10 Best True Crime Documentaries Of 2023 (So Far)
The very best 2023 true crime documentaries you can watch right now.
What makes a true crime documentary truly stand out amongst its peers?
Whether the documentary in question is a full-length film or a limited series with multiple installments, true crime outings require a balanced blend of carefully considered factors to ensure success. An engaging premise and balanced perspective are an absolute must in the interests of legitimacy, while a high standard of production quality and due sensitivity paid to the subject matter is important to stand out.
While this year has yet to yield a Tinder Swindler-esque true crime mega-hit, 2023's array of candidates have impressed.
What is perhaps most refreshing about this year for the genre is the variety of stories being offered. As opposed to a billion rehashed serial-killer-centric series, 2023's true crime efforts have diversified in approach, spotlighting different facets of the genre. There's considerably more to an excellent true crime production than gruesome murders, with several of the following documentaries serving as proof.
10. Jared From Subway: Catching A Monster
The story of Jared Fogle - a beaming spokesperson hired by fast food giant Subway after their sandwiches played a vital role in him miraculously shedding more than a hundred kilograms of weight - was meant to be an inspiring, uplifting tale.
Regrettably, the harrowing feature presented by Discovery+, Jared From Subway: Catching A Monster, instead lays bare the abhorrent true nature behind Fogle's facade. Fogle was ultimately sentenced to 15 years in prison on child pornography and sex tourism charges.
Catching a Monster's reveals about the ins-and-outs of Fogle's abuse are sickening, utilizing audio of the man himself to paint a picture of just how repugnant this individual truly was. This is due in no small part to the efforts of Rochelle Herman - a journalist who became an FBI informant and feigned complicity to expose Fogle's horrendous crimes.
Catching a Monster does an excellent job of highlighting just how prominent a figure Fogle truly was. Forget the fact that he was the face of Subway commercials for years - the man was literally spoofed by comedic titans in the vein of Southpark and Saturday Night Live, underlining just how significant this was.
9. How I Caught My Killer
Considering the sprawling monopoly that Netflix holds over the true crime genre, it's refreshing to see Hulu put forward one of 2023's more impressive offerings.
How I Caught My Killer is a nine-episode docuseries providing an innovative take on the genre. The series analyzes how the show's murder victims actually participated in the apprehension of their killer from beyond the grave.
Be it through the use of historic social media entries, snippets of writing that the deceased left behind or testimony from their friends and family, the documentary calls attention to the mind-blowing and exceedingly unlikely manner in which the guilty parties behind the victims' deaths were caught. Some of the case studies featured quite literally beggar belief, which makes for gripping viewing.
Hulu's documentary even manages to avoid falling into the trap typically posed by utilizing reenactments within the confines of a true crime narrative. These sequences can often appear cheesy - not to mention distasteful - but How I Caught My Killer sidesteps this potential pitfall, blending said sequences with carefully sourced interviews and footage in such a seamless manner that the finished product lands perfectly onscreen.
Featuring first-rate editing and pacing against the backdrop of compelling stories, How I Caught My Killer offers an exemplary true crime viewing experience.
8. Catching Killers
Recently debuting on Netflix with relatively little in the way of fanfare, the latest four-part installment of the gripping true crime documentary series Catching Killers tackles some of their biggest and most notorious murderers to date, with episodes concerning the infamous tales of the New York Zodiac and the Olympic Park Bomber amongst others.
Catching Killers operates from the perspective of those investigating the cases. The varied and spine-chilling accounts provided by notable faces involved add an extra layer of detail, cultivating an ominous atmosphere of tension.
As with past seasons of Netflix's series, a key strength of the documentary is the manner in which it highlights the ramifications these investigations had on the detectives' lives outside of work. The emphasis on this element allows for a layered insight examination of the lives of these remarkably resilient human beings.
7. Death In The Dorms
Death in the Dorms had all the potential to be trashy and exploitative. The Hulu docuseries presents six harrowing installments - each concerning students who were murdered on college campuses across America and hitting home with just about any viewer who has a loved one attending university.
However, the documentary turned out to be a somewhat pleasant surprise. Rather than falling into the sloppy trap of poring over the manner of death that these young adults endured, the series instead chose to focus on the investigations and aftermath of the killings themselves.
Smoothly narrated and crisply shot, Death in the Dorms does an excellent job of painting the tragic pictures of these young lives cut short in vivid clarity. The sequences featuring the effect of the murders on the families involved number amongst the documentary's strongest - casting light on the varied number of methods that human beings use to process such unimaginable levels of grief.
It's shocking, intelligent and legitimately terrifying in many instances - a polished documentary that simultaneously pays respectful tribute to the unrealized potential of the victims while bringing the traumatic circumstances behind their deaths to life onscreen.
6. Waco: American Apocalypse
Released on the 30th anniversary of the Waco siege, Waco: American Apocalypse recounts the explosive true story of the standoff between the ATF and the Branch Davidians, an apocalyptic cult led by David Koresh. With bullets flying from both sides of the conflict, the siege concluded when the cult's compound was destroyed in a fire. By the time the dust had settled, 86 people had lost their lives.
This captivating three-part documentary benefits enormously from a lack of any kind of discernible agenda. American Apocalypse avoids a pitfall associated with many Netflix true crime contemporaries by placing emphasis on recounting the events in a faithful and diverse manner, without attempting to point the finger of blame or stoke the fires of conspiracy theories (looking at you, MH370: The Plane That Disappeared).
