10 Easily Avoidable Deaths In Sci-Fi Movies

Lethal lapses in logic don't just happen in our world.

Deep Blue Sea
Warner Bros.

Sci-fi can be more captivating than any other genre. It provides the perfect realm for filmmakers to use familiarities from our world against us by pushing one element of our reality over the edge. At its best, it can thrill us and keep us guessing while pondering the most fundamental questions.

But at its worst, it can be disastrous. Half-baked or convoluted plots aren't uncommon; they often try justifying nonsensical action or excuses for yet another sequel. Yet, we film fans keep coming back for more in our endless pursuit of finding the next one to rave to our mates about.

Of all the sins sci-fi commits, there are little less infuriating than a stupid character death. Films like these can ask a lot from audiences to keep up with in terms of plot and detail, the least we ask for in return is not to have our intelligence insulted by making us accept insane lapses of logic by the characters we're following.

We get it, deaths need to happen at times for dramatic or storytelling purposes, but please treat them with the same respect that you expect us to give to your film. And these are the times where they really should've done better.

10. Keep Your Finger Off The Trigger - Andrew Fassbach (World War Z)

Fassbach World War Z 2013 Deaths
Paramount Pictures

Low as it may be, zombie films still have a bar to clear some bar to be considered believable. But, for the most part, World War Z gives a good account of itself in this area. Aside from one crucial moment, though, which lets it down.

At this point, humanity pinned all hopes for a cure on virologist Dr Andrew Fassbach. So, he heads to South Korea along with Brad Pitt's Gerry Lane and some military personnel. All armed and anticipating an attack from their flesh-eating antagonists, Gerry instructs Andrew to keep his finger off the trigger. That's sound advice, as it's an essential rule to uphold if you want to carry a gun safely.

Did the doctor follow this advice? Of course not. He starts running away in panic before slipping and falling over, shooting himself in the head in the process.

You could almost forgive this stupid decision, maybe as an attempt to demonstrate the importance of gun safety. Or, perhaps, how manic situations lead to irrational actions from even the most intelligent people.

Either interpretation, however, isn't quite enough to justify a death that somehow rendered a doctor more brainless than the zombies he was trying to cure.


9. Do Anything Else - Darth Maul (Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace)

Star Wars Darth Maul
Lucasfilm

Putting it lightly, the Star Wars prequel trilogy is a point of contention amongst fans, with The Phantom Menace getting the brunt of the ire from fans. However, even its biggest detractors would praise the climactic showdown where Obi-Wan Kenobi and Qui-Gon Jinn valiantly go against Darth Maul.

That is, apart from one critical moment. Obi-Wan has just seen his master die and is presently hanging off a ledge, with Maul towering just a few feet above. Having already used the Force to push Obi-Wan over, certainly just repeating that move once more would finish the job. Indeed, many options were available to him, really; he could reach down and knock him off with his lightsaber or even drop it on top of him.

And out of all of those, what does he pick? Well, taking aimless swipes at him, of course. He doesn't even bend down to get close. All he's doing is hitting the ledge, making some nice sparks for the kids watching. This utter lapse in any common sense gave enough time for Obi-Wan to use the Force to recover and take out Maul, surprise surprise. Given what Maul just did, he probably deserved it just for that.


8. Don't Abort The Mission, President - The Whole World (Don't Look Up)

Don't Look Up Leonardo DiCaprio Jennifer Lawrence
Netflix

There are rare cases where writers meant for deaths to be easily avoidable. Yet, just because the film's a satire doesn't automatically prevent the demise of virtually everyone on Earth from appearing on this list.

As a fascinating depiction of the ease in which greed and the media come together to obscure facts from the public, it had to be greed that drove the apocalypse. At this point, the best scientists have just successfully launched a mission to destroy a comet hurtling towards Earth. It all looked so hopeful until Madame President called it off, convinced that she could make money off the rare elements on the comet instead.

