10 Comic Book Characters Race-Swapped On Film

Sometimes the best actor doesn't always share the same race as their comic book counterpart...

Comic book movies, the big blockbuster movie genre of the moment, are kind of racist. Not usually in an outspokenly abusive or judgemental fashion, but very much in the way that there are extremely limited roles for people of colour. Just look at X-Men, a series that dramatises a civil rights analogue with an almost entirely white cast. The reason for this lies largely in the fact that most of these movies are based on decades old properties. Comics enjoyed their Golden Age almost a century ago and very few movie franchises are based on characters any less established than those with their origins in the 1960s Silver Age. Naturally, these relics of an earlier age contain a cast of characters lacking in diversity and their 21st century movies usually reflect this. Both Marvel and DC have finally attempted to redress this imbalance by announcing future films with black superhero leads: Black Panther and Cyborg. Perhaps a more interesting development, though, is embodied by last week's announcement of the cast for DC's villain team-up Suicide Squad and its biggest star Will Smith. The charismatic A-lister will take in the role of deadly assassin and top marksman Deadshot, a character that has always been depicted as white. Perhaps inevitably, the news of this casting has been met with a certain amount of "I'm not racist, but..." commentary on message boards viewing the almost perpetually masked character's skin colour as a defining element of his character. Deadshot is, however, far from the first comic book character to be race swapped in coming to screen. As these ten examples show, sometimes the best actor for the job doesn't always share the same race as their comic book counterpart. And thanks to these race swaps the comic book movie world has become a whole lot more diverse and representative.

10. Ripcord

A perpetual background character in Marvel's G.I. Joe comics (as well as the toys that they were written to sell), HALO jump expert Wallace A. Weems AKA Rip Cord was always characterised as an experienced, reliable military man. And, oh yeah, he's a pasty looking ginger. In Stephen Sommers' 2009 adaptation G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra, however, Ripcord (now all one word) was bumped up to a bigger role, the sidekick to Channing Tatum's protagonist Duke. A new recruit and something of a comic relief joker, the movie Ripcord was virtually unrecognisable from his comic counterpart and that applied even more to his physical appearance after Scary Movie star Marlon Wayans was cast in the role. Rise of Cobra was not what anyone would consider a great movie, nor was Wayans' role deemed worth bringing back for a sequel that culled most of the original cast. However, Wayans' version of the character became the new version. Unsurprisingly, in the wake of the movie the toys were redesigned in Wayans' likeness, but the effect continued afterwards. In both the new IDW G.I. Joe comics and the G.I. Joe: Renegades cartoon Ripcord is now portrayed as an African-American new recruit.

9. Wasabi

An unusual entry for this list in that the original character in the Marvel comic is not white, the race swap of Wasabi for the Disney animation version of Big Hero 6 nevertheless serves the same purpose: to give the film a more diverse cast. The product of Disney's acquisition of Marvel, Big Hero 6 is the first Marvel product to become a Disney animated feature and as such represents as much a fusion of Disney animation and Marvel comics as it is of Eastern and Western styles. The pretty much entirely Japanese cast of the comic has, therefore, become the more international superpowered residents of San Fransokyo. Although protagonist Hiro and some of the other supporting cast remain Japanese in the Disney animation, the likes of blade-wielding Japanese chef Wasabi-No-Ginger have become loosely adapted characters like African-American laser cutting techy Wasabi (now not a Japanese chef so in need of an explanation for that name). Played by Damon Wayans Jr. (nephew of Ripcord actor Marlon), this new version of Wasabi has been part of a film that has already enjoyed far more attention and success than its rather niche comic originator. UK audiences can judge for themselves when the film is released here at the end of January.

8. Alicia Masters

With forty years of appearing in Marvel comics before she arrived on the big screen, Alicia Masters, love interest to the Fantastic Four's human lump of stone The Thing, had always had a fairly established appearance as a white woman with strawberry blonde hair. However, the character's defining features have always been her role as a successful sculptor who is also blind. Alicia's blindness allows her to "see" the world and its characters in a different way, not judging by surface appearance, making her the perfect love interest for craggy Ben Grimm. It also meant that it made perfect sense for the film's casting directors to look beyond Alicia's established physical appearance to find an actress right for the past. Django Unchained's Kerry Washington was given the role for both the slightly lacklustre Fantastic Four films directed by Tim Story in the 2000s. Her performance in an underwritten and somewhat idealised role was perfectly adequate, but the films themselves were unmemorable. The franchise is being rebooted next summer and having race swapped a relatively minor character before, the studio now has the confidence to do the same with one of the leads (more on that later).

