10 Best Times Actors Played Themselves
The greatest on-screen send ups.
The process of an actor is intriguing and ineffable. Performers over the years have gone to great lengths to inhabit the disparate characters that make up their careers, with all manner of techniques used to get inside the head of another. The truly talented can disappear into a role, truly convincing you that they have become someone else.
On other occasions, though, you may be lucky enough to score the role of: you. Whether you’re doing this for a piece of stunt casting, a quick gag, or something more complex, an actor portraying themselves on film can be enjoyable - but a lot more tricky than you may imagine.
It’s not enough, of course, to simply show up and smile for the cameras. You’re playing You but you’re playing yourself as a character. Maybe you’re skirting close to the truth, or taking your public image and twisting it. You may even be inventing something out of nothing, using your name and your face but telling a story completely outside of your realm of experience.
It’s the kind of tricky metaphysical quandary that only Hollywood’s finest can fully grapple with. Whatever the purpose, these actors have truly gotten inside themselves.
10. Bill Murray - Zombieland
The enigmatic Bill Murray picks his projects carefully. He famously has an answerphone in lieu of an agent, and tends mainly to work with folks he has an existing relationship with, like Wes Anderson and Jim Jarmusch. So it was a surprise to see him pop up towards the end of Zombieland, clad in ghoulish makeup and playing himself.
The role was initially intended for Patrick Swayze, but the part found its way to Murray after Swayze’s death, and it’s a perfect fit. Murray is a known eccentric, and were the world to fall foul of a zombie plague, it’s not too difficult to imagine that he would disguise himself as a member of the walking dead so as to continue with his regular life.
Murray’s appearance in the film was a real shock at the time, and though his presence didn’t stay secret for long, if you were able to watch without this aspect being spoiled, it was a real treat.
He’s an actor of such rare charisma that the sheer sight of him is one of the most exciting aspects of a film about a zombie apocalypse.
9. Al Pacino - Jack And Jill
It seems odd to put any aspect of Jack And Jill on a complementary list, and in a sense, it is. Adam Sandler’s 2011 sibling comedy is not a good film. In fact, it’s a very bad one, with the majority of the comedy coming from the sight of the comedian in unflattering drag.
What it does boast, however, is Al Pacino playing himself. Pacino has made some dodgy choices in his career, and this ranks along his worth. But the Oscar winner deserves immense credit for the sheer work he puts in on set.
Pacino rarely phones in a performance - indeed he’s more liable to go too far in the other direction - and he mines this shonky script and dreadful premise - that he’s deeply in love with Adam Sandler in the guise of a socially inept woman - for all it’s worth.
He’s the only worthwhile element of the film, and while he’s not able to redeem Jack And Jill, he should be praised for his sheer investment. Pacino is an actor with an underrated funny bone, and he puts it to work here in a role he could’ve sleepwalked through. Here’s hoping the payday was a sizeable one - he deserves it.
8. Julia Roberts - Ocean's Twelve
This is a truly bizarre scene that you’d imagine was divisive among the production staff. It’s audacious, fun, and just the right side of stupid.
Danny Ocean and co are attempting to steal a precious Faberge egg, and in order to get close, they must adopt some of their signature disguises. Tess, it is noted, bears a striking resemblance to Hollywood actress Julia Roberts, and she masquerades as the famous movie star in their quest to pull off the ultimate heist.
It’s a bizarre meta-performance, Roberts playing a character playing her, but she pulls it off with no small amount of verve. Indeed it’s just about the only thing people tend to remember about an otherwise pretty bland piece of work.
The Ocean’s trilogy is at its best when it takes itself the least seriously, and they’re certainly not taking themselves seriously with this scene. Roberts injects the film with a large amount of its charm in a bizarre role few actors would have been able to pull off.
7. Carl Weathers - Arrested Development
One of the most acerbic comedies of the early noughties, Arrested Development takes aim at a lot of targets: the moral bankruptcy of the wealthy, the war in Iraq, the media, its own flagging ratings. For some reason, they also chose to take a wild swipe at Rocky and Predator star Carl Weathers, who is depicted as a scheming, tight fisted delinquent with an obsession for getting a stew going.
Weathers had a solid seventies and eighties, but hadn’t appeared in anything particularly major for a while before scoring a recurring part as himself in Arrested Development, becoming one of the funniest and most memorable characters the show “created”.
Why they decided to posit Weathers as a tightwad is anyone’s guest, but the actor throws himself into it with abandon. He runs a con on the airlines to get paid for being bumped from flights, he picks through food scraps for anything to form the base of one of his famous stews, and he manages to make off with the Bluth family story for his own personal use.
It must have been strange for Weathers when this particular offer came in, but we’re certainly glad he took it.
6. Neil Patrick Harris - Harold And Kumar Series
Before Barney Stinson, Neil Patrick Harris played another scheming, amoral womaniser: himself. His appearance in 2004’s Harold & Kumar Go To White Castle was nothing short of a revelation, a career reinvention for the actor then best known for playing medical prodigy Doogie Howser.
Harris is delightfully demonic playing himself in the stoner franchise. In his first appearance, he’s rolling on ecstasy throughout, a hedonistic risk taker whose early success led him down a dark path.
