10 Films That Took Themselves Way Too Seriously
Who wants to see Arnie playing it straight, anyway?
To nobody’s great surprise, Paul Verhoeven recently professed himself unimpressed with the remakes of Total Recall and Robocop, claiming they missed the light tone of the original films.
“They take these somewhat absurd stories and make them much too serious. I think that is a mistake,” the filmmaker said. “Both those movies needed the distance of satire or comedy to situate it for audiences. Playing it straight without any humour is a problem and not an improvement.”
Humour has recently been in short supply at the multiplex, with any superhero movie that wasn’t Deadpool loaded with dark introspection, lots of growling and not much else. Most other pictures seem to have been made with a “no jokes” policy, lest audiences start to loosen up and start enjoying themselves.
Not every movie could be improved with a few jokes, but in the case of the following, they sure wouldn’t have gone amiss.
10. Maggie
Arnold Schwarzenegger finally gets a zombie movie with Maggie, and it’s everything you’d expect, with loads of action, explosions and a bit where Arnie shoots his zombie wife in the wife and says, “Consider that a divorce.”
Nah, just kidding. So listless that it might be an episode of Fear The Walking Dead under another name, Maggie consists of Arnie moping about while his daughter (Abigail Breslin) slowly succumbs to infection after being bitten. Just like FTWD, it’s basically a zombie story for people who’ve never watched a zombie movie in their lives.
Which begs the question: why cast Arnie? The last thing you expect from the Terminator, particularly at this stage of his career, is a bit of “serious” acting in a movie that goes nowhere fast. What next? A dark, introspective alien invasion movie starring Chuck Norris?
9. Crimson Peak
Crimson Peak yearns to be classic Guillermo Del Toro, but it lacks the wit and invention necessary to pull it off. If there really are two Del Toros – the Oscar caliber filmmaker who made Pan’s Labyrinth and the evil twin who directed Pacific Rim – then Crimson Peak is the work of the evil twin.
It’s a period gothic that’s aiming for profundity, but for all its symbolism and self-importance, the movie is all surface and no substance. Jessica Chastain, Tom Hiddleston and Mia Wasikowska try so hard to breathe life into the material but despite their efforts, the characters still sound like the invention of a pretentious screenwriter.
“The things we do for love like this are ugly, mad, full of sweat and regret,” Chastain says at one point. “This love burns you and maims you and twists you inside out.”
And so it goes for two hours, with the plot unfolding pretty much as you’d expect.
8. Final Girl
Final Girl – which is not to be confused with The Final Girls, starring Taissa Farmiga – should’ve been great. The main idea is that blonde, butter-wouldn’t-melt-in-her-mouth Abigail Breslin is trained to become the ultimate weapon against slasher movie villains, but the filmmakers play all their cards too soon.
Wes Bentley plays a creepy guy (doesn’t he always?) who tells Breslin how to turn the tables and go from victim to victor before sending her out into the field. Lured into a remote spot by some boys with murder on their mind, she easily defeats them, which was never in doubt – having watched her being trained for such an event, we know what she’s capable of, so where’s the suspense?
The lack of surprises mean that Final Girl plays more like a pilot for a failed TV series than a movie, and the lack of tongue-in-cheek humour leads you to expect more than the film delivers. If ever a movie could’ve used a Tarantino-esque non-linear structure (not to mention a few jokes), it’s this one.
7. My Soul To Take
Wes Craven must’ve experienced a ‘senior moment’ and forgot he was the director of Scream because My Soul To Take is as bad as one of that movie's clones, a joyless and pedestrian slasher where teens say “I’ll be right back” without irony, sneak up on each other, wander down dark corridors etc.
He probably forgot about A Nightmare On Elm Street and Shocker too because here’s another movie where the killer has supernatural powers, the family has a dark secret and the hero has a connection to the killer. At least the opening scene has a few unintentional laughs.
Moments after a TV reporter has informed us that The Riverton River, a serial killer who uses a knife with ‘Vengeance’ written on the blade, is still at large, Abel Plankov discovers just such a knife in his cellar, causing him to black out. He wakes up next to his wife, who’s lying in a pool of her own blood, which is when his psychiatrist phones to ask, “Is everything all right?”
6. The Happening
Attention fans of Signs and The Village: you’re the ones who equipped M Night Shyamalan with a bulletproof ego and allowed him to keep making humorless, po-faced movies. The Happening is all your fault.
Another in a string of anti-masterpieces that make The Sixth Sense look like a fluke, The Happening is bad enough to convince you that Shyamalan must be sending himself up. An early sequence where an entire construction crew leaps to their collective doom is funny enough, but it’s nothing compared to a scene where Mark Wahlberg attempts to brainstorm a solution but can’t concentrate because his colleagues keep shooting themselves.
Trapped in the midst of this, and looking like Bambi in headlights, is poor Zooey Deschanel. Hopelessly miscast, and called upon to deliver lines like “Just when you thought there wasn’t any more evil that could be invented!” her ‘stoned goldfish’ acting is the icing on the cake.
To Shyamalan’s credit, though, The Happening isn’t his worst film – The Last Airbender was still in his future.
