10 Most Desirable Girlfriends In Comic Book Movies

Well, a guy can dream, can't he?

If you€™re a woman in a comic book movie, then the only thing more hazardous to your health than living in a major metropolitan city is drawing the eye of the local superheroes. Once you fall in love with a superhero, that usually leads to a whole host of problems to deal with. We€™re talking about an unavailable partner always making up lame excuses for why he€™s late or missing, staying up nights wondering if he€™ll come home, and being the target of ruthless supervillains who will kidnap you and put your life in jeopardy. There€™s also those awkward chats with his alien ghost dad. The €œdamsel in distress€ trope has existed in centuries of heroic myths, and it€™s continued on into the modern day. Unfortunately, it has also led to some extremely dreadful portrayals of great female characters, some of which we€™ve covered in the past. But this time, we€™re going to flip the lens around and have a look at the other side of the spectrum. This isn€™t about those comic movie girlfriends who make you root for the villain to win, this is about the women who are great characters in their own right and serve as more than just something for the villain to dangle over the hero€™s head...

10. Lois Lane (Margot Kidder) €“ Superman: The Movie

Margot Kidder€™s Lois Lane kind of falls somewhere in the middle territory. She doesn€™t do a whole lot in the Superman movies to help advance the plot or to aid Superman in any way and she frequently does end up as the damsel in distress. But that being said, Kidder does get a pass because of her overall portrayal. Right from the opening scene, we€™re introduced to Lois as a motormouth, confidant reporter, who also has the amusing tendency of being an absolutely terrible speller. She€™s got virtually every single person at the Daily Planet fawning over her, including the hero. Lois proves herself when after leaving the Planet with Clark, they€™re attacked by a mugger. Here, it€™s Lois who plays the role of defiant hero, kicking their attacker and proving she€™s not one to put up with any crap (it almost gets her shot, but fortunately Clark is there to help her). While she does get a bit too schoolgirlish in the presence of Superman, Margot Kidder still set the stage for the other women on this list and deserves mention if for no other reason than that.

9. Sarah Ross (Mary Louise Parker) €“ RED

RED may not be a superhero movie, but it is based on a comic book. Albeit extremely loosely based on a comic book, but that€™s good enough to get it on this list. Sarah Ross is nothing more than a customer service agent working at a pension office, and her most frequent caller is Frank Moses. What Sarah doesn€™t know is that Frank is a retired CIA agent, and that he creates opportunities to talk to her by tearing up his pension checks and saying they never arrived. Of course, that all changes when a CIA hit squad is sent after Frank and he kidnaps Sarah for her own good. RED was a light-hearted, fun romp with its tongue planted dead-center in its cheek. And a lot of those fun moments came from Mary-Louise Parker€™s portrayal of Sarah. Going from unwitting (but witty) kidnapping victim to energized participant was a great transition, and her charm and humor is good enough to have her contend with the rest of the cast. No easy feat when your co-stars include A-list talent like Helen Mirren, John Malkovich and Morgan Freeman.

8. Rachel Dawes (Maggie Gyllenhaal) €“ The Dark Knight

We mentioned Rachel Dawes as one of the most annoying, but that was a different actress. Katie Holmes, who played Rachel in Batman Begins, declined to reprise the role in The Dark Knight so that she could Mad Money instead. Although it€™s a decision Holmes likely regrets, for the fans it was a blessing. Because out of that, we got Maggie Gyllenhaal to replace her. In the Nolan Batman films, Rachel Dawes was this ideal woman Bruce aspired to be with, but unfortunately, no one in the theater during Batman Begins could understand what exactly it was that Bruce saw in her. Gyllenhaal provided that answer. Her Rachel was just as smart and gutsy as Gordon, Dent, and Bruce, not afraid to take chances. After Harvey is attacked in the courtroom by one of Maroni€™s goons, he€™s the one who is more shaken up about it than Rachel, who just quips that €œif you€™re not getting shot at, you€™re not doing your job right.€ Unfortunately, Rachel did end up a victim of the Joker. But at the very least, Gyllenhaal made her a far more memorable character than she had been by the end of Batman Begins.

