10 Most Disappointing Movies Of 2014 (So Far)

Not good, not bad... those movies that have just left us wanting more in 2014.

And so here we here... at the last in our recent trilogy of articles designed to look back at the filmic year up until this point in time. Firstly, we outlined our picks for the best movies of the year thus far, the list of which you can read here. We followed this with a list poised on the opposite end of the spectrum; those movies which resulted in feelings of annoyance and rage - our choices for the absolute worst movies to have graced cinema screens over the course of 2014. And now, as we come to the final article, it's time to explore the movies that fell into neither camp. Varied in quality, it's arguably the films which disappointed us that remain the most interesting. Here we take a look back at those movies that might have divided opinion, caused a stir amongst critics and audiences alike, but ultimately served to disappoint those who had been long awaiting them. When compiling our list here, then, the qualifications for consideration were as follows: any movie released theatrically for the first time in either the UK or the US either between January 1st 2014 and now were thought about. It's also important to remember this isn't a list of bad movies, but of those that failed to live up to expectations; many of the picks still have redeeming factors. Here are the 10 most disappointing movies of 2014 (so far), starting with...

10. Muppets Most Wanted

The most notable thing about Muppets Most Wanted is that is isn't the total disaster it probably could have been, given its status as a follow-up to what was arguably the greatest Muppets movie yet. Director James Bobin (who helmed the original, too) attempts to acknowledge the fact that the movie isn't going to be quite as good as the first installment by deploying a catchy song to inform readers of this notion from the very beginning, and it's hard not to admire his intentions; Muppets Most Wanted lacks the zing of the the 2011 flick, but it's good enough. The biggest problem, of course, is that the movie doesn't really seem to know what to do with itself - whereas the original had a simple but solid plot to build its songs and gags around, Muppets Most Wanted spends a lot of time flailing in and amongst an overly complicated story. The film is helped by comedian Ricky Gervais, who - as a life-long fan of Jim Henson's fuzzy friends - clearly relishes every moment he spends on screen with them. For every joke that hits, however, two miss. Which is to say, for a sequel, it's an admirable attempt, but we wanted better.

9. Bad Words

Jason Bateman's debut movie as a director is almost there; shot with a clear, vivid style, Bad Words also features one of the gifted actor's best performances as a downright bitter son of a bitch who will stop at nothing to win a children's spelling bee. For the first half of Bad Words, then, Bateman seems connected to the script perfectly... as the movie goes on, though, it begins to lag, and what at first seemed intriguing and highly unique begins to feel like something we've witnessed before. It's hard not to feel like the opportunity ended up a little wasted. Still, this is undoubtably a solid movie worth 90 minutes of your life (though it does begin to strain under the weight of even that relatively short running time). All of the joy here stems from Bateman's Guy Trilby, who - having found a loophole in the spelling bee competition rulebook - embarks on a profanity-laden revenge quest against a person who shall remain nameless for spoiler purposes. The biggest error the director makes here? Sacrificing the mean-spirited tone for what feels like a cop out ending; Bateman seems afraid to go all the way.

8. Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit

There was something inherently exciting about the notion of Shakespearean icon Kenneth Branagh getting behind the camera for a Jack Ryan reboot, even if the world wasn't all that bothered about seeing the character - embodied previously by Alec Baldwin, Harrison Ford and Ben Affleck on the begin screen - in another motion picture. The annoying thing about Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit, however (aside from that irritating subtitle), stems from the fact that it's very nearly a good action movie... it just settles to be highly generic in almost every way. So whereas Chris Pine does a somewhat serviceable job as the eponymous spy of the title (he's not very memorable, though), the movie itself mostly feels like its treading water - not narratively, exactly, but in its thematic approach to rebooting this franchise. Ryan goes up against a Russian baddie (played by Kenneth Branagh, of course), and it all feels very been there, done that from opening credits to end titles. "This is the very definition of an OK thriller," said critic Richard Roeper in his own review. There's really no better way to say it.

7. Breathe In

What looked to be both intriguing, smoldering and rather controversial in the trailer, what with its plot about an exchange student (Felicity Jones) who disrupts the lives of a New York family when she begins a relationship with the father (Guy Pearce), actually comes across as fairly tepid in the actual film - a disappointing revelation, you'll admit, given the potential of the premise and the talents of its leading actors. What could've been had the script been injected with an extra oomph to push it over the edge; Breathe In simply fails to be all that gripping. What's great about the movie, however, is Guy Pearce, who without a doubt gives one of his best performances. And yet, to recommend Breathe In on the basis alone still feels wrong... once our lovers have resolved their situation, there's a sense of "What was the point of the whole thing?" There's too much emphasis on the way things look as opposed to the way they feel, which leaves the movie - for all its good points - feeling a little false. It's hard to put a finger on what, exactly, doesn't work, but ultimately it's just too hard to buy into what you see.

6. 300: Rise Of An Empire

Was it too much to expect better things from a 300 sequel that didn't really need to exist in the first place? Perhaps, but that didn't stop hordes of people from getting super excited at the mere prospect that a follow-up to Zack Snyder's immensely popular tribute to the wonders of CGI from way back in 2007 was in the works. 300: Rise Of An Empire, then, is probably about as good a sequel as one could have expected for this franchise; and yet it's hard to escape the feeling that it could have been a lot better with a few minor tweaks here and there. Though 300 clung to a fairly thin plot, Rise of an Empire attempts no such thing... and that's kind of where the movie lets itself down most. Despite the fact that 300 was a movie about people fighting each other in slow-motion, there was still an interesting narrative driving the story. Empire is more like a video game - happy to exist as a 100 minute tapestry of blood and gore. Eva Green's Artemisia makes the movie watchable enough, however, and if you want a film to zonk out to, this one fits the bill. A shame it wasn't better thought through.

