10 Film Sequels That Made Fans Rage Quit

Freddy became too much of a nightmare for fans.

The Riddler Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

Rage quitting typically is a video gaming term, referring to a game or a moment that angers the player so much they quit in righteous frustration and never return. But of course, that same sort of fatalist rage happens in the worlds of TV and film series as well, though, usually where the story takes a turn for the worst and fans bail out long before the end.

It’s never fun to be in love with a movie series only to have it break your heart, but it’s happened more than once. The danger of this happening gets higher with each passing entry, where the plot or characters become more and more ridiculous, to the point where audiences forget why they even liked the franchise to begin with.

Here we’ll be looking at a few examples of movie franchises that caused fans to walk away in anger, and the exact reasons why. Some of them managed to bounce back following a classy reboot, whilst other found themselves assigned to the bargain bin forever.

10. Superman III

Superman Iii
Warner Bros.

The third Superman movie is a relic from an era where studios didn’t know what the hell they were doing with comic book movies. The film makes Superman a supporting player in his own franchise, and instead focuses on Richard Pryor’s annoying criminal.

It’s a weird hybrid of unfunny crime comedy and superhero movie, and it’s remarkably dull most of the time. Christopher Reeve is still great and is clearly having fun playing the corrupted version of Superman midway through, but even he couldn’t save it. Lois Lane is reduced to a cameo, Lex Luthor is replaced by a lame substitute and there isn’t even any decent action.

Coming off the back of two great movies Superman III was a massive disappointment to fans, who wisely steered clear of Superman IV: The Quest For Peace a few years later.


9. Friday The 13th Part VII: The New Blood

Friday The 13th New Blood
Paramount

It was arguably the fifth movie that strained the fanbases relationship with the series, since it was a sleazy, mean-spirited affair with a twist ending that revealed Jason wasn’t actually the killer. The reception to that entry hurt the box office receipts for part six, despite the film receiving surprisingly good reviews.

Fans were pretty much done after part seven though, which is dismissed as “Carrie Vs Jason.” This outing was originally supposed to feature Jason fighting Freddy, but when a deal couldn’t be worked out Paramount decided to have him fight a psychic teenager instead. It’s a boring, badly acted chore to sit through, and it doesn't even have any decent gore since the MPAA insisted most of it was cut.

The negative critical reaction saw fans dodging the series for years, with the likes of Jason Takes Manhattan and Jason X suffering weak box-office. It wasn't until his reboot in 2009 that Jason became a box-office player again.


8. The Crow: City Of Angels

The Crow City Of Angels.jpg
Miramax

Considering the Brandon Lee tragedy on the original Crow, a sequel didn’t feel like the best idea anyway. City Of Angels had potential, though, with the director and screenwriter intending it to be completely different from the original. The story has a guy called Ashe coming back to life to avenge the death of himself and his son, by taking down the gang responsible.

Angels was a good deal darker originally, ending with Ashe being left to wander the earth as a spirit, following his decision to intervene in the affairs of the living. The studio was concerned about the borderline depressing tone, deciding to heavily re-edit the movie so it was more of an action flick.

The results were disastrous, resulting in a confusing storyline with inconsistent character actions and scenes that made little sense. The director disowned it, and it grossed less than half the original. The next two movies went straight to DVD, with the fourth entry – Wicked Prayer –being notable for just how awful it was.


7. Jaws 3-D

Jaws 3d
Universal

The success of Jaws 2 made a third entry inevitable, but neither Spielberg nor the original cast wanted anything to do with it. The studio pressed ahead anyway, deciding to set it in SeaWorld Orlando – which isn’t actually connected to the sea – and filming it in glorious 3-D.

The result is a stunningly dull “adventure”, where SeaWorld employees somehow fail to realise there’s a 35-foot shark hiding out in the resort. The effects for the film are legendarily poor too, with the money shot of the shark crashing into an underwater control room being a real howler. The film was as far away from the classic original as you could possibly get, and it killed interest in future sequels.

Not that the release of Jaws: The Revenge helped that cause much.


6. The Grudge 2

the grudge 2 sarah michelle gellar
Ghost House Pictures

The American remake of The Grudge was a surprise smash back in 2004, so naturally a sequel had to be churned out. They managed to bring Sarah Michelle Gellar back for a cameo, before throwing her off a roof because she didn’t want to star in the whole thing.

The rest of the movie is a patchwork of jump scares and needlessly convoluted plotting, and it’s so badly paced it’s easy to nod off for twenty minutes without missing anything. The creepy ghost lady with a sore throat returns to haunt some boring teens, but her power to chill had already been picked worn out by the previous movie.