The talking heads featured within the series have been selected for maximum immersion, with accounts provided by one of Koresh's "wives" and an FBI sniper providing notable highlights amongst the fascinating array of faces involved in the siege.
For such an infamous historical flashpoint, Waco: American Apocalypse also deserves acclaim for the manner in which it sheds light on the lesser known aspects of the tragedy, bringing thought-provoking new information to life as opposed to revisiting well-trodden ground.
5. American Manhunt: The Boston Marathon Bombing
On April 15th, 2013, two Chechen extremists detonated a pair of homemade explosive devices near the finish line of the world-famous Boston Marathon - killing three and injuring hundreds in an abhorrent terrorist attack that shocked the world.
Netflix's American Manhunt: The Boston Marathon Bombing focuses on the devastating aftermath of the explosions themselves and the frenzied three-day manhunt that immediately commenced in pursuit of the perpetrators.
The riveting documentary provides a never-before-seen backdrop to the pressure-cooker hours spent in search of the two Tsarnaev brothers.
Extensive first-person video footage of the horrific events as well as in-depth analysis of the attack and manhunt provided by various law enforcement members makes for an extremely solid true crime offering. American Manhunt also does an admirable job of maintaining a neutral tone, attempting to provide context and factual clarity to the formative events that molded the Tsarnaevs into killers.
While it could be argued that the documentary doesn't break any new ground, the series remains a fitting tribute to those who lost their lives in the bombings on the event's tenth anniversary - as well as one of 2023's more polished true crime efforts.
4. Victim/Suspect
Nancy Schwartzman's Sundance Film Festival entry Victim/Suspect focuses on the real-life tales of numerous women who ultimately found themselves in handcuffs after attempting to report sexual assaults to the police. Victim/Suspect analyzes the sickening failings of the police officers involved in these cases - individuals who pressured these victims into recanting their statements, before subsequently arresting them for making a false accusation.
Presenting an unflinching examination of sexual assault and rape culture, Schwartzman's evocative production explores the pervasiveness of these issues within society. The timing of the documentary's message has never been more appropriate - the relationship between women and the police is an issue of seismic social relevance in 2023. One has to look no further than the revolting abuse of power exhibited during the vigils for Sarah Everard - incidentally, a woman murdered by a serving police officer.
Victim/Suspect pays tribute to the appalling struggles of the women involved in these heartbreaking miscarriages of justice, inviting relevant social debate by calling attention to the damage inflicted by these incidents in a thoughtful and measured manner.
3. The Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker
The Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker recounts the larger-than-life tale of viral sensation Caleb Lawrence McGillvary, a.k.a. Kai - an unashamedly eccentric drifter who received nationwide press attention after using a hatchet to subdue a violent criminal attacking a woman. The story didn't end there though - Kai was convicted of a brutal murder roughly three months later.
Netflix had some ridiculously alluring subject matter to work with here and the streamer did not disappoint. Over the course of 85 minutes, The Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker expertly juxtaposes Kai's wacky personality and the lighthearted manner he was portrayed by the media against the stark reality of the man's true nature. Kai was ultimately sentenced to 57 years in prison for beating an elderly man to death.
The Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker adds a further engrossing element of authenticity by drawing upon legitimately compelling sources to add context to this unlikely tale. The testimonials from Kai's mother, as well as the reporters and police officers that dealt with his case, are first class, building a nuanced image of Kai as an individual and the macabre consequences that his newfound fame brought with it.
2. American Pain
American Pain is relentlessly entertaining and wickedly intelligent. CNN Films' true crime epic paints a vivid portrait of a story so laughably unbelievable that it can be a struggle to believe that the events depicted happened even as they unfold before our very eyes.
There's clearly something in the Floridian waters. Society has seen it all from the Sunshine State, to the point where one rarely even bats an eyelid at headlines in the vein of "Florida Man Charged With Assault After Throwing Alligator Through Drive-Thru Window". American Pain focuses on the story of the George brothers - two bodybuilders and proud Floridians who became the unlikely figureheads of the largest oxycodone trafficking ring in the history of the United States, set against the backdrop of some decidedly Wolf of Wall Street-esque shenanigans.
It's hard to overstate just how engaging the documentary is - 105 minutes legitimately flash by. American Pain manages a true crime experience that is on par with a blockbuster film in terms of entertainment value, flawlessly combined with slick commentary and insight into the by-products of a devastating opioid epidemic and the failings at the heart of local government responsible for this unlikely tale.
1. Madoff: The Monster Of Wall Street
Unsurprisingly, Netflix strikes again with the top spot in 2023's true crime documentary sweepstakes with the unflinching offering that is Madoff: The Monster of Wall Street.
The documentary series unpacks the true story of the world's most notorious Ponzi scheme in blockbuster fashion - $64 billion dollars worth of daylight robbery that went unchecked until the FBI came calling in 2008. Detailing Bernie Madoff's rise to power, the jaw-dropping details at the heart of his financial crimes and the crushing finality with which his endeavors were ultimately crushed, The Monster of Wall Street is must-see viewing.
Madoff: The Monster of Wall Street is packed with a fascinating level of detail, presenting information in such a way that it never feels like an avalanche of financial concepts or abbreviations.
The Monster of Wall Street invites spirited debate through its insightful analysis, from the need for more stringent regulation within the financial sector to philosophical musings on the nature of greed and success. It's an inspired piece of television, and the most gripping true crime documentary of 2023 so far.