10 Directors Whose Debut Movie Ended Their Careers

One and done.

Sky Captain And The World Of Tomorrow
Paramount

Directing isn't for everyone, in the same way that being an astronaut, or opening a little patisserie, or going outside and socialising with other human beings isn't for everyone, either.

Sometimes we have to stop and remember that there are things that will always remain beyond our reach, no matter how hard we try.

There are some film fanatics out there so determined to become movie directors that they actually found a way to do it, only to late realise that they totally sucked and should stop forever, or somebody else realised that they totally sucked and made them stop forever...

10. Joe Alves - Jaws 3-D (1983)

Jaws 3d
Paramount

Joe Alves sounds like a cool guy. He probably takes his family on awesome vacations, says funny things at barbecues, and isn't afraid to tell amusing anecdotes about that crazy time he somehow ended up directing Jaws 3-D.

No offence to Mr. Alves, who is now in his 80s and continued working in the industry doing other odd jobs 'til 2000, but man... what were you thinking when you delivered this bucket of chum, Joe?

Not only is Jaws 3-D the worst movie in the incredibly dodgy Jaws canon, but it's the kind of movie in which - having seen it - you casually mention to your friend that "the person who directed that movie should never be able to direct anything ever again."

We're not usually lucky enough that such sweeping statements actually come true, but in this case it thankfully did.


9. Bo Welch - The Cat In The Hat (2003)

Cat In The Hat
Universal Pictures

Of course they hired a guy named Bo Welch to helm the Cat In The Hat movie, because hiring somebody with a name that didn't sound like one that Dr. Seuss himself made up would have been totally insane.

Unfortunately for Mr. Welch, his first and only venture into the realms of directing wouldn't prove itself to be all that great.

The Cat In The Hat is godawful, cemented by the fact that Bo was nominated even nominated for a Razzie for his efforts. In the aftermath of such a calamity, Bo has gone back to doing what he does best, which is not directing movies. He's actually a production designer by day, though, and has worked on movies like Thor and Men In Black 3 since, but also Space Chimps, which is your go-to movie for monkey puns, if you're into that sort of thing.

All we can say to Bo, then, is: keep not directing, and we look forward to you not directing anything else in the future.


8. Pitof - Catwoman (2004)

catwoman halle berry.jpg
Warner Bros.

If you hire somebody who calls themselves "Pitof" to helm your latest big-budget movie blockbuster, you deserve all the bad press, negative reviews and lost revenue that comes to you.

Pitof - blagh - worked in visual effects before some hip new executive presumably thought he should realise his talents with a comic book adaptation. Catwoman was technically his second movie, but since his first - Vidocq - was never released outside France until 2007, I'm counting Catwoman as his debut.

It was an unmitigated disaster, of course, and is frequently cited as one of the worst movies ever made. Rumour has it that another human being has never spoken to Pitof since it got released, and he hasn't ventured back to directing movies ever since.


7. Gordon Willis - Windows (1980)

Windows Poster2
tumblr

Gordon Willis is something of a legend, given that he was the cinematographer on a few small movies like The Godfather and Manhattan - before somebody suggested that he might like to take up directing a movie on his own. The movie was Windows. There's a reason as to why you probably haven't heard of it, of course.

Panned because it apparently succumbed to "homophobic stereotypes about lesbians," (the movie is about a lesbian love affair), Willis' movie was greeted with the kind of reception that might await Hitler should he rise up from his grave and announce that he was "giving World War II another go."

That's to say, Willis never tried directing again, and went back to working as the cinematographer we all know and love, citing Windows as "a mistake."


6. Joel Gallen - Not Another Teen Movie (2001)

Not Another Teen Movie Kiss
Columbia Pictures

Joel Gallen was the guy responsible for giving you a few laughs (but mostly not) when he found himself in the driver's seat for 2001 teen comedy spoof Not Another Teen Movie, which is kind of amusing in places, but also kind of isn't.

Given that it made back its budget four times over, though, Gallen probably could have wormed his way into another director's job (on a Scary Movie or something), but decided directing movies wasn't for him after all. A noble decision, really, given that it probably spared us an ill-judged sequel or something.

According to Gallen, he didn't enjoy the pressures associated with being a bigshot Hollywood filmmaker, and returned to the world he knew best: TV, where he went on to direct stuff for Comedy Central.

