10 Film & TV Serial Killers We Can't Help But Love

We all go a little mad sometimes!

You know that awkward feeling when you find yourself loving the serial killer in a television show or film? Well, it happens more than you might think. As the explosive Loki fandom can attest to, it's not a secret that a lot of people identify with the villains more than anyone else. Whereas the heroes are usually noble and honorable and basically perfect, the bad guys are more complicated. There's a level of moral ambiguity that is intriguing by its very nature. But serial killers? That's got to be crossing some sort of line, doesn't it? Well, not really. It's not their fault that they're written to be more charismatic and interesting than the people that we're actually supposed to root for. Genuinely good people are wonderful in real life, but in a television show or movie, we're really just looking to be entertained. And no matter how bad they are, evil people are incredibly fun to watch. So sure, maybe sympathizing with (and let's be honest, sometimes crushing on) the bad guys means that we're probably all going to Hell when we die. But it's a small price to pay for the enjoyment that these villains have generously given us over the years.

10. Dexter Morgan - Dexter

Dexter Morgan has managed to capture the imagination of the viewing public, despite (or perhaps because of) the fact that he is probably the most accurate depiction of a psychopath that has ever been put on television. He struggles to understand and mimic basic human emotions, as well as fighting the urge to commit violent acts. But Dexter manages to blur the line between hero and villain, because he lives by a code. Although he is a vicious murderer, he satisfies his lust for violence by only killing other criminals. It's not ideal, of course, but he can convince himself that it's better than murdering innocent people. Rapists, murderers...the world won't miss them, or so he justifies it to himself. And there is a certain logic and elegance to the arrangement -- after all, as weird as it sounds, him horribly murdering serial killers does save lives. Interestingly enough, despite the fact that Dexter repeatedly insists that he is totally detached from human emotions, we do see him show affection and maybe even love to some of the people in his life, notably his foster father, sister, wife Rita, and son. You could pretty much write an entire psychology textbook on Dexter.

9. Patrick Bateman - American Psycho

Come on, how can you not be drawn to Patrick Bateman? He represents dark humor at its best, living in a shallow yuppie world where he's a stockbroker by day, psychotic ax-murderer by night. How can you not be taken in by the perfect light Bateman shines on the utter emptiness of modern society? The mask that he wears while he's out in public is a masterpiece, and Christian Bale creates so many small moments that really make the film. His entire interior monologue about the different types of business cards, and the horrible jealousy he feels upon realizing that one of his coworkers has a better business card than he does, is classic. Patrick Bateman is the one bad guy who is capable of making serial murder hilarious, no mean feat. You don't want to like him -- after all, he's a greedy, sex-crazed maniac who chops people into little bits. But when he makes the call to murder Jared Leto while enthusiastically extolling the virtues of Huey Lewis and the News, you just can't help it.

8. John Doe - Seven

The introduction of John Doe in Seven is so brilliantly done that by the time the character ever actually appears on camera, the audience's anticipation is at a fever pitch. It's a testament to Kevin Spacey's performance that the dramatic tension only escalates by the time he shows up. Director David Fincher goes to great lengths to conceal the identity of the serial killer from the audience, even excluding Spacey's name from the opening credits to maintain the element of surprise. And it pays off in spades. Throughout the film, he displays a captivating yet grotesque style of murder, creating a pattern of deaths based on the seven deadly sins. A vain model has her face mutilated and commits suicide (pride), a fat man is forced to eat himself to death (gluttony), and so on and so forth. But usually, there is some security in a serial killer who follows a strict pattern. If you know what he's done in the past, you can predict what he'll do in the future. Not so with John Doe. He continually raises the stakes, managing to maintain the upper hand until the film's shocking and abrupt conclusion.

7. Sweeney Todd - Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber Of Fleet Street

Sweeney Todd, Stephen Sondheim's interpretation of a penny dreadful serial killer. And to be fair, he pulls out all the stops. Todd is a maniacal barber, who kills his enemies by inviting them in for a shave and then slashing their throats. Is there a way to make this worse? Of course. He has a deal with Mrs Lovitt, who uses the human remains to bake into her meat pies that become a neighborhood favorite. Yummy. But Sweeney Todd also has a tragic backstory. When he was a younger man, he was falsely imprisoned by a magistrate who coveted his wife, and was sent away on a prison ship for many years. While he was gone, the magistrate raped and humiliated his wife, driving her to insanity, and raised the couple's infant daughter as his own. So while Sweeney Todd can't be totally absolved of his crimes, it's hard to feel sympathetic towards the victims who were complicit in the magistrate's evil acts.

