10 Films That Should Have Never Flopped At The Box Office

fight club soap When a film flops at the box-office, there is usually a good reason. That reason is usually that the film is absolutely terrible. Although that's not always the case, sometimes there are outside factors at work which drag down what should be outstanding box-office smash... and as is the case with the following 10 films. The ideas were solid, the concepts strong but somewhere along the line, something went wrong and these films were denied the success they deserved. Some recovered nicely in later years, landing on their feet with a little help from the home video market, though others weren't so lucky and have been counted among the worst films ever. Let's take a look at 'em.

10. Speed Racer (2008)

Speed Racer

Budget: $120 million Box Office: $43,945,766 The Wachowski brothers became household names thanks to their visually stunning, ground-breaking Matrix trilogy. However their signature style of special effects heavy filmmaking did not earn them the same success in 2008 with the big screen adaptation of Speed Racer. The Wachowskis take on the classic sixties anime and manga character is a flashy showing of CGI and green screen. With lots of bright colors and fast paced racing action and little else. That's all somewhat understandable - after all it's a story about a race car driver - but where's the spirit of the old cartoons? Speed Racer was pop through and through, a campy thirty minutes of television where good triumphed over evil on the race track. That's what this film really lacked: the campiness. Speed Racer surely has enough fans to have made this movie a mild win, but stripping Speed of what the fans loved can only hurt. Had the Wachowski taken a step back, toned down the effects and lovingly amped up the corny nature of the old cartoons, Speed Racer would have raced to box-office success.

9. The Green Lantern (2011)

Green Lantern HeaderBudget: $200 million Box Office: $116,601,172 With the sudden boom of comic book movies in Hollywood, Green Lantern seemed like a no-brainer: a large scale sci-fi action adventure made to clean up at the box-office. But Green Lantern fell short of studio and fan expectations. The movie had all the components for a summer blockbuster except for one: a strong script, proving that - once again - visually stunning special effects mean little without a powerful story. In the world of comics, the Lanterns are some of the most in-depth characters with a long history and fascinating mythology. Though Hollywood seemed to neglect that in favor of expensive action sequences (possibly hoping comic fans would simply shell out their hard earned cash for anything born in the realm of the graphic novel), Green Lantern not only should have been a major success it should have helped get the ball rolling for DC Comics to begin a similar Hollywood siege like competitor Marvel Comics. Nope.

8. Howard The Duck (1986)

Howard the DuckBudget: $37 million Box Office: $16,295,774 Steve Gerber€™s comic book series Howard the Duck was a dark satire with surreal elements. One in which social issues were dealt with in a serious manner despite the fact that the main character happened to be a talking duck. Gerber had stated the main joke of the series was the simple fact that there was no joke. Such an absurd concept would be a hard sell as a film by today€™s standards, let alone back in the eighties, though George Lucas felt he was up to the task, working with director Willard Huyck. The original plan was to make an animated feature but Lucas was contractually obligated to provide his distributor with a live-action film and it was all downhill from there. The end result began with screenwriter who just didn€™t have a grasp on the source material, a script written to sacrifice story for special effects, and a film that couldn€™t figure out if it was meant for children or adults. Hopefully with the recent surge in Marvel comics based movies, Howard will get another chance at Hollywood fame, or at least a cameo in Iron Man 3.

7. Showgirls (1995)

showgirlsBudget: $45 million Box Office: $20,350,754 What was meant as a smart and edgy adult film turned out to be a trashy, poorly written box-office debacle. The first widely released NC-17 rated movie Showgirls was primed to pave the way for more adult oriented features. Too bad the movie was little more than a poorly-written skin flick. Showgirls should have broken new ground, and pushed cinema forward in its opening up of new story avenues. Instead it flopped, losing a good chunk of money and causing studios to shy away from the dreaded NC-17 rating.

6. Man On The Moon (1999)

url-18Budget: $82 million Box Office: $34,607,430 There are few people in the world who deserve their own movie more than Andy Kauffman. A true genius and an innovator in the comedy world, but we all know biopics are tricky business. You need the perfect actor to pull it off, an amazing screen writer and director, and - of course - a life worthy of an entire film. And in 1999, Man on the Moon had all those things. Sadly, much like Andy's career, it seemed people didn't quite get it. While Kauffman is a legend known by just about everyone nowadays (save for a few newborns), most people only know him by name, and a few choice career highlights. Today that's quickly changing thanks to the internet, though, and a quick Google search can lead to a detailed breakdown on everything Kauffman ever did. Man On The Moon was a superior film with an outstanding cast about a truly amazing talent. It was just ahead of its time, much like its subject.

