10 Great Films About Forbidden Love
The films that prove love is never easy.
Forbidden love is one of the most dramatic themes a movie can tackle. Tales of forbidden romance are as old as time, with some of the most recognisable coming from Ancient Greece and Egypt. These days, it's a theme best associated with William Shakespeare and period pieces.
Over the years, films about forbidden, tragic love have become more popular than ever, offering up slices of melodrama few other films are able to muster.
Such projects are also some of the most difficult to pull off. Try too hard and force the emotion, and what you're left with is an over-the-top, potentially cringe-inducing spectacle; don't try enough, and the film loses its emotional kick and ends up a tepid experience.
For this list, focus will be put on the films that took the concept of forbidden love and made it work without fault, whether it's a daring adaptation of The Bard's most famous work, a film about love confronting racial strife, or a drama that playfully - and tragically - looks at love in the most unconventional of places.
With that in mind, here are 10 great films about forbidden romance, ready for your next movie night.
10. Romeo + Juliet (1996)
There have been many brilliant cinematic renditions of Shakespeare's most recognisable play, from the excellent faithfulness of Franco Zeffirelli's 1968 classic, to the inspired musical West Side Story (1961). But no adaptation is as equally faithful and innovative as Baz Luhrmann's 1996 modern-day tragedy.
Starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Claire Danes as the star-crossed lovers, Romeo + Juliet tackles the Capulet-Montague feud almost as a gang war, fuelled by generational hatred. Amongst the friction, Romeo and Juliet fall in love, initially unaware of their family roots, and upon recognising their feelings for each other find their lives thrown into turmoil.
With an incredibly stylish aesthetic, vibrant action sequences and classic Shakespearian dialogue set against a modern backdrop, Luhrmann's adaptation of Shakespeare's play is a fast-paced, beautiful tale of forbidden love and the tragedies that come with it.
Some liberties may be taken with character and tone, but all told Romeo + Juliet is one of the most unique and heart wrenching interpretations of a story that has been maddeningly overdone through the years.
9. Loving (2016)
Certainly one of the most underrated films of the last decade, Jeff Nichols' powerful biographical drama tells the inspiring story of Richard (Joel Edgerton) and Mildred Loving (Ruth Negga), who were run out of Virginia in the late 1950s for violating the state's strict anti-miscegenation laws.
Loving sensitively details the racism the couple faced during their marriage, and digs deep into the Supreme Court case that they spearheaded to invalidate laws against interracial marriage.
A relevant and painful tale of prejudice and strength in the face of bigotry and racism, Loving is as much an historical drama as it is a tale of tragically forbidden love. Thanks to the truly phenomenal performances of Edgerton and an Oscar-nominated Negga, it's the love story that is most memorable about the film.
Despite the push backs from their community, Richard and Mildred never waver in their devotion to each other, and their strength is perfectly immortalised throughout the film. Theirs is a story that has to be seen.
8. La Belle Et La Bete (1946)
Like Romeo and Juliet, Beauty and the Beast is a story that has been done to death over the years, the most recent Emma Watson-led musical being one of the least inspired of the bunch. Whilst the most famous retelling of the story came with Disney's admittedly amazing 1991 animation, the most effective of them all is Jean Cocteau's 1946 version, La Belle et la Bete.
The first major movie adaptation of the original 1740 fairy tale, La Belle et la Bete is today widely heralded as an all-time classic of French cinema, a live action riff on the tale that uses startling practical effects to craft the image of the Beast (Jean Marais), who here is portrayed as lonely, misunderstood and broken by his curse.
The film is rife with striking visual metaphors linking to the Beast's isolation and Belle's (Josette Day) growing feelings for the monstrous prince. It's a truly magical experience, overshadowed by the Disney classic through the years, but still more haunting and beautifully crafted than any of the tale's various adaptations.
7. The English Patient (1996)
Based on Michael Ondaatje's award-winning novel of the same name, The English Patient is a tale of forbidden love, war, memory and regret. Ralph Fiennes stars as László Almásy, a severely burned cartographer being cared for by a nurse, Hana (Juliettte Binoche), in a war torn monastery.
During his pain-ridden final days, the titular English Patient tells his tale to Hana and monastery newcomers Kip (Naveen Andrews) and Caravaggio (Willem Dafoe). In his tale, he talks about an affair he had with a married woman called Katherine (Kristin Scott Thomas) and how they tried to make their relationship work despite the road blocks in their path.
The English Patient is a deeply moving tale of forbidden love and grief. Unlike most others on this list, it doesn't have a particularly happy ending, but remains all the same a staggering achievement worthy of its massive critical praise and Best Picture Oscar win.
The acting, set design and themes of loss, memory and retribution are all sublimely well-handled, and The English Patient is certainly one of the most powerful films of the '90s because of them.
6. Guess Who's Coming To Dinner (1967)
Guess Who's Coming to Dinner was ahead of its time upon its release in the late 60s, as it portrayed the interracial relationship of Joey Drayton (Katherine Houghton) and John Prentice (Sidney Poitier) in a positive and accepting light.
