10 Film Parodies Better Than The Original
Sometimes mockery goes beyond tribute...
Oscar Wilde once said “Imitation is the highest form of flattery that mediocrity can pay to greatness” but he never met the likes of Leslie Nielson or Mel Brooks. Sometimes imitation is the highest form of flattery that greatness can pay to mediocrity, and those are the movies we’re going to look at today.
Film parodies have fallen out of favour in recent times. Seen these days as cash grabs of more popular properties, but it wasn’t always like this. Before lazily titled Disaster Movie and Meet the Spartans parody movies, were gut busting takes on films that took themselves far too seriously.
These films took an idea and improved on it by making it funnier, more satirical or even just more ridiculous than the original. Here are the 10 film parodies better than the original.
10. Hot Shots
Original Movie: Top Gun
Top Gun was already a little bit of a funny movie wasn’t it? I mean come on, the volleyball scene, the cheesy nicknames and who can forget the films love affair with the song “Danger Zone”. Don’t get me wrong the film is a lot of fun when its characters are up in the air, but when they have to come back down and talk to one another it can be the absolute definition of 80s cringe.
Well the people behind Hot Shots noticed all this as well and decided to make a gut busting parody satirizing the hyper macho, ultra-cool aesthetic of Top Gun. Charlie Sheen plays “Topper” Harley a caricature of Tom Cruise’s “Maverick” Mitchell. Sheen’s character has a lot in common with his more serious counterpart, a tragic backstory, a need to one up those around him (hence the name Topper) and some serious flying skills.
See what makes Hot Shots better than Top Gun is the fact that both are silly movies but only Hot Shots knows it’s a silly movie and leans into it. As well as some good hearty laughs in Hot Shots you also get the over the top action sequences that you’d see in Top Gun, except these are really over the top. At the end of the film Charlie Sheen takes down a whole squadron of enemy planes, then blows up a nuclear plant while dropping a bomb directly on Saddam Hussain, let's see Tom Cruise do that.
9. Scary Movie
Original Movie: Scream
Now I know I started this list with an intro berating what parody movies have become in recent years and that trend can be traced back to the first Scary Movie. But the sins of the son are not the sins of the farther and although Scary Movie had 4 disappointing sequels the first one holds up as a solid parody of the slasher film Scream.
Scream was already kind of a parody of slasher movies, so there was little satirizing the Wayne’s brothers could do with scary movie, except of course go the opposite route turning a clever and ironic movie into a stupid, gross and over the top one.
What the two films share is they both pushed the boundaries when they came out. Scream was as innovative as it was violent and Scary Movie was so crude and relentless in its jokes that people were shocked it only got an R rating. Let's clarify that Scary Movie was so shocking in its humour people thought it should have a harsher rating than the horror film it was parodying.
Scary Movie is not for everyone, there are people who prefer their comedy subtle and snarky. But if you’re the sort of person who finds people falling over funny (and there’s nothing wrong with that), then this big in your face parody is for you.
8. Spy
Original Movie: Modern spy movies
This one may surprise a few but spy was a clever and funny take down of the spy movie genre as a whole. Directed by Paul Feig and starring Melissa McCarthy you really begin to understand how talented a comic pairing these two are when they’re not working on a Ghostbusters movie.
Melissa McCarthy starts out the film as the voice in Jude Laws ear, giving him technical support. Jude Law does a phenomenal impersonation of a smooth and charismatic James Bond type but also plays it in such a way where you know he’s just a little bit slow. Once law is murdered then McCarthy must leave the desk and go out into the field to avenge him.
The film then manages to squeeze every drop of comic potential from its basic premises, employing a great cast of characters to aid it in doing so. We have Melissa McCarthy thinking on her feet as she guides us through this fish out of water story.
The aforementioned smooth but stupid Jude Law who, Peter Serafinowicz plays the handsy Italian spy Aldo who through out the film parodies how creepy certain characters were around women in old spy movies and maybe the best part of the film Jason Statham playing a parody of Jason Statham characters.
If you have any familiarity with spy movies this one has something for you.
7. Galaxy Quest
Original Movie: Star Trek
Galaxy Quest is more than a parody movie, it’s a love letter to its source material that with a different cast could have been a phenomenal episode of Star Trek on its own merits. Not that the cast is a problem, in fact if there was never a William Shatner, Lenard Nimoy and Nichelle Nichols then Tim Allen, Alan Rickman and Sigourney Weaver would be the next best three to replace them.
Tim Allen plays does a wonderful impression of the idea of William Shatner, a pompous and arrogant starlet who thinks he’s gods gift to women. Rickman plays the straight man to Allen being snarky and cynical throughout and Weaver plays the ships communication officer who is very aware of the fact she is there to be eye candy and reasonably frustrated by it.
They were all stars on Sci-Fi TV show Galaxy quest, a show that is mistaken to be a documentary by aliens who assume the misfit actors are actual heroes of the stars and recruit them to help them in their war. From there the film plays off Sci-Fi clichés and Star Trek tropes in increasingly hilarious ways.
6. Austin Powers: International Man Of Mystery
Original Movie: 60s Era James Bond film
The second spy movie parody to make this list but this one is a little different to Spy. Instead of taking aim at modern spy movies Austin Powers went back to the 60’s era of James Bond. This was the films first great idea because 60s Bond was campier, sillier and had a lot more room for comedy. The second great idea the film had was taking their campy and silly version of Bond and putting him in modern times, allowing the world around Powers to play straight man to his over the top theatrics.
