10 Deleted Scenes That Explain Confusing Star Trek Moments
So where did Nero go for 25 years?!
Like all major Hollywood franchises, Star Trek's history is full of what-ifs and alternate versions of episodes and movies we never got to see.
We've been treated to director's cuts of Star Trek: The Motion Picture, The Wrath of Khan, and The Undiscovered Country, as well as extended episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation released when that series was remastered for blu-ray. Still, there exists numerous other missing scenes or deleted material for extended editions and ultimate cuts that will likely never see the light of day.
Some of these deleted scenes are just fun additions (Kirk skydiving in Star Trek Generations, anyone?) and still others would explain points of confusion and mysteries that have cropped up over the films and episodes . With that in mind, here are 10 mysteries from Star Trek films and television episodes and the deleted scenes that explain them all away.
10. Star Trek Generations - Soran Tortures Geordi
The Mystery:
What did Soran mean when he told the Duras Sisters Geordi's "heart just wasn't in it" after they captured LaForge in Star Trek Generations?
The Deleted Scene:
Likely deleted to retain the family friendly PG rating, a torture scene was filmed but ultimately removed from Star Trek Generations that featured Soran torturing a captured Geordi LaForge.
While the scene in the theatrical cut ends with LaForge strapped to a table and Soran asking him about trilithium, the sequence was meant to continue and show Soran attempting to find out exactly what the crew of the Enterprise-D knows about his plan and what, if anything, Guinan told them about his past. While LaForge keeps his answers technical, Soran isn't satisfied and uses a Borg nanoprobe to stop Geordi's heart to motivate the engineer to talk.
The torture apparently still doesn't work, but Soran has heart jokes. He tells LaForge in the deleted scene he can tell Geordi has "a good heart" and later, in the theatrical cut, there's the whole "his heart just wasn't in it" line. Also in the final cut, Doctor Crusher can later be heard telling Geordi she's removed the nanoprobe and that she thinks he's going to be fine. Tough guy that LaForge.
9. Star Trek: Discovery - Welcome To Section 31
The Mystery:
What were those black badges in "Context is For Kings" and how did Georgiou end up in Section 31 after she slunk away at the end of Star Trek: Discovery Season One?
The Deleted Scene:
This was shot as part of Star Trek: Discovery's first season finale "Will You Hold My Hand?" and actually released as a "bonus scene" online a month after the episode aired.
Set some time after the events of that episode, Mirror Universe Georgiou is running a cabaret on Qo'noS where she's approached by Alan Van Sprang's Leland to join Starfleet's secret police, Section 31. Disguised as a Trill, Leland (who would go on to be a recurring character in season two) offers Georgiou a black badge and welcomes her to Section 31.
These badges first appeared on Discovery at the beginning of the first season in "Context is For Kings" and even commented upon, but their significance was never explained. This deleted bonus scene finally provides fans that answer as well as clear motivation for why Georgiou joined up with Section 31. As Leland says, Georgiou can either keep her day job selling lap dances or help shape galactic affairs – an irresistible offer for the former Emperor of the Terran Empire.
By the third episode of Discovery's second season, Georgiou is already deep in Section 31, playing spy with Leland. This deleted bonus scene puts that into context and would've been a useful inclusion in the first season proper.
8. Star Trek (2009) - Kobayashi Maru Virus
The Mystery:
Just exactly how did Cadet Kirk reprogram the Kobayashi Maru simulation?
The Deleted Scene:
In Star Trek (2009) as it was released in theaters, Rachel Nichols' Orion Cadet Gaila is just a pretty girl Kirk has seduced to show what a bad boy he is. However the filmmakers intended this flirtation to connect to the subsequent Kobayashi Maru scene with deleted material showing that Kirk was actually using Gaila to reprogram the simulation.
During the make out sesh, Kirk tells Gaila he's written her a love letter which she has to open the next day precisely at 3 o'clock. Later, Gaila goes to her console in the Kobayashi Maru simulator control room and opens Kirk's note only to have the email trigger a computer virus that affects the simulation and allows Kirk to beat the so-called no-win scenario.