5. Non-Stop

The premise alone is enough to provoke giddy squeals: Liam Neeson, channelling his badass character from the Taken franchise as US Air Marshall Bill Marks, finds himself trapped on a plane facing a series of text messages informing him to instruct the airline to transfer bundles of money to a secret account. It's up to Marks to figure out what the hell is going on before it's too late. Any movie that suspends its characters mid-flight and asks them to solve a crisis is instantly appealing even without Neeson, of course - with him, though, it's downright irresistible. Which is what makes Non-Stop so darn frustrating as both standard action fare and as a Neeson vehicle: it very nearly pulls the whole thing off before making a few critical mistakes at the end which threaten to overhaul the entire movie. Still, despite its flaws, Non-Stop is a blast to watch if you're the kind of person who can sit back and just enjoy the flight, ignoring plot holes and logical lapses. Neeson is on fine form, doing what he does best in this bizarre new era where it's okay for him to be a 61-year-old action star. Disappointing, then, but not entirely unbecoming.

4. RoboCop

One could certainly argue that the worse possible thing that a movie can be is unsure as to what, exactly, it wants to be. Unfortunately for the recent remake of RoboCop, that's the one aspect that stops it from working as both a remake and as a reboot of a once successful franchise. The basic plot is the same as the 1987 version: Detective Alex Murphy, wounded beyond incomprehension, is selected as a candidate for a new project led by a doctor played passively by Gary Oldman. As half man, half robot, he will police the street as... well, RoboCop. The results are noticeably muddled - though the plot tries to be respectful of the source material, all of the irony is lost and director José Padilha is left with an inferior product that doesn't know whether or not it's supposed to be making fun of itself. That's not to say there's zero fun to be had here, although it's safe to say there's not a single memorable action scene in the bunch. For a movie that seems so desperate to say something, it's near on impossible to come away knowing what that something is; it could have been a lot worse, but it's no patch on the original.

3. Divergent

Given the acclaim that has been heaped upon its admittedly superior source material, Divergent was toted to be something of a kindred spirit to The Hunger Games franchise - indeed, the producers who managed to get their mitts on the rights to the books presumably thought they had a gold mine on their hands. Still, despite the fact that the movie made a good amount at the box office, there's no doubting this super stilted adaptation is a fairly lackluster one; in fact, it's biggest problem might be the fact that it feels like we've seen it all before elsewhere. And we have, kind of. Set in a dystopian future world where people are divided into groups according to their abilities, the plot centres on Shailene Woodley's Tris, who - as the go-getting protagonist - obviously doesn't fit into any of those categories (cue a conspiracy led by Kate Winslet that drives a narrative crammed with plot holes). The major pitfall of Divergent, though, is that it spends almost the entirety of its runtime trying to cater to the sequel; by the time the credits are rolling, we're bored, exhausted, and not at all interested in the follow-up.

2. The Amazing Spider-Man 2

As if the relative critical failure of Spider-Man 3 wasn't warning enough, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 bizarrely set out to reprise some of its most obvious mistakes. That's not to say that the movie doesn't work in places - the chemistry between Andrew Garfield's Peter Parker and Emma Stone's Gwen Stacy is undeniable, to name one aspect, and some of the set-pieces are rendered with CGI pizzaz. And yet it's still hard to escape the feeling that the movie was too jammed packed for its own good; too many villains, not enough focus on the human aspects. Given that the first entry in this rebooted franchise did a relatively good job in setting up what should have been a more exciting and immediate sequel, it's a shame to see that The Amazing Spider-Man has nothing on Sam Raimi's first Spidey follow-up, Spider-Man 2, which took what was great about his first movie and crafted what is arguably the perfect comic book flick. Aside from Garfield and Stone, Dane DeHaan offers up a memorable Harry Osborn... and yet despite all its efforts to please, the movie feels like a hodgepodge; messy, chaotic, forgettable.

1. The Monuments Men

Who knew that George Clooney was capable of making a movie quite as throughly disappointing as this one? Given his near impeccable track record as a director thus far, it's almost sickening to see how far he falls with the admirable but otherwise humdrum The Monuments Men. Looking at the trailer, and going by the plot (which features an allied group deep behind enemy lines trying to recover stolen art from the Nazis), this movie should have been a savvy cross between Ocean's Eleven and Inglourious Basterds; surprisingly, it's a total yawnfest from start to finish. With a cast made up of immensely talented actors such as Matt Damon, Bill Murray, John Goodman, Cate Blanchett and Clooney himself, it's fairly shocking as to how much of The Monuments Men seems less than fully formed. Directed on what feels like autopilot by the man who usually seems so very at ease behind the camera, the movie still manages to cling to a few impressive aspects. There's certainly a sense that the flick has been approached from place of respect, and the production design is majestic, but the film never finds its footing. Which is to say, the most disappointing thing about The Monuments Men isn't in how bad it is, but in how disappointing it is - almost as if Clooney, once riveted by the material, found something else that interested him during pre-production and quickly threw the movie together before moving on to other things. The cast do their best, and there are occasional moments of beauty and wit, but for a picture that could have been so much fun, it's a tired shame that most of Monuments Men hinges on a plot about Matt Damon chatting up Cate Blanchett. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.