7. Betty Ross (Jennifer Connelly) €“ Hulk

Ang Lee€™s Hulk has been raked over the coals many times since its release, and is sometimes compared unfavorably with its successor, 2008€™s The Incredible Hulk reboot that brought the green giant into the Marvel Cinematic Universe. And though The Incredible Hulk did do some things better than Hulk, one aspect it did not get better was in the portrayal of Betty Ross. Jennifer Connelly is an extremely talented actress, and casting her as Betty Ross was probably the second-best decision that casting director made (the first was getting Sam Elliott to play her father, Thunderbolt Ross). They made some changes to Betty€™s character, turning her into a scientist instead of just the daughter of a general, and it was a change that worked. Connelly€™s Ross provides an emotional rock for Bruce to anchor himself to. She avoids the traps that her successor, Liv Tyler, fell into, never once devolving into a hysterical fit of crying. Betty remains a solid figure throughout the entire film, and many of the best scenes in the movie are those with her. It€™s a shame that the stigma of the film prevented us from getting another performance as Betty out of Connelly.

6. Karen Jenson (N'Bushe Wright) €“ Blade

Considering what a huge impact the first Blade film had on the comic book movie (essentially reviving it after Batman & Robin killed it with camp), it€™s kind of amazing how much the movie has been swept under the rug. Even within the world of the Blade films, we never get another mention of N€™Bushe Wright€™s Karen Jenson, a hematologist who gets dragged into this seedy underworld of monsters after she€™s bitten by a vampire and rescued by Blade. A stereotypical damsel character would have probably freaked out in this situation, or been reduced to arm-candy there only for expository purposes and so the villain has someone to threaten. Instead, Karen accepts that vampires exist and devotes herself to finding out a way to fix her situation, while also having the guts to walk right into the vampire€™s den alongside Blade with only a fraction of his arsenal and not a single bit of his training or powers. Karen serves a role almost equal to Whistler, perhaps a bit more. She€™s the one who devises a way to not only help Blade deal with the growing threat of his vampire site, but also devises a method that proves to be the undoing of Deacon Frost. The first film seemed to set up Karen to take over Whistler€™s old role, but unfortunately we never got a single mention of her in the sequels.

5. Knives Chau (Ellen Wong) €“ Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World

In the previous article, we put down Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World€™s Ramona Flowers as one of the most annoying girlfriends. It€™s interesting to note here that the original ending for the film (shot before the final issue of the comic was released) had Michael Cera€™s Scott end up not with Mary-Elizabeth Winstead€™s Ramona, but rather Knives Chau, played excellently by Ellen Wong. Knives is introduced in the movie as Scott€™s high school girlfriend, and while this does border a bit on creepy for Scott, Wong helps bring the character to life and it becomes a bit heartbreaking when Scott cheats on her to be with Ramona. Snubbed, Knives cuts her hair, dyes it blue, and swears revenge. Knives goes from sweet, innocent, naive high school girl to vengeance-driven, but then we see that innocence come back when she goes fangirl in Envy€™s presence. She even comes to Scott€™s defense against Gideon (even though he clearly doesn€™t deserve it), and proves to be more than capable with the weapons she€™s named after. The biggest problem with Knives is why would she even be interested in Scott to begin with, when he€™s far below her level. In that way, maybe it€™s best that the ending was changed and Scott ended up with Ramona.

4. Selina Kyle (Anne Hathaway) €“ The Dark Knight Rises

The Dark Knight Rises had its fair share of problems, many of which we€™ve documented before. One of those problems, however, was not the addition of Anne Hathaway€™s portrayal of Selina Kyle. As fans of the Batman comics are already very familiar with, Catwoman is an important character in the mythos. She straddles the line between hero and villain, shares a mutual attraction with the Caped Crusader, and can stand up both to him and any villains that come his way. Hathaway beautifully captured the essence of Selina in both the physical (not only because of her stunning looks but because her movements were exactly what we€™d picture from Catwoman) but also the emotional. We see Selina torn between her attraction to Bruce and doing what€™s right and doing what€™s profitable for her. The Dark Knight Rises was criticized for its lack of humor, but what levity we do get is rendered perfectly by Selina. She never falls into the damsel trap, being used as bait by Bane and Talia. Instead, it€™s Selina who has to come to Batman€™s rescue by taking out Bane. Now that Nolan€™s films are finished and Warner Bros. Are moving ahead on a cinematic DC universe that will reboot Batman, it€™s unlikely that we€™ll see Hathaway get another chance to reprise her role as Catwoman. That€™s a pity, because Hathaway brought a lot to the character and she€™ll be a hard act to follow.

3. Mariko Yashida (Tao Okamoto) €“ The Wolverine

Tao Okamoto had a rough road ahead of her when she was cast as Mariko Yashida in The Wolverine. Not only was she playing one of the most important superhero love interests, but this was also her debut in the world of film. In the comics, Mariko was the daughter of Lord Shingen, who had turned the Clan Yashida into a criminal empire. After Shingen was killed by Wolverine, Mariko and Logan were briefly engaged before intervention by a supervillain drove them apart. From then, Mariko dedicated herself to ridding her family of the criminal influence her father had corrupted it with, becoming a fierce warrior in her own right. Okamoto€™s portrayal of Mariko was perfectly in line with the comics. Although she does have a few damsel-esque moments, for the most part Mariko becomes a huge help to Logan throughout the course of their journey together, and she proves capable of handling herself in many scenes, being a trained knife-thrower. Although Mariko is eventually killed in the comics by Wolverine€™s enemies, that fate has thankfully not occurred in the end of The Wolverine. And with a third Wolverine film in the works, we just might see Okamoto return for a repeat performance as Logan€™s true love.

2. Peggy Carter (Haley Atwell) €“ Captain America: The First Avenger

Peggy Carter not only served a crucial role in Captain America: The First Avenger, but she also received a cameo in The Winter Soldier, a Marvel One-Shot movie dedicated to her, she€™ll appear in Avengers: Age of Ultron, and now the rumor mill is she€™ll get her own television series. Not bad at all for a character who hasn€™t had a fraction of that amount of exposure in the comics in which she was created. And a lot of that is due to Haley Atwell€™s mesmerizing performance. As a member of the Strategic Scientific Reserve, Carter proved herself to be just as capable as her male compatriots, even more so. She doesn€™t take any crap from the soldiers around her, literally knocking a mouthy pervert the first time we see her. Carter is never the damsel, always viewed as an equal to both Cap and the rest of the Howling Commandoes. Despite her gorgeous looks, she gets just as down and dirty as the rest of them. And in the Agent Carter one-shot, she takes on a mission intended for three to five agents and completes it solo. Carter has already started to break out of the €œCaptain America€™s girlfriend€ role and if the TV show does happen, guarantee that she€™ll be known on her own terms.

1. Gwen Stacy (Emma Stone) €“ The Amazing Spider-Man

WARNING: This entry contains spoilers for The Amazing Spider-Man 2. Proceed at your own risk. Let€™s just get this out of the way right now - if you do not love Emma Stone, there is something wrong with you. In role after role, she has exuded charm, intelligence, and wit. Nowhere was this put on better display than as her role as Gwen Stacy in The Amazing Spider-Man films. Fans are divided on whether The Amazing Spider-Man reboot films are better than the preceding trilogy directed by Sam Raimi. At the least when it comes to the portrayal of Peter Parker€™s love interests, the reboot ranks far above that of the Raimi films. Whereas Kirsten Dunst€™s Mary Jane was a shallow character whose only purpose was to be threatened by the villains, Stone€™s Gwen is a genius on the level of Peter. Consistent with the comics, Gwen is an intelligent young woman, and in fact her knowledge of science sometimes surpasses that of Peter€™s. She isn€™t just bait for the hero, but rather she€™s a valuable asset. If not for Gwen€™s help in both films, Spider-Man wouldn€™t have been able to triumph against either the Lizard or Electro. But as fans of the comics are painfully aware, any time Gwen Stacy appears in a movie, the clock begins ticking. One of the most controversial and important stories not only for Spider-Man but for all of comics was €œThe Night Gwen Stacy Died.€ And unfortunately, that story was loosely adapted in The Amazing Spider-Man 2. Like this article? Agree or disagree with our picks? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Percival Constantine is the author of several novels and short stories, including the Vanguard superhero series, and regularly writes and comments on movies, comics, and other pop culture. More information can be found at his website, PercivalConstantine.com