10 Dumbest Movie Plot Twists Of 2020
THAT Wonder Woman 1984 twist is deeply problematic.
It goes without saying that a plot twist can either make or break a movie. A great twist will recontexualise the movie's events in a clever or unexpected way, while a bad twist will generally feel like it was deployed for mere cheap shock value.
2020 may have been a lighter year for cinema than anyone could've ever expected, but it still served up a slew of tantalising plot twists (which we won't spoil here).
But these 10 films went in another direction entirely, delivering twists that, rather than elevate the drama or enrich the characters, were just flat-out stupid.
These revelations, whether genuine, earnest attempts to be clever or more wilfully trashy rug-pulls, represent 2020 cinema at its most mind-bogglingly dumb, fielding out sappy, silly, and flat-out ridiculous revelations that weren't at all justified by the material.
Whether you were left laughing, sighing, or cringing, these 10 films were largely talked about because of their big reveals, which were at least divisive if not universally reviled in some cases.
Then again, some of these films would've evaporated from the cultural conversation within seconds were it not for these attention-grabbing, thoroughly idiotic reveals...
10. Melanie Is Secretly Crazy - Fantasy Island
It's totally apt that one of 2020's stupidest movies also plays host to one of its most inane plot twists.
This horror-themed reimagining of the hit 1977 TV series Fantasy Island follows a group of strangers who visit the titular island, with the promise that their grandest fantasies will come true.
It doesn't take long for the wish fulfilment to turn weird and then deadly, leading to the howlingly ridiculous reveal that all of the events on the island have actually been the vengeful fantasy of just one person - protagonist Melanie (Lucy Hale).
As it turns out, all of the other guests were in some way involved in the accidental death of Nick (Evan Evagora), the object of her affection who she was supposed to go on a date with the night he died in an apartment fire.
Effectively, an insane Melanie wanted to get violent revenge on those who deprived her of Nick, though in an hilarious bout of comeuppance, one of the surviving guests then uses her own fantasy to "reunite" Melanie with her lost love.
At this point, a zombified Nick bursts out of the nearby water fountain and drags her into its depths. It may be a thoroughly dumb series of events, but at least it probably made you laugh.
9. It's Set In A Civil War Reenactment - Antebellum
The marketing for Antebellum was wilfully mysterious, implying that the film had some sort of a time travel twist in which protagonist Veronica Henley (Janelle Monae) is kidnapped and somehow sent back in time to a Louisiana Civil War plantation.
The suggestion was that Veronica would need to find a way to get back to her own time, though in actuality this wasn't the case at all, with the film instead concluding on a deflating final reveal that would make even M. Night Shyamalan cringe.
As Veronica makes her violent last stand against her captors and escapes the plantation, it's revealed that she was actually being held prisoner in a Civil War reenactment park all along, and the entirety of the film was indeed taking place in the modern day.
It wouldn't have been quite so infuriating had the film not treated this reveal like it was a genuinely clever and creative subversion, rather than a smug-yet-ridiculous attempt to shock viewers. Black Mirror this ain't.
8. Armando Is Mike's Son - Bad Boys For Life
Bad Boys for Life turned out considerably better than just about anyone could've expected from a belated sequel to Michael Bay's hit action franchise.
But the script also leaned back rather lazily on a plot twist that's become wildly over-used in recent years - the villain being related to the hero.
The Star Wars franchise alone has rehashed this twist enough to make it seem tired and cynical, so audiences probably either laughed or groaned when it was revealed that the film's secondary villain, Armando Aretas (Jacob Scipio), is the son of Mike Lowery (Will Smith).
As it turns out, Armando was the result of a love affair between Mike and the film's main antagonist, Isabel Aretas (Kate del Castillo), years earlier.
This naturally throws a melodramatic spanner in the works during the climax, where Armando learns the truth about his parentage and that his mother has been trying to manipulate him into killing Mike.
Ultimately Isabel is killed and Armando is sent to prison, though not before he teams up with Mike to rescue Marcus. Furthermore, the ending implies that Armando may join Mike on a future mission to shave some time off his prison sentence.
It's all sappy, melodramatic nonsense, but at least it's entertaining sappy, melodramatic nonsense.
7. The Boy Starts A Revolution Against The Witches - The Witches
As brilliant as Nicolas Roeg's 1990 adaptation of Roald Dahl's The Witches was, many were nevertheless excited to see how Robert Zemeckis' remake would handle its ending.
Given that the Roeg film famously erased the darker climax of Dahl's book in favour of a slightly rushed happy finale, Zemeckis' promise that he would stay true to the spirit of that original ending left many hopeful.
And though Zemeckis' finale is certainly more faithful to the source material, it comes with a major caveat.
Indeed, The Witches 2020 ends, as Dahl's book does, with the young protagonist (Jahzir Kadeem Bruno) still turned into a mouse, but also tacks on a wildly unnecessary mid-credits epilogue that wasn't present in the novel.
This scene takes place many years later with the boy now teaming up with his grandmother (Octavia Spencer) to lead a worldwide revolution against the witches, giving a presentation to a huge assembly of children on how to defeat them.
Whether you consider this a setup for a potential sequel or simply an attempt to tie up every loose end, it's a totally needless extension of Dahl's original story.
6. The Doll Is Actually Possessed - Brahms: The Boy II
2016's horror film The Boy may not have been great, but it's practically masterful compared to its recent sequel, which despite being written and directed by the same people, made the inexplicable decision to effectively retcon the first film's big twist.