Anyway, this guy was responsible for that America: A Tribute to Heroes benefit concert in the aftermath of 9/11, which bagged him an Emmy. So, yeah, lay off.


5. Liam Lynch - Tenacious D: The Pick Of Destiny (2006)

TENACIOUS D Pick Of Destiny
New Line Cinema

Back in 2006, Tenacious D and Jack Black were two things still considered to be pretty cool, so director Liam Lynch - best known for his music videos at the time - must have counted his blessings when Black offered him the chance to direct the Tenacious D movie, subtitled the Pick of Destiny.

Lynch had worked with the D (call them "the D", it's cooler) on their music video for "Tribute" previously, so what, exactly, could go wrong? A lot, apparently, given that Tenacious D: The Pick of Destiny was pretty darn sucky, as it happens.

Can we blame all this on Liam Lynch, though? Perhaps not, but it's easier if we do. To be fair to everyone involved, if you like Tenacious D (ahem - I mean "the D"), then you'll probably find some good in this movie, but it's mostly one-joke stretched out over 90 minutes, and no thanks.

Anyway, Liam Lynch does TV stuff now, because this movie lost $7 million.


4. Alexander Witt - Resident Evil: Apocalypse (2004)

Resident Evil Apocalypse Milla Jovovich
Screen Gems

Alexander Witt has amassed a truly impressive filmography across the span of his lengthy career - he's worked as a second unit director on Gladiator, Fast Five, The Town and Casino Royale, among, like, thirty others. Still, if this guy's work on Resident Evil: Apocalypse as a fully-fledged director doesn't perfectly sum up "The Peter Principle," then nothing does.

"The Peter Principle" denotes, by the way, that "members of an organization where promotion is based on achievement, success, and merit will eventually be promoted beyond their level of ability." Which is to say, Witt was doing perfectly fine where he was, but given his years of experience, he was given the opportunity to direct an actual movie, and it turns out it was all too much for him.

Which is why he's back on second unit now, where he belongs.


3. Tommy Wiseau - The Room (2003)

The Room
TPW Films

How in God's name did The Room - you know, The Room - cost $20 million to make? I mean, to put that into perspective, Lost In Translation only cost $4 million. You could make Lost In Translation five times over with the budget of the room.

Tommy Wiseau's debut "masterpiece" hasn't ended his career in the sense that he's still somehow making money out of promoting and touring and introducing this thing at festivals, but it certainly doomed his chances as a director - nobody in their right mind is going to let him get behind the camera having seen this hilarious train-wreck in motion, after all.

Thank God he raised all the money himself, huh?


2. Kinka Usher - Mystery Men (1999)

Mystery Men
Universal Pictures

Kinka Usher's first and only turn as a director was on the 1999 movie Mystery Men, which starred Ben Stiller - among other Hollywood bigshots like, uh, Hank Azaria and... um, William H. Macy - as a group of inept superheroes who are forced into a confrontation with a supervillain.

It was a risky movie to make, given the subject matter, but given the ironic premise and the fact that superheroes weren't that popular in '99, it totally flopped, losing a whopping $30 million. Which left Kinka Usher without much work for, oh, the rest of his career.

To be fair to the guy, Mystery Men isn't without merit, but it isn't good either, and it's kind of understandable as to why audiences don't flock to theatres to check it out - it's about as hit and miss as a movie comes.

So what's Kinka up to nowadays, you ask? He's directing commercials, apparently, and according to his online profile has "at least" five children. I don't know what that means.


1. Kerry Conran - Sky Captain And The World Of Tomorrow (2004)

Angelina Jolie Sky Captain And The World Of Tomorrow
Paramount

Kerry Conran must have been over the moon when somebody said: "Okay, you can make Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow, and you know what? Here's Jude Law and Angelia Jolie, and $70 million dollars so you can ensure that this is the best looking movie that it can be." For a first time writer and director, such words must've been something of a dream come true.

Unfortunately, nobody actually went to see the movie when it came out in 2004. Which meant that Kelly Conran was suddenly a guy who had lost his financiers almost $20 million dollars, which did not bode well for his career, in the sense that his career is now over, and the poor dude can't get another directing job because he "messed up" when it counted most: helming a super-expensive debut movie which he wrote.

Who else was there to lay the blame on?

What's worse, Sky Captain isn't even that bad and it actually looks great. Go figure.


Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.