10 Directors Who Should Helm The X-Men Reboot

The gifted individuals who could rescue the fading franchise...

Joss Whedon XMen
Fox

Reboot.

It's a word that conjure mix feelings amongst film fans. Sometimes it means a tired series could be revitalised, working for the series like Bond, The Planet of the Apes and Batman. But it could also be seen as a cynical attempt by a studio desperate to keep the rights to property, i.e. Sony and FOX's approach to the Spider-Man and Fantastic Four franchises.

There are now rumours that FOX are considering rebooting the X-Men series after X-Men: Apocalypse underperformed at the box office and with critics. Plus a straight continuation looks unlikely because Michael Fassbender, Jennifer Lawrence and James McAvoy's contracts have come to end and they have stated that either all three return to the series or none of them do. And then of course there's the small matter of Hugh Jackman and Patrick Stewart are also set to call it a day with their X-Men roles with 2017's Logan being their last appearance as Wolverine and Charles Xavier respectively.

Seeing that the X-Men series will be heading towards a new direction lets look at 10 filmmakers who would this popular property and take on their society. It could be soft reboot within the same continuity featuring a younger cast, a dark interpretation looking at social themes of the X-Men or be more like its contemporaries such as the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

10. Duncan Jones

Warcraft Movie Duncan Jones Travis Fimmel
Universal Pictures

Since the release of Moon back in 2009 Duncan Jones has become an in-demand director, making Source Code and was linked to Man of Steel before making Warcraft. Moon was a terrific debut, a deliberate throwback to sci-fi films from the '70s that aimed to thoughtful rather than just be about grand spectacle - not that it was without big special effects moments, using traditional model work over CGI.

Both his sci-fi films were character driven and ambitious, characteristics that any potential X-Men reboot. The best X-Men movies are focused on the character relationships and some of the most intense moments are not necessarily the action ones. Jones could match the best emotional moments that Bryan Singer, Matthew Vaughn and James Mangold were able to provide.

Jones' films have been on the serious and Warcraft was his first skirmish into a more a light-hearted storytelling, an approach that some X-Men fans have been calling. Even though Warcraft was a hot mess of a film, requiring the Chinese market to make it profitable there were virtues to the film, namely showing the Orcs in a complicated light and the motion capture. That was at least a useful experience to show the different ideologies within the X-Men universe and mutant super powers.

Jones' next film is a sci-fi thriller for Netflix but film fans would be want to see him direct another major franchise.


9. Alex Garland

68th Annual Directors Guild Of America Awards - Show Alex Garland
2016 Getty Images

Alex Garland is a novelist and screenwriter turned director and hiring him would be a bold statement by FOX because he is one of the best writers around. Garland has become known for writing popular genre films, his credits include 28 Days Later, Sunshine and Dredd - films that have earned cult status because of their intelligent storytelling and great thrills.

Garland also wrote the adaptation of Kazuo Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go, a story that has some transferable elements to the X-Men series. Never Let Me Go was set in an alternative version of Britain where there is an underclass of clones who are educated to be nothing more than organ donors, kept subservient for the rest of humanity. Garland could easily do something similar with the X-Men, showing that they are willing to protect a hates and fears them.

Garland also had great success adapting Judge Dredd to film, using a simple day-in-the-life narrative like Training Day to how horrific life is in Mega City One where crime and riots are rampant: the judges are only able to response to 6% of incidents and people in the profession have a low life expectancy. He showed a love for the source material, helping make an unabashedly violent sci-fi film that's not made enough of these days. Fans of the comics loved it and want a sequel of some sort.

His directional debut was Ex Machina, a taut, Kubrickian style sci-fi thriller about the creation of artificial intelligence. It used its limited setting to great effect as three characters in a claustrophobic environment play mindgames with each other in their battle for survival. It helped make Alicia Vikander popular with genre audiences and she would be a great choice to play Jean Grey.


8. Neill Blomkamp

Actress Neill Blomkamp arrives at the world premiere of
Jordan Strauss/AP

Since their inception, the X-Men have been a metaphor for oppressed minorities. The comics were originally written during the Civil Rights Movement whilst the films turned mutation into an allegory about gay rights and issues. South African filmmaker Neill Blomkamp has become known for making sci-fi films with a political edge. He made a great debut with District 9, a film where aliens land in Johannesburg and segregated from the rest of society in a commentary about the policy of Apartheid.

It's a template for an X-Men film to follow, looking at the various forms of discrimination mutants face despite being much more powerful than the rest of humanity. Blomkamp's follow-up film Elysium was also politically themed, although it was as subtle as a brick with its look at immigration and healthcare provision in the distance future.

