10 Failed Movies That Actually Deserve A Reboot
10. The Shadow
The Shadow is a crime fighter best known for his presence as a radio mainstay during the 1930s and 40s, as well as a storied mythology in various comics. This is a reboot that has been on the cards for a while, though it has yet to come to fruition, in the wake of the execrable 1994 Alec Baldwin take. The character, who dresses all in black except for a crimson scarf, is supposed to be an awesome, slightly scary vigilante, yet the Baldwin film went the PG-13 route and thus severely neutered the character, with director Russell Malcahy clearly not knowing which tone to strike. The result was oddly cheesy, campy in much the same way that Warren Beatty's middling Dick Tracy didn't manage to service its source material. The movie was subsequently a box office bomb, barely making its budget back and putting to rest the plans for a Shadow franchise. However, the film still made it clear that there was something worth pursuing here, so with a darker, grittier, Nolan-style reboot, this one could be the sort of film that, say, Daredevil wanted to be.
9. Max Payne
Video game adaptations are rarely good, though the trailer for Max Payne had me totally psyched; John Moore's visuals seemed to live up to the source material, and Mark Wahlberg appeared well-cast in the role. The end result, then, was a tremendous disappointment; the plot from the video game was re-arranged - so that Max finding his dead family is a flashback in the middle of the film - and a number of bizarre flourishes were introduced that make little sense. Most distressing of all, however, is the troubling casting of Mila Kunis as Mona Sax - she's far too young and cute for the role - and a dispiriting lack of action. Above all else, something a film like this should get right is the action, but it comes only in brief fits and starts. What a reboot needs is a hard R-rating - how is a film about drugs and murder supposed to be a PG-13, like the previous effort? - and a director versed in film noir, someone like Robert Rodriguez. Shoot it in the same visual style, but just get a writer who understands and respects the source material this time...
8. Cowboys & Aliens
Cowboys & Aliens is based on the 2006 graphic novel of the same name created by Scott Mitchell Rosenberg, revolving around a mysterious outlaw suffering from amnesia (Daniel Craig), a wealthy cattle rancher (Harrison Ford), and a mysterious traveler (Olivia Wilde) who are forced to team up to save a town being attacked and abducted by aliens. It's a hilarious idea for a film regardless of where it came from - turning the classic game of Cowboys & Indians on its head - yet the final result was such a limp, tepid disappointment, all the more so because it came from Jon "Iron Man" Favreau. Despite assembling a top-notch cast and a sky-high budget of $163 million, the film is one of the most oddly boring action movies in recent years, and as a result it only made $174 million at the box office. Compounding things is the overly self-serious tone; no film with a title this ludicrous should be anything but tongue-in-cheek, and in the unlikely event that any studio ever agrees to reboot it, the emphasis this time needs to be on silliness and fun.
7. Timecop
Jean-Claude Van Damme hasn't made many great movies throughout his career, and Timecop certainly isn't one of them, but it is unquestionably one of his most ambitious, interesting failures, one that with a hot new star at the helm could kick-start a new franchise. While the film fared well at the box office, it was a critical flop due to its nonsensical narrative, which didn't stick to its own time travel rules, and focused too much on propping up Van Damme's star credentials. The film simply didn't have the budget to do all the cool things filmmakers should do with time travel, like going back to ancient times - the film only briefly visits the Civil War era and 1920s - or travelling into the future. Oh yeah, that's right, you can't travel forward in time in this movie, a senseless plot device intended solely to ensure the budget of the movie didn't balloon out of control. For a reboot, it needs a big-ass budget, get rid of the time restrictions, and throw someone like Bradley Cooper in as the lead. Sorted.
6. Green Lantern
Do I even need to explain how this one went wrong? Martin Campbell's disappointingly straight-faced, incoherent take on one of DC's best-loved superheroes was a mess in almost every aspect; the haphazard direction, the mind-numbingly bad writing, and the dreadful visual effects. The bad decisions range from Ryan Reynolds' Green Lantern suit being completely CGI to characterising Hal Jordan as a misogynistic douchebag who was difficult to warm to (a shame, as Ryan Reynolds seemed totally up for the assignment). Reynolds acquitted himself well enough that you wouldn't even need to recast him if you didn't want to, though that may be advisable simply to erase the bad memories of last time. This reboot seems particularly urgent given the perilous status of the much-anticipated Justice League movie, which needs as many well-established characters at the helm as possible, other than just Superman (and let's not even get started on what they might do with Batman...)