In the film, Joey brings John to meet her parents (Spencer Tracy and Katherine Hepburn), who are both understanding of the relationship despite the societal views of the time, but worry that their future will be too difficult to maintain because of the pressures put on them by American society.
This tension is ramped up and expectations are subverted when John's parents (Roy E. Glenn and Beah Richards) arrive and are equally pessimistic about the union.
An intelligent and deeply heartfelt film that asks some big questions - whilst supplying some affecting answers - Guess Who's Coming to Dinner is a stark movie with minimal sets, placing all its focus on the characters as they hash out their differences and discuss the problems of modern social norms.
Right up until its pitch-perfect conclusion, it's a film that defies expectations and still packs a punch all these years later.
5. Her (2013)
One of the most original and surprisingly affecting films of the last ten years, Spike Jonze's bizarre but soulful romantic drama casts Joaquin Phoenix as a depressed and socially distant writer who, in the midst of divorce from his wife (Rooney Mara) falls in love with an intelligent AI system (voiced by Scarlett Johansson).
An inventive and smart premise, Her is a film all about acceptance and falling in love with what makes you happy. Theodore's ex-wife doesn't understand his new relationship when she learns about it, and Theodore himself feels continuously confused by his own feelings on the matter.
Her, despite its strange sci-fi write-up and potentially off-putting subject, works wonders as a wholly human, thoughtful drama. It's darkly funny, tragic, and anchored by Phoenix's commanding lead performance and Johansson's impeccable voice work.
Admittedly, Her might be a touch too odd for some people, but between its thoughts on what love means and how relationships work, as well as Spike Jonze's inspired script, it's nonetheless a moviemaking masterclass with more than enough heart to keep itself afloat.
4. Brokeback Mountain (2005)
Ang Lee's emotionally devastating drama Brokeback Mountain stars Jake Gyllenhaal and Heath Ledger as a pair of lonely cowboys who, between 1963 and 1983, embark on a powerful affair whilst battling their conflicting feelings about their lives and their futures.
Ennis (Ledger) is the most complex of the pair, a man who struggles through the years to completely open himself up to Jack (Gyllenhaal), right up until the film's crushing finale.
With staggering, award-winning performances from Gyllenhaal, Ledger, Michelle Williams and Anne Hathaway, Brokeback Mountain pulls no punches in detailing the trials and tribulations of the men's relationship, which carries with it threats of violence, ostracisation and even death.
Few films can claim to be as affecting and important as Ang Lee's romantic drama, a film which leaves a lot open to interpretation but still manages to craft a compelling story about love in a complex form, without resorting to forced melodrama or unnecessary cliches.
3. Ali: Fear Eats The Soul (1974)
One of the most acclaimed German films ever made, Ali: Fear Eats the Soul is a romantic drama directed by R. W. Fassbinder, a leading voice in German filmmaking who created numerous classics throughout his career, including The Marriage of Maria Braun (1979) and Fox and His Friends (1975).
The most enduring of his films, however, has to be Ali, a moving and deeply symbolic movie in which 60-year-old German woman Emmi (Brigitte Mira) falls in love with Moroccan immigrant Ali (El Hedi ben Salem). The pair eventually get married, only for their relationship to find them shunned from their community and abandoned by their friends.
It is, at various times, uncomfortably funny, tragic and life-affirming. The way it details the pair's relationship and the prejudices of their community is hard hitting and even cruel, but thanks to the great leading performances of Salem and Mira, Ali: Fear Eats the Soul is still a hopeful tale of love and what it can overcome.
2. The Piano (1993)
The Piano is perhaps best remembered by many for winning Anna Paquin an Oscar when she was only eleven-years-old, and whilst she is undeniably an absolute triumph in the film, The Piano's biggest strength is its emotionally rich love story between mute pianist Ada McGrath (Holly Hunter) and sailor George Baines (Harvey Keitel).
In the film, Ada is married off to an emotionally distant and eventually abusive frontiersman (Sam Neill) in New Zealand, moving there with her daughter (Paquin) and forming a relationship with Baines in the midst of her loveless marriage.
A haunting, beautiful tale of love - both romantic and familial - and the power of music and fighting for what you love, The Piano is brilliantly put together, and anchored by an Oscar-winning Hunter. It's at times a distressing watch, but never overcooks the melodrama. Rather, it's the perfect balance of tragedy and hopefulness.
A brilliant character study and moody period piece, The Piano is a must-see for any major film fan.
1. Carol (2015)
When Carol first aired at the Cannes Film Festival, it was reported to have received a ten-minute standing ovation. Watching it even six years on from its premiere, it's easy to see why it was so acclaimed upon release.
Carol was directed by Todd Haynes with a script penned by Phyllis Nagy, who spent nearly twenty years trying to get the film made. It follows Therese (Rooney Mara), a photographer who finds herself forming a relationship with married Carol (Cate Blanchett) whilst the pair grapple with their conflicted love lives.
Set in the 1950s, Carol could quite easily have been made in the era; it's elegant, charming, stylish and beautifully shot, and only gets better when you realise how moving Mara and Blanchett are in their respective roles. Both are confused, emotionally and romantically, and the film works to craft a wondrous character study around Mara and Blanchett's seamless performances.
With Carol, romance and cinema have never looked so good.