10 Famous Film Heroes Who Totally Failed In Their Quest
Heroes always win right? That's supposed to be how every great quest turns out. For all the trials our beloved protagonists face, for all the shocking events that endure, the deaths, the anguish, possibly even a couple of films fighting the enemy; the good guys always win in the end. The end... Except sometimes it's much bleaker than that in the movie world. Sometimes the good guys don't win. Or if they do, it's at a cost we didn't quite expect. Because sometimes our movie heroes ultimately fail in their quests. And that can go one of two ways; 1) It makes for amazing drama. Real life isn't always black and white and so our movies shouldn't be either. Good doesn't always triumph. Evil doesn't always win. And for all the escapism movies bring us, shouldn't movies have a sense of realism too? 2) It makes for an incredibly frustrating experience. This is a theme that will appear more than once in this article. You watch your heroes fight the good fight for a number of films. Sometimes they even succeed in their quest. But that inevitable sequel comes along and their quest is undone, we don't get the closure we need and we find ourselves repeat watching the whole franchise with a sense of doom. Realistic perhaps? But sometimes we need a simple tale of good defeating evil. Let me me take you through ten iconic characters that failed in their quests. Whether that was a good thing or not, well let's decide... 10. William Wallace (Braveheart)
THE QUEST Mel Gibson plays Mel Gibson the Scotsman AKA William Wallace, a patriot (not that film) who seeks to free the people from the tyranny of English rule and their ruthless king Edward The Longshanks. WHAT HAPPENS? Wallace's wife is murdered soon after the wedding and the tragedy leads him to declaring war against the English responsible. He gathers the support of Scottish nobility and becomes the figurehead for freedom as he leads a rebellion. Much bloodshed and passion on the Scottish war front. Oh and he has a bit of a fling with a French Princess who just happens to be Edward Longshank's daughter in law.... WHY DID HE FAIL? Sure the films ends with the battle, led by the once traitorous Robert The Bruce, but William Wallace himself didn't get to see this. In a tragic turn of events he is betrayed by those closest to him, brought back in chains the Tower Of London and brutally executed. Only after his death do the Scottish people finally rally to defeat the English.
9. Dr. Sam Loomis (Halloween 1-2, 4-6)
THE QUEST To warn the world of the danger that is Michael Myers. WHAT HAPPENS People die. Lots of people. No one believes Loomis and two thirds of the teenage population of Haddonfield end up dead. What starts off as a brilliant, tense piece of horror descends into hilarity. (And not in the good way!) WHY DOES HE FAIL Loomis comes off as a raving lunatic. Michael Myers spends five films leading a bloody slaughter, before Loomis himself finally succumbs to the killer's knife. Never has one man failed so miserably in his quest.
8. Indiana Jones (Raiders Of The Lost Ark)
THE QUEST To discover the lost Ark of the Covenant and stop it falling into the hands of the Nazis. WHAT HAPPENS? Indy ropes in old flame Marion Ravenwood to help find the Ark and they head to Egypt with their ally Sallah to uncover it's location. Fighting 0ff Arabs wielding scimitars, Nazis with machine guns and a tomb full of snakes, Indy actually finds the Ark but the enemy follows him and takes it. Indy might have found the Ark, but he led the Nazis right to it's location. WHY DOES HE FAIL? Well anyone who watched the recent 'The Raiders Minimization' episode of The Big Bang Theory will know that, despite all his awesomeness, Indy completely fails in his quest. In fact, fellow writer Simon Gallagher even surmised that he did nothing to affect the plot. Which is probably true. The Nazis do get their hands on the Ark because Indy inadvertently leads hem to it. And then they go and open the damned thing. Fortunately the light of God melts their skulls and they all die. Indy and Marion live on and the good guys win...because the enemy did exactly what they set out to do and perish as a result.
7. Neo (The Matrix Trilogy)
THE QUEST To free the last vestiges of Humanity from the machines that run the Matrix. WHAT HAPPENS? Neo is freed from the Matrix, fulfills his destiny as 'The One', defeating Agent Smith and leads the rebellion to free mankind. (Yes, The Matrix is still awesome...it's just ruined by its sequels). But then we're introduced to the Architect, the monster behind the machines, we have some silly dancing in an underground city, and Agent smith returns a hundredfold. The war rages on within the Matrix, while the machines invade the city of Zion. And then...well, we go back to square one and it kind of happens all over again... WHY DID HE FAIL? Well, like old William Wallace, Neo doesn't make it out alive. Sure, the machines withdraw from Zion but there are literally millions of humans still plugged into the Matrix. The initial war might be over, but humanity isn't free. The war will likely happen all over again. Or at least we think. Was it even that clear?
6. Ellen Ripley (The Alien Quadriology)
THE QUEST To destroy the alien menace and return to Earth. WHAT HAPPENS? Ripley encounters the alien after her ship lands on LV-426. She sees the entire crew slaughtered before she manages to destroy her vessel and blow the alien out of an airlock. Many decades later her escape pod is picked up and she (almost) makes it to Earth. Ripley heads back to LV-426 to destroy the alien threat that has arisen among the colonists living there. The marines accompanying here are picked off one by one, she locates surrogate daughter Newt, takes on the Alien Queen and...blows it out of the air lock (her weapon of choice). But she gets infected anyway, crash lands on a prison planet (loosing Newt and survivor Hicks in the process) and goes face to face with a new alien before throwing herself into a massive furnace to destroy the alien queen gestating within her and prevent the Company from getting hold of its DNA for their own nefarious purposes. Oh and then she wakes up a few centuries later, cloned and it starts all up again, resulting in a bizarre alien hybrid, and whole new alien threat that is only thwarted by the ship crashing into the Earth (and probably starting another ice age as a result!) WHY DID SHE FAIL? Another case of almost succeeding. As bleak as it was, Ripley did destroy the alien within her at the end of Alien 3. Only those pesky scientists got their hands on her DNA anyway and the whole menace returned and Earth kind of got decimated anyway. Stupid scientists!