5. Tomb Raider
There is one single thing that both Tomb Raider films got right, and that is the flawless casting of Angelina Jolie as Lara Croft. Though Jolie tried her best to make the films fun and exciting, the scripting prevented them from being anything more than generic, hollow adaptations of the classic video games, and after the sequel disappointed at the box office, producers and Jolie swore the franchise off. However, there is a very easy way to re-purpose Tomb Raider as a new cinematic venture, as video game developers Crystal Dynamics have done much of the hard work already. The recent Tomb Raider video game reboot re-imagines Lara's journey with a far darker, more brutal tone, while also presenting to us a Lara Croft who is less a sex object and more an anatomically plausible human being with both vulnerability and extreme resourcefulness. Given how in vogue dark reboots are these days, a Tomb Raider movie in this vein would likely do exceedingly well, and in changing the character's physical properties, it opens up the casting call to women beyond those who have Jolie's impossible figure.
4. League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen had the potential to be a fantastic movie, yet once again, Alan Moore's disdain for Hollywood is proven right, as his beloved project is summarily given a $78 million trashing, taking everything complex and entertaining about the source material and distilling it for a young, kiddie audience. Given how the LXG comic books were aimed at adults, this just ended up pissing a lot of people off, though the film did to its credit take about 2-and-a-half times its budget at the box office. A reboot should hew closer to the graphic novel rather than introduce characters for American audiences - Tom Sawyer, anyone? - while handling a larger budget to accomodate the litany of battle scenes that were in the comics, yet curiously curiously cut from the 2003 film. Hire a director more experienced with big-budget blockbusters, and then just watch the money - and critical acclaim - come rolling in.
3. Street Fighter
There probably aren't many studios that are keen to reboot the Street Fighter franchise, given that neither of the two attempts thus far have been particularly successful financially, and both have been critically savaged into oblivion. Street Fighter: The Movie was elevated only by Raul Julia's amusingly cartoonish performance as M. Bison ("Of course!"), whereas the more recent Street Figher: The Legend of Chun-Li tried a more serious approach that ended up being no less hilarious (largely thanks to Chris Klein's bizarre is-it-self-aware-or-isn't-it supporting performance). A reboot needs to focus more closely on the game's tournament of fighters, such that we actually get to meet more of the characters this time. Structure the movie properly and this could be great fun, as long as plucky actors are cast in the colourful roles, and the fight choreography is much stronger than it has been in the first two films. Few will be expecting great things from it, so even a merely competent reboot will do wonders for its cinematic cred.
2. Ghost Rider
The first Ghost Rider film was bad enough, but the second was truly the scourge of Marvel at the movies, and one of the worst comic book movies ever made. The movies hewed away from Johnny Blaze's stature in the comics as a badass who loves to drink, smoke and kick ass, towards something more "sensitive" and "meaningful"; in layman's terms, a wimp. Cage gives one of his worst performances - in a Razzie-nominated role - and turns a potentially terrifying character into one who's more unintentionally hilarious than anything. Given that the films didn't post horrendous box office figures, a reboot is always possible, but it would need to return to the dark, gritty roots of the character, as is fashionable now anyway. Cast someone better-suited to the role than Cage, and actually focus on depicting villains who are developed beyond the moustache-twirling variety.
1. Catwoman

Halle Berry's Catwoman movie had a lot of promise...at least until we got our first sight of the costume...and then the trailer...and then the movie. Berry won a Razzie for her work on the film, and rightly, the film is regarded as one of the worst comic book movies ever made.
Not only is the character's name changed from Selina Kyle to Patience Phillips, but the tone is too campy, and the plot revolves around an evil cosmetics CEO (Sharon Stone) who has developed an anti-aging cream. Yeah, because that sounds...totally awesome...
Anne Hathaway totally knocked the role of Catwoman out of the park in The Dark Knight Rises, and as long as it was kept separate from Nolan's Batman mythology, I would be totally down for a Catwoman reboot about Selina Kyle's pre-Batman days.
There's a huge built-in audience for something like this, and as long as it follows a similar style and tone to the Nolan Batman films, there's the potential for a real winner here.
Which failed movies do you want to see rebooted the most? Let us know in the comments below.
