10 Comic Book Castings That Were Perfect (But In A Different Role)

The right actors, but definitely the wrong roles.

Topher Grace Spidey Comic book movie casting is a tricky business. Just ask the casting agents working on Batman Vs Superman. The whole Batfleck reaction was insane and more controversy has erupted since Warner Bros. announced Jesse Eisenberg would be the new Lex Luthor. Both Affleck and Eisenberg are talented actors in their own right, but many fans still object to their casting. The key issue is that neither actor is terrible but they're both terrible for THOSE roles. Have you ever watched a comic book film and thought a particular actor was terrific, just not for the part they were given? "Right movie, wrong role" syndrome has plagued many a superhero movie, so let's set the record straight and re-imagine 10 tricky comic book castings by recasting them in different roles that the actors are better suited for. Whether you agree or disagree with the following choices, let us know what you think either way by writing in the comments section below. What do those Hollywood casting agents know anyway, right?

10. Cobie Smulders As The Scarlet Witch Instead Of Maria Hill

Scarlett Witch Maria Hill The first Avengers film was heavily dominated by male leads, so it was exciting to hear that Black Widow will be joined in the sequel by the Scarlet Witch, a mutant who can manipulate probability in her favor. It's just a shame that Cobie Smulders was already spoken for. Although Smulders has proven to be successful in the role of secret agent Maria Hill, with further appearances scheduled in Captain America: The Winter Soldier and Avengers: The Age of Ultron, I can't help but picture her as the Scarlet Witch. Fans are optimistic regarding Elizabeth Olsen's casting, but Smulders is a better fit for the character. The Scarlet Witch is generally calm and restrained yet has a strong presence about her, a raw power that I think Smulders could convey more effectively than Olsen. Smulders also looks the part, combining an inner strength with a sultry appeal that suits the Scarlet Witch more than S.H.I.E.L.D. Agent Maria Hill.

9. George Clooney As Deadshot Instead Of Batman

Clooney Lanzer Fans and critics alike deride Batman & Robin... hell, even George Clooney admits how terrible the film was, bat nipples and all, but that shouldn't spell the end for Clooney's affiliation with the Batman universe. A bold career move for Clooney would be a return to the franchise, but as a villain rather than the main hero. Batman's rogues gallery is one of the most iconic, but when I think of Clooney, I can't see him in any of the roles that have already been snatched up by previous film adaptations and besides, it's boring to see the same few villains recycled for each new reboot of the franchise. That's why Deadshot would be a perfect pick for Clooney. The hired assassin originally appeared as a new crime fighter in Gotham City until his plot to replace the Dark Knight was revealed. Clooney always goes for the charming characters usually, but this role would require him to subvert that persona in a darker manner that may surprise his usual fans.

8. James Marsden As Superman Instead Of Richard White

Poor James Marsden. With his all-American looks and charismatic smile, you would imagine that he has the pick of leading man roles in Hollywood, but for some unknown reason, he always ends up in a supporting role. Marsden's turn as Cyclops in the X-Men trilogy should have been his big shot at leading a superhero movie, but the producers said otherwise, dismissing the team's leader in favor of Wolverine, the fan favorite. Marsden then appeared in Bryan Singer's Superman Returns playing Richard White, nephew to Perry White, editor-in-chief of the Daily Planet. Unfortunately, the film didn't perform as well as expected at the box office. Some fans blame this on Brandon Routh, the unknown actor cast to play Superman at the time. Give Marsden a chance. He may not look exactly like Superman, but the actor possesses a wholesome quality that would have been a perfect fit for Clark Kent. While his role as Cyclops underwhelmed in the X-Men films, they did prove that Marsden can also handle an action sequence if needed.

7. Jessica Alba As Crystal Instead Of Sue Storm

Sue Storm CrystalThe Fantastic Four films were flawed in many ways, but a key issue was problems with casting. No matter what you think of Jessica Alba as an actress, one thing that can be agreed upon is that she doesn't play a convincing scientist. Forget the Invisible Woman. Alba would have been far better suited to the role of Crystal, a member of the super powered Inhumans who live on the moon. Crystal's character had a long term relationship with the Human Torch and because of this, the two super teams have a lot of history together. The Inhuman story line would have proved popular with fans and could have led to a film dedicated solely to their team, including such iconic characters as Medusa and Black Bolt. As Crystal, the element wielding heroine, Alba would still have been an important part of the franchise, just in a role that actually suited her.


6. Kirsten Dunst As Gwen Stacy Instead Of Mary Jane Watson

Dunst Stacy

Kirsten Dunst is one of those rare child actors who matured into a respectable award-winning actress but it was her role as Spidey's love interest Mary Jane Watson that catapulted her into the big leagues. Guaranteed, a montage of Kirsten's greatest cinematic moments will include the now iconic upside down kiss from the first Spider-Man film.

