10 Films With Amazing Casts That Should Have Been SO MUCH Better

Turns out a great cast does not a great movie make...

Despite the fact that seeing a cast containing Brad Pitt, Michael Caine, Charlize Theron and Kevin Spacey would usually have you immediately buying tickets, big names do not necessarily a good movie make. But it's a natural reaction to get tempted into the cinema by a good cast list; after all the script, director and plot are all important, but none are as simple a sale to audiences as putting in a few famous actors. That said, how many times have your expectations been raised by a star-studded cast only for the film to be another turkey? Sadly, it's an unfortunate fact of Hollywood that sometimes studios throw money at big names to try and guarantee big bucks, even if it's to the products detriment artistically. Even worse, there are plenty of examples of a studio choosing the most recognisable talent over the best person for the role. The films on this list are those with casts so great it's almost impossible to figure out why they didn't work. In most cases, audiences flocked to see these movies thinking they were about to witness something special, only to come away entirely underwhelmed.

10. The Men Who Stare At Goats

Cast: George Clooney, Ewan McGregor, Kevin Spacey, Jeff Bridges What It Could Have Been The Men Who Stare at Goats isn't exactly a bad film, and for that reason it just squeezes onto the list, but with the cast it has, it really should have performed better, both critically and commercially. It's not just the cast which suggests this film should have been a major hit either: the plot, - remarkably based on a true story - was intriguing too. Ewan McGregor is sent to Iraq to investigate rumours that the US has been training a band of psychic soldiers to do battle with its enemies. What's not to love? The Reality Unfortunately the film never gets out of second gear. It's one of those comedies that only rarely extracts a chuckle from its audience, and while the performers are all pretty solid, there just isn't enough in this plodding movie to really get the actors sparking off each other. And with the film being so one-paced, the performers were always going to struggle to really grab our attention. It's a shame: nice idea, classy cast, but the execution is just too bland.

9. Mars Attacks!

Cast: Jack Nicholson, Danny DeVitto, Pierce Brosnan, Natalie Portman, Glenn Close, Annette Benning, Michael J Foxx, Jack Black, Tom Jones What It Could Have Been Expectations were this would be a self-consciously silly sci-fi romp, with a string of funny cameos from some of Hollywood's best acting talent - the cast list above is just the tip of the iceberg with this film; unbelievably, there is even more A-list talent on display than the cast list above suggests. With Tim Burton at the helm, audiences could rightly have predicted the B-movie look would be handled effectively, and that the film would include plenty of Burton's trademark macabre-isms. The Reality On paper, that's exactly what the film offers, but after a watching it, there's something deeply unsatisfying. It seems Mars Attacks! gets away with so much because of the B-movie pastiche it hides behind. Roger Ebert got it right when he said 'a movie like this should be a lot better, or a lot worse'. The fact is, the film sinks under the weight of its acting talent, and Mars Attacks! fails in its self-conscious attempt to become a cult classic because it isn't good enough and isn't stupid enough either. It was asking a lot to get Tim Burton and the incredibly varied and talented cast to make a 'bad movie' on purpose. What we get instead is a collection of 3 minute cameos which range from serviceable to distracting from A-list heavyweights, up-and-coming talent, and random celebrities.

8. American Hustle

Cast: Christian Bale, Jennifer Lawrence, Amy Adams, Bradley Cooper, Louis CKWhat It Could Have Been Everyone was getting excited about this one before it was even released due to the period setting, respected director and INCREDIBLE cast. In fact, such was the hullabaloo caused by the incredible ensemble that people forgot it was an average movie even after watching it. With the look and subject matter, audiences crossed their fingers for a film of Scorcese-like quality. The Reality Audiences were so eaten up deciding who was the better actor out of Bale, Cooper, Lawrence et al that they failed to realise this was all style and no substance. Even the usually acceptable running time of two hours seemed bloated here, and it was so obvious how reliant the film was on its period setting, spending way too much time on how the film looked. The film seemed to place aesthetics over story. In the end, there's little to say about it other than, 'look how curly they made Bradley Cooper's hair!' and 'boy, did Christian Bale put on a lot of weight for this movie!'. Perhaps unsurprisingly the film was nominated for 10 Academy Awards. Interestingly it failed to win any. Perhaps the interim period allowed critics to see through the casting and see the film for what it is: a decent film, but a bit light, and certainly overrated due to its big name stars.

