10 Film Directors Who Desperately Need A Win

Director's Jail can often be a very difficult place to escape from.

JJ Abrams Leia Rey
LucasFilm

Long gone are the days when movies were marketed and sold based on the person behind the camera, with the director now arguably one of the least important aspects in modern Hollywood when it comes to their most expensive and potentially lucrative projects.

Steven Spielberg, James Cameron, Christopher Nolan and Quentin Tarantino are some of the very new names who can convince people to go to the movies based on the strength of their personal brand alone, with existing properties and big-name franchise now king.

Even the likes of Martin Scorsese and Michael Bay have joined the streaming revolution in recent years, with many auteurs finding it more difficult than ever to get their latest efforts off the ground at the major studios. However, sometimes a string of bad movies in a row, constant rumors of misbehavior or even flat-out bad luck can have a profound effect on a director's career, one that can potentially take years or even decades to recover from.

10. Doug Liman

American Made Tom Cruise Doug Liman
Universal

Doug Liman may have directed one of the best sci-fi movies in recent memory in Edge of Tomorrow, and then stayed in the Tom Cruise business with wildly entertaining biopic American Made, but he still hasn't managed to shake his reputation as a filmmaker that greatly struggles to get his projects across the finish line, or even off the ground at all.

He's been labeled as difficult to work with ever since The Bourne Identity, and that tag has only gotten heavier around his neck in recent years. Not only did Edge of Tomorrow's shoot go way over schedule, Liman also re-shot the ending to his low-budget Amazon exclusive The Wall, and in the interim agreed to direct comic book flicks Gambit and Justice League Dark before quickly jumping ship on both.

His latest movie, literary adaptation Chaos Walking, started filming in August 2017 but isn't set to be released until next January, with the studio so unhappy with an early cut of the $100m blockbuster that they ultimately replaced him with Fede Alvarez when they decided to spend another $15m on extensive re-shoots.

His next project is set to be Edge of Tomorrow sequel Live Die Repeat and Repeat, and for the sake of his career prospects and reputation, he really needs it to go off without a single hitch.


9. Zack Snyder

Batman V Superman Zack Snyder Henry Cavill
Warner Bros.

There's been so much continued speculation surrounding the near-mythical Snyder Cut of Justice League that a lot of people might not even be aware that Zack Snyder recently wrapped shooting on $90m zombie flick Army of the Dead for Netflix.

It marks the filmmaker's first project outside of the DCEU since Sucker Punch almost a decade ago, and having dedicated so much of his time to a franchise that he's no longer the driving force behind that also seems to be quietly rebooting and distancing itself from his involvement altogether, how his next movie fares is crucial.

As a Netflix movie from a big-name director, Army of the Dead is going to rack up a lot of viewers regardless, but reviews need to be solid at the very least for a number of reasons. For one, Snyder is returning to the genre that launched his career with Dawn of the Dead, and his latest needs to be good enough to avoid comparisons or accusations that he's simply playing it safe by returning to the well.

Second, if it receives widespread critical acclaim then the conversation surrounding the Snyder Cut will only intensify, particularly with HBO Max available by then, but if it turns out to be a bust then his already-slim chances of ever getting to complete his original version of Justice League will surely be gone completely.


8. Alex Proyas

I Robot Will Smith Bridget Moynahan Alex Proyas
Fox

Alex Proyas will always be held in the highest esteem by fans of 1990s cult classics for directing both The Crow and Dark City, but you can't coast by on previous accomplishments alone, especially not in modern-day Hollywood. The 56 year-old has only directed three movies in the last sixteen years, but they've nonetheless marked an alarming slide into mediocrity for someone who was once pegged as sci-fi and fantasy's next big thing.

I, Robot seemed right up his alley as an Isaac Asimov adaptation, but it left a lot of big ideas behind in order to mold itself into a standard Will Smith blockbuster, although it did solid business at the box office. Nicolas Cage vehicle Knowing was also a decent-sized hit, but the movie completely fell apart halfway through and ended up being incredibly serious but also totally ridiculous at the same time.