However, as respectable as Dunst is, Mary Jane Watson needs to be played by someone with a lot more sass. In the comics, Watson is a fiery, independent woman who gets along just fine with or without Peter Parker. Watson lost some of her spark in the Raimi trilogy along with her party girl edge. It's hard to imagine Dunst saying the classic Watson line "Face it, Tiger... you just hit the jackpot," with enough conviction. So why not cast Dunst as Spider-Man's other key love interest, Gwen Stacy? Bryce Dallas Howard did an adequate job of portraying Gwen Stacey in Spider-Man 3, but Dunst would have nailed the part by bringing a more nuanced take on the character. She's already proved she can play the sweet girl next door in numerous teen comedies,. This would have been a perfect fit.

5. Emma Stone As Mary Jane Watson Instead Of Gwen Stacey

Emma Stones

On the flip-side of the Spider-Man franchise, we now have Emma Stone playing Gwen Stacy in the reboot with Andrew Garfield.

Stone is fantastic in the role, trading comic remarks with Peter Parker, but doesn't it just feel like she's playing Mary Jane Watson with a blond wig? It's as if the studio wanted a witty Mary Jane Watson to keep the banter going, but they selected Gwen Stacy to be the love interest instead, purely to distance the new Spider-Man films from the original trilogy. Listen up studios! Emma Stone should have been cast as the fiery redhead and Kirsten Dunst should have been cast as the sweet girl next door. It's not rocket science people!

4. Nicolas Cage As Mephisto Instead Of Ghost Rider

Nicolas Cage Mephisto Nicolas Cage is insane, genuinely insane and that shines through in his most off-beat roles. Something about his portrayal of Ghost Rider just didn't work as well as it should have though. Maybe it was the manic expressions or maybe it was those crazy eyes, but Cage is clearly not suited to superhero casting, despite rumors of him being up for the role of Superman back in the early 2000's. Cage's extreme style of acting could have worked brilliantly within the Ghost Rider films, but just not as the title character. The anti-hero was originally created in the comics when a demon named Mephisto struck a Faustian deal with Johnny Blaze, bonding him to a fire demon called Zarathos. Just imagine it for a moment: Cage as Mephisto, the pure personification of evil in the Marvel universe. The role would give Cage the freedom to be as extreme and ridiculous as he wants, hamming it up to his hearts content. Another missed opportunity.

3. Amy Adams As Lana Lang Instead Of Lois Lane

You have to congratulate Amy Adams. It took three auditions for three separate Superman films, but after much perseverance, she finally bagged the iconic role of Lois Lane. Adams is a phenomenal actress and her portrayal as the roving reporter was received well by critics and fans alike. However, Adams could have been even better suited to another key supporting character who has been conspicuously absent from some of the big screen adaptations of Superman over the years. While Lois Lane is Superman's primary love interest, another LL won his heart first, back before Clark Kent left Smallville to work in Metropolis. Adams is clearly too old to play a young Lana Lang from Clark's teenage years, but the upcoming Superman sequel could have introduced the character as an adult in Metropolis, vying for Clark's affections. The resultant love triangle would inject a much needed spark into Lois's and Clark's romance, but unfortunately, this will probably never happen now. And no, this choice isn't just about the hair colour!

2. Topher Grace As Peter Parker Instead Of Eddie Brock

Venom is one of the few super villains to star successfully in his own comic book series. That's how popular he is. Expectations were high when it was originally announced that he would be a key antagonist in Spider-Man 3, that is until people actually saw the film. Sam Raimi admits that Venom was forced upon him and unfortunately, this reluctance to use the character really does show. His entire arc in Spider-Man 3 feels rushed from the start and numerous fans also have issues with the casting. To be fair to Topher Grace though, he did what he could with the role, but it's painfully obvious that he just wasn't right for the part. If only the producers had thought of casting Grace in the Spider-Man role instead. As the star of That 70's Show, Grace nailed the likable teenage geek bit and with some body building, the young star could have easily looked the part too. Also, Tobey Maguire's comic timing was almost non-existent. Just saying.


1. Jesse Eisenberg As The Riddler Instead Of Lex Luthor

Eisenberg Riddler Jesse Eisenberg has had one hell of a week. The internet actually melted last weekend when the young Oscar nominated actor was officially cast as Lex Luthor in the upcoming blockbuster Batman Vs Superman. As usual, fans responded passionately both for and against the announcement. If you're in need of some reasons why Eisenberg is wrong for the part, head on over to this article to find out more. Forget Luthor. Eisenberg has definitely been cast in the right movie, but just as the wrong villain. His cerebral performance as Mark Zuckerberg in The Social Network demonstrates what a perfect fit Eisenberg would be for The Riddler, one of Batman's most famous antagonists. The character requires a neurotic arrogance that Eisenberg was born to play. Jim Carrey was far too theatrical with his interpretation in Batman Forever, so it would be fantastic to see someone like Eisenberg ground The Riddler with a more realistic performance better suited to face the darker Batman fans have grown to love in recent years. Eisenberg in Batman Vs Superman is the definition of 'right movie, wrong role'. Let me know if you agree!

Contributor
Contributor

David is a primary school teacher who tries his best to turn every math lesson into a discussion on the latest Pixar film. Passions include superheroes, zombies and Studio Ghibli. In between going to the cinema, moving to South Korea and eating his body weight in KFC, David writes for a number of movie sites, http://becarefulyourhand.blogspot.co.uk/