Having consulted no one but a billionaire tech company CEO, you can see why this choice was ill-advised. While failing to consult any expert at all, it would've been far easier to let the professionals do their job. The film uses this to perfectly encapsulate how easily a bit of misinformation fuelled by greed can lead to rash decisions that do so much damage.

Given that is the point, is this gripe a tad pedantic? Maybe. But no one gets a free pass for ignorance here, even if it was intended.


7. Use Your Grenade Properly - Robert Neville (I Am Legend)

I Am Legend Will Smith
Warner Bros.

There's a reason why debates about this film's conclusion persist.

More in line with the source material, the alternative ending gives audiences a mental 180°. It puts Robert Neville's motives into question and provides a refreshing shred of humanity to the Darkseekers. Explaining that Neville is as much of a threat to them as they are to him, Neville still gets to walk away knowing the cure.

However, the theatrical cut's ending is more a traditional action movie finish. Neville, instead, sacrifices himself to save the cure, letting the others escape with it. It's not without some merit; it fulfils Neville's character arc by reuniting him with his family through his death once he's achieved his goal of finding the cure.

If you intend to make this massive change to favour something familiar, though, at least give Neville a great death. Unsurprisingly, they didn't do that, opting for Neville to blow himself and the Darkseekers up via grenade. If anyone forgot, grenades don't blow up immediately, providing time for a getaway before the explosion. How did no one think of this? It makes everyone look incredibly dumb for choosing this stupidly avoidable death over the superior alternative they had already shot.


6. Wait A Few Minutes - Billy And The Other 3 Survivors (The Mist)

United States Army The Mist
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Dimension Films

Here we have another instance of intentionally avoidable deaths, but its irony compounded a tragedy rather than added to satire (as in Don't Look Up).

Similar to I Am Legend, this concerns a different ending to the source material. However, the change proved so impactful that even Stephen King (who wrote the original novella) praised it. While driving off into The Mist, things look bleak for the survivors. David's at the wheel, having just learned the fate of his wife and is now only driving to see if they can get out of the mist.

At this point, the novella ends, but the film isn't done. Running out of fuel, the passengers come to a silent agreement. David mercy kills everyone - including his son - to spare them from suffering a worse fate outside. Since he's a bullet short of doing the same for himself, he exits the car to instigate his swift death. But instead, he meets the arrival of the military and the dissipation of the mist. As they were mere moments away from safety, and how easily David could've saved his son, this ultimate troll ending is the prime example of avoidable deaths executed effectively.


5. Set A Camp In The Waterfall - Lee Abbott (A Quiet Place)

Quiet Place Waterfall
Paramount Pictures

This might be a nitpick, but your writer has to call out when a film itself provides an unbelievably simple solution to the problem at hand. It focuses on a family living in a world ravaged by monsters who hunt excellently based on sound alone. Their presence sentences our protagonists to life in total silence, lest they get murdered.

Nowhere was safe, right? Actually, we do learn about one place, a waterfall. It's so loud that it drowns out any noise you make while under it. Yes, it's only supposed to serve as a happy escape for Lee and his son, Marcus. However, we can't help but question why they haven't used this to their advantage, especially with Evelyn expecting.

It may be impractical (and a tad extreme) to permanently move to the waterfall; you'd still desire a somewhat normal life. But it seems illogical not to set up a temporary camp here for Evelyn to spend the last few weeks in. After all, she could go into labour suddenly, upon which sounds are unavoidable. Unfortunately, this wound up happening while she was still in the house, setting events in motion leading to Lee's death. All due to a profound lack of foresight.


4. No Need To Jump In - Dr Susan McCallister (Deep Blue Sea)

Deep Blue Sea Saffron Burrows
Warner Bros.

You'd be wildly mistaken if you thought we'd give it a pass since test audiences demanded this via reshoot.

The demand made sense - kill off Dr Susan McCallister, given her role in creating the rampaging sharks. The production handled this by having Susan sacrifice herself - she cuts her hand and jumps in the water to distract the final shark and so prevent it from escaping. Now, this makes absolutely no sense.