But you know this movie is good, most people have at least one Austin Powers quote memorized through no fault of their own. If you say the words “1 million dollars” in conversation you have to fight the urge to put your little finger to your mouth.
The film never loses its light-hearted tone either. Far too often parody movies can become far too pleased with themselves and come off as smug, but not Austin Powers. All the characters are meant to be laughed at and not laughed with, there’s very little nodding and winking at the camera and these are things that make the film even better when you compare it to its campy but doesn’t know it predecessor, a 60s Bond movie.
5. Shaun Of The Dead
Original Movie: Dawn of the Dead
Shaun of the Dead is a subversive and witty zombie movie that came out at just the right time. Hitting theatres in 2004 before we were inundated with zombies in pop culture its amazing how Shaun of the Dead managed to satirize not just the zombie movies that came before it, but also the ones that came after it. Part of that is how broad the film is, somehow Shaun of the Dead manages to be a parody film, a zombie movie, a romantic comedy, a buddy comedy and an action film all at once.
It never feels forced though because the characters are so normal and relatable. Simon Pegg and Nick Frost are just a couple of losers who like getting drunk and playing video games but when the zombie outbreak hits they must go on rescue mission to save their loved ones and find a nice quiet place to wait until this all blows over.
It’s a fairly standard zombie movie plot but where it goes from there is truly special. Action sequences set to Queen songs, Uniquely British humour and the realisation that these characters are just normal people trying to work through their issues and can’t because they just keep getting interrupted by those pesky zombies.
Shaun of the Dead is a classic, perhaps the best out of the Cornetto Trilogy and one of the greatest zombie movies of all time.
4. The Naked Gun: From The Files Of The Police Squad
Original Movie: Any cop drama
Naked gun is not just one of the best parody movies of all time but one of the best comedy movies of all time period. We follow Lesley Nielson as Frank Drebin a hardened L.A detective and just like Jason Statham in Spy part of what makes Nielsen’s portrayal of Drebin so funny is its exactly the type of role Nielson had played before in more serious movies.
Because of this prior experience Nielson plays everything straight and serious which makes every crazy and wacky thing that happens in the film even funnier. For example, some parody films have a simple and normal plot because it allows them to focus on the jokes once they have a basic story in place. The Naked Gun on the other hand has a plot concerning a hypnotized baseball player trying to assassinate the queen of England and OJ Simpson.
The film employs a machine gun style of comedy that fires puns, slapstick and gags so quickly and efficiently you will need to re-watch this film to catch all the jokes you missed because you were laughing so hard.
3. Airplane
Original Movie: Zero Hour
From one Leslie Nielson classic to another, Airplane is a lot a like The Naked Gun they both have that fast-paced comedic style and they’re both directed by the Zucker brothers and Jim Abrahams. But Airplane might just be a little bit better, partly because it came out first meaning it was more ground-breaking than its spiritual sequel and partly because its one of the only parody movies to become more well known than the film its parodying.
Zero Hour came out in 1957 and has almost the exact same plot as Airplane. I’ve never seen it and I’m willing to bet you haven’t either. So that begs the question how good is a parody movie that its still funny even if you haven’t seen the film its parodying? The answer phenomenal and that’s exactly what Airplane is.
It’s a masterpiece of comedy with endlessly quotable lines. The main characters drinking problem and Leslie Nielsen’s dead pan delivery are just a few of the classic moments that stand out in this film. Yes, the tone of the movie is cheesy and juvenile and while that may be a criticism of a lesser film Airplane is quite often at its funniest when its being cheesy and juvenile.
2. Blazing Saddles
Original Movie: The Western genre
Well, how did it take this long for a Mel Brooks movie to appear on this list? To be honest most of this list could have been Mel Brooks films. Space Balls, Robin Hood Men in Tights and Young Frankenstein are all classics in their own right but if there was going to be only one Brooks film on this list it had to be Blazing Saddles.
What makes Blazing Saddles so great is it does not only satirize the entire genre of western movies but also the industry that created them. Brooks made a cowboy movie about racism long before Tarantino made Django. We follow Bart the black sheriff of a small town, hated by the town’s population. Brooks pointed out that while Hollywood was making idealized versions of the old west, they’d forgotten a lot of the ugly and racist parts of the time.
When Brooks cast a black actor as the sheriff in a story about how difficult it would be for a black man to gain acceptance in that time, you could be forgiven for thinking this is a serious film without any fart jokes. But luckily it isn’t, in fact it has a whole symphony of fart jokes, as well as a huge over the top dance number and a man punching out a horse.
Of all of Brooks’ parody movies Blazing Saddles is not only the most important with a heartfelt message but quite possibly the funniest too.
1. This Is Spinal Tap
Original Movie: Gimmie Shelter
What makes Spinal Tap such a good parody movie is if you showed it to someone who didn’t know the film was a spoof, they’d believe the band was real. Rob Reiner recruited fellow comedic genius Harry Shearer, Michael McKean and Christopher guest to satirize the genre of documentaries about rock stars. They decided the best way to do this would be to shoot hundreds of hours of footage, like a documentary and have the actors improvise, which creates a noticeable sense of authenticity in the film.
This approach also practically created a new genre, the mockumentary. So not only is Spinal Tap a hilarious parody that could pass for a genuine entry into the genre its parodying, its also a ground-breaking film that led to other great mockumentaries such as The Office, Arrested Development and What we do in the Shadows, to name a few.
You don’t have to be familiar with rock bands to get the jokes because you’ll likely have an idea of what a rock star is in your head, and Spinal Tap will meet the expectations in your head and then some. That’s why it's the best parody film of all time.