10 Great Directors Who Should Really Helm A Superhero Movie

#7 - Rian Johnson This Friday marks the release of Thor: The Dark World in the United States, the latest in Marvel's cinematic journey to total world domination, sponsored by shawarma. It also marks the big budget feature debut of director Alan Taylor. Taylor is primarily known for his work television work on shows like Oz and Game of Thrones. Hiring Taylor was a risky move on behalf of Marvel Studios, but one that seems to be paying off if the early reviews are any indication. And Taylor's not the only interesting director coming down the superhero pike. Joe and Anthony Russo (known mostly for their work on Community and Arrested Development) are the men behind the camera on the Captain American sequel, and my wettest dreams are basically coming true as we'll see both James Gunn and Edgar Wright directing superhero films before the end of 2015. With such a diverse and creative group of people coming Marvel's way, here's a few more suggestions for some great directors that we would love to see make their superhero debut...

10. John Fawcett

John Fawcett For those of you who don't watch Orphan Black, which, statistically, is most of you, you should probably start watching Orphan Black. I've written about it before for WhatCulture - it really is a special piece of television, blessed with a phenomenal lead actress and filling the incredibly niche "TV Show About Clones" market that is so coveted by people who want to sell T-shirts but don't want to put in the effort to draw more than one face. The series is also bolstered by a truly wonderful directorial staff, including John Fawcett, the man at the helm of the show's fantastic season 1 finale. The sensibilities Fawcett acquired on Orphan Black would be really integral to grounding some of the more fantastical elements sure to arise in the more otherworldly projects Marvel seems interested in making. He'd be my number one choice to direct a Doctor Strange movie, or something else involving space or wizards or anything a director like Zack Snyder wouldn't know how to handle. Plus, his involvement could signal the coming of Tatiana Maslany as the next great force in the actress world.

9. Martin McDonagh

Martin Mcdonagh Shane Black proved with Iron Man 3 that you can make an out-and-out comedy superhero film and that it can work like gangbusters. And now that Martin McDonagh's directing is finally catching up to his superior writing skills, this would be a great opportunity to let him step up and take a superhero franchise. Nothing too lofty, but if you want a deeply funny and deeply emotional superhero film, McDonagh is your man. He likes profanity a bit too much to helm something aimed more at children (although Iron Man has always killed a disturbing number of people to be considered real children's fare), but it would be great to see him handle a Punisher film. Or, honestly, how about Iron Man 4? I don't trust many people to find distance left for Tony Stark to travel, but I'm positive McDonagh could find some really interesting places for Iron Man to go, almost definitely involving missing limbs. Maybe McDonagh's intervention means his muse Colin Farrell would come along for the ride as well, getting the chance to play a villain in a decent superhero film for once.

8. Alfonso Cuaron

Alfonsocuaron600 This will never, ever happen, but boy it would be truly wild to see! Cuaron is the man behind the best Harry Potter film (that would be Prison of Azkaban for those of you who like quality acting and genuinely good movies), as well as this fall's unbelievably huge hit Gravity. Gravity is that rare movie with a 98% on Rotten Tomatoes that has also made over $200 million. Cuaron is at a curious place in his career, then. I mean, where do you go from here? After Jon Favreau nailed Iron Man, he played a supporting character in the R-rated comedy I Love You, Man - I doubt very seriously that Cuaron is going to turn up anywhere in 22 Jump Street, so he's got to find some other place to hang his hat (preferably one not being made fun of by Jonah Hill). Cuaron would make a damn fine superhero film, and a few more financial successes could give him a Christopher Nolan level of freedom to basically make whatever movie he wants to make. And since I want to see Cuaron's Inception (or his Rango), it'd be nice for him to take the wheel of the third Thor movie or something. It would be damn interesting, to say the least. Also, go watch Children of Men: it is your civic duty.

7. Morten Tyldum

Morten Tyldum Ff

Tyldum is a name you probably don't recognize, unless you're one of the fortune folks who have seen Headhunters. Check it out. It's on Netflix and is a better thriller than American cinema has spit out in years. He's got a few American films coming up, including one starring Benedict Cumberbatch, who really has to have a Time Turner or something to make it possible for him to appear in every film. It must get tiring, being in all of those GIFs. Tyldum has a very interesting and dark sensibility and would be wonderful behind the camera of a really taught and suspenseful superhero film.

