10 Deleted Scenes That Would Have Ruined Their Movies

Sometimes a scene is deleted for a very, very good reason...

After most film shooting schedules are wrapped up on the final call of "Cut!" the filmmakers often find themselves with tens of thousands of feet of film (or, in this day and age, countless terabytes of digital data) which they have to take into the editing room to cut down to a managable length. With many first rough cuts weighing in at around the four hour mark, it's inevitable that plenty more footage is going to wind up on the cutting room floor. Sometimes it is a trim here or there to a scene which is ultimately retained, at other times entire performances can be omitted from the final cut we get to see in the cinema (Terrence Malick is one director notorious for removing stars completely from his films). With studios unwilling to release overly long movies, this is the price the filmmaker has to pay if they want to work within the system. For the most part these cuts are minor elements that the film can survive without. Sometimes, however, a movie positively benefits from their exclusion - watching some deleted scenes you can't help but wonder how they got filmed in the first place, so out of place with the rest of the film they seem to be. Here are ten deleted scenes for which we should all be completely thankful were left on the cutting room floor - had the filmmakers decided to leave them in, they may well have completely ruined the film.

10. Recovering In Hospital - The Shining

Stanley Kubrick's masterful - if unfaithful - adaptation of Stephen King's The Shining proved that the great director was more than capable of tackling the horror genre and transforming it into something nobody had ever seen before - it remains one of the greatest horror movies of all time. It might not have been remembered quite as fondly as it is had a deleted scene made it into the final cut. Kubrick, it seems, had a soft spot for the characters Danny and his mother Wendy and wanted audiences to feel reassured that they were okay after surviving their ordeal in the Overlook Hotel, so he shot a scene showing them recovering in hospital. Fortunately he had a change of heart at the last minute and removed the scene from the released cut. It's probably a good job that he did - a happy ending like this would have totally changed the tone of the film, and not for the better.

9. Magneto In Drag - X-Men: First Class

After a promising start to the life of the X-Men on the big screen with Brian Singer's first two movies, things went considerably downhill once Brett Ratner got behind the camera for The Last Stand. Fortunately, with Matthew Vaughn helming X-Men: First Class, matters ultimately improved for the mutant superheroes. With its strong script and great performances, X-Men: First Class is certainly a memorable addition to the franchise. Although had a certain moment not been removed from the final cut, it could have been memorable for all the wrong reasons. A scene exists where Charles Xavier and Eric Lehnsherr are on a recruiting mission in a gentlemen's club where they encounter Angel (Zoe Kravitz) working as a stripper - to convince her of their mutant powers Xavier transforms Eric's appearance to make him appear to be in drag. Maybe Michael Fassbinder, who plays Eric/Magneto, wasn't too happy about appearing in a dress - or perhaps more likely they took one look at the footage and realised how completely out of place it would be in the movie, lowering the tone just a little bit too far. Either way, it's a good job it remained on the cutting room floor.

8. Luke Witnesses The Opening Battle - Star Wars

With the trailer for Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens currently doing the rounds in cinemas and on the internet, the buzz for all things Star Wars-related is picking up once again in anticipation of J. J. Abrams' contribution to the franchise. The beginning of the film which started it all could have turned out significantly different to the one we all know and love had a few different decisions been made in the editing room. A scene in which Luke Skywalker observes the opening battle over Tattoine with a pair of binoculars was originally shot, following which the farm boy rushes off to see his friend Biggs. Had this been included in the final cut it would have completely detracted from Luke's initial starting point of ignorance and altered his character's arc as he comes to understand the nature of the powerful forces operating in the galaxy. Far better that he was introduced as the naive and innocent character we met in the final released version.

7. Encountering A Cocooned Dallas - Alien

Just as Stanley Kubrick practically reinvented horror with The Shining, so too did Ridley Scott fuse horror and science fiction in a way never seen before with his 1979 movie Alien. Scott's tension-filled direction mixed with H. R. Giger's incredible designs have ensured that this remains one of the greatest movies of all time. As with a lot of films, however, there are some scenes which were best left out of the final edit, and with Alien that scene comes later on in the movie where Ripley (Sigourney Weaver) stumbles across the alien's lair and finds the barely alive body of Dallas (played by Tom Skerritt) cocooned in the wall. While there's nothing entirely wrong with the concept - a similar scene played out perfectly in Aliens - Ripley's dialogue feels completely out of character and the overall tone of the scene lacks impact. Check it out for yourself and see why it's a good thing it wasn't included. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5rLnDtuQrtE

