10 Films That Should Never Be Remade

Don't fix what isn't broken.

Rocky Horror Picture Show
20th Century Fox

Hollywood seems to be somewhat stuck in a rut.

For the last decade, there has been a sharp rise in the number of remakes and reboots circulating world cinema. Ghostbusters, Carrie, Point Break and Total Recall are just some to see their attempted remakes bomb at the box office and with critics, and let’s not divulge this current trend of Disney live-action remakes.

The big studios seem to be running out of ideas.

Not to say that original films are few and far between. On the contrary, you will be hard-pushed to find any remake in recent years to have been nominated for major awards, and this is how it should be.

The classics are classics for a reason, whether it be the outstanding cast, original ideas, incredible new special effects or narrative themes evoking issues of the time of its release, and many simply cannot make the transition.

Hollywood needs to put its emphasis on new, exciting ideas that can revolutionise the industry, not attempt to capture former glories. A surprisingly high number of films successfully stand the test of time, and hopefully, this selection of film industry greats will remain unpolluted by modern trends.

10. Vertigo

Vertigo still
Paramount Pictures

Every time Alfred Hitchcock’s name is attached to a project, it seems to be an instant success. From his entire filmography, it is the 1958 release of Vertigo that deserves to remain unsullied the most.

Centring around Detective John “Scottie” Ferguson, played by James Stewart, who retires from the force following the death of his partner. Scottie, however, quickly becomes enthralled in a favour for a friend turned love affair turned suicide case. So much for retirement.

Elster hires Scottie to follow his wife, Madeleine, whom Scottie quickly falls in love with. After declaring their love for one another, Madeleine appears to hurl herself from the top of a church steeple, killing herself.

This transpires to have been a ploy all along. Elster had actually hired a body double to impersonate Madeleine so that he could use the ‘suicide’ as a cover to dispose of his real wife, whom he had murdered.

Vertigo is a brilliantly told narrative filled with twists and turns, with just enough of that 1950’s Hollywood cheese to keep the audience nibbling like eager mice. Although modern Hollywood lacks original police/crime films, remaking the classics shouldn’t even be a last resort.


9. The Green Mile

Green Mile Michael Clarke Duncan
Warner Bros.

The Green Mile is one of the most emotionally moving films of all time.

Based around the memories of former prison officer Paul Edgecomb, played by Tom Hanks, we are transported into Cold Mountain Penitentiary just as John Coffey (played by the late Michael Clarke Duncan) is sentenced to death for the rape and murder of two young girls.

John is shown to have supernatural abilities, which he uses to cure cancer and bring another inmate’s pet mouse back to life, shortly before his execution, he discovers that one of the other inmates, William Wharton, had actually committed the crime that John had been found guilty of.

John reveals this truth to Paul and transfers his abilities into the prison officer. Unable to change the sentencing, John is executed for a crime that he had not committed, and Paul lives the rest of his life in quiet remorse.

The performances from the cast are powerfully moving, and offer a wistfully dark depiction into the life of an innocent death row inmate. No attempt at remaking this piece of cinematic brilliance could ever come close to capturing the raw emotion on display.

Sentimentality, sadism, wonder, despair, regret; this film has it all.


8. First Blood

Rambo First Blood
Optimum

After establishing himself as the legendary boxer Rocky Balboa, Sylvester Stallone went on to create the first of the Rambo franchise, First Blood, in 1982.

Centred around a Vietnam War veteran returning to an America that treats him as a dirty outsider, John Rambo is forced to run, hide and fight against the oppressive forces that seek to take away his rights as a human.

As an interesting analysis into the damaged psyche of a soldier, Rambo suffers from PTSD, and when abused by some police officers, Rambo reacts, if only in uncontrollable self-defence. Escaping into the woods, a manhunt ensues, with Rambo doing his utmost not to kill any of his pursuers.

Stallone has taken on many iconic films over the years, but arguably none with such a potent anti-war message. Although Rambo’s survival and combat skills make him an ideal soldier, he reaps no benefits from the time he serves.

If anything, he wields these skills as a curse.

This anti-war message is exactly why it should be left well enough alone; a remake today would simply be another fun/dumb action film.

