10 Great Movies It’s Cool To Hate

We get it – it’s hip to hate the mainstream, right?

Avatar Scream
Paramount Pictures

You know the drill: a movie is released, lavished with praise from critics and mere mortal moviegoers alike and rakes in a tonne at the box office. It might even nab an Oscar or two or at least a spot on a few Best Films of (insert year here) lists. In short, the general consensus is that we have just witnessed a great piece of cinema.

Soon enough though the tide starts to turn and out of the woodwork crawl the cynics to tear the movie down. Admit it: the inner hipster that lurks inside all of us has done it. A film becomes wildly popular or exalted as the best thing ever and the very mention of its name triggers a hearty eye roll from us.

But just because a film is well-liked and – dare we say – a mainstream success it doesn’t mean it’s not a great film too. Yet there are a tonne of movies out there – truly great movies too – that get a lot of unnecessary hate.

And something needs to be done about that...

10. Titanic

titanic movie
20th Century Fox

James Cameron’s Titanic occupies the unique position of simultaneously being one of the most loved and most hated films in cinema history. Then the most expensive movie ever made, Titanic broke box office records and swept the board at the Academy Awards but almost as soon as adoration was heaped upon it a horde of haters crawled out of the woodwork to dis it at every opportunity.

Some of the criticisms levelled at Titanic are justified. Cameron did indeed often favour artistic licence over historical and technical accuracy and it was far cry from the films we were used to from Cameron like Aliens and Terminator 2: Judgment Day. And yes, Titanic’s flock of female teenaged fans were incredibly annoying.

But let’s ignore our inner cynic and be honest for a moment: it’s actually a brilliant film. It’s grandiose and romantic and a true modern-day epic. Go on, admit you love it.


9. Signs

Signs Mel Gibson
Buena Vista Pictures

Until Split was released earlier this year, director M. Night Shyamalan’s career had become something of a joke and his once masterful plot twists so predictable they practically became a trope themselves. While it’s true that films in his later career like The Happening and The Last Airbender are godawful, it doesn’t mean that earlier Shyamalan offerings should be tainted by their sub-par successors.

Case in point: Shyamalan’s 2002 alien invasion horror Signs. Yes, it has its implausible elements – namely Mel Gibson playing a priest and aliens that are deathly allergic to water invading a planet that is 70% water – and its ending is a bit cheesy but it’s still a creepy film with a brilliant build-up.

And don’t even try to deny that you crapped your pants when Shyamalan’s alien makes its big screen debut at the Brazilian kid’s birthday party. We all did.


8. Watchmen

Watchmen  The Comedian Jeffrey Dean Morgan
Warner Bros.

Calling a movie too faithful to its source material might seem like an odd criticism but that’s exactly what the haters had to say about Zack Snyder’s Watchmen. Based on Alan Moore’s graphic novel series of the same name – a dark and gritty take on the superhero genre complete with cutting social commentary – Snyder’s movie has been dismissed as too reverent (its altered ending aside) and alienating to non-comic fans.

To give Snyder his dues, he was in a tricky position. Stray too far from the source material and risk pissing off Watchmen fanboys or craft a faithful film and have people pan it as not cinematic enough – a damned if you do, damned if you don’t dilemma.

It’s a bit petty to write off Watchmen on these opinions and it still stands up today as one of the most visually stunning and thought-provoking comic adaptations, the latter being a quality not often found in the comic book movie genre.

Having said this, any critiques of that awkward Hallelujah sound-tracked sex scene are completely understandable.


7. La La Land

La La Land Ryan Gosling Emma Stone
Summit Entertainment

It’s only been out for a year, but the haters already have a few salty things to say about Damien Chazelle’s musical romantic comedy La La Land. It didn’t even take a whole 12 months for them to start piling on the hate really. You could practically hear the collective sneer earlier this year after that embarrassing Oscar flub when it was mistakenly announced as the Best Picture winner.

It’s too derivative of MGM musicals of yore, they cry. Or it’s too !*$% optimistic and brightly-coloured and Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone are clearly no Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers. There are far too many Toyota Priuses zooming around for a film about struggling actors and musicians and Ryan Gosling’s Sebastian is the quintessential white saviour singlehandedly rescuing Los Angeles’ jazz scene.

Okay, that last point has some merit. But as for some of the other criticisms, what’s so wrong with paying homage to films of yesteryear? What’s so bad about an exuberant movie that takes such delight in itself? Why do you hate Priuses so much? You bunch of miseries.