7. Harvey Dent

Crusading District Attorney Harvey Dent's descent to becoming disfigured criminal madman Two Face has been memorably immortalised on film with Aaron Eckhart's performance in The Dark Knight. However, the role had first appeared in cinemas almost twenty years earlier and looking quite different. Billy Dee Williams, still best known as the only black guy in the Star Wars galaxy, signed on for Tim Burton's Batman in a relatively minor role as Dent in the knowledge that the character's role would grow as he turned to the dark side. Unfortunately for Williams, the already villain filled Batman Returns had no place for the Two Face story on top of everything else. His role was instead taken by the original character Max Shreck. By the time the Two Face story did come up in Batman Forever, Burton had moved on and Joel Schumacher was hired instead. Schumacher decided to drop Williams and replace him with Tommy Lee Jones. Audiences were less bothered by the fact that Dent had changed colour than by Jones' dreadfully hammy performance. Batman Forever was nothing like the disaster that Batman & Robin was, but audiences were left imagining how a Burton-Williams Two Face could have been so much better.

6. Perry White

Clark Kent and Lois Lane's boss, Daily Planet editor Perry White, has been appearing on screen since the serials of the 40s and 50s. Always characterised as hard-edged, often frustrated but ultimately fair-minded, White has also always been, well, white. That is until the recent reboot with Man of Steel in which Laurence Fishburne appeared as the Planet editor. Giving non-white actors the roles of authority figures like this sets a positive example that this kind of character doesn't have to be a stuffy old white dude. Charlie Brooker lookalike Fishburne has made a career of bosses and mentor characters and brings that same solidly reliable gravitas to another similar role here (without ever uttering the character's catchphrase "great Caesar's ghost!"). While there were some inevitable objections from fans who wanted an entirely white, anglo-saxon cast for their movie adaptation of a couple of Jewish kids' comic about an alien illegal immigrant, Fishburne seems pretty established in the role of White. Set to appear in the upcoming Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice and contracted for many more movies in the DC Cinematic Universe, Fishburne could yet become the definitive on screen Daily Planet boss.

5. Electro

When Sony decided to reboot their Spider-Man franchise rather than continuing with the Sam Raimi directed series starring Tobey Maguire, one of the popular rumours for the new Spidey suggested Community's Donald Glover in the role. Ultimately the studio went for a more conservatively conventional choice with Andrew Garfield, who has proved one of the stronger elements in a largely pointless reboot. (Glover, who Garfield himself suggested would make a good future Spidey, has at least the consolation of voicing alternative Spider-Man Miles Morales in an upcoming arc of the Ultimate Spider-Man cartoon). The big screen version of the story did feature a black actor in a leading role, however, in last summer's Amazing Spider-Man 2. The movie's main villain, engineer Max Dillon (AKA Electro), usually portrayed as a white guy in a somewhat preposterous green and yellow jumpsuit and star-shaped mask of lightning bolts, was completely reimagined and redesigned. In the context of changing the whole character's look so that he was blue skinned and crackling with electric currents, having the pre-transformation Electro appear as African-American is a relatively minor shift. Oscar winning actor Jamie Foxx gave Electro more presence than the rest of the excessive number of villains and was successful enough to be likely to return in a leading role for 2016's Sinister Six.

4. The Kingpin

About to be rebooted as a Netflix miniseries, the original Daredevil movie directed by Mark Steven Johnson is generally regarded as an early mis-step during the time when comic book movies were first establishing themselves as a major blockbuster genre. Despite this the movie, which is a much superior beast in Johnson's director's cut, has a number of strong points, not least its villains. As corpulent cigar chomping crime boss Wilson Fisk, the Kingpin, The Green Mile star Michael Clarke Duncan looked about as close to the character on the page as you could get whilst still being a completely different race. The Kingpin's massive suit would be difficult for any actor to fill with sufficient size, presence and menace, but the late Duncan pulled it off with style. The film (and its less redeemable spin-off Elektra) flopped too hard for Duncan to make a mooted return in a sequel, but he made a sufficient impact in the role to return to it as a Spider-Man villain. In 2003, Duncan voiced a version of The Kingpin clearly styled to look like him for two episodes of Spider-Man: The New Animated Series. When the actor died of a heart attack at the age of just 54, the Kingpin was one of the roles for which he was fondly remembered.