Not only does this explain exactly how Kirk cheated, it also explains why Gaila's in the background during the court martial scene, staring daggers at Kirk.
The storyline is continued in additional deleted footage in which Kirk apologizes to an Orion crew member aboard the Enterprise that he mistakenly believes is Gaila. Which is actually just kind of icky and definitely better it didn't make it into the film, even if the other Gaila scenes might've been useful.
7. Star Trek Nemesis - The Crushers
The Mystery:
What was Wesley Crusher doing at Riker and Troi's wedding and where did Beverly go?
The Deleted Scene:
Rightly hated by fans and non-fans alike, Star Trek Nemesis favors underwhelming action set pieces (a pointless dune buggy chase, a protracted space battle) over the characters its supposed to be bidding farewell to.
Still, tons of footage was shot to tie up the Enterprise crew's arcs only to be cut from the film. Much of this footage is simple but useful character development: Picard and Data musing over the passage of time; Riker, Troi, and Worf sharing a meal in Ten Forward; Worf expressing his long held suspicion of the Romulans. But other material actually explained what happened to these people and gave both Wesley and Beverly Crusher something of a send off.
Set immediately after Picard's toast at Riker and Troi's wedding, material deleted from the film actually gives Wil Wheaton's Wesley Crusher dialogue. In it, he reveals he's off to join Riker and Troi on the USS Titan and Picard comments on seeing Wesley back in Starfleet. The exchange doesn't actually explain why Wesley and the Traveler broke up, but it's at least an acknowledgment of the last time we saw the former acting ensign. And hey, Wil Wheaton gets a few lines after an eight year absence from the franchise rather than the glorified background role he has in the final cut.
Wesley's mother, Beverly, is treated just slightly better in Star Trek Nemesis but she still just up and disappears before the film's conclusion without explanation. That explanation was included in a deleted scene that showed Beverly had departed the Enterprise-E and was now head of Starfleet Medical. Might've been a nice conclusion for a character who often had nothing to do when she wasn't having sex with a candle ghost.
6. Star Trek Nemesis - Spot's New Owner
The Mystery:
What happened to Data's cat?
The Deleted Scene:
Audiences probably weren't too worried about Spot after Data exploded during the climax of Star Trek Nemesis, but the cat did appear in the film and his/her (depending on what episode you watch) fate then went unexplained.
Along with Beverly Crusher, the final film simply ignores what happened to Worf, LaForge, and yes Data's cat after the Android gave his life for his ship and crew. A deleted scene was shot that showed a grieving Worf and LaForge sort through Data's old things in his quarters.
The scene featured several easter eggs from the course of Data's life (his Sherlock Holmes pipe from TNG, his sailor's hat from Star Trek Generations) and showed Worf adopting Spot. In itself a callback to the time Worf cared for Spot in the episode "Phantasms", this might've been the kind of cute note the film could've used in an otherwise dreary slog. And we could've had a moment to say goodbye to Worf, LaForge, and, yes, Spot.
5. Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country - Operation Retrieve
The Mystery:
Who was the Klingon Scotty shot in the climax of Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country?
The Deleted Scene:
Immediately following the capture of Kirk and McCoy, a deleted scene would've featured Starfleet's Colonel West (played by DS9's René Auberjonois) briefing the Federation President on a rescue mission called "Operation Retrieve". While the president rebuffs Starfleet's plan, Colonel West makes one more appearance in the film: he's the Klingon Scotty shoots and kills during the film's climax. Following the Klingon's death, a deleted moment showed Colonel Worf ripping off the Klingon's mask to reveal Colonel West in a very Scooby Doo-ish moment.
These scenes were actually previously included in the VHS and DVD releases of Star Trek VI before being omitted from the blu-ray and digital versions that are now widely available. But they expanded the conspiracy to include rank and file Starfleet officers and not just Lieutenant Valeris, Admiral Cartwright, and several mustache-twirling Klingons.
There are plenty of other deleted moments like this in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country that were included in Nick Meyer's 2004 DVD director's cut, the biggest mystery is why Paramount hasn't made these available in high def formats...
4. Star Trek (2009) - Kirk's Childhood
The Mystery:
Where did young James T. Kirk get a 200 year old antique car?