6. "Made For Each Other" Ending - Blade Runner

Sticking with Ridley Scott for a second of his science fiction masterpieces, Blade Runner's chequered history has seen it released in a number of cuts of variable quality, with the most recent Final Cut considered to be the definitive version. Earlier cuts were considerably different, not least with the dreadful inclusion of Deckard's voice over, which even Harrison Ford thought was pretty terrible at the time he recorded it. Still, it could have been even worse - one scene filmed for the movie's ending had replicant Rachel telling Deckard "You and I were made for each other" as they drive off towards the horizon. It would be hard to come up with something more contrived and Hollywood if they tried, and fortunately it was omitted from even the initial theatrical release. Watch it for yourself to see why. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8t9_081E9Y

5. A Famous Narrator - Life Of Pi

Few directors working today are anywhere near as diverse in their choice of projects as Ang Lee. From the underrated comic book adaptation Hulk through to kung fu masterpiece Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, Lee has proven himself to be adept at tackling any genre. His wonderful adaptation of Yan Martel's novel Life Of Pi is no exception - Lee handles the difficult source material with remarkable assurity and utilises 3D technology with a beauty the format has rarely seen. Had he stuck to his original casting decision for the character of the writer who interviews the central character, however, the feel of the film could have been quite different. Tobey Maguire was originally cast in the role, and his star status might have seriously detracted from the otherwise unknown international cast. In the end, Lee dropped Maguire after realising he was too recognisable for the role and opted for Timothy Spall's son, Rafe, a relative unknown and in keeping with the rest of the casting decisions.

4. Aragorn Vs Sauron - The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King

It's impossible to deny the fact that Peter Jackson's adaptation of J. R. R. Tolkien's epic fantasy series The Lord Of The Rings is something of a cinematic triumph - few movies can compare when it comes to lavish production values and commitment to crafting a fully realised and authentic fantasy world. For the most part, fans of the original novels were more than satisfied with his vision, although perhaps their opinion would have differed had he included one particular scene from The Return Of The King in the final cut. The scene in question sees Aragorn facing off against Sauron in physical form outside the Black Gate. Fortunately Jackson changed his mind at the last minute and replaced Sauron with the giant troll we're all familiar with. It's a good thing - the main appeal to Sauron's character is the fact that he exists outside the temporal realm as we know it, and the Eye of Sauron alone is more than enough to instill the right amount of menace and fear.

3. Musical Quint - Jaws

Steven Spielberg's 1975 film Jaws give us the first "animal attack" movie while at the same time introducing the world to the summer blockbuster. One of the most memorable characters in Jaws is undoubtedly Quint, the old timer fisherman whom Chief Brody enlists to take to the waves and hunt down the killer great white shark. Quint has a number of excellent scenes which really flesh out his character - not least the one in which he bares his scars and tells of his ordeal with a pack of tiger sharks - but one deleted scene was best left omitted. It shows Quint going into a music shop to buy piano wire where he torments a young boy attempting to play Beethoven's Ode to Joy on the clarinet. To say that the scene is superfluous to both the film and his character is stating the obvious - thankfully Spielberg understood this himself and left it out of the theatrical release. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfX1MkMazwc

2. Peter Parker Meets His Father - The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Few people are going to come out from the woodwork and defend The Amazing Spider-Man 2 as being one of the greatest superhero movies of all time - from its overblown villains who feel like they belong in a cartoon rather than a feature film to its incredibly muddled plot, it's a far cry from reaching the full potential of the character. Still, there's one scene which, had it been included, would have made the film worse than it already is. As if the film hadn't already thrown one too many contrivances and cilches at us, director Mark Webb also shot a scene in which Peter Parker meets his father in a cemetery. Is it actually his father? Did he manage to somehow - inexplicably - survive the plane explosion? Or is it someone else disguised as his father? Or a hallucination? Does it really matter? Probably not - thankfully the scene wasn't included in the final version, which means The Amazing Spider-Man 2 isn't quite as terrible as it could have been. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Ft3xxOSQPo

1. The Alien Survives - The Thing

Readers who are old enough to remember growing up terrified by Ridley Scott's Alien are most likely also familiar with John Carpenter's The Thing - its creature designs by Rob Bottin are among some of the most gut-churning and terrifying ever committed to film, and still look a damn sight better than the CGI monsters found in the 2011 prequel/remake. Dozens of pages and several short films have been made analysing the great ambiguous ending to The Thing, in which survivors MacReady (Kurt Russell) and Childs (Keith David) sit amongst the burning remains of their scientific research outpost. With many theories as to who is infected (most people conclude it must be Childs) the uncertainty makes the film all the more chilling, with many eagerly anticipating a sequel which wasn't to be. One scene - left out of the final cut - removes this ambiguity altogether, showing a dog running away from the burning camp at the end of the film. Most people agree that leaving this out was a very wise decision on the part of Carpenter - not knowing whether or not the alien had survived made this downbeat ending work so much better. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Xu2cFljkPw What other deleted scenes would have ruined their movies? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Andrew Dilks hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.