10 Failed Movies That Became Cult Classics

John Carter didn't even need critical acclaim and box office success!

John Carter Taylor Kitsch
Disney

Obviously, not all movies can be stonking financial hits, and every year without fail, there are countless ambitious and daring projects which fail to connect with a wide audience.

Sometimes these movies score strong reviews from critics, but most of the time, the pundits are as mixed on them as general audiences. However, often a film will fail on its initial release only to be granted a new lease of life years later on home video.

There's no real formula for predicting future cult classics, but you can usually hedge your bets on stylish box office bombs winning fans over on home video. So, don't be surprised if last year's gorgeous dud Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets ends up re-evaluated in the years to come...

10. Natural Born Killers

Natural Born Killers
Warner Bros

Oliver Stone's highly controversial 1994 satirical crime thriller may have benefited from a Quentin Tarantino-penned screenplay and a cracking cast - namely Woody Harrelson, Juliette Lewis, Robert Downey Jr. and Tommy Lee Jones - but it tanked at the box office and scored middling reviews from critics.

Far removed from its contentious initial release where the film was widely lambasted by the mainstream media for inspiring "copycat" killings, Natural Born Killers lives on as a cult fave.

Stone's bold, visually dynamic direction combines with Tarantino's sledgehammer-subtle critique of American culture and a quartet of unforgettable performances to deliver an uncommonly confronting piece of filmmaking.

It's an undeniably messy film, yes, but also a shining example of the hot-blooded, muscular work Stone was capable of in his better years.


9. Event Horizon

Event Horizon
Paramount

This grisly sci-fi horror flick is surely the best thing ever directed by Paul W.S. Anderson...despite the fact it didn't even crack half its $60 million budget worldwide and holds an inexplicable 26% approval on Rotten Tomatoes.

Event Horizon became popular with sci-fi fans almost immediately after it hit home video, though, and 20-plus years later, it's continually held up as one of the most striking and under-appreciated genre offerings of its period.

Stylish, inventively gory and boasting strong work from Sam Neill and Laurence Fishburne, this is the single work in Anderson's filmography that actually feels like a film, with atmosphere and thought put into it, rather than merely a product.


8. The Boondock Saints

The Boondock Saints
Franchise Pictures

The story of The Boondock Saints' eventual release is an absolutely fascinating one and arguably more compelling than the actual movie itself.

Writer-director Troy Duffy's script started out as one of the hottest being passed around Hollywood in the late-90s.

Even once it actually ended up shot, though, production woes and the unfortunate timing of the Columbine shootings resulted in the final movie only being released in five cinemas in the U.S. for a single week.

After it made just $30,471 theatrically while opening to largely negative reviews, Blockbuster came to the rescue and released it straight-to-video, where it grossed approximately $50 million, pushing the $6 million thriller far into the black.

Critics hated it and the film was sent out to die in cinemas, but the home video crowd fell in love with it.

Fondly remembered as one of the more evocative Tarantino-inspired thrillers of its era, The Boondock Saints has little patience for tone or taste, but its gratuitous violence, entertaining characters and gonzo Willem Dafoe performance make it an easy win.

The less said about that belated 2009 sequel, though, the better.


7. Dune

Dune Kyle McLachlan
Universal Pictures

This 1984 adaptation of Frank Herbert's legendary sci-fi opus Dune materialised following a lengthy development period in which both Ridley Scott and Alejandro Jodorowsky attempted in vain to get the film made.

David Lynch was ultimately hired for the job, and the $40 million tentpole opened to both brutal reviews and a dead-on-arrival box office (falling short of even making its budget back).

Dune was skewered for its impenetrable script, unconvincing effects and excess of melodrama, while Lynch himself eventually admitted that he probably shouldn't have made the movie.

However, in the 35 years since its release, critical favour has turned around somewhat, veering from uniformly negative to more mixed, currently sitting at a not-terrible 55% on the Tomatometer.

The film is absolutely more accessible if you have some familiarity with Herbert's source novel, but even if not, there are those who herald Dune as one of the most intriguingly baffling blockbuster experiments ever conceived.

That Lynch was ever given so much money to create such an oddball, off-kilter rebuke to Star Wars in the first place makes the film worthwhile to many.

It's certainly an interesting film whether it clicks with you or not, and it's little surprise that such a uniquely odd film, especially one produced by a strident auteur filmmaker, has its devoted army of fans.


6. The Room

The Room
TPW Films

Director Tommy Wiseau may refuse to admit it, but clearly his 2003 romantic drama The Room was created as an earnest attempt at a prestige-worthy movie.

Produced on an explicable budget of $6 million, the film scooped just $1800 from its initial theatrical run, with reviews railing it for Wiseau's flat direction and inconsistent performance, as well as its melodramatic and incoherent screenplay.

But this of course transpired into cult success years later as the film's infamy went viral, and Wiseau himself took advantage by hosting retrospective screenings catering to those who took a perverse joy in the movie's hilarious badness.

In the years that followed, a book was released, a video game and, of course, last year's terrific movie The Disaster Artist, which ironically scored a Best Adapted Screenplay Oscar nomination.

It's a terrific result for a movie which could've so easily faded into obscurity and been lost to time, but thanks to its uniquely charming awfulness and Wiseau's industrious promotion, The Room will endure for decades (if not longer) as "the Citizen Kane of bad movies."