Hopefully Rambo: Last Blood bombing with the critics and managing a marginal success at the box office will prevent any remakes or reboots. Hopefully.


7. Fight Club

Tyler Durden yellow gloves Fight Club
20th Century Fox

Fight Club is often touted as having one of the best twists to come out of Hollywood in the 21st Century, and it’s easy to see why.

We follow the brilliant interactions between Brad Pitt and Edward Norton’s respective characters, Tyler and Jack (one of Norton’s character’s various aliases) as Jack descends into the dark underworld of illegal fight clubs in order to combat his inner demons.

The duo opens their very own fight club and Jack unravels, growing cold and even resorting to blackmailing his former boss to fund his illegal racket. After the death of a fighter, Jack tries to stop the fights.

It turned out that, when Jack believed himself to be sleeping, he was actually assuming his role as his dissociated personality, Tyler. That’s right, he had been fighting himself all along.

After a confrontation with his own split personality, Jack manages to ‘kill’ Tyler, freeing himself of, well, himself. Pitt and Norton, supported brilliantly by Helena Bonham Carter, play their roles perfectly, and the fact of the matter is that Fight Club’s twist is something that must remain unique. Any attempts to remake this twist will fall flat.

If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. Don’t let your other personality fix it, either.


6. Jaws

Richard Dreyfuss and Robert Shaw in Jaws
Universal Pictures

The fact that Jaws scared cinemagoers so much that people stopped going to the beach and there was a documented spike in reported cases of aquaphobia is quite incredible.

Based around a great white shark with a hunger for humans stalking the coast of New England, Jaws is still the greatest shark movie of all time.

Many film critics are quick to point out the flaws in the film, including the buoyancy of the prop and the fact that hydraulic tanks are visible in the beast’s throat in some frames. Ask yourself this: have advancements in technology made fake sharks any better?

When we look at the Sharknado franchise and 2019’s The Meg, the answer is almost certainly no. 47 Meters Down and The Shallows are still very good films, but no movie shark has ever struck fear into the hearts of viewers quite like Bruce.

Alongside this terrifying foe is the fantastic performance of the fairly small cast. The core trio of Brody (Roy Scheider), Hooper (Richard Dreyfuss) and Quint (Robert Shaw) all provide stellar performances.

Their fear felt genuine, inviting the viewers to live vicariously through them and experience the terror as their own.

Please, Hollywood, never let a cheesy rendition like ‘we’ve got a bigger boat’ make it to the silver screen.


5. Casablanca

Casablanca farewell
Warner Bros.

Many war films – particularly surrounding World War 2 – retell the bloody massacres of different battles. The D-Day landings have been recreated so many times in Hollywood that I might make a different top 10 dedicated to it.

Michael Curtiz’s Casablanca, however, tells a contained narrative of the life of Rick Blaine.

Escaping the German invasion of France, Rick moves to the Moroccan town that the film is named after, opening a club named Rick’s. Having believed he had left his old life behind in Paris, his past comes back to haunt him as his ex-lover, Ilsa, flees to Casablanca with her new husband.

As one of the few war films ever to be released during the time of the war that the narrative discusses, Casablanca is a classic period piece that, had it been released even so much as a decade later, would not have had such a huge impact on Hollywood.

Between beautifully dour musical numbers, the building animosity between Axis and Allied soldiers and the undeniable chemistry between Bogart and Bergman, Casablanca is still regarded as one of the greatest war-time narratives and taught on many university film courses.

Casablanca is about to turn eighty years old and remains a compelling watch to this day.


4. Pulp Fiction

Pulp Fiction Samuel L Jackson.jpg
Miramax

It’s not often that you find a film with such a stellar cast from top to bottom as Pulp Fiction.

Samuel L. Jackson, John Travolta, Uma Thurman, Bruce Willis, Tim Roth, Christopher Walken… this cult classic is absolutely stacked with Hollywood stars, and the cast certainly live up to their individual reputations with fantastic performances.

None stood out quite so much as Jackson in the role as the leading man, Jules Winnfield.

The fact that this man’s performance alone is enough to ensure that this film will never be remade allows me to refrain from waxing lyrical about Jackson for the rest of the article.