7. Jonah Hex

Cast: Josh Brolin, Michael Fassbender, Megan Fox, John Malkovich Slow West may not be a bona fide classic, but at least it proved Westerns can still sort of work into the 21st century. Before that, audiences had to endure a run of real turkeys: Wild, Wild West and Cowboys vs. Aliens to name just a few. One film that seemed to have a chance of reinvigorating the cowboy genre was Jonah Hex. Warner Bros. sourced their movie from DC comics in order to give it a modern edge, and laced it with some great acting talent. Audiences tentatively hoped this would give the Western the kick up the backside it sorely needed. The Reality The end result was disappointing however. The decision to include Megan Fox is a perfect example of the dangers of when producers get money signs in their eyes, even if they know including such an actor is bound to hurt the integrity of the film. Instead of an edgy Western for a modern age, we get silly, made-up superpowers and Megan Fox-based innuendo. A missed opportunity and another failed attempt to convert comics into cinema.

6. Movie 43

Cast: Hugh Jackman, Seth MacFarlane, Kate Winslet, Chris Pratt, Naomi Watts, Emma Stone, Uma Thurman, Gerard Butler, Richard Gere, Stephen MerchantWhat It Could Have Been In getting so much acting talent on board, the feeling was audiences would finally see some major Hollywood talent out of their comfort zone, dipping their feet into a bowl of toilet humour for our collective amusement. The Reality That's what we got, but the quality was so low, we wished we hadn't. Many critics wondered how such an appallingly bad film could be made with so many hot-shot stars involved, and why they'd ever agree to join the sinking ship at all. The answer probably has a lot to do with economics. In agreeing to do a few days work on this film, the stars were then entitled to a cut of the profits. Win-win... or so it seemed. The resulting film is so bad it is a wonder it didn't take a wrecking ball to more actor's careers - just how Anna Farris and Chris Pratt picked up the pieces and moved on with their lives after their 'poop scene' together is anyone's guess. So bad is this film that even one of the longest roll-calls of A-list talent ever assembled couldn't save it from nestling among the worst movies ever made.

5. Ocean's Twelve

What It Could Have Been Another film to add to the list of 'Not Bad, But Should Be Better' movies. The first film in the series got everyone's attention because it was attempting to remake a classic with one of the most glittering casts in cinema history. Brad Pitt, George Clooney, Matt Damon and Julia Roberts all got together for an enjoyable and respectable re-romp. People expected more of the same here, only on an even more extravagant scale. The Reality Ocean's Twelve tried to repeat the formula but got caught out. People didn't need to see the same thing again. They were wise to the studio's tricks in using A-list celebs to pad over by-the-numbers storytelling. Ocean's Twelve tries to raise the stakes even higher with the inclusion of Katherine Zeta-Jones, but even she and her other acting counterparts couldn't do anything to battle the creeping sense that this was another unnecessary Hollywood cash-in. The movie isn't helped by a sloppy ending which sort of invalidates what went before it either. It's a decent enough film, but if you've got Clooney, Pitt and Damon on board, you're surely expecting a classic?

4. Sphere

Cast: Dustin Hoffman, Sharon Stone, Samuel L. Jackson, Queen LatifahWhat It Could Have Been Ignore Queen Latifah, Samuel L. Jackson and Dustin Hoffman in the same movie? Yes please! Just as encouraging to audiences was that this film was based on a story by Michael Crichton (the writer of Jurassic Park) who was hired to turn his novel into a screenplay. The Reality The problem is that this Crichton novel does not translate into film as seamlessly as Jurassic Park. The ideas are too abstract and the set-pieces - being attacked by a giant squid - too silly. As the film approaches its conclusion, the plot spirals out of control: thoughts turn into reality, memories have to be wiped, the crew's subconscious minds begin to communicate with them through the ship's computer - it all gets way too cerebral. Because of this, the film never gets the best out of Jackson or Hoffman. Instead, their characters spend most of the film staring at a glittering sphere and pondering the possibility of alien life forms. The high-brow content neutralises the acting talent.