The most prominent flaw here is that she could've easily achieved this without jumping in. If she wanted to use blood so badly, she could have tried spreading it on the water's surface. If she wanted to be more precise, she could've even wet something in her blood and thrown it in.

But the most egregious aspect of this decision is that she was a doctor who specialises in researching sharks. Undoubtedly, she must know several ways to distract a shark without resorting to something that unnecessarily risks her own life; it would've been part of her job.

It would've been much more believable if she had slipped and fallen in the water. But, astoundingly, this isn't even the stupidest heroic sacrifice by diving. That's for our next entry.


3. Absolutely No Need To Jump In - Grandma Ruth (Dante's Peak)

Dante S Peak Grandma
Universal

As film veterans will tell you, one of the most run-of-the-mill tricks writers pull to redeem villainous or unlikeable characters is giving them a heroic death. Sure, there's a reason why this manoeuvre is so popular; just ask Darth Vader.

Of course, many take it too far, with writers or studios so desperate to go down this route that they completely ignore any opposing context. What this blindness results in is characters making the most illogical decisions purely for story-based reasons. Take Grandma Ruth in Dante's Peak. She was a thorn in our protagonists' side until she "valiantly" gave her life for them to make it through the acidic lake, dying of the injuries incurred in the process.

Maybe her decision to jump into the lake to help push the boat into shore looked ok on paper. But again, context is critical. They were only a couple of metres away from their destination, rendering her sacrifice utterly pointless. Any remotely observant person would've certainly sat tight, as doing anything else would be bonkers.

A mindless heroic act both Will Smith's Robert Neville and Susan McCallister would be proud of, this takes the crown for the "Most Idiotic Heroic Death In Modern Cinema". Congrats.


2. Jump In - Toad (X-Men)

X Men Toad Death
Fox

Still, if some characters were meant to jump into the water, Toad would undoubtedly be among them.

Perhaps dated and cheesy by today's standards, X-Men is still a culturally important achievement. While entertaining enough, it sets a decent bar for its successors, paving the way for bigger and better things. One such cheesy moment, though, is the climactic showdown between Storm and Toad. Sure, everyone now groans at Storm's one-liner, and rightly so. But this distracts from the even more stupid part of the scene.

Because nobody watching the film is paying attention to what Toad is doing. Hanging onto a railing via his tongue after being thrown from a window, he chooses to do nothing, which wouldn't be too bad until you consider two vital things. Firstly, it isn't that big of a drop, a height most Olympic divers are comfortable doing. Secondly, he's above a river. If any mutant would be good jumping off into actual water, surely it'll be Toad.

So, rather than going for the far easier option of simply falling into the water, he waits to be struck by lightning. It's a horrifyingly dumb decision that you can't unsee, and it only gets dumber the more you think about it.


1. Run Sideways - Meredith Vickers (Prometheus)

Prometheus Charlize Theron
20th Century Studios

There was always going to be one clear winner in this straight race (pun intended).

In Prometheus, audiences watched plenty of characters making stupid decisions who came together to form the least competent fictitious space crew. Among them was a scientist who actively touched an alien creature that looked unquestionably hostile and a geologist who was surprised they got lost, even though preventing this was the actual purpose he was on the mission.

Of course, these paled compared to the ultimate idiotic move that would follow. Put yourself in Meredith Vickers' shoes: you're on an alien planet, and a ring-shaped spaceship is falling near you. As it crashes, it rolls towards you. With its shadow looming, you realise you're about to get crushed and need to run out of the way.

Indeed, anyone with a functioning brain would run to the side. But not Meredith. She runs straight ahead, right into the path of the falling ship. It's made even worse once you notice she had a good few seconds to decide and that Shaw survived by rolling to the side despite her falling over.

The scene now lives in infamy as one of the most unintentionally comedic deaths in sci-fi history. And rightly so.


Watch Next


Contributor

Born in the Med but made up north. Loves a cheesy action flick almost as much as the walk back to the seat after another round of karaoke