Then came the infamous Gods of Egypt, which saw Proyas forced to publicly apologize for whitewashing the majority of the cast, with the end product being a massive box office bomb and one of the worst big-budget studio movies in years, although it has since found a second life as 'so bad it's good' entertainment.

After such a promising start, Proyas' career seems to be slipping away from him, and he needs to come back with his creative batteries recharged and a point to prove, or else he risks becoming a total afterthought.


7. Roland Emmerich

Independence Day Resurgence
20th Century Fox

Roland Emmerich built his reputation as being the guy the studios would call if they wanted to make a movie that blew up the world, and it worked out very well for him. Independence Day, Godzilla, The Day After Tomorrow and 2012 may not have been universally beloved by critics, but they all did huge business and the box office and solidified Emmerich's reputation as Hollywood's pre-eminent master of disaster.

When he finally decided to change things up and move into more serious territory, it coincided with him sliding down the industry's totem pole. Revisionist drama Anonymous tanked at the box office, which led to Emmerich immediately returning to familiar territory with White House Down, which turned out to be the least successful of 2013's competing 'Die Hard in the White House' movies.

Stonewall marked another venture into dramatic territory and was panned by critics, before he again reverted to type with Independence Day: Resurgence, which also suffered scathing reviews and failed to even earn half as much as its predecessor at the box office.

Last year's Midway was basically 'Roland Emmerich does Pearl Harbor', but didn't end up turning a profit for the studio, and with his recent filmography littered with critical and commercial failures, his next move could go a long way to determining if he was a future left at big-budget cinema's top table.


6. Oliver Stone

oliver stone mother
© Katy Winn/Corbis

Oliver Stone used to be one of Hollywood's most incendiary filmmakers, responsible for a string of classics like Platoon, Wall Street, Born on the Fourth of July, JFK and Natural Born Killers. However, in recent years his political stabs have become severely less pointed, and his genre efforts instantly forgettable.

World Trade Center, W. and Snowden all lacked the insight and focus that characterized his earlier, similarly-themed efforts, Savages and Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps were by-the-book genre movies that didn't really have anything to say, while the less said about the ill-fated Alexander the better.

Stone's singular voice used to be one of the loudest and most powerful in the industry, but if he continues down this current trajectory he could find himself in 'old man yells at cloud' territory before too long.


5. M. Night Shyamalan

Glass M Night Shyamalan Bruce Willis
Universal Pictures

The Sixth Sense marked one of the greatest breakout movies of the modern era, earning almost $700m at the box office as well as earning Academy Award nominations for Best Picture, Director and Original Screenplay, and instantly ascending to iconic status by delivering an all-timer of a twist ending.

However, less than a decade later M. Night Shyamalan had virtually descended into self-parody, with his subsequent output simply repeating similar tricks to increasingly diminished returns. He tried to reinvent himself as a director of big-budget blockbusters, only to fall flat on his face with the one-two punch of The Last Airbender and After Earth.

The Visit and Split saw him rehabilitate his reputation by going back to basics and working with smaller budgets, but the hotly-anticipated Glass saw him go full Shyamalan again in the massively underwhelming Unbreakable crossover fans had waited years for.

Over his last three movies we've seen both sides of Shyamalan, and whatever he decides to do next could be the make-or-break movie of his career. Either he reinvents the wheel yet again and pursues something wholly unique and original, or he continues being the guy known for big twists and nothing else.


4. Josh Trank

Fantastic Four Josh Trank
20th Century Fox

Josh Trank was only 27 when Chronicle hit theaters, and after the found footage superhero movie earned over $125m at the box office against a $12m budget and scored near-universal acclaim in the process, it looked like there was a new cinematic wunderkind on the block.

Then came Fantastic Four, which effectively torpedoed is entire career before it had ever really gotten started. There were countless tales of extensive studio-mandated re-shoots, reports of behind-the-scenes clashes and rumors of some truly bizarre behavior on Trank's part, and when the movie was released it bombed spectacularly at the box office and soon became known as one of the worst comic book movies ever made.