5. The Reaping
The kind of movie that ought to star George Kennedy, play rural Drive-ins and eventually appear on Mystery Science Theatre 3000, The Reaping’s brief is simple: take as many clichés as possible and throw money at them.
Katherine (Hilary Swank), a former Christian missionary who lost her faith after her daughter died, travels to some Bible Belt backwater where rivers run red, frogs fall from the sky and a Creepy Kid stands staring at folks before weird stuff happens. There are also locusts, boils, stupid false scares plus it-was-only-a-dream sequences before the denouement, but you’ll have given up caring before then.
For most of the movie’s 96 minutes, you’ll wonder where the money went, at least until co-producer Joel Silver delivers one of those noisy, effects-heavy, supposedly show-stopping finales that are his forte. Overblown and incoherent enough to make The Matrix Revolutions’ climactic tussle look like a masterpiece of understatement, the skies are ripped open, characters are sucked away by death rays and the viewer is left wondering what all this has to do with the Bible, or even filmed entertainment.
4. Cabin Fever
Using the same script as Eli Roth’s 2003 movie, but with enough changes to make it “contemporary”, this remake is so flat and dispiriting that you’ll be convinced you’re watching a cheap knock-off from The Asylum. Characters you couldn’t care less about wander through a narrative that’s been nipped and tucked to remove all the racial and homophobic slurs, and in the process the filmmakers have somehow excised whatever charm the original possessed.
Numbing in its soullessness, all this dull rehash does is prove that attempting to sanitize extreme horror is a really bad idea. We get the same story about a group of college graduates that encounter a flesh-eating virus at a mountain cabin, but the filmmakers do nothing with it except change the ways in which certain characters die.
Whatever your opinion of Roth’s film, it at least had verve and personality, but this retread appears to have been slapped together by people who’ve never seen it. After a while, its by-the-numbers approach achieves something the original never did – it becomes boring.
3. Ouija
For a movie produced by Michael Bay, Ouija is surprisingly low on both humor and fun. Even Bay’s worst films attempt a little nudge-wink humor (remember Ben Affleck getting an injection in Pearl Harbor?) but Ouija’s script appears to have been divested of anything that might cause an audience to enjoy itself.
There’s an important fact to be gleaned from the movie, however: it turns out that the eponymous board, which can receive messages from the dead and in extreme cases lead to demonic possession, is really a harmless toy sold by Hasbro. Together with Bay, they’ve slapped together a joyless, utterly generic slab of teens-in-peril tosh that doesn’t even have the decency to be So Bad It’s Good.
You’d think the board had received enough publicity already from the 1,279 other movies where idiot teenagers attempt to communicate with the dead, but Hasbro and Bay think otherwise, so here’s another film where the lights go out for no reason and people start dying one after the other. Startlingly, at no point does anyone say, “It’s just like that cheesy movie I saw…”
2. Black Swan
Black Swan made $330 million worldwide on a $13 million production budget and won Natalie Portman an Oscar, but if you scratch the surface you’ll find a Joe Eszterhas movie ripe with corny clichés and cheesy laughs, making you wonder about the Academy’s standards.
Just like the world of (lap) dancing exposed in Showgirls, ballet is really all about sex, as is none-too-subtly shown when Vincent Cassel takes Portman for drinks, inquires if she’s a virgin and suggests she “live a little” by masturbating. Which, in one hilarious scene, she does – unaware her mom’s asleep five feet away.
Black Swan might consider itself High Art, but it’s really just tat with pretensions, the kind of film where every character has a way with sexual innuendo, even the fast food waiter (“Let me know if it’s juicy enough for you!”). Eszterhas specializes in cod psychology, but even he’d draw the line at delineating characters by dressing one in black, one in white, and suggesting our heroine might’ve gone off the deep end by having the eyes of her paintings literally follow her around the room.
Chalk such moments down to director Darren Aronofsky, who also gave us the immortal classics The Fountain and Noah.
1. The Equalizer
A movie about a mysterious vigilante who tangles with Russian mobsters really belongs in the 1980s, so it’s no surprise that The Equalizer, which re-teams Denzel Washington with Training Day director Antoine Fuqua, is based on the TV show that aired on CBS from 1985-9. Even though it's set in the present day, the film remains hopelessly stuck in the past.
Tired clichés are the order of the day, from slimy foreign gangsters to dirty cops, plus there’s also dialogue of the “f**k you, you mother**ker” variety and Chloe Moretz as a teenage hooker (with a heart of gold, obviously) who has Taxi Driver written all over her.
When she’s hospitalized by thugs, Denzel wipes out those responsible, which leads to a cat-and-mouse game with mobster Teddy (Marton Csokas, also a slimy foreigner in XXX and The Bourne Supremacy). You know the drill: they talk in a restaurant, Denzel gives him the “I’ve done things I’m not proud of” speech, Teddy decides to “send him a message” etc.
The script is by Richard Wenk, who also co-wrote The Expendables 2 and The Mechanic, which breeds expectations for a trashy good time, but don't get your hopes up. The Equalizer just wants to party like it’s 1989 and ignore how familiar the material is.