The Boy follows an American nanny, Greta Evans (Lauren Cohan), who is hired to care for a child named Brahms. But Brahms is actually a porcelain doll serving as a stand-in for the real boy, who allegedly died years earlier.
The initial implication is that the spirit of Brahms is living inside the doll, only for the film's genuinely surprising twist to reveal that, in fact, Brahms is alive and living inside the walls of the family mansion.
By film's end the doll is shattered yet Brahms is still very much alive, only for The Boy II to throw all of this out, retconning Brahms to be the haunted doll we all originally thought he was all along.
As for the wall-dweller from the first movie? He was basically just a meat-puppet who got possessed by the doll to do his bidding. Yikes.
Contradicting your own established lore just two movies into a franchise is never a good look, and so it's little surprise that the film rustled up just a fraction of its predecessor's box office business.
5. The Protagonist Is The Mastermind - Tenet
Audiences remain massively divided on whether or not Christopher Nolan's Tenet is a masterfully complex sci-fi action film or a sloppy, near-incomprehensible work of filmmaking hubris.
As much as most can agree that the action sequences are creative and visually stunning, many have misgivings about the film's twist ending, which is dropped in the audience's lap in the final moments and barely elaborated upon.
The final scenes reveal that not only was Neil (Robert Pattinson) recruited by the Protagonist (John David Washington), but that the Protagonist has actually been the mastermind of the Tenet organisation all along, and set in motion the events to stop Sator's (Kenneth Branagh) apocalyptic ploy.
Granted, quite a few fans predicted this twist months before the movie came out, as the in-over-his-head operative turning out to be the man at the top fits neatly within the film's theme of how reality, perspective, and context can be altered by the flow of time.
But for many, it just wasn't a twist that felt earned or even particularly coherent: a smug attempt by Nolan to once again prove his cerebral smarts as a filmmaker, yet failing to do the leg-work to earn our reverence as he did in the likes of Memento and Inception.
4. Sully Is Augustine's Daughter - The Midnight Sky
George Clooney's new Netflix sci-fi drama The Midnight Sky is a visually stunning spectacle and gives Clooney the floor to deliver a terrific performance, so it's just a shame that the film wraps up with such an arch, predictable plot twist.
The finale actually serves up two twists for the price of one, first revealing that Iris (Caoilinn Springall), the young girl stranded on a dying Earth with Augustine (George Clooney), is nothing more than an hallucination of his own daughter, who he caught only a brief glimpse of when she was young.
This is followed up by a second reveal, that Sully (Felicity Jones), the pregnant astronaut Augustine is trying to dissuade from returning to Earth, is actually Iris herself.
Though Clooney and Jones certainly act the hell out of their final scenes, the twist is just too contrived and sentimental for its own good, ending the film on a rather sappy note which it didn't even begin to earn.
3. Adam Is The Secret Villain - The Craft: Legacy
The Craft: Legacy was basically what everyone expected: a cynical "soft reboot" that attempted to rehash a brand name for a new generation while still appealing to fans of the original.
As both a sequel and a reboot the film was a failure, not least because of its ridiculous third act villain reveal.
Early in the film we're introduced to protagonist Lily's (Cailee Spaeny) new stepfather Adam (David Duchovny), a man who may as well have "Bad Guy" stamped on his forehead from the moment we meet him.
To the surprise of not a single living soul, Adam turns out to be a pagan zealot who wants to steal Lily's magical powers for his own nefarious ends.
Between Duchovny's total miscasting in the role and the utter predictability of the primary male character being the villain in a feminist horror film, audiences were more likely to roll their eyes than gasp at the big reveal.
2. Steve Trevor Hijacks Another Man's Body - Wonder Woman 1984
Wonder Woman 1984 was undeniably one of 2020's most disappointing films - an inane, overstuffed mess of ideas and tones that never really cohere, but it's never more actively insulting than when it drops that Steve Trevor (Chris Pine) twist.
It was no secret prior to the film's release that the long-dead Trevor would be somehow resurrected in 1984, but the means through which this comes about are troubling to say the least.
Near the start of the film, Diana (Gal Gadot) inadvertently uses the Dreamstone artefact to wish Steve back to life.
Yet as his introductory scenes make bafflingly clear, he hasn't simply been wished out of thin air: he's actually been shoved into the body of a random guy off the street (Kristoffer Polaha).
This naturally invites a ton of ethical questions about the man whose life Steve "hijacks", especially as it's implied that Diana has sex with him, not to mention the mortal danger that his body is put in numerous times.
Considering that the script could've easily just magicked Steve into existence without the moral messiness of him stealing another man's life, it's a twist not only staggeringly idiotic but also totally unnecessary.
1. Borat Was COVID-19 Patient Zero - Borat Subsequent Moviefilm
But a dumb plot twist isn't always a bad thing, as proven by the hysterical Borat Subsequent Moviefilm.
The film's thoroughly insane ending offers up a parody of The Usual Suspects' final twist, revealing that Borat (Sacha Baron Cohen) was himself patient zero of COVID-19, having been unknowingly injected with the virus by the Kazakh government as revenge for making the country a worldwide joke in the first film.
Borat is then sent off around the world, where he causes the initial outbreak in Wuhan by coughing at a seafood market and even gives the virus to Tom Hanks by coughing on him in Australia.
It's a brilliantly ridiculous twist on which to end the film, and somehow still more believable than the pandemic being a hoax or caused by 5G masts.
It's completely, unapologetically stupid, and yet, who would have it any other way?