Trank was also dumped from Star Wars as a direct result, leaving his reputation in tatters. His first movie since the Fantastic Four debacle is biopic Capone with Tom Hardy in the title role, but that isn't even getting a theatrical release and is heading straight for digital instead.

If the reviews are kind enough, it could open a pathway for Trank to rehabilitate his career. If it gets slaughtered, then there might not be any way back for a filmmaker who once showed so much promise and potential.


3. Neill Blomkamp

Elysium Neill Blomkamp Matt Damon
Sony

As far as debuts go, District 9 was a hell of a way for Neill Blomkamp to put his name on the map, earning over seven times its budget at the box office and scoring four Academy Award nominations including Best Picture and Best Adapted Screenplay. At the age of 30, it looked like the South African filmmaker had the world at his feet.

Elysium and Chappie saw the law of diminishing returns begin to set in, with both movies echoing the socio-political subtext and themes found in District 9 without bringing anything new to the table, and despite the latter being released five years ago we're no closer to seeing Blomkamp's latest big screen effort.

During that time, he's focused on his experimental short film company Oats Studios and also tried to mount long-delayed sequels to James Cameron's Aliens and Paul Verhoeven's Robocop, although both projects ultimately fell apart and he doesn't seem to have anything currently in the pipeline.

There's no doubting Blomkamp's talents behind the camera and eye for sci-fi spectacle, but the lack of forward momentum is only going to hurt his prospects in the long run, and he could well be best served jumping into bed with one of the studios as a big-budget hand-for-hire.


2. Shane Black

Shane Black
MARIO ANZUONI/Reuters/Corbis

Shane Black will always be an icon to fans of the buddy genre having written Lethal Weapon, The Last Boy Scout and The Long Kiss Goodnight, but despite being the director of the twentieth highest-grossing movie in history, the 58 year-old really needs a hit under his belt sooner rather than later.

Iron Man 3 may have made over $1.2bn at the box office, but given that it was the first installment in the MCU to follow The Avengers, it was always going to be a massive hit no matter who was directing. Black's next foray into big-budget territory was The Predator, which bore the obvious fingerprints of heavy re-shoots and studio interference and only raked in a disappointing $160m worldwide.

Both of the original concepts that he's directed have bombed at the box office, despite Kiss Kiss Bang Bang and The Nice Guys being two of the greatest crime thrillers of the 21st Century. Both movies make great use of Black's signature style, but there simply wasn't much of an audience for either.

With four movies, one mega-hit and three flops on his resume as director, whatever he decides to tackle next could have a lasting impact on his standing in the movie business. Black has the talent and the reputation to hang with the big boys, but one more dud and serious questions will be getting asked.


1. J.J. Abrams

Star Trek Into Darkness JJ Abrams Set
Paramount

Before The Rise of Skywalker apologists leap to his defense, J.J. Abrams' position at the top of this list has nothing to do with the quality of his output or his abilities as a filmmaker. Instead, it asks if he's really earned his position as one of the most important and powerful directors in Hollywood.

Bad Robot have their fingers in many pies across Hollywood, with Abrams recently signing a huge first-look deal with Warner Bros., but when you look at his filmography as a director you notice a startling lack of originality. He's directed six movies so far, made up of a Mission: Impossible sequel, two Star Wars sequels, a Star Trek reboot and a sequel to that Star Trek reboot. The only original thing on it is Super 8, and even that's nothing but a blatant love-letter to Steven Spielberg and the heyday of Amblin.

Abrams has always come under criticism for his writing, and can you name any of his visual flourishes or signatures other than lens flare? Mission: Impossible III is the lowest-earning installment in the entire franchise, and his work on both Star Wars and Star Trek has faced highly-publicized backlash from certain sections of the fanbase. It's about time he threw himself into something completely unique and original instead of relying solely on existing properties.


In this post: 
JJ Abrams
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I don't do social media, so like or follow me in person but please maintain a safe distance or the authorities will be notified. Don't snap me though, I'll probably break. I was once labelled a misogynist on this very site in a twenty paragraph-long rant for daring to speak ill of the Twilight franchise. I stand by what I said, it's crap.