10 Comic Book Movie Performances So Boring It Actually Hurt

Yawn.

Robert Downey Jr.. Heath Ledger. Tom Hiddleston. Patrick Stewart. Ben Kingsley. Tom Hardy. Ian McKellen. What do all these fine folk have in common? Why, they've all played insanely memorable and brilliant executed comic book characters in major film adaptations, of course. And memorable is the key word of the day, because what's the point in agreeing to take on a comic book character if you aren't going to inject your performance with a bit of oomph? Not to mention the fact that "comic book character" kind of implies a sense of heightened reality: bigger is better. But tell that to the following actors, all who seemed to miss the memo about "having fun" when they agreed to play some of the most iconic and best loved comic book characters of all-time on the big screen, and somehow managed - instead - to have us yawning in the aisles. If that sounds harsh, it means only to imply that the actors gathered here left barely an impression on us, despite the fact they all had the potential to make their characters memorable and somehow didn't. In some cases it might not have been their faults entirely, of course. But mostly it was....

10. Black Widow - Scarlett Johansson - The Avengers

Before you take to the comments section to defend Scarlett Johansson's portrayal of Black Widow (having recently seen her in Captain America: The Winter Soldier), hear us out: the first time we glimpsed Natasha Romanoff in Iron Man 2, she was played as a mere piece of eye candy for Tony Stark to ogle over, before we found out that she was actually an undercover agent working for S.H.I.E.L.D. and... you know the rest of the story, anyway. Next time we met Black Widow was as a member of the Avengers in - yes - The Avengers, brought in by one Nick Fury. Which is to say: up until her leading role in The Winter Soldier, Johansson seemed to be playing Black Widow on a sort of autopilot. Sure, her lines were delivered competently, and she did what she needed to do... but there wasn't a sense of "character" attached to the way she was playing her superhero. Anybody could have filled in the role. But here's where we divert and say that Johansson finally came into her own as Black Widow in The Winter Soldier, and with a sense of sexy, fun and badassery, it almost felt as though they'd hired a different actress entirely.

9. Ioan Gruffudd - Mister Fantastic - Fantastic Four

Granted, Mister Fantastic is a fairly insipid character as far as comic book heroes go, but the fluffy nature in which Ioan Gruffudd plays him (read as: incredibly boring way) in the pretty awful Fantastic Four movies is enough to invoke sleep. Whereas Chris Evans, Michael Chiklis and - to a lesser extent - Jessica Alba manage to at least inject a bit of life into their performances, Gruffudd's Reed Richards is so bland and uninspired that it almost smarts. And speaking of smarts, an actor of gravitas could have made this genius true to his origins and also not so dull. Is it useless - and pointless - to complain about a flat performance in an underwhelming superhero movie aimed squarely at children? Perhaps not as much as you might think: if the movie was aimed at kids anyway, and the associated filmmakers weren't all that bothered about things like "making a good movie," they could have at least hinted that Gruffudd should have brought a bit of pizazz to Richards, as opposed to playing him like the missing part of an inflatable liferaft. Richard isn't a super interesting character, sure, but Gruffudd's take is an injustice.

8. Bruce Banner - Edward Norton - The Incredible Hulk

Marvel didn't have much luck casting Bruce Banner until they eventually stumbled upon Mark Ruffalo, the first actor since forever to successfully render the character "interesting," achieved by making him far more good humoured and self-deprecating and far less mopey mopey. Unfortunately for Edward Norton, his performance as Bruce Banner in the relatively good - but ultimately forgettable - The Incredible Hulk movie didn't leave much of a mark: aside from feeling a little phoned-in, it also felt remarkably shy of "character." His Banner just felt like Ed Norton. Eric Bana's performance as the Hulk in Ang Lee's movie of the same name fell into a similar trap as Norton's: by making Bruce too broody and too sulky, it also made him feel super dull. So perhaps we'll never know if Norton's "flat" performance was a conscious choice here, or whether he just got tired of the project and decided to play his fatigue as a character trait. You almost feel sorry for him in the sense that Mark Ruffalo's Bruce Banner felt complete the moment he uttered his first line. People have already forgotten that Ed Norton was the Hulk.

7. Emma Frost - January Jones - X-Men: First Class

On the whole, January Jones gets a lot of schtick for being a "not very good actress." For those who want to change their minds about that, check her out on TV's Mad Men, where she excels as Betty Draper. For those who want hard evidence that, no, January Jones cannot act, look no further than her turn as Emma Frost in X-Men: First Class, where she stands out like a sore - and very frost-bitten - thumb against the likes of Michael Fassbender, James McAvoy, and Jennifer Lawrence. Presumably hired for gorgeous looks, her performance is just ice cold. And not at all in the way that a character like Emma Frost demands; January looks like she's having trouble reading her lines for the most part, and never seems to "gel" with the comic book world she's supposed to be inhabiting. Aside from looking confused, though, mostly Jones is just downright forgettable - Emma Frost is without a doubt one of the most interesting characters in the Marvel canon, and yet the actress brings none of the weight or dimension - and she's given a relatively good amount of screentime to do so, too. Back to Mad Men you go, Jan.