5. Heaven's Gate

Heaven S Gate Kris Kristofferson
United Artists

Heaven's Gate is perhaps the most infamous example of filmmaker hubris that Hollywood has ever seen.

Fresh off Best Picture and Best Director Oscar wins for The Deer Hunter two years prior, Michael Cimino conceived an epic historical western which ended up quadrupling its initial planned budget as it ran wildly off-schedule.

The near-four-hour final film was a mind-boggling box office failure, grossing just $3.5 million against a $44 million budget. Its disastrous performance caused both the financial collapse of studio United Artists and the destruction of Cimino's career as a result.

To rub salt in the wound, it was also instantly scorned by critics, with many even deeming it one of the worst movies ever made. Ouch.

Contemporary re-edits of the film, however, managed to renew interest to the point that Heaven's Gate now sits at a nearly-fresh 57% on Rotten Tomatoes.

Though many recent reviews still contend that Heaven's Gate is a tough slog to get through, its sheer scale, ambition and heart-on-sleeve emotion has won it a cavalcade of staunch defenders.

While you probably won't want to watch it more than once, it's certainly worth a single viewing if only to observe the mind-blowing madness - and often, arrogance - of Cimino's beguiling vision.


4. The Fountain

hugh jackman the fountain
Warner Bros.

Over a decade before Darren Aronofsky confounded audiences and critics alike with mother!, he befuddled everyone with his glossy existential fantasy epic The Fountain, a tripartite, millennium-spanning meditation on love, life and death.

Even with its fairly modest $35 million budget given the ambition and visual majesty of the project, it tanked with audiences and failed to gross even half its price tag, while critics were and remain enormously mixed on it.

But just like mother!, the movie has its fans for sure, with Aronofsky's signature arresting visuals, loose spiritualist themes and, of course, a killer Clint Mansell musical score preventing The Fountain from fading into obscurity.

If you can swallow down some of Aronofsky's more heavy-handed and arguably "pretentious" symbolism, there is a sumptuous, emotional feast of a movie in here. And you can almost watch it thrice in the time it takes to watch Heaven's Gate, so there's that.


3. Showgirls

showgirls movie
MGM-UA

Fresh off the massive success of 1992's erotic thriller Basic Instinct, director Paul Verhoeven opted to helm the epic $45 million erotic drama Showgirls, a movie which upon release became an instant scarlet letter for just about everybody involved.

Savaged by critics for its unintentional humour, awful performances, excessive length, rampant misogyny and lack of actual titillation, Showgirls went on to win seven Razzie Awards including Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Actress (Elizabeth Berkley) and Worst Screenplay.

Reviews combined with a restrictive NC-17 rating resulted in it failing to even make its budget back theatrically, compared to Basic Instinct's incredible $352.9 million haul on a similar budget.

However, in the 25 years since its release, the tide of opinion has turned somewhat, with the film grossing over $100 million on home video, being embraced by fans as a campy, self-aware classic and even accepted as a serious satire by some contemporary critics.

Though Showgirls will never fully live down its initial infamy, it's fair to say that no other Worst Picture winner has enjoyed quite such a healthy and passionate discourse about its potential merits.


2. John Carter

John Carter Taylor Kitsch
Disney

The live-action directorial debut of Finding Nemo and WALL-E's Andrew Stanton is one of the most colossal flops of the last decade, a $300+ million sci-fi action epic that styled itself as "the next Avatar."

Once John Carter hit cinemas, though, the comparisons were closer to Will Smith's iconic dud Wild Wild West, with critics praising the film's style and visuals but panning its bland script and chaotic direction. It's fair to say that reviews were generally more mixed than outright negative, though.

Audiences weren't particularly enthused either, with the movie falling just shy of making its budget back, though in blockbuster terms it needed to gross around $600 million to actually turn a decent profit.

And yet, almost immediately after John Carter was released, a cult of fandom emerged around it, enamoured with its ambition, old-school charm and unique style.

Many lamented that it wasn't successful enough to get a sequel, and though it's not exactly regarded as criminally under-appreciated these days, many fell in love with its singular aesthetic and throwback appeal.


1. Troll 2

Troll 2 OMG
Epic Productions

Long before The Room, 1990 fantasy-horror Troll 2 was agreed by consensus among bad film aficionados to be the best-worst movie ever made.

Though made under the title "Goblins", it was marketed as a sequel to the 1986 box office success Troll, which it has no tangible connection to. Hell, Troll 2 doesn't even feature any trolls: it's actually all about goblins.

Despite bombing at the box office and being universally scorned for its appalling writing, direction and performances, Troll 2 won a second life as a viral online hit in the early 2000s.

Ever since, Troll 2 has endured as a fondly-embraced staple of bad movie fandom, defined by quotable, hysterically bad dialogue such as, "They're eating her! And then they're going to eat me! Ohhhh my goooood!" and "You can't p*ss on hospitality!"

Troll 2 child star Michael Stephenson even directed a documentary about the film's cult popularity, Best Worst Movie, which serves as a fascinating, hilarious and occasionally depressing companion piece to the oddball production.

As much as it fails as a serious attempt at a horror film, its gonzo campy value has kept it at the top of so-bad-it's-good movie lists for the last 15-ish years, and it's going nowhere anytime soon.

What do you make of these duds-turned-cult classics? Got any others to share? Shout them out in the comments!


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.