6. The Matrix Reloaded

The Matrix Reloaded Keanu Reeves
Warner Bros.

Like many a trilogy before and after it, the latter films in The Matrix franchise suffered under the weight of expectation created by its first amazing instalment. Was the trilogy’s second film The Matrix Reloaded as good as the original movie? Probably not, but that doesn’t mean it’s deserving of half the hate it gets.

Much of the flack that Reloaded gets focuses on the fact that it spends far too much time on exposition and waxing philosophically and not enough on actual action. While it’s true there’s a quite a lot of navel-gazing going it’s not necessarily a sad thing for a sci-fi action flick to have a bit of a brain, but the lack of action criticism is silly.

Are we forgetting about that epic freeway chase scene or the so-called ‘Burly Brawl’ scene in which Neo singlehandedly takes on a tonne of Agent Smith replicas? Come on, take the red pill. You know you want to.


5. Avatar

Avatar faces
20th Century Fox

When James Cameron’s Avatar was released in late 2009 it not only broke a tonne of records, becoming the first movie to pass the $2 billion mark at the box office and the world’s highest grossing film (a title it still holds today) but had everybody from Roger Ebert to Steven Spielberg hailing it as the best sci-fi since Star Wars.

But like Titanic before it, it was only a matter of time before Avatar started getting people’s backs up. Despite its ground-breaking and awe-inspiring visuals, sceptics started pointing out its similarities with other films – it’s Dances with Wolves in space! – and took issue with its supposedly anti-militarism and anti-American message. Or you know, it could’ve just been the fact it was both massively popular and massively profitable pissing off the film hipsters.

Unluckily for them, four Avatar sequels are currently underway. Expect the next wave of Avatar haters to rear their ugly heads when Avatar 2 hits screens in 2020.


4. Citizen Kane

Citizen Kane
RKO

Routinely hailed as the greatest film in the history of cinema, it’s not too hard to see why Citizen Kane might put off modern audiences. When you’re constantly bombarded with the fact that Citizen Kane is without a doubt the best thing ever and anyone who disagrees is a cultural ingrate and just doesn’t get it, it’s annoying and kind of alienating. In fact, it almost makes you want to hate it.

But film snob puffery aside, Citizen Kane is a landmark movie. Even if you can’t stand its outdated feel and admittedly slow pacing, it’s influence is undeniable. Those techniques that we scoff at as commonplace nowadays – deep focus, the invisible wipe, flashback, nonlinear narrative – were truly trailblazing back in 1941. Not to mention it was pretty ballsy back then in its takedown of one of America’s most influential men.

Like it or not, you can’t deny that Citizen Kane is the Citizen Kane of … uh … Citizen Kanes.


3. Interstellar

Interstellar Cooper
Warner Bros.

Clunky, silly, overly complicated, sentimental hogwash. Those are just a few of the less than pleasant things detractors have had to say of Christopher Nolan’s 2014 sci-fi epic Interstellar alongside such critiques as it’s lack of scientific accuracy (it’s a sci-fi fantasy not a documentary, people) or Nolan’s daring to mix science fiction and love (have a heart, for god’s sake).

Come to think of it, the Interstellar haters are part of a wider backlash against Nolan himself. Once popular Nolan films like The Dark Knight trilogy and Inception have too gotten a lot of flack after their initial praise. It seems like maybe Nolan’s transition from the indie fringe to Hollywood mainstream or the fact he’s able to make films that are both thought-provoking and entertaining, commercially successful vehicles irks people somewhat.

But back to Interstellar. It’s a beautiful film and if you can suspend your disbelief long enough, it’s really not that complicated or unbelievable. And who’s to say that love isn’t the fifth dimension, you cynical bastards?


2. Fight Club

Fight Club.jpg
20th Century Fox

The first rule of David Fincher’s Fight Club is that you do not admit that you love Fight Club, apparently. Although swathes of young men and armchair anarchists fell in love with its anti-establishment message, to be fair not everybody was so enamoured with Fight Club first time around citing its supposed promotion of violence, nihilism and toxic masculinity as worrying.

They kind of missed the point though: watch Fight Club a few times and you’ll realise that it’s really satirising the things its critics thought it was promoting. Since that initial backlash though, the nit-pickers have come out in force to dismiss Fight Club as trite and cliched – kind of like Anarchism 101 for the uninitiated.

But we suspect their dislike of Fight Club is far simpler than that. It’s a cult film that became wