10 Comic Book Movie Firings That Changed Everything

These guys and gals got Supercanned...

Considering the rate at which Hollywood is churning out comic book-inspired blockbusters at the moment, it shouldn€™t come as a huge surprise that everything doesn€™t always go to plan during the production process. With that many movies being produced, there's bound to be a few horror stories. It's no longer all that rare to hear of a person €“ be they an actor, director or writer - getting fired from comic book movie. The massive studios behind these box office behemoths need to keep the wheels turning, and if you€™re causing trouble, you could well be forcibly removed. (Unless you€™re Josh Trank, in which case you get to stay, for some reason.) Many different things can get you canned from a comic book movie, it would seem: financial issues, studio demands, and even that familiar old beast we call creative differences. Sometimes, said sacking might be handled in a civil manner, but on other occasions, it can be a very public, very acrimonious split. Often, a person will be fired before a single frame of their comic book movie career is even in the can. In other cases, they could film an entire movie before being shown the door ahead of the sequel's shooting commencement. That€™s certainly what happened to this chap€


10. Val Kilmer - Batman & Robin

Val Kilmer inherited the lead role in the Batman franchise €“ for Joel Schumacher€™s 1995 film Batman Forever - when Michael Keaton turned down a huge sum of money to reprise his role from Tim Burton€™s two previous movies. You might think you'd approach such a big role with all the professionalism you could muster, but this didn't turn out to Kilmer's chosen approach. €œHe was being irrational and ballistic with the first assistant director, the cameraman, the costume people," Schumacher later said to Entertainment Weekly, speaking of Val Kilmer's behaviour on the Batman Forever set. "He was rude and inappropriate. He was childish and impossible.€ So, when it came to casting his second Bat-movie, Batman & Robin, Schumacher didn€™t want Kilmer anywhere near the film. €œHe sort of quit,€ Schumacher is quoted as saying, €œand we sort of fired him.€ So, Kilmer was shown the door. Clooney jumped on board in his stead, and ended up starring in a movie he€™d probably rather forget.

9. James Purefoy - V For Vendetta

James Purefoy has had an eclectic career including roles in A Knight€™s Tale, John Carter and Solomon Kane. At one stage, his CV would have included the comic book film V For Vendetta as well. He was cast in the title role of V in James McTeigue and the Wachowkis 2005 Alan Moore adaptation. However, Purefoy was sacked from the film with six weeks of shooting already in the can. Creative differences were cited at the time, although the prevailing rumours suggested that Purefoy was fed up of wearing V€™s iconic mask, and was resultantly given the boot. Purefoy has denied this since, though. He said to ComicBookMovie.com that €œI don€™t really talk about it much because we agreed not to. The only rumour I can scotch is that if anybody thinks I was too pussy to wear a mask, they€™re completely wrong. It was nothing to do with wearing the mask.€ The exact reason for his departure remains a mystery, then. Purefoy has had no shortage of work since, so we doubt he€™s loosing too much sleep over this one. Despite the mask, V ended up being one of Hugo Weaving€™s iconic roles. Everyone€™s a winner.

8. Tim Burton - Batman Forever

As we€™ve touched upon already, Batman Forever marked a huge turning point for the Batman franchise. Michael Keaton left the cowl for Val Kilmer, and Joel Schumacher took over the directorial reins from Tim Burton. You might expect that a director of Burton€™s calibre made the decision to walk away, but what really happened sounds a lot like a sacking. "I remember toying with the idea of doing another one,€ Burton recalled in the documentary Shadow Of The Bat. €œAnd I remember going into Warner Bros and having a meeting. And I€™m going, €˜I could do this or we could do that.€™€ But Warner Bros didn€™t want Burton€™s ideas, according to the man himself. €œAnd they go like, €˜Tim, don€™t you want to do a smaller movie now? Just something that€™s more ?€™€ he recounted. €œAbout half an hour into the meeting, I go, €˜You don€™t want me to make another one, do you?€™ And they go, €˜Oh, no, no, no, no, no!€™ And I just said, €˜No, I know you!€™ So, we just stopped it right there.€ That€™s pretty much a sacking, then, albeit a very polite one that took half an hour.

7. Patty Jenkins - Thor: The Dark World

Thor: The Dark World was initially going to be directed by Monster€™s Patty Jenkins. Taking the reins of the franchise from Kenneth Branagh, she would have been Marvel Studios€™ first female feature film director. (A title that, to this day, still hasn€™t been claimed.) However, less than two years before the film€™s release date, she was shown the door. Initially, all we heard was €˜creative differences,€™ but it didn€™t take long for another version of events to surface. According to The Hollywood Reporter, €œJenkins was fired without warning€ after €œMarvel became concerned that Jenkins was not moving decisively enough and feared the film might miss its November 2013 release date.€ Natalie Portman was said to be furious. In stepped Game Of Thrones director Alan Taylor, who got the film (albeit not Marvel€™s finest movie) finished on time. Patty Jenkins has landed on her feet, though €“ she€™ll direct Wonder Woman for Warner Bros, which is expected on our screens in 2017.