6. Lois Lane - Amy Adams - Man Of Steel

Amy Adams is without a doubt one of the finest actors of her generation, and yet... she was sort of rubbish in Man of Steel, wasn't she? Okay, maybe she wasn't exactly "rubbish," but her role very much was, which made her seem rubbish in turn. Lois Lane has the potential to be a very interesting character, but here Adams does pretty much nothing to define her as anything other than a somewhat plucky reporter who has no choice but to become a love interest. It's not all Adams' fault - it's the role - but this marks one of her most noticeably dull turns for ages. It's probably true to say that absolutely nobody went home thinking about Lois Lane or Amy Adams having seen Man of Steel - what other Amy Adams movies you can say that about? Usually she's the best thing in the movies, as witnessed by recent turns in Her and American Hustle. The material she was given to work with here was not great; when you're forced to fall in love with Superman in such a short space of time, it's hard to make it believable. But Adam's Lois very nearly feels like she walked onto the set, caught between other projects, and acted as herself.

5. Storm - Halle Berry - X-Men

There seems to be a misconception of sorts regarding Halle Berry's talents as an actress: although she bagged an Oscar for her wonderful performance in Monster's Ball, she's literally done nothing since to convince us that she was worthy of the accolade. Before there was Monster's Ball, though, there was X-Men, a movie which pretty much set the standard for each and every one of the comic book movies we see today - even before the likes of Spider-Man. Berry has played Storm four times, and yet her performances seem to grow more and more tiresome. So whereas the original X-Men gifted us with Ian McKellen's unforgettable turn as Magneto and Patrick Stewart's phenomenal performance as Professor Charles Xavier (not to mention Hugh Jackman as Wolverine - woah!), it also offered us Halle Berry as Storm. Although this should have been great, there's actually nothing memorable or particularly notable about the way in which Berry messes up - and then drops - her accent - her preference for acting as this character seems to be "speak very, very seriously. She also lacks Storm's inherent, raw strength.

4. Jane Foster - Natalie Portman - Thor

You know that something has gone seriously wrong when Kat Dennings, playing a character who was invented as a sidekick for the film only, is putting in a more interesting performance than Natalie Portman. That's right: Oscar-winning, "I've been acting since I was a child brilliantly," intelligent and sexy Natalie Portman, struggling to hold her own against the girl from 2 Broke Girls (no offence, Kat). How did Natalie Portman even end up playing such a blandy, non-superhero role in the Marvel Cinematic Universe anyway? Why did she settle for Jane Foster? As Thor's not very interesting love interest, then, Portman has phoned Jane in on two occassions, and - despite rumours that she wants out - is bound by contractual obligation to do it again. The problem with Portman as Jane is that you can clearly see her trying to think of ways to make her character - a perfunctory romantic tool if ever there was one - a little bit more interesting. Coming up short (mostly thanks to the underwritten nature of the role), Jane comes across as no better than countless unremarkable rom-com leads played by the likes of Katherine Heigl.

3. Hawkeye - Jeremy Renner - The Avengers

You can't blame Jeremy Renner entirely for the relative disaster that was his Hawkeye, given that the actor himself has lamented in interviews that he wasn't given all that much to work with with regards to his arrow-inclined Avenger. That, coupled with the fact that Hawkeye remained "brainwashed" and under Loki's control for the entire first half of Joss Whedon's The Avengers, meant that Renner's interpretation of the character never really stood a chance when stacked up against other, more developed members of the team, such as Tony Stark and Thor. The problem with Renner's performance, however, is that it's just bland and one-dimensional: yes, this is partly due to the underwritten nature of his character, but also because Renner opts to plays Hawkeye cold and straight, with little personality and no idiosyncratic touches to remember him by. The Hawkeye of the comics is a fun, cocky and confident character - none of this came over in the movie. By the time the credits were rolling on The Avengers, we felt more connected to everyone except our archer, who failed to excite us fans in nearly every way. Meh!

2. Cyclops - James Marsden - X-Men

There are many, many Cyclops fans - and James Marsden fans, for that matter - who will stop at nothing to protect their most beloved hero whenever he gets slammed on a blog or website (and he does a lot). But despite the fact that Marsden is a likeable chap, it's difficult to deny the fact that, yes, as painful as it is to say it, his embodiment of Cyclops is fairly boring. Remembering that he's appeared in three X-Men movies, there was never a moment in any of them where he felt like a person: it's surprising that his power is "laser beam eyes" and not "being a bore." So how much of this character's failings are down to Marsden? A fair amount, we say. Whereas Cyclops is a comic book character renowned for his stoic, responsible and sensitive tendencies, he's also noticeably less flat on the page - which is really saying something. In all his appearances as the character, it mostly felt like Marsden was telling himself not to display a solid emotion, as if Bryan Singer had cast RoboCop in the role instead (and we're not talking about the actor who plays him, but the actual character of RoboCop). Defend him if you must; he's tedious.

1. Rachel Dawes - Katie Holmes - Batman Begins

Christian Bale. Gary Oldman. Michael Caine. Morgan Freeman. Katie... Holmes? It's safe to say that, looking back on Katie Holmes' role as love interest Rachel in Batman Begins, that she doesn't really gel with Christopher Nolan's movie at all, and seems to have been implemented because... well, why was she implemented? Has it ever made any sense? Replaced by Maggie Gyllenhaal for the sequel, of course, who is far improved and far more believable in her feistiness, it's really a wonder as to why Bruce Wayne was ever enamoured or attracted to this girl: she's a bore. So whereas Holmes is sort of cute in that way that Katie Holmes is cute, she also plays Rachel like she's just been removed from a plastic packaging box. Her performance is lightweight and curiously one-note - it genuinely feels like she's wandered out of a classroom and into rehearsals for a school play. To say that Holmes is a tedious as Rachel is to understate it: she gets plenty of dialogue and screentime to make allow herself to be memorable, but botches it purely because - as an actress - she's not strong enough. We should count our blessings she bailed. Like this article? Agree of disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.