10 Great Film Ideas Utterly Wasted On Terrible Actors

10. Jumper - Hayden Christensen

jumper If you ask me, teleportation's just about the best superpower you could have. Yeah, maybe it's not the flashiest or the best for helping mankind (if you're into that kind of thing), but can you imagine never having to take the subway or go through airport security ever again? That's why the concept of Jumper is so interesting to me. I love the idea of this ability that hasn't really been explored in film too much, and the potential ramifications of its use. But here's where the film falls off the rails: they cast Hayden Christensen in the lead role. He's capable of turning in decent performances under only the very best of circumstances, and unfortunately his work in this film is poor to mediocre. Jumble the casting around and put Jamie Bell in the lead role, and you've got a significantly better picture... one that could have started a franchise.

9. Snow White And The Huntsman - Kristen Stewart

SnowWhiteandtheHuntsman-Still2 On paper, the idea of a darker, more gritty Snow White sounds pretty awesome. Less singing to birdies, more fighting. No complaints here. I've always found the Huntsman to be a really interesting character, so I was excited to hear that in the new film he'd be getting a lot more attention. And then I realized that Kristen Stewart would be playing Snow White, and my words of praise turned to ashes in my mouth. If she could have mustered up any amount of enthusiasm for the role, it might have been salvageable. Chris Hemsworth is fine as the Huntsman, and while Charlize Theron has a tendency to chew on the scenery a little bit, overall the performance works. The giant, insurmountable issue of this film is Kristen Stewart's complete lack of emotion or believability as the titular Snow White.... Her climatic battle speech is half-hearted and cringeworthy, and any momentum that had been building up to that point died a swift and painful death. Painful for the audience, anyway.

8. The Shining - Shelley Duvall

shelley duvall With Jack Nicholson going mad and the vengeful ghosts of people in the service industry, it's hard to imagine anything bringing this horror classic down. Even the child actors in the movie are all on point. So where's the weak link? Well, that would be Shelley Duvall. Her downtrodden, sniveling housewife is so over the top and tonally off from the rest of the film that it creates a jarring disconnect. Legend has it that this was an unusually difficult shoot for Duvall, who was often pushed to the breaking point by director Stanley Kubrick. She was consistently at the brink of hysteria, keeping water bottles with her at all time so that she wouldn't run out of tears. While I can appreciate her commitment to the craft, her portrayal of Wendy is a poor interpretation of the character.

7. Kingdom of Heaven - Orlando Bloom

kingdomOfHeaven How can an action adventure movie about the battles of the Crusades fail to be exciting? That's like, one of the most interesting, dramatic periods in history, and I would jump at the chance to watch a shiny, expensive, modern version of the events. Wait, what's that? You cast Orlando Bloom in it? Oh. Now, this might be a little unfair, because Orlando Bloom really isn't a terrible actor. He's just incredibly bland and not at all right for a film like this. Sure, he's nice to look at, but despite the high profile roles he's had in the past, he lacks a certain charisma and screen presence one needs to pull off these types of roles. Sorry, Legolas. It had to be said.

6. Gangs of New York - Cameron Diaz

fhd002GNY_Cameron_Diaz_009 Gangs of New York is a fantastic film, telling the story of the notorious Five Points neighborhood in New York City. Daniel Day-Lewis and Leonardo DiCaprio, as well as the majority of the supporting cast, really rise to the challenge of bringing the past to life. In fact, it features great performances from just about everyone except the inexplicably cast Cameron Diaz. She might work in lightweight romantic comedies or even modern dramas, but she feels so incredibly out of place in this period film. Give me about five minutes and I can give you a list of actresses who would have been better suited for the role. Maybe even one who could do a passable Irish accent. In doing further research, I happened upon a rumor that Sarah Polley was originally meant to be cast in the role, but the producers insisted upon the bigger star. Way to rub salt in the wound. This is why we leave creative up to the creative, guys.

5. School Ties - Brendan Fraser

fraser school ties I studied history in college, so I can appreciate a film that explores issues of anti-Semitism in American boarding schools, the WASP meccas of the world. It was definitely an ugly, pervasive problem that most people were willing to completely sweep under the rug and never speak about. But for the life of me, I don't understand why it needed to be Brendan Fraser. Don't get me wrong, Fraser's your guy if you need action or goofy comedy. Need to fight a mummy? Absolutely. But this kind of historical drama requires a defter hand. He just can't pull off the more serious moments, and the "COWARDS!" scene out in the rain is cringeworthy and all kinds of lame. This movie deserved to be made, and it really deserved to have a better leading man.

4. Liz and Dick - Lindsay Lohan

lohan liz Look, Elizabeth Taylor lived an interesting and glamorous life, and the late movie icon deserved so much better than this. I'm genuinely shocked that any movie executive did the math and decided that it was worth insuring the famously unstable Lohan when there are dozens of other less risky actresses who could have done a better job with the role. Maybe it was for the publicity, or even a kind-hearted attempt to revive an erratic starlet's acting career. But that doesn't change the fact that Liz and Dick could have been a strong film that honored Liz Taylor, instead of a trainwreck. No matter how hard Lindsay Lohan tries, she comes off as a girl playing dress up in shoes that are way too big for her to fill.

3. From Hell - Heather Graham

from_hell11 Everyone loves a fresh interpretation of serial killer Jack the Ripper, who went on one of the world's most famous unsolved murder sprees. It's not Johnny Depp's best work, but the premise is sound and for the most part the idea has real potential. He plays the drug-addicted inspector gamely enough, and Ian Holm turns in a panto performance that oddly works with the sinister Victorian atmosphere. The film falls apart, however, with Heather Graham's performance as a Whitechapel prostitute in danger of becoming Jack's next victim. This involves a misguided attempt at a Cockney (or possibly Irish) accent and acting skills that are not up to the level one would expect from an actress starring in a high-profile Hollywood film. She's not even convincing as a redhead.

2. Much Ado About Nothing - Keanu Reeves

keanu Emma Thompson, Kenneth Branagh, and Keanu Reeves: which one of these things is not like the others? The one thing that I've always respected about Keanu Reeves is that he usually knows the type of roles he should be playing -- he works in stoic (read: wooden) parts that don't require a huge amount of emotion. But wow, was he out of his depth in this movie. Wrap your head around the idea of Keanu Reeves acting in a straight Shakespeare film adaptation, alongside some of the best classically trained actors Great Britain has to offer. It's an inspired idea for a film, but who on earth thought Keanu Reeves needed to be in it? His discomfort with the material is immediately apparent, and it's borderline uncomfortable to watch him desperately try to keep up with the rest of the cast.

1. The Butterfly Effect - Ashton Kutcher

butterfly This film has a really cool, inventive concept. What if you could flash back to previous points in your life and change things? The smallest change could have drastic, unintended consequences, and you never know what you're going to wake up to. In a world full of sequels and remakes and adaptations, this was a unique, interesting idea. So the fact that they cast Ashton Kutcher in the lead role is really, really sad. He's a passable actor in the sitcom world, but on film his weaknesses are exposed and he comes off as incredibly one-note. Kutcher lacks the credibility to sell the sillier and less believable elements of the script. A wasted opportunity for a potentially awesome science fiction film. Any we missed? Let us know in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.