Machete Kills.

9. Owen Wilson - The Royal Tenenbaums

Owen Wilson is a welcome face for many comedy lovers. With undeniably loveable mannerisms and a feel-good approach to his movie choices, it's unfortunate that Wilson should be listed among the worst actors in Hollywood today. Painful comedy upon endless painful comedy have plagued Wilson's career, giving him no chance to shine (but surely lining his pockets, thanks to their commercial success). It all started so well for Wilson, with hits like Rushmore under his belt. He really garnered a dedicated following of fans following his impressive turn as Eli Cash in the surreally dark The Royal Tenenbaums in 2002. In this role, he plays the hapless, well-intentioned author and sometime drug addict who serves as a fob to the titular family - he's an outsider who's just as strange as the insiders. Wilson's turn in The Royal Tenenbaums drew on his comedic prowess, but also revealed a tantalising depth to the actor that few had seen before. This led the critics to wonder, could Wilson have leading man potential hidden behind that funny-man persona? Not so much. Soon after the Tenenbaums, the rom-com curse began to plague Wilson. Before fans knew it, his acting light was being suffocated under the proverbial bushel of scripts like Hall Pass. Perhaps if he'd taken on a more significant role in 2015's Oscar forerunner, The Grand Budapest Hotel, things would be looking a little different for this sadly wasted talent.

8. Jennifer Lopez - Selena

No, really; the most reliable of Hollywood's flopsters can actually boast one reasonable role that the critics didn't hate. Lopez's 1997 on-screen interpretation of the life of Selena Quintanilla proved endearing, energetic and even touching. Sure, the whole thing was a little Lifetime-y, but it's certainly worthy of a mention. Especially given that Lopez would go on to assure herself the reputation of worst actress in Hollywood many times over - four Razzie nominations and one win feature on Lopez's discredited acting resume. It's safe to say Jenny's consequent critical panning has been merited. She has yet to show any glimmer of the modest talent on display in Selena: in that promising role she was inspiring and even a little gritty, although it could be argued that Lopez's authentic portrayal of Selena was thanks to her emotional proximity to the diva-esque, troubled singer. No matter what you make of her inspiration for Selena, Lopez's failed acting career is truly down to a lack of talent rather than a lack of luck.

7. John Travolta - Pulp Fiction

There's no denying Travolta's importance in Hollywood. His Tony and Danny, of '77 and '78 respectively, defined musical cinema as you know it today. He proved he still had it twenty years later in 2007's musical hit, Hairspray. Those worthy achievements aside, Travolta's career has been marred by some real stinkers. Indeed, after the epic Look Who's Talking trilogy, nobody expected Travolta to do anything of note for the remainder of his on-screen career. And he shocked everyone, with Pulp Fiction. Smooth, stunning and right on the Tarantino mark, Travolta contributed in no small way to one of modern cinema's greatest achievements. Travolta's character in Pulp Fiction was by turns effortlessly comic and achingly stylish, and his dance scene with Uma Thurman would become one of the most iconic in cinema history. Incredibly, it was a fluke that Travolta was cast in the role of Vincent Vega at all; Tarantino had been hoping for Michael Madsen of Reservoir Dogs fame, but Madsen chose instead to film Wyatt Earp that year. A few flares of possibility shot into the dark skies of Travolta's career after this defining moment in 1994, Get Shorty and Face/Off being two noteworthy critical successes. Still, it's impossible to think of Travolta as anything other than a wasted acting talent given the dizzying heights to which his resume has too infrequently climbed - and the painful lows to which he has regularly fallen.

6. Eddie Murphy - Dreamgirls

It's worth noting that Eddie Murphy has only really achieved unanimous critical acclaim for his voice work on Shrek and Mulan. Perhaps he simply has a face for radio. When Murphy has attempted to grace the big screen, however, his dated '90s persona has not translated well. Of course, even in the '90s Murphy's comedy wasn't setting the critics pens alight. Early successes in the '80s, like Trading Places, were quickly overshadowed by sad attempts at sequels like Beverly Hills Cop II and Another 48 Hrs. Among all of this, however, there has been one performance that was noteworthy for the right reasons. More than just a relief to see Murphy hanging up his badly-aged comedy hat, the actor's role as James Early in Dreamgirls was a worthy feat of dramatic acting. It was a shock for moviegoers to see Murphy, normally the loud, slapstick character, playing an understated but slyly manipulative and domineering music manager and husband. The subtlety and complexity of the role was unprecedented for Murphy, and hasn't reappeared since.