It made decent money despite the horrendous reviews, but the studio knew better than to push their luck. They churned out a straight to DVD sequel a few years later, where it sat dusty and unrented on video store shelves.


5. Howling II: Your Sister Is A Werewolf

howling 2 stirba
Vidmark Entertainment

While not exactly Joe Dante’s best work, The Howling was a fun werewolf movie with great monster effects. He had nothing to do with this sequel, where the brother of Karen from the original avenges her death, and chases after an evil werewolf queen who wants to conquer the world.

Christopher Lee shows up as a werewolf hunter, and famously walked up to Dante on the set of Gremlins 2 a few years later to personally apologise for appearing in the film. It’s hard to blame him, since Howling II is so shoddy and poorly put together it acts as an insult to the original. It seems doubtful those who made even it even saw the first film, and lead Reb Brown appears to think talking quietly and then loudly yelling makes for a compelling performance.

Bad movie fans might get something from it, but those loved the original detested it, and the series subsequently headed straight to video.


4. Nightmare On Elm St 5: The Dream Child

Nightmare 5
New Line Cinema

The fourth Nightmare movie was an enormous success in 1988, but with Freddy at the peak of his popularity at that point, the only direction was down. It didn’t help that The Dream Child was an utter misfire, with a strange storyline about Freddy invading the dreams of an unborn baby, and set designs that Tim Burton would have rejected as “too gothy.”

The plot is muddled, the bodycount is low and the “Super Freddy” scene is the moment the series officially jumped the shark. It scored poor reviews and only made half the money of the previous entry, despite being released only a year later.

The next couple of entries – including the excellent New Nightmare – suffered weak box-office. His team-up with Jason give Robert Englund’s version of Freddy a decent send-off, but the less said of the remake, the better.


3. Hellraiser: Bloodline

Hellraiser Bloodline
Dimension Films

Poor Pinhead never achieved the popularity of his mates Freddy or Michael Myers, but he became a cult horror icon based on the first film alone. Part three attempted to turn him into more of a campy villain, with mixed results.

Bloodline pretty much crashed the series, though, despite the intriguing story. The film has three time periods, following the guy who created the puzzle box, a modern-day descendent and yet another ancestor in the future, who wants to destroy Pinhead once and for all.

The ambiguous idea is let down by a painfully low-budget, and the studio taking it out of the director's hands and hacking it to bits; hence the Alan Smithee credit. Audiences weren’t sticking around for more and the series then descended into straight to video hell, where only the most masochistic would bother to rent them.

2017 will see the arrival of the tenth entry Judgement, a film that appears to have been shot for around a tenner.


2. Batman Forever

Sonar suit Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

Warner Bros ditched Tim Burton after a backlash to the tone of Batman Returns, with parents feeling it was too dark and perverted for children. They replaced him with Joel Schumacher, who immediately caused Michael Keaton to walk away in disgust by asking “Why does everything have to be so dark?”

So he turned the franchise into a campy, garish nightmare, allowing Jim Carrey and Tommy Lee Jones to ham up a storm. It was basically a toy commercial masquerading as a movie, which lead to it becoming a huge hit. The backlash was swift and brutal, though, with fans lashing out at everything from the Batsuit nipples to the Batmobile driving up a wall.

Fans burned by Forever stayed far away from Batman & Robin, and toxic reviews ensued everyone else did too. The next sequel was canned, and a few years Christopher Nolan came along to wipe the memory of Schumacher’s era away.


1. Highlander II: The Quickening

Highlander The Quickening
Entertainment Film Distributors

This is a prime example of smothering a promising franchise before it had a chance. To be fair, crafting a Highlander sequel was always going to be tough, since the original ended with MacLeod winning the game and killing the other immortals; in short, the story was done.

It turned a healthy profit, though, so a terrible script was tossed together that retconned the original completely. It turns out the immortals were alien exiles from a distant planet, and in the sequel an alien general insists on killing the now mortal MacLeod – for no real reason – causes his immortality to return. He also resurrects Sean Connery’s mentor by screaming his name; it’s completely bananas.

The film is ugly, boring and nonsensical, and fans of the original left the cinema utterly disgusted with it. The Quickening regularly tops lists for worst sequels ever made, and subsequent Highlander follow-ups bombed.


Contributor
Contributor

Handsome. Charismatic. Intelligent. Noble. Witty. I'm none of these things, but I'm a half decent writer, I guess.