10 Comic Book Characters That Need The Brightburn Treatment

Which other heroes need the horror movie treatment?

Doppelganger Spider Man
Marvel Comics

Brightburn recently released to lukewarm reviews, but it has potential to be a bit of a cult classic in the future, and it has one of the best pitches for a horror movie in ages: Superman, but evil.

The merits and failures of the movie can be discussed at another time, but it's difficult to argue that the film didn't boast an interesting premise. Regardless of the outcome, Evil Superman has a lot of potential.

Yes, Superman has broken bad before, and we’ve had Ultraman, but not like this. This isn’t him becoming a bad guy, this is him becoming a horror movie monster, with the horror cranked up to the maximum.

A lot of other superheroes have gone bad before, but again, not like this. Well, what if they did?

These superheroes could all benefit from having their origin story warped into creepy, horror movie version of itself. With their intense power and imposing presence, the fear factor is already there, they typically just scare the baddies.

There’s a couple of villains in there too, but only ones who typically avoid horror themes but could make great movies if they leaned into them hard.

10. The Riddler

The Riddler
DC Comics

The Riddler has been treated poorly by Batman adaptations. Though Jim Carrey was good in the role, the whole Batman Forever movie was far too campy. Chris Nolan’s Batman Trilogy, on the other hand, didn't even reference the villain at all.

Then there’s the Arkham games. Though the Riddler has a central role there, some of it seems very off brand. He’s hidden little question marks around the Asylum/City, which seems a bit lame but solving them does help some tortured civilians escape, so at least there’s that.

In Arkham Knight though? His riddles are just a racetrack. Yes, one that moves and requires some quick thinking and quicker steering, but still... it’s a racetrack.

In fairness, there are several henchmen suited up in various horrific traps by the Riddler, so it’s not like he’s completely took his eye off the ball. It’s this which could inspire a Brightburnt Riddler movie.

A Brightburn style Riddler movie could be an intense horror festival, like Saw with less body horror and more of a thriller focus.

Is this sort of movie unique in the way Brightburn is? No, but a) it’s only number ten and b) so many of these films are rushed, schlocky and just... bad. A high quality, detective horror inspired by the Riddler could be big news.


9. Zatanna

Zatanna Wizard
DC Comics

Zatanna hasn’t had the best time of it with DC adaptations. She’s still not the the DCEU, either in movies or TV, and while there do appear to be plans to bring her over eventually, with the way DC have been squandering their potential and launching into reboots, nothing is really set in stone.

Injustice: Gods Among Us, where you’d expect her to play a pivotal role, given it's a DC fighting game, relegated her to DLC.

Is she a big enough character for her to get a full scale Brightburn adaptation? Pfft, heck no. But there’s a lot of potential for a spin off comic (which you feel Brightburn could benefit from too, even after the movie) to explore a horror styled Zatanna.

Eternally peppy, there’s a lot of potential to turn her dark. With such a high point to fall from, Zatanna offers a deep well. She can be a little campy, but then so can Joker, and he works for horror just fine.

Brightburnt Zatanna would be Joker’s Dark Knight pencil trick on acid. All her typically funky magic tricks, transformed into some of the most diabolical ways to kill ever.

Her history as a stage magician is inherently creepy too, and lends itself to a horror/Brightburn spin well.


8. Hulk

The Hulk
Marvel Comics

The Hulk lends himself to horror so easily.

The idea of experimenting on man and creating monster is nothing new; in fact, Hulk itself is a pretty clear riff on the Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde Victorian novella by Robert Louis Stevenson. Still, there are ways it can be Brightburnt to the extreme.

Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde is itself a gothic horror, so any look at the Hulk from that sort of angle has already been done. However, with a little bit of a twist on the origin, it could work.

The recent Godzilla movies have proved hugely ambitious, trying to recreate the nuclear symbolism of the Japanese original but falling short. An overcrowded plot, focus on the the wrong characters and some heavy handed cinematography have all pegged Godzilla back from its lofty goals.

Enter Brightburnt Hulk. A monster created by poison within his own blood, becoming rage personified. A more monster-like Hulk, smashing with impunity and without any heroics, mixed with commentary on pollution, military deterrents and experimentation on what makes man man (and what man is capable of when pushed) could see Hulk turned into a much darker character.


7. Rogue

Rogue Marvel
Marvel Comics

Rogue is the perfect mutant to give the ol’ Brightburn treatment to, because it’s not just her powers, but her nature that would get a twist. Brightburn’s key strength was that it was a Superman origin story but with an abuse of his powers; that’s why Rogue is ripe for the picking.

Rogue is pure of heart, and views her deadly powers as a curse to endure. To Brightburn her, the pitch is simple... what if she didn’t?

Rogue can absorb the strength, memories and sometimes even the life of anyone she touches. Throughout most of her comic tenure, she therefore tries desperately hard to avoid touching anyone. When written well, it can be a massively compelling story... when done poorly you end up with X-Men: The Last Stand.

A Brightburnt Rogue wouldn’t be so cautious though.

In a way, Rogue has the most chilling power set of all the heroes. Okay, the idea of being pummelled by Superman or smashed to pieces by Thor wielding Mjolnir is scary, but terrifying?

A beautiful woman sapping away your every thought and every sinew of strength, leaving you nothing more than a frozen husk is horrifying to the core.


6. Catwoman

Catwoman Darwyn Cooke
DC Comics

Catwoman hasn’t had a solo film, seeing as the Halle Berry movie was Catwoman in name only and focussed on an entirely new character, Patience Phillips.