6. Paul McGuigan

Paul Mcguigan1 I know McGuigan as the director of the film Lucky Number Sleven, a film in which Morgan Freeman and Ben Kingsley play rival gangsters and Josh Hartnett just sort of runs back and forth helplessly between them being handsome. But I suppose most would know him as the director of four of the six existing episodes of Sherlock. That fact alone ought to be enough to a cause a literal earthquake of fan-casting from the depths of Tumblr, strong enough to shake the very Earth from its axis and send us careening towards the sun. Why, that's a situation right out of a superhero comic, the premise kind of adaptation I would love to see McGuigan develop. Huh, that metaphor came back in a roundabout way. Almost like I planned it like that.

5. Kathryn Bigelow

Bigelow is someone I named as a great candidate all the way back in my Wonder Woman article, and I still stand by her as the definitive person to direct that film. The woman behind The Hurt Locker and Zero Dark Thirty hasn't yet announced her next project, and it would be phenomenal if she made the switch to some more commercial fare, especially if it's only just for one amazing, exhausting shot. Maybe they'd let her direct the first real lady superhero movie, since Elektra doesn't count because ooooohhhh boy does Elektra not count. Girl power, Ms. Bigelow. Girl power.

4. Jack Bender

Jack Bender Bender is also someone I cited in my Wonder Woman article. The director of 38 episodes of Lost during its triumphant run on the Desperate Housewives network, Bender has more than proven that he can take sometimes the most ridiculous, unwieldy, obnoxious material around and turn it into something really memorable, heartfelt, and grounded. No matter how many Galaxies the Guardians are guarding, things must feel grounded and rooted to real human emotion. Bender might as well be the unofficial king of that sort of thing, making him the unofficial king of whatever superhero film he could choose to partake in.

3. Michelle MacLaren

Michelle Maclaren H It may seem like I'm specifically targeting TV directors for these positions. You wouldn't be entirely wrong with that assumption, although I'd watch where I was pointing that accusatory finger and if you want to see David Fincher on this list you can just go make one of your own (WhatCulture has a really wonderful application process). There's two main reasons I kept coming back to television for this article. Firstly, television is in its all-time Golden Age right now, with more great and diverse television on the airwaves right now than ever before. Television is where I am seeing the really interesting directors at work, those who are about to break out big time. Secondly, as with Alan Taylor, the Russo Brothers, and Edgar Wright making superhero films of their own in the next few years, it's not so unfeasible that any of these people could snatch up another spot. MacLaren has more than proven herself as a director during her time on Breaking Bad, and she would be as great as anyone might possibly be at the wheel of the S.S. Capeandtights. She did direct "Gliding Over All," after all

2. Adam Arkin

Adam Arkin1 Adam Arkin never really made it as an actor. He did some shows, but none of them really supplanted him into the public consciousness the way that he obviously wanted them to. So, like many handsome older gentlemen before him, he has stepped behind the camera in recent years and really proven himself as the creative lead. He recently helmed an episode of Sons of Anarchy, and was the leading director for Season 1 of The Americans, FX's amazing new show about Russian spies in the United States during the Cold War. He has also done more than a few episodes of Justified, and he handled some pretty fantastic ones at that. I never thought I'd say this, but the love interest from 8 Simple Rules for Dating My Teenage Daughter would make one hell of a superhero flick.

1. Rian Johnson

Another list entry, another Breaking Bad director. Rian Johnson is a directorial force to be reckoned with, and is the voice to be watching in Hollywood at the moment. His sci-fi film Looper, starring Bruce Willis and Joseph Gordon-Levitt with a suspicious forehead, was phenomenally reviewed and did bang-up work on Top 10 lists all across the land. You also might recognize his name as the one on the Breaking Bad episode "Ozymandias," one which your Facebook feed most likely called "The Best Ep of TV I have Evar Seen LOL Hands Down!!!" That's all I saw the night this episode aired, and is definitely indicative of something. It says that Johnson is going to be a huge force in the industry very, very soon. It says that he is a talented and wonderful filmmaker who is finally getting his due. And it also says that he would make one kick-ass superhero flick. Like this article? Who would you add? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Kevin Lanigan is a fun-loving Sagittarius who enjoys long walks on the beach and sunsets. While running a popular blog called Chekhov's Gunman, Kevin hopes to one day write the best movies and television you can complain about on the Internet. One of those movies, entitled IT DIDN'T TAKE, just opened up on Indiegogo and would appreciate all donations. Rosebud is a sled.