District 9 looked incredible for its $30 Million budget and turned it Sharlto Copley into a star. Blomkamp certainly can provide the special effects action fans would want and properly have a lot of fun with the mutant superpowers - he gave audiences the fun of a pig armed rocket launcher in District 9.

Blomkamp is currently attached to a continuation of the Alien series which is currently on hold - however, his style of sci-fi would be appropriate for the X-Men series, mixing a grounded and gritty look, huge action sequences and a willingness to tackle political themes.


7. The Spierig Brothers

Daybreakers Ethan Hawke
Lionsgate

Born in Germany and raised in Australia, Peter and Michael Spierig are twin brothers who are writers, directors and visual effects artists, best known for the vampire flick Daybreakers and time travel mystery Predestination. They have built a reputation for elaborate world building and complex storytelling, perfect experience for the X-Men series.

Their work on Daybreakers serves as the best example of what they could do with the X-Men series, a unique vampire film that shows vampires achieving world domination - but at the cost their potential survival because of a dwindling food supply, i.e. human blood.

The Spierig Brothers created a world in crisis as riots happen around the world, food prices are rising and there was a moral dilemma regarding what the government should do with devolved vampires that could become a burden on society.

This complex world building could easily be transferred to the X-Men, showing a tapestry of warring factions like the X-Men, The Brotherhood of Mutants, Mister Sinister's Marauders, governmental elements involving Senator Kelly and Bolivar Trask and hate groups like Friends of Humanity. The Spierig Brothers would be perfectly capable of creating a new universe involving the mutants.

Daybreakers also looked impressive for a film made with $20 Million budget, looking far more expensive. They could easily step up to a big budget blockbuster. The Spierig Brothers are currently working on a reboot of The Saw franchise, but their talents would be better served with a superhero franchise that has a lot more story potential.


6. Jake Schrier

Robot And Frank
Samuel Goldwyn Films

It has reported that FOX and producers were interested in making an X-Men film centred around younger characters. The OC and Chuck's Josh Schwartz was hired to write a screenplay based on the X-Men: First Class comic book series and considered to direct before it evolved into the 2011 prequel. The Fault in Our Stars' Josh Boone has also linked to writing a spin-off based on the New Mutants comics.

If FOX does plan to make a reboot starring a younger cast then a filmmaker like Jake Schrier should be considered. He has shown his ability with sci-fi with his debut Robot & Frank, a smart, indie film set in near future that was praised by critics where a retired burglar is given a robot helper. His follow-up Paper Towns was an adaptation of a John Green novel, focusing on a group of high school seniors searching a classmate who deliberately disappears.

Schrier is a young, emerging director who studios would want to tap up for a big project. He has enough experience to make a bigger budgeted film and he can combine his sci-fi story and a teenage drama/coming-of-age drama in the world of the X-Men.


5. J. A. Bayona

ja bayona
wikipedia

Spanish director Juan Antonio Bayona, usually known as J. A. Bayona has an impressive filmography, making The Orphanage, The Impossible and the upcoming A Monster Calls. His reputation has led him to be linked to big projects like The Twilight Saga: Eclipse and the World War Z sequel and currently attached to the Jurassic World sequel. However, working on the X-Men would be better suited to Bayona's talents.

As a director Bayona has focused on personal, emotional films, The Orphanage and A Monster Calls centred on the theme of lost. Whilst Bayona has a good dramatic grounding it's his work on The Impossible that makes him a great candidate for the X-Men, showing the Spaniard was able to the story of the family trying to reunite after being separated by disaster and showing the impact of the 2004 Tsunami in Thailand.

Any director of the X-Men would need balance the personal stories of the heroes and villains and the show the wider universe.

His work on A Monster Calls (which is currently been praised on the festival circuit) shows that Bayona can handle CGI sequences, bringing to live a huge tree monster that boomed and crashed around everywhere it went. He could certainly show a large amount of destruction a mutant fight can bring to a city.


4. Denis Villeneuve

Enemy Denis Villeneuve
A24 Films

Québécois filmmaker Denis Villeneuve has quickly risen to become one of the most critically acclaimed directors around, having made a splash with his English language films Prisoners, Sicario and Arrival. Villeneuve has shown that he is a genre hopper of a director, all his movies are different.

Prisoners was a dark and twisted mystery about a father pushed to the edge, Sicario, a violent crime thriller that showed what Villeneuve with action and recently earned praise for his most recent film Arrival, getting a 93% Rotten Tomatoes rating.