6. Henry - Henry: The Portrait Of A Serial Killer

Henry is the only character on this list who is loosely based on a real person, with Henry: A Portrait of a Serial Killer drawing from the experiences of serial killer Henry Lee Lucas. It details a random killing spree throughout the Midwest, and tells the true crime story in the style of a horror film. At the center of the film, designed to appear as a grisly documentary, is Henry, played by Michael Rooker (best known for his work as Merle on The Walking Dead). He and his sidekick Otis travel around the greater Chicago area, killing indiscriminately but attempting to make the murders appear as random as possible -- having a different modus operandi for each crime would help them evade capture. Henry is hardly likeable, but the way that the film is made, on an incredibly low budget and with attempts to look as realistic as possible, makes his murderous antics incredibly engaging.

5. Billy Bickle - Seven Psychopaths

Well, first of all, Billy Bickle is played by Sam Rockwell, so we as human beings are contractually obligated to like him. He's one of the leading characters in the criminally underrated Seven Psychopaths, which comes off as an only slightly less intelligent version of a Quentin Tarantino film. Essentially, Rockwell plays the main character's best friend, who suggests that he use the recently publicized Jack of Diamonds Killer as the basis for his newest screenplay, the aptly named Seven Psychopaths. Then later, we find out that he actually is the murderer, who kills people and leaves a Jack of Diamonds playing card at the scene of the crime. But he only did it to provide his friend, suffering from writer's block, with a little bit of inspiration. It's such a strange, misguided display of friendship, and of course Sam Rockwell manages to sell it. But even beyond the frankly bizarre origin story, there's something a little bit different about Billy. Unlike a lot of serial killers, he isn't withdrawn or emotionally distant. In fact...well, is it too glib to say that his murder spree could basically be chalked up to, "it seemed like a good idea at the time"?

4. Tom Ripley - Plein Soleil/The Talented Mr Ripley

Tom Ripley is an undeniably odd bird. He's a master forger and professional moocher who is hired by a wealthy American to convince his son to toe the line and come home. And for part of the film, we don't really see any murderous tendencies on his part, just an overwhelming desire to be liked. Even after he kills Philippe (or Dickie, as he's known in Plein Soleil's slightly lesser remake The Talented Mr Ripley), it feels less like the premeditated murder we usually see from serial killers, and more the crime of a man who has been humiliated and is seeking revenge. That is, until he takes over Philippe's identity. A master mimic, he steals the late man's entire life, and doesn't hesitate to kill again. What makes Tom Ripley so interesting is that in a lot of ways, he's a riddle wrapped around an enigma. He spends so much of his time pretending to be someone else, that we never actually figure out who Tom Ripley really is.

3. Norman Bates - Psycho

Norman Bates is probably the most psychologically interesting murderer of the film world. Such is his appeal that he is not only the most enduring element of Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho, but they've even recently created a new television show that details the development of the famously unstable man during his teen years. He's devastatingly fragile, played with sensitivity by Anthony Perkins, which was in a way unprecedented for the role of a tremendously disturbed individual. The genius of Perkins' portrayal of Norman Bates was that the audience genuinely wanted to sympathize with him. On the surface, he came off as a slightly socially awkward, lonely young man. So while he certainly comes off as a creepy guy, one that you might shy away from being alone in a room with, the depths of his madness aren't immediately clear. You feel bad for Norman far before you realize exactly how far off the reservation he is. The introduction of a quasi-sexual, Oedipal relationship between Norman and his mother is fascinating, and is currently being explored in further detail on the alarmingly uncomfortable drama Bates Motel.

2. Anton Chigurh - No Country For Old Men

Anton Chigurh is so unique because he doesn't actually feel like a character, as much as he does a force of nature. He seems to embody the nature of fate itself in the slow, methodical drama No Country for Old Men. Chigurh is a nearly emotionless hitman, executing people ruthlessly and without sentiment. Except sometimes, he offers them a chance to live: with the mere flip of a coin, he lets them decide their own fate. There's this element of randomness that enters into the equation, then -- not only is the coin making a random decision, he is as well, when he chooses which people he kills outright and which he even offers the chance at a coin flip. With most serial killers, there's a lot of effort in the film devoted to figuring out how they tick, what made them the monsters that they are today. Chigurh is an ineffable figure, textbook enigmatic at its best. He is frightening and engaging precisely because we the audience have no idea what's going on inside his head.

1. Hannibal - The Silence Of The Lambs

Hannibal Lector is pretty much the gold standard when it comes to charismatic serial killers. He's a charming, sophisticated man, who just happens to have a taste for human flesh. Is that a deal breaker? The magic of Hannibal, and probably why he has become so popular over the years, is largely down to his ability to simultaneously fascinate and repulse us. Even the characters in the film can't help but be drawn in to his psychopathic allure. While Anthony Hopkins was the man who originated the iconic role of Hannibal back in 1991's Silence of the Lambs (only the third film in history to win the Big Five Oscars - Best Picture, Best Actor, Best Actress, Best Director, and Best Adapted Screenplay), the beauty of the character is that it isn't limited to just that one portrayal. Mads Mikkelsen has been taking a pretty fair crack at the famous cannibal in NBC's Hannibal, introducing his unconventional diet to a new generation of audiences.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.