5. Madonna - Evita

Another infamous Hollywood try-hard, most critics agree that Madonna should stick to reigning supreme in the pop business; she's no thespian. In fact, Madonna holds the dubious honour of being nominated for more Worst Actress Razzies than any other woman in the biz. The songstress has failed in Hollywood, painfully and often. Still, when she turned her very talented voice and prepossessing presence to the on-screen adaptation of Andrew Lloyd Webber's biographical musical, Evita, Madonna shone. Of course, the stylised nature of the musical meant that the Queen of Pop wasn't often called on to portray much of the depth you might expect of an Eva Peron. In 1996, Madonna sang and pranced her way through this memorable musical to earn the only respectable acting credit of her career. Madonna had allegedly hankered after the role of Eva Peron throughout her career. There's no denying that the powerful, charismatic persona suited Madonna perfectly, making this on-screen musical adaptation a resounding success among Andrew Lloyd Webber fans.

4. Kristen Stewart - Adventureland

If moviegoers can disentangle Kristen Stewart from the mess of Vampire movies, personal scandals and general unpleasantness surrounding her public persona, it's possible to appreciate her acting chops in 2009's Adventureland. In 2009 Stewart hadn't become world-weary yet. She successfully played a curious, oddly lovable teen in this nostalgic coming-of-age comedy drama. The slightly rambling, mumblecore dialogue suits Stewart's reclusive style, while her Em Lewin didn't drown in the apathy which has plagued her subsequent roles. Early reviews of her upcoming movie, Clouds of Sils Maria, alongside Juliette Binoche are positive, so there's still the hope of more critical success for Stewart in the future. She has even been nominated for the 'Redeemer Award' at 2015's Razzies for her role in Camp X-Ray, so it looks like K-Stew's career could be set to make a turnaround.

3. Lindsay Lohan - Mean Girls

It's hard to imagine that LiLo was ever an up-and-comer, but her breakout role in Mean Girls promised great things - at least in the realm of comedy. Lindsay was a precocious child star who had landed memorable roles in movies like The Parent Trap, and her teenage foray into edgy comedy couldn't have been better managed. Mean Girls was a runaway success and, of course, a modern cult classic. Lohan held up her part of the bargain admirably, playing the displaced geek and the desperate wannabe mean girl with aplomb. She was awkward, she was desperate, she was confused and she was just about everything a teenage girl can relate to at some point. Lohan managed to shine through clever one-liners and a colourful cast. Success went straight to Lohan's questionably talented head, however, and her next questionable film choice - Herbie Fully Loaded - was beset by problems caused by the star's erratic behaviour. A tabloid feeding frenzy and some dire movie choices later, Lohan is left with a patchy, D-list resume, while a number of her Mean Girls co-stars scale the heights of the Hollywood A-list.

2. Nicolas Cage - Leaving Las Vegas

Is Nic Cage talented? This is an ongoing and heated debate among film lovers. His filmography is as long as it is coloured, with hits and misses in almost equal measure. His unquestionable successes span decades, from 1983's Valley Girl to 2010's Kick-Ass, right up to 2014's Joe. Fans of Cage will cite Leaving Las Vegas as proof positive that he's a great actor trapped in a subpar actor's body. His turn as the depressed alcoholic Ben Sanderson in the 1995 movie earned Cage the Academy Award for Best Actor. Later, his role in Adaptation saw Cage showered with praise from even the most hardened critics. The film was lauded almost universally, and one critic even stated, "What gives the film power is Nicholas Cage." Cage may be Hollywood's greatest enigma, but movie-goers must decide for themselves whether his shining moment in Leaving Las Vegas is enough to atone for Cage's horrific mistakes, like 2014's Left Behind.

1. Adam Sandler - Punch Drunk Love

Two early critical successes in the '90s, The Wedding Singer and Happy Gilmore, saw Sandler play variations of himself. What was originally seen as talent would come to be recognised as lazy as his comic skills, obvious in those early works, soon became diluted to the point of being unrecognisable. Yet 2002's Punch Drunk Love gives even the most high-brow film critic pause. From the movie's ironic title to the astute dialogue, there are levels of subtlety in Punch Drunk Love that most movie lovers wouldn't believe Sandler to be capable of. While the brutish comic has, in recent years, become known for his sloppy, heavy handed and lazy comic offerings, his depiction of Barry Egan is almost heart-rending. Egan is the downtrodden, emotionally abused singleton who bizarrely stalks the object of his affections and becomes entangled in a strange but sweetly innocent love affair. The role is undoubtedly a challenging one for any actor, but Sandler pulls it off by managing to be more loveable than creepy. Of course, Sandler's acting skill may hold the movie together, but it was Paul Thomas Anderson's script (of Boogie Nights, There Will Be Blood and Inherent Vice fame) that added the gravitas that Sandler lacks, allowing the otherwise vapid comic actor his chance to shine. Which other terrible actors managed to only deliver one good performance? Share your picks that were missed down in the comments.

Contributor

Sarah loves gaming but isn't a great gamer, is practically a professional horror movie buff, and will probably beat you in a grammar nerd-off.