5. Dune (1984)

dunefightBudget: $40 million Box Office: $30,925,690 Frank Herbert€™s Dune series is one of the most well-known and beloved science-fiction series in history. So it€™s only logical that that love would translate over to the film world, right? Wrong. In 1971 Universal Pictures set out to bring Herbert€™s epic tale to life, and acclaimed science-fiction director Ridley Scott sat in the captain's chair. A beautiful master piece of cinema was sure to follow. Then Scott dropped out due to issues with his brother€™s health leaving the project in need of a new director. In 1981 enter David Lynch, one of the most amazingly talented filmmakers to grace God€™s green earth. Lynch is one of those rare filmmakers who transcends film into the realm of art. The draw back to that was Universal had pumped quite a bit of money into this project and weren€™t looking for an artistic expression. They wanted a blockbuster, and the conflicts lead to several re-writes, then re-edits, and re-shoots. All of which came together to make a movie that to this day David Lynch refuses to speak about. What should have been an unforgettable cinematic journey ended up being a movie most would rather forget. Dull.

4. Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story (2007)

url-19Budget: $35 million Box-Office: $18, 317,151 One year before John C. Reilly and Will Ferrell became best friends, Reilly attempted to sing his way into American's hearts in Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story. A low-brow, spoof of Walk The Line, the Johnny Cash biopic. Co-Written by Judd Apatow, the film failed to bring in the big bucks even with the rising star power of Reilly. Perhaps had they waited a year until after Step Brothers was released and John C. Reilly became a fully fledged star, Walk Hard would have gotten the attention it deserved. None the less, a certified flop.

3. Grindhouse (2007)

Budget: $67 million Box Office: $25,037,897 I may not be the biggest Quentin Tarantino fan, but Grindhouse was a truly inspired concept. Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez's Grindhouse film was a love letter to the films that influenced their youths. Trashy, cheap exploitation with over the top stories, gratuitous sex and explosions. Unfortunately for the two super star directors, their wallets were a little too deep to pull this one off. The three hour flick was a bit too much for mainstream audiences to handle. And the Hollywood big budget feel was way too much for true Grindhouse fans. There is no doubt that had this movie utilized a shoe string budget, bad dialogue and hacky acting, the end result would have been a fairly successful commercial hit with a strong cult following.

2. Fight Club (1999)

fight club soapBudget: $63 million Box Office: $37,030,102 It's hard to imagine that director David Fincher's adaptation of Chuck Palahniuk 's nihilistic manifesto was ever anything but a hit (let alone such a box-office flop that it lead to the resignation of a top studio executive). But when Fight Club opened, controversy surrounded it and its main stream draw took a hit. Although you can't keep a good film down, and Fight Club's legion of devoted fans can prove that: it's considered a classic today.

1. The Adventures Of Baron Munchausen (1988)

url-1Budget: $46.63 million Box Office: $8,083,123 Cult film maker Terry Gilliam made his name back in the early '70s as part of Monty Python's Flying Circus. Since then, Gilliam has become one of the world's most beloved creative minds with highly imaginative and unique films like few others. In 1988 Gilliam would release The Adventures of Baron Munchausen, a film that would round out his Imagination Trilogy (the other two films being Time Bandits and Brazil). Despite critical praise Munchausen failed to show profit upon its theatrical run. Production problems lead to shoots running longer than accepted which ultimately lead to more money being spent. Making matters worse, Columbia Pictures (the intended distributor) was in the process of being bought out by Sony Pictures. But the final slap came when the film was completed. A measly 117 prints were made of the final film to be distributed throughout North American, giving it little to no chance of succeeding at the box office. If there was ever any film that didn't deserve to flop, it was this little gem. Like this list? Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Chris Librizzi is a Stand-Up Comedian from Atlantic City NJ. He has three cats, drinks too much coffee and is an avid Macho Man Randy Savage enthusiast. Dig it. (Dictated but not read) Check Chris out on Facebook and get yourself some free good karma http://www.facebook.com/pages/Chris-Librizzi/417127695030524