3. The Dark Knight Rises

Cast: Christian Bale, Michael Caine, Morgan Freeman, Gary Oldman, Anne Hathaway, Tom Hardy, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Marion CotillardWhat It Could Have Been How many advantages does one movie need? Not only was The Dark Knight Rises working off the bat of two great movies in the series, it had enlisted an even heavier list of acting superstars to prop it up. When fans saw that Tom Hardy and Anne Hathaway had been added to the cast list, they were naturally excited. Hardy had already worked with Nolan, and his ability to change his physical approach to character meant he was an ideal fit for Bane. Similarly Anne Hathaway seemed an obvious fit. Add these names to acting royalty like Bale, Caine and Morgan and you've got safe hands all round. The Reality While some will always dispute this analysis, Rises is significantly weaker than the previous two films in the Nolan-directed franchise. Aside from the distracting plot holes, there's also the matter of Hardy's character being completely ruined in cinema by that voice mask that makes him impossible to understand. The main problem however is the dodgy pacing, with the film taking a good 45 minutes to hit it's stride. Since almost everything seems to happen in the final hour of this bloated Nolan outing, the film becomes a little too lop-sided to be rubbing shoulders with its predecessors.

2. Alexander

Cast: Colin Farrell, Angelina Jolie, Val Kilmer, Anthony Hopkins, Jared LetoWhat It Should Have Been Speaking of advantages, how about a film that combines a truly amazing cast of Oscar nominees with the sand and sandals story of one of the greatest military leaders in history? Alexander tells the story of Alexander the Great (who, for the record, led a pretty interesting life - the sort of life that should have made a great film) with Colin Farrell in the leading role. Expectations were high for this ambitious film, and after the cast list was released, most people were confident this was going to be closer to Gladiator as opposed to another Troy. The Reality It was not to be, and surprisingly a lot of the blame has to be pointed at the cast. The performance given by Anthony Hopkins is one of the hammiest of his illustrious career, while clearly no one dared tell Angelina Jolie the accent she affected would be distracting and frankly weird. Finally it's hard to accept an Irishman playing the role of Alexander of Macedon. Could they not have found someone even vaguely Mediterranean-looking for the role? Or at least given him a tan? The cast list initially looked to be a strength of this movie, but it certainly didn't turn out that way.

1. The Monuments Men

Cast: Matt Damon, George Clooney, Bill Murray, Cate Blanchett, John Goodman, Jean Dujardin, Hugh BonnevilleWhat It Should Have Been Has any film produced such an underwhelming, unenthusiastic response from audiences with such a glittering resource of acting talent at its disposal as Monuments Men? Almost certainly not. With a quirky story, WWII setting and the above names on board, it should really have been an open goal for this George Clooney foray into directing. While punters might not have been too excited by the initial story outline, they would have at least have hoped for fireworks from the actors. The Reality The end result is dull as dishwater, but perhaps it reveals the dangers of an ensemble cast more than most films. Rather than creating a competitive or stimulating environment for actors, maybe it just turns into a bit of a holiday instead. Since all of these actors have literally hundreds of acting credits between them, it seems likely a film like Monuments Men just became a place for them to turn in a solid enough performance, chat to some friends, pick up the cheque and leave. Sadly, there's such a mix of comedic and dramatic talent on display here, but it seems to have had a neutralising effect. It's a shame because, had filming begun at a different moment in the careers, you can't help but feel they might have put a bit more of themselves into the project. Or at least have had a bit more fun on screen. The end result is a cautionary tale regarding using A-list actors to cover up a shoddy idea. Which other misused ensembles belong on this list? Share your picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor

Adam Thompson hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.