An actor who never phones in a performance, Harris sells the part spectacularly, with an addled glint in his eye throughout. He’d been in the wilderness for a while when he landed this role, and so it was not impossible to believe that this really was what had become of the former Doogie Howser MD.
Later films play on Harris’ increasing public profile, with his coming out pitched as a scheme to make it easier to pick up women. It’s a mischievous, invested performance in a series that didn’t necessarily require such effort. It paid off, though - the comedy chops he displays here can only have been good for his future career.
5. Danny McBride - This Is The End
Seth Rogen’s apocalyptic comedy is built around actors playing themselves. Some run with their public image (James Franco as a pretentious weirdo), others reinvent themselves (Jonah Hill as a delightfully prissy creep).
Danny McBride, though, gets to turn himself into a full on monster. As himself, he’s roundly similar the the type of character he usually plays: he’s brash, profane, full of unearned confidence and barely disguised self loathing.
It’s a character type McBride can play in his sleep, but few can do it better than he does. He’s always able to find a layer of pathos to even his most oafish creations, including himself.
McBride keeps the film ticking, preventing it from becoming just a chance for Rogen and pals to muck about in a big house. One of the best comedy performers around, he can make just about anything funny. He’s the movie’s antagonist, but he’s by far the most compelling presence, from his slo-mo intro to his eventual comeuppance.
4. Joaquin Phoenix - I'm Still Here
It’s hard to remember now that he’s an Oscar winner and one of the finest actors in the world, but there was a time when it seemed like Joaquin Phoenix had truly lost the plot. In 2008, Phoenix announced that he was quitting the world of acting to embark on a rap career. He made dishevelled appearances on late night TV, released a few tracks that were bad but not dreadful, and otherwise retreated from public life.
A few years later it turned out it was all a big gag, a longform performance piece for the benefit of 2010 film I’m Still Here, directed by his then-brother in law Casey Affleck. Everyone had a good laugh and then moved on pretty quickly, and Phoenix’s run of exceptional films and performances overshadowed the project.
It’s a shame, because I’m Still Here is well worth a watch. For a prank it’s surprisingly hard hitting, examining the loneliness and pressure of the artistic temperament and the challenging life of its star. Phoenix is superb, happy to send himself up on camera as a real jackass, but with sensitivity and pathos. It’s a deeply strange film, but Phoenix, as ever, is utterly captivating.
3. Cate Blanchett - Coffee And Cigarettes
Jim Jarmusch’s 2003 anthology film is full of actors playing themselves. A delightfully quirky collection of short films about the titular addictive treats, it features great self depictions from the likes of Alfred Molina, Bill Murray, and Jack and Meg White.
Best of all, though, is Cate Blanchett, who pulls double duty as herself and her overly enthusiastic fictional cousin Shelly. One of the most gifted actresses of her generation, Blanchett gets a rare opportunity here for freewheeling comedy as she acts out both parts of a passive aggressive meeting. Shelly envies Cate for the perks she assumes makes up her movie star life, and only wants to talk about her musician boyfriend.
Cate, meanwhile, goes through the motions of the conversation, flaunting her privilege as she puffs away in the no smoking lounge and makes disingenuous promises to meet up at a later date.
It’s a hugely charming short, and Blanchett’s chops mean the two characters are made distinctive and whole. It’s one of the best moments of a great film by one of America’s most distinctive auteurs.
2. John Malkovich - Being John Malkovich
The endlessly inventive Charlie Kaufman started as he meant to go on with his debut script Being John Malkovich, a high concept comedy in which a puppeteer discovers a portal into the brain of the titular bald actor.
The script was written with Malkovich in mind, due in combination to his screen presence and the aural quality of his name, and while the thespian was shocked to learn someone had written such a bizarre film about him, the script was too good to turn down.
Malkovich makes the premise work through sheer deadpan sincerity. Like much of Kaufman’s work, the otherworldly concept masks serious themes of power and identity, and it’s Malvovich’s stately, dignified performance that allows the other actors - John Cusack, Catherine Keener, Cameron Diaz - to run wild.
Best of all is the scene in which Malkovich enters his own mind, finding himself in a Malkovich multiverse wherein everyone has his face and can say only his name. The temptation would be to ham it up, but he sells the craziness all the more with his quiet incredulity.
1. Larry David - Curb Your Enthusiasm
Larry David’s second great sitcom has become a case of life imitating art imitating life. The Seinfeld creator initially used his Curb Your Enthusiasm character to say some of the things he wished he could really express, but admits that, over time, he has become increasingly like his curmudgeonly TV persona.
TV Larry David is a walking id, a ticking social timebomb who is incapable of having a thought he doesn’t immediately express. He is, more often than not, in the right, railing against petty unjustness or hypocrisy, but he goes about things the worst way possible, making no end of enemies on the way.
David’s performance is a masterpiece. He can say and do the most dreadful things - screaming at a teenage girl to stop singing while he tries to sleep, penning an obscene obituary for his wife’s aunt - but he remains endlessly likeable.
In fact, he’s downright aspirational. It’s easy to see some of ourselves in Curb’s David, but at times he’s the person we wish we were, saying what we’re thinking with the full courage of his convictions. Larry David has turned himself into a superhero.