Away from the acting, the standout of this movie is almost certainly the non-linear storytelling on display.

Cut into seven parts, Pulp Fiction never has a subsequent run of chronological events. Whilst many films attempt this on a far smaller scale – more often than not just using one or two flashbacks for some context and exposition – Pulp Fiction executes this storytelling method throughout, as opposed to relying on it as a gimmick to dump some key parts of the narrative on the viewer.

Pulp Fiction has built a huge cult following, and a remake should certainly never be considered.

Jules Winnfield, Ezekiel 25:17.


3. The Rocky Horror Picture Show

Rocky Horror
20th Century Fox

"I see you shiver with antici-"

Comedy? Musical? Horror? There are so many categories that Jim Sharman’s The Rocky Horror Picture Show can be shoehorned into. ‘Normal’ is not a tag that it can ever be associated with.

Rocky Horror brought to light all kinds of niches and taboo topics in Hollywood when it first appeared at midnight-movie screenings in 1975, obliterating conventional public opinions en route.

The film released in a landscape entirely different from what we know and accept today, thus giving a voice to many people that had been shunned and oppressed by wider society.

It is still seen as an iconic film for LGBTQ+ movements today, with Tim Curry playing the quite incredible role of Dr. Frank-N-Furter, a bisexual transvestite that seeks the secrets of life.

With a vast array of killer musical numbers – very literally 'killer' – Rocky Horror is by a long shot the most original musical to ever hit the big screen.

Sure, the whole idea surrounding suggested cannibalism and aliens launch the film straight into the downright ridiculous, but this takes nothing away from everything the film represents. For how vital the film was for its time, a remake would lose a lot of the magic and meaning behind the characters.

"-pation".


2. The Godfather

GODFATHER PT I
Paramount

Although many mafia movies have made their way onto the silver screen in the last forty years, none have managed to come even close to capturing the atmosphere of Francis Ford Coppola’s The Godfather.

Marlon Brando offers the most compelling performance of his career through the perennially calm yet always intimidating Don Vito Corleone.

Centred around the passing of the torch to Vito’s son, Michael – played by the brilliant Al Pacino in his breakout role – is forced to play a dangerous game against five rival families if he and his family are to survive the ongoing feuds.

This culminates in a brutal final few scenes as the Corleone family, at the command of Michael, wipe out the other family leaders, traitors and business rivals, to the detest of his wife.

With representations of mafia families and crime syndicates being fairly commonplace in the last few decades, it is not the story that cannot be recaptured, but the individual performances.

Each and every character fits seamlessly into this fictional New York, and whilst the subsequent sequels certainly could have benefited from closer attention to detail (and less nepotistic casting), The Godfather is certainly as close to perfect as we may ever see in the crime genre.


1. The Princess Bride

Inigo Montoya Princess Bride
20th Century Fox

Told from the perspective of a father regurgitating a bedtime story to his child, this Rob Reiner cult classic follows a tale of love, betrayal and revenge.

The young damsel, Buttercup, unfortunately, sees herself captured and kidnapped more than once: she is forced into marriage by Prince Humperdink, kidnapped by Inigo Montoya and gang, and rescued by her love, Westley, only to be recaptured by Humperdink’s men.

The Princess Bride did not sell well at the box office and only garnered a following after it was released on VHS. Nowadays, though, The Princess Bride is revered as an all-time classic, and an exceptional performance from Mandy Patinkin in the role of Inigo has seen Hollywood blessed with one of its all-time greatest quotes.

It continues to stand out in today’s movie collections through its combination of light-hearted fairy-tale tropes, interesting characters and just the right amount of ridiculousness.

In what would be the only starring film role of Andre Rene Roussimoff, better known as WWF’s Andre the Giant, any attempted remake of The Princess Bride would only draw comparisons to the original, and when the original is so adored, that is a risk that no studio should dream of taking.


Watch Next


Contributor

Lover of all things zombie. Secretly wishing for the apocalypse, but only on easy difficulty. Top of the world leaderboards for a couple of songs on Pro Drums on Rock Band 4. Can name every world flag. Currently doing my MA in Creative Writing in an attempt to do something with my life.