5. Qui-Gon Jinn (Star Wars Episode 1: The Phantom Menace)
THE QUEST To help bring balance to the Force. WHAT HAPPENS? Qui Gon finds an irritating little kid Anakin, wins his freedom, brings him before the Jedi Council, announces that he is the 'chosen one' and will bring balance to the force. The Jedi Council refuse because he's 'too old'. Seriously? Did the Jedi turn every potential with masses of power away just because they'd passed their fifth birthday? No wonder they all lost... Qui Gon takes Anakin with him, meets bad ass Darth Maul and dies. Oh and Anakin...he goes on to become Darth Vader... WHY DOES HE FAIL? Well I guess, that's the question. On one side he didn't. Because of his actions, Anakin does bring balance to the force. (Two Jedi, two Sith)...it just results in the rise of the Galactic Empire, the death of the Jedi Order and civil war. And I'm fairly sure that wasn't his intention. At the other end of the scale, Qui Gon made it his mission to restore greatness to the Jedi. Well in that respect, he failed totally...
4. Sarah and John Connor (Terminator / Terminator 2: Judgement Day / Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines)
THE QUEST To stop Judgement Day. WHAT HAPPENS? Sarah is targeted by a cyborg from the future for termination. She encounters a man sent back to save her, has a night of passion with him, watches him die, manages to kill the terminator and gives birth to the saviour of mankind, John Connor. An even more awesome Terminator travels back to kill John while he is a teenager. Sarah is transformed into one of the greatest bad asses in film history and helps blow up the company responsible for the rise of the machines, kill the Terminator and saves humanity. Then she gets leukaemia and dies. John Connor goes off the grid, surviving on veterinary medicines and Judgement Day happens anyway... WHY DID THEY FAIL? First you've got to ask...did we need any more films after Terminator 2: Judgement Day? Not really. Because had that actually been the end of the saga 1) we would have only had fantastic films in the franchise and 2) Sarah Connor would have succeeded. Instead, all her actions in T2 and John's in T3 are for naught. What was a heroes victory against incomprehensible odds because a miserable tragedy where mankind is doomed to its fate.
3. Thor (Thor: The Dark World)
THE QUEST To keep Asgard Safe from its enemies. (Warning - spoilers to follow) WHAT HAPPENS? In Thor, our hero seeks redemption after reigniting the war between Asgard and the frost giants and prevents Loki from having his revenge and taking the throne for himself. Then there was a little film called The Avengers, with Loki up to his galactic brand of 'mischief'. Defeated after a resounding beating from the Hulk, Thor takes his half-brother prisoner back to Asgard. Loki is imprisoned. For an hour at least. You see, he's not all bad and Thor needs him to help defeat Malakeith from unleashing his own galactic Armageddon. And Loki is killed...or is he? WHY DID HE FAIL? If the ending of the second Thor film is anything to go by, then everything he sought to achieve in the first film is undone. Odin has been disposed and Loki, disguised as his father, is now on the throne. If Thor was about how Thor stopped Loki from ascending the throne then Thor: The Dark World is about how Loki got there anyway...
2. Frodo Baggins (Lord Of The Rings: Return Of The King)
THE QUEST To destroy the ring in the fires of Mount Doom and destroy Sauron forever WHAT HAPPENS? Frodo inherits the one ring from his uncle Bilbo, who stole it from Gollum / Smeagol, who stole it from Deagol, he found it long after Isildur was killed, who in turn cut it from Sauron's finger... With the help of the Fellowship, and later Sam Gamgee and Smeagol, he braves the perils of Mordor to make it to the fires of Mount Doom... WHY DOES HE FAIL? Possible one of the greatest narrative twists portrayed here so brilliantly on screen...Frodo succumbs to the power of the ring and takes it for himself. It is only the greed of Smeagol and a rather nasty struggle that results in Frodo having his finger bitten off, that the ring is destroyed...as Smeagol slips from the ledge and falls into the lava bubbling within Mount Doom. Had Smeagol not been there at the end...would things have turned out very differently? Or would Sam have been forced to fight his friend to destroy the ring once and for all?
1. King Arthur (Monty Python And The Holy Grail)
THE QUEST To find the Holy Grail. WHAT HAPPENS? Much hilarity. 'Bring out your dead!'. The Black Knight. (It's only a flesh wound). Camelot. (It's a silly place). The rude Frenchman and the Trojan Rabbit. Castle Anthrax. The Knights Who Say Ni. (Bring me a...shrubbery!) A wedding massacre to rival Game Of Thrones. The enchanter called Tim and his questions three. A monstrous rabbit. And lots of coconuts! WHY DOES HE FAIL? Because King Arthur and his knights of the round table stumble into a battle with the taunting Frenchman? Because modern day police burst onto the scene and arrest everyone? Because the Monty Python crew never intended to have a resolution? Does it really matter? This is (in my opinion) the funniest film they ever produced. And it's Monty Python. What do you expect? And there you have it. Some of our best film heroes failed in their quest because they 1) die, 2) had their actions undone by unwanted sequels, 3) their actions were ultimately pointless or 4) we got a few glimpses of delicious irony. Do you agree? Are there other, more fitting failures you would have chosen? Have I been too harsh of our movie heroes? Please feel free to share your comments below!