3. Heimdall

Kenneth Branagh's Thor was impressively successful in managing to make a ludicrous seeming cod-Shakespearean Norse mythology-space opera mash-up function not only as a standalone movie but also within the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Nevertheless, there were still comics fans who found this extremely fantastical fantasy flick somehow unrealistic if all the cast weren't Aryan white. Branagh, whose various Shakespearean films have always been keen to cast familiar characters with the best actors regardless of skin colour, personally picked out rising star Idris Elba as Asgardian gatekeeper Heimdall. While Heimdall on the page (and his inspiration, the real Norse mythical figure Heimdallr) has always appeared as a stereotypical looking Viking, the film is set in a heightened space fantasy world where there is no real requirement for any character to resemble any Earthly stereotype. Elba brought a quiet dignity to a fairly insignificant part and impressed sufficiently to be given a somewhat expanded role for the sequel Thor: The Dark World. The actor has already let slip that he will make an appearance in Avengers: Age of Ultron as part of a four film deal with Marvel. By the end of it, Elba is likely to be many fans' image of the character.

2. Nick Fury

Arguably the greatest success of race swapped casting has been the one that allowed a role previously played on screen by David Hasselhoff to be assumed by Samuel L. Jackson. The story with eye-patch wearing superspy and S.H.I.E.L.D. boss Nick Fury is a little bit more complicated than the others on this list, however. While the battle scarred Fury's appearance ever since the 1960s has had him as a rugged white guy with stubble and hair greying at the temples, in 2001 a separate version appeared in Marvel's Ultimates universe. Ultimate Nick Fury is not only an African-American take on the character, but his appearance and style were directly based on Jackson. Given many of the current crop of Marvel film adaptations are based on the Ultimates universe versions, casting Jackson as Fury was kind of a no brainer. Since first appearing in a cameo in Marvel Studio's first film Iron Man, Jackson as Fury has been the franchise's most ubiquitous figure, cropping up in seven movies including the upcoming Age of Ultron and various episodes of TV's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. Jackson has become the definitive version of Fury, a good indication of the positive benefits of casting a charismatic actor regardless of race, and the result has been a Jackson-esque Fury appearing in the mainstream Marvel comics continuity as well as the Ultimates. In 2012 Marvel introduced the original Fury's son, Nick Fury Jr., who bears a remarkable resemblance to Jackson and will assume his father's mantle.

1. The Human Torch

While there have been examples of mentors, sidekicks, love interests and villains so far on this list, there are still precious few comic book heroes in the lead roles that aren't white. That is why, on top of the potential movies for Black Panther and Cyborg, it is an impressively progressive step to see 20th Century Fox casting for the four leads of their next superhero blockbuster and not simply using four white actors. Tim Story's 2000s Fantastic Four movies already paid scant regard to making brother-sister pair Johnny and Sue Storm look remotely similar, with Hispanic-American Jessica Alba looking uncomfortable in blonde wig and blue contacts. It's arguable that Alba's staid performance would have been better without such effort going into making her physically resemble her comic book counterpart. This time around, the Storms are to be played by the even more different looking Kate Mara and Michael B. Jordan. The Fantastic Four director Josh Trank worked with Jordan on his previous superpower picture Chronicle and the Friday Night Lights star showed that he has the easy charm and charisma to work as the brash, cocky Human Torch. Jordan is a rising star in Hollywood and The Fantastic Four could be the film that really makes his name. Of course it remains to be seen how successful the film is, or Jordan's performance is in it, or whether its plot will explain why the siblings look so different, but either way in bringing a black hero to a superhero blockbuster it is a big step in the right direction.

Contributor
Contributor

Loves ghost stories, mysteries and giant ape movies