The Selina Kyle version of the character though, as well as being popular in the comics for decades, has been adapted several times too. Almost universally, the adaptations of her have been praised, and as a complex femme fatale who’s more of an altruistic villain than she is an anti hero, she’s a compelling character.

Her shtick is quite simple in that she breaks into places and steals expensive things. It’s almost a Robin Hood situation, in that she largely takes from the rich, except the poor she gives it to is simply herself.

She also has an on again off again relationship with Batman, although their moral compasses rarely line up. So how would she get the Brightburn treatment? That’s easy - she kills people.

Through subtle, almost undetectable means, a Brightburnt Catwoman would go after those who deserve it. Catwoman meets Dexter meets Sherlock, for the unusual killings.

Not as horror filled as Brightburn, granted, but a dark and deeply intriguing concept nonetheless.


5. Wolverine

Wolverine Yellow & Blue
Marvel Comics

There are so many ways to take a horror Wolverine, with plenty of options for a slasher flick in the style of Freddy or Jason. Those two are terrifying enough, but imagine Nightmare On Elm Street or Friday the 13th with Wolverine as the lead character?!

There’s an opportunity to stay closer to Brightburn though and retell the origins. Speaking of, in X-Men: Origins Wolverine, the best scene (i.e. the only good one) occurs near the start as we see an ageless Logan fighting in various wars... imagine a horror take on that.

Think Predator, but where the Predator is in the US army. It could be a old ghost story, of a certain unit being picked off one by one by an animalistic creature. They’re shredded open in a way no man could do; they’ve been attacked by beasts.

It happened in American Revolution, then in the Civil War, then in World War II. Now it’s happening in Vietnam, with the Wolverine stalking his fellow soldiers once more.

Logan already proved how great a darker Wolverine movie could be, but something like this could be pitch black.


4. Mystique

Mystique X-Men
Marvel Comics

While a Brightburnt Catwoman would be graceful, silent and act without a trace, a horror style Mystique would have far less subtlety. A transforming killer has been done before in various sci fi TV shows, but Mystique offers another angle.

The X-Men movies toyed with exploring Mystique’s twisted psyche and fear of abandonment, especially in X-Men: First Class, but never really dug too deep below the surface. A Brightburnt version of the character could do just that.

Set in a world of mutants, Mystique could be a double agent or cultist (with Magneto as the cult leader, of course), exacting revenge. Her killings could have a political bent to them, or else play up the horror angle of her constant body switching.

A Jack the Ripper style story with Mystique as a street walker taking out her own kind has potential too. It’s a shame the Fox X-Men neutered her, despite making her one of the central star. She has a lot more potential than the movies suggest.

A Mystique style Brightburn seems at once one of the most open yet least likely; still, it’s fun to speculate.


3. Captain America

Captain America
Marvel Comics

Brightburn’s tagline of ‘He’s not here to save us’ plays on the classic Superman theme of his descending to earth to save the world; or at least the USA, which often views itself as the whole world. The similarities to Jesus are clear, with Superman a pure, messiah figure who protects all mankind with a message of peace... and laser beam eyes, which were for some reason were omitted from the Bible.

That’s a key reason behind the thinking of Brightburn, and indeed Red Son. Taking Superman away is one thing, turning him against you is a whole other story.

Captain America is (arguably) an equally iconic American treasure, embodying the ideals of his nature. At least, the way they’re supposed to be.

America has not always been the bastion of freedom and peace it claims to be. Pax Americana is peace by force. A horrific retelling of Captain America, where a good soldier is turned corrupt by military experimentation, indoctrination and corruption, could be an intense and introspective tale.

In the 1950s, a version of Captain America existed in exactly this style. What better way to have Falcon take up the title than by battling this version of Cap?


2. Spider-Man

Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #1 2019
Marvel Comics

Spider-Man, Spider-Man, does whatever a spider can... except, does he?

Spiders are amongst the most popular phobias around, and to some are the most terrifying creatures on our planet. A Brightburnt Spider-Man could play up to this idea and really explore the horror of what it means to be a Spider-Man.

Obviously Peter Parker’s ability to crawl up walls and shoot webs links into spiders, but are they really the things we think of when we think of arachnids? The eight legs, creepy crawly nature, the many eyes and the eating flies all come first.

Even the webs are linked more to catching prey than they are to swinging around New York City, saving civilians.

So why not reinvent the origin story? Make him a real Spider-Man? Bitten by the radioactive spider, our hero starts to mutate. He starts to hunger.

He’s still the loveable goofy, nerdy kid with a crush on the pretty girl, except now he spins webs to feast on unsuspecting prey. The great power and great responsibility line turned inwards, with Peter struggling to overcome his guilt while continuing to satiate his need to feast would be very dark indeed.


1. Batman

Batman DC
DC Comics

Batman has gone incredibly dark before, especially in the comics, though never as dark as Brightburn. He’s got a gothic noir edge to him already, which seems to make him perfect for horror. However, for it to really be the Brightburn treatment, there’s a few things that need to happen.

Simply making Batman darker won’t work. It’s been done to death and Batman is a darker hero anyway: the Dark Knight. Brightburn works (as an idea, at least), because Superman is usually a symbol of hope and goodness. Batman is a hero, but not one who personifies the ideals of heroism the way Supes does.

To Brightburn Batman, you need to go deeper.

Batman is built on the idea of fear; he lurks in the shadows and picked a traditional symbol of horror as his emblem. Christopher Nolan’s Batman Begins explores the themes behind the bat well.

What if it went even further though? A man who attacks you, based on your own fears? Compelled himself by some sick and twisted coping mechanism for his own fears? Scarecrow's fear toxin mixed with Batman’s gadgetry and imposing physical presence could make for something truly terrifying indeed.


Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)