The Deleted Scene:
This scene actually explains a lot about the Kelvin Timeline's Kirk and how the death of his father (who survived in the Prime Universe) affected his life. It also gives a little more context as for why, in the theatrical cut, we see young Jimmy absconding with a 200 year old Corvette and rocking out to 200 year old hip hop.
In the deleted scene, young Jimmy Kirk is caught between his brother, George, and his uncle, Frank, engaged in a shouting match. Jimmy tries to stop him, but George runs away, telling Jimmy that he's the good brother – the one who gets good grades and is good at taking orders. After George leaves, Uncle Frank demands that Jimmy wash his late father's car, which he does, until he finds the keys and decides to do something rebellious.
In the finished film, we drop in after this scene has taken place and while George makes a brief appearance, he's referred to as "Johnny" and likely no longer intended to be related to Kirk.
Nevertheless, this deleted material refers back to Star Trek: The Original Series and its depiction of Kirk as a studious young man and not the rebel without a cause as seen in JJ Abrams' reboot flick. Here, we find out that after the death of his father, Kirk's home life is a mess, his brother runs away, and while he was a good kid, these events pushed him to be the "genius-level repeat offender" we see played by Chris Pine later in the film.
3. Star Trek II: The Wrath Of Khan - Peter Preston
The Mystery:
Who was the crewman who died in Scotty's arms in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan?
The Deleted Scene:
In the theatrical version of Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, the young officer who Kirk meets in the engine room and later appears charred and near death in Scotty's arms after the initial battle with Khan is just that, some young officer. However, deleted material included a bit of dialogue explaining that young midshipman Peter Preston is actually Scotty's nephew. This further explains why Scotty would be so devastated by Preston's injuries in the battle that he would haul his body to the bridge to shock everyone, rather than immediately take the kid to see Doctor McCoy.
The scene is contained in Nick Meyer's director's cut that is actually available in both blu-ray and digital formats, unlike the other extended cuts of Star Trek films which remain, sadly, unreleased in high def.
2. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine - Why The Prophets Chose Sisko
The Mystery:
Why did the Prophets choose Commander Sisko to be their Emissary in DS9's "Emissary"?
The Deleted Scene:
One of the few actually useful deleted scenes from a television episode, this scene was intended for Star Trek: Deep Space Nine's pilot episode but cut for time.
In it, Sisko would have returned to Bajor to meet with Kai Opaka after his experiences with the wormhole aliens aka the Prophets. Opaka would've explained to Sisko that the Prophets chose a non-believer and a human to be their Emissary because "one should never look into the eyes of one's own gods".
The line would go on to be repurposed in the season finale, "In the Hands of the Prophets", but it would've had much more impact if it had stayed in the pilot. It's the perfect encapsulation of Sisko's relationship with the Prophets and while the show went on to expand on that dynamic, nothing is as concise or reasonable as this deleted explanation would've been.
1. Star Trek (2009) - Klingon Prison Planet
The Mystery:
What were Nero and the crew of the Narada doing for 25 years? Why didn't they just repair their ship and immediately head to Vulcan to destroy it?
The Deleted Scene:
In the most interested material deleted from Star Trek (2009), after the Narada is disabled by the USS Kelvin, the ship is surrounded by a fleet of Klingon warbirds. Following the 25 year jump, it's revealed that the Klingons have captured Nero and his crew and held them on their prison planet, Rura Penthe. When the Klingons discover Nero's notes and calculations, they realize he's from the future and offer to help him in exchange for information about the Federations' weaknesses.
Victor Garber plays the helmeted Klingon interrogating Nero and informing the audience about Nero's objective and motivations. He also introduces Nero to the Centaurian slug which Nero would later use on Captain Pike. Before the Klingon's can get information out of him, Nero attacks them, releases Ayel, and the scene cuts away.
The next time we see Nero and the Narada, they're just in time for Spock to arrive in the 23rd century via black hole. Uhura later states that the Narada had attacked the prison planet and destroyed 47 Klingon warbirds, but the Klingons and Rura Penthe remain off camera in the final cut of Star Trek (2009), arguably to the film's detriment.