6. Kevin Smith - Superman Lives

Superman Lives is one of the weirdest and wackiest tales of a movie trapped in development hell. In the year 2000, Kevin Smith was on board to script the comic book film which would relaunch DC's Man of Steel on the big screen. He had several meetings with Warner Bros producer Jon Peters, who had some interesting ideas for the movie. Kevin Smith turned in several drafts of a screenplay, incorporating every barmy idea that Peters threw at him. These included a giant spider for Supes to fight, polar bear security guards and €œa gay R2-D2 with attitude.€ He also didn€™t want Superman to wear his traditional costume, or to fly. Determined not to let the job of a lifetime slip away, Smith kept working on draft after draft. Sadly for Smith, when Tim Burton came on board to direct, he sacked Smith and threw out his draft. €œI certainly would never read anything written by Kevin Smith,€ Burton said at a later date. Harsh. Superman Lives never came to pass, with Burton€™s Superman vision failing to reach cinemas either. J.J. Abrams€™ Superman: Flyby was similarly unsuccessful. Eventually, Warner Bros got Bryan Singer€™s Superman Returns all the way through production. (If you want to learn more about Superman Lives, you could do worse than checking out this excellent documentary.)

5. Terrence Howard - Iron Man 2

Terrence Howard played Colonel James Rhodes in Iron Man, the film that first introduced us to the Marvel Cinematic Universe. In Iron Man 2, Iron Man 3 and Avengers: Age Of Ultron, though, Don Cheadle plays the same role. So what happened? Well, essentially, it€™s all about the money. Terrence Howard€™s agent said €œf*ck you€ and promptly hung up the phone when Marvel€™s contract negotiator raised the idea of reducing Howard€™s pay cheque for the second movie. Don Cheadle was reportedly hired within 24 hours. There€™s no love lost between Howard and Robert Downey Jr. these days. When all this was going down, Howard turned to his old pal Downey for help, and never heard back. "And guess who got the millions I was supposed to get?" Howard said to Rolling Stone earlier this year. " got the whole franchise, so I've actually given him $100 million, which ends up being a $100 million loss for me.€

4. Ed Norton - The Avengers

Back in 2008, Ed Norton played Bruce Banner in Louis Leterrier€™s The Incredible Hulk, the second film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe franchise. Four years later, in 2012, Mark Ruffalo played the same character in Avengers €“ a crossover movie set within the same continuity. To the casual viewer, this could seem a little confusing. €œWe have made the decision to not bring Ed Norton back to portray the title role of Bruce Banner in The Avengers,€ Marvel€™s head honcho Kevin Feige said to HitFix at the time. €œOur decision is definitely not one based on monetary factors, but instead rooted in the need for an actor who embodies the creativity and collaborative spirit of our other talented cast members.€ Although his agent denied the claims that Norton didn€™t want to be part of an ensemble, Ed Norton isn€™t too beaten up about losing the role. This is what he said to NPR: "My feeling was that I experimented and experienced what I wanted to. I really, really enjoyed it. [€] I think you can sort of do anything once, but if you do it too many times, it can become a suit that€™s hard to take off, in other people€™s eyes."

3. Peyton Reed - Fantastic Four

Peyton Reed directed Ant-Man, the Marvel Studios movie that came out earlier this year. This wasn€™t the first time he had been involved with a comic book movie project, though. He was €“ for quite a while €“ attached to the movie that became Tim Story€™s 2005 Fantastic Four film. "I went in, got the movie and I developed it for the better part of a year with three different sets of writers," he recently explained to Yahoo. However, "it became clear after a while that Fox had a very different movie in mind and they were also chasing a release date, so we ended up parting company. I felt like I couldn't make the movie I wanted to make in that environment.€ €œThey wanted to pitch it much younger than I wanted to, and I always felt like they were treating those characters like B-level characters. I never felt like they understood the real strength of that property." With Fox and Reed remaining professional, it€™s never been fully clarified whether Reed was sacked or if he chose to walk away. Either way, it doesn€™t sound like the happiest working environment.

2. Richard Donner - Superman II

 Superhero cinema owes a lot to Richard Donner€™s ground-breaking picture Superman: The Movie. However, Warner Bros and the film€™s producers (the Salkinds) didn€™t have enough faith to stick with his vision for the film€™s sequel, Superman II. The two films were shot back to back, but in October 1977 production on the second film ground to a halt so Donner could finish editing the first one. Come 1979, the Salkinds hired Richard Lester €“ who they€™d worked with before on The Three Musketeers and The Four Musketeers - to finish the movie in Donner€™s stead. Exactly how Donner departed the project remains a topic of debate. The Salkinds assert that they offered Donner the chance to direct, but he turned it down. He denies that this ever happened, claiming that he was told via telegram that €˜your services are no longer needed€™ after Lester had already begun his shoot. Gene Hackman €“ who plays Lex Luthor in both movies - refused to return and film more scenes without Donner, so a body double was used to fill in for him. Lester brought a campier feel to proceedings, but remarkably the movie still remains an impressive accomplishment. It€™s the third and fourth ones that suck.

1. Edgar Wright - Ant-Man

This remains one of the most famous parting of the ways in comic book movie history: Edgar Wright€™s departure from Ant-Man, after eight years in production with Marvel Studios. With neither party willing to start a slagging match, fans will always be left wondering exactly what happened to force Edgar Wright out. There are a few clues out there, but a definite answer remains elusive. Certainly, it seems like a lot of the movies links to the wider MCU were added after the Shaun Of The Dead, Hot Fuzz and The World€™s End director exited the movie. The Falcon scene was definitely a late addition, according to a Peyton Reed interview by Uproxx. The Hollywood Reporter also had some intel about Wright€™s departure. According to their unnamed source, "Kevin Feige run Marvel with a singularity of vision, but when you take a true auteur and throw him into the mix, this is what you get [€] They don't want you to speak up too much or have too much vision.€ Wright is certainly an auteur, and it€™s difficult to imagine him wanting to conform to Marvel€™s rules over his own vision. We don€™t know if that€™s exactly why he left, but it€™s the best guess we have.

Contributor
Contributor

Film & TV journo. Quite tall.