Arrival took the most realistic approach to the idea first contact and there was a lot of spectacle and grandeur and it takes a special kind of talent for someone to make a film about linguistics compelling. Villeneuve has confidence with big special effects and his work on Prisoners and Enemy shows he can handle complicated plots and character relationships - useful skills for anyone directing an X-Men film.

Villeneuve is also a fan of the sci-fi genre, his next film is the sequel to Blade Runner which seems a lot more promising because of his work on Arrival and he was considered to direct Terminator Genisys before Alan Taylor got the job. Villeneuve has also stated he would like to direct a Bond film. It is easy to imagine that studios would want him to start one of their franchises.


3. Joss Whedon

US film director Joss Whedon attends a press conference in Italy
© THIERRY PRONESTI/ANSA/Corbis

With Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel, Firefly and the first Avengers film to his credit Joss Whedon is a fan favourite and has earned a reputation for his ability to subvert genres whilst also showing respect toward them. He is also known for his witty lines and smart storylines in his work and having a love for strong female characters. Considering what he had made fans would love to him make the X-Men reboot.

As well as making some major film and TV staples Whedon has also been a comic writer and one of his most well-known works was the Astonishing X-Men series. In his series, Whedon brought together some famous mutants who reformed the X-Men, brought one famous mutant back to life and fight threats like an alien race who fear a mutant would destroy their world, The Hellfire Club and a robot that formed with the Danger Room.

The most famous storyline during his run was the Gifted storyline where a scientist creates a 'cure' for the mutant gene. FOX did approach him to direct X-Men: The Last Stand which used the Gifted storyline but he turned them down.

Whedon has been burnt with his superhero experience, he had pressure from Marvel Studios to make a sequel to Captain America: The Winter Soldier and set up the films of Phrase Three. The film ended up collapsing under its own weight, Whedon turned the opportunity to make Avengers: Infinity Wars and quit Twitter.

FOX's reputation for studio interference can at times be worst but if they are smart enough to let Whedon have a lot of creative control over the X-Men reboot then they could be onto a winner.

Whedon would be able to bring some colour and humour to the mutant team and handle a film with a large cast of characters.


2. Edgar Wright

The World's End Edgar Wright
Universal

Edgar Wright is a popular figure with fanboy and fangirl audiences and many would love to see him direct a superhero film. He has already adapted the cult comic book series Scott Pilgrim vs. the World and co-wrote The Adventures of Tintin: The Secret of the Unicorn with Steven Moffat and Joe Cornish. He was famously linked to direct Ant-Man before creative differences with Marvel Studios led to a parting of ways.

Wright is a fan of genre cinema, Shaun of the Dead and Hot Fuzz loving mick-take of the zombie and buddy cop genres, making fun of tropes whilst also embracing them. Some fans of the X-Men comics would want to see the films to take a lighter tone and Wright would bring a colourful, comic book look to the films.

Wright is also one of the best action directors around and deserves the opportunity to make a big budget blockbuster. He could make some truly terrific superhero fights if given the chance.


1. Matthew Vaughn

Matthew Vaughn X-Men set
20th Century Fox

Iconic, that perhaps the best filmmaker to reboot the X-Men is the man who already has rebooted the X-Men, Matthew Vaughn. Vaughn famously took over the X-Men series after the first trilogy ended with The Last Stand and X-Men Origins: Wolverine bombed with fans.

He was tasked to do a soft-reboot in the form of a prequel and despite the rushed production schedule and FOX's lack of interest in the reboot - the lacklustre marketing campaign was a testament to that - Vaughn made what is debatably the best X-Men film: it's certainly in the top three.

The body of Vaughn's filmography has been comic book adaptations - it includes Kick-Ass, Kingsman: The Secret Service and of course X-Men: First Class. This has made him into a fan favourite because of his respect for the source material and has a sweet spot which has delivered films that are colourful and fun, while also have moments of emotional sincerity and darkness.

First Class was in keeping with this style, having the comic book look visuals with is colour pallet, editing, costumes and set design whilst also having a dark revenge storyline involving Magneto hunting the Nazi scientists who experimented on him.

Fans want to see more of this approach for the X-Men films and Vaughn would be a wise choice whether the reboot is soft or hard. He is one of FOX's premier directors, having already directed First Class and Kingsman: The Secret Service and Kingsman: The Golden Circle is coming out next year. If it's a hard reboot Vaughn would have a clean slate to craft the X-Men into his image.

Vaughn could do what Martin Campbell did the Bond series: save a series twice.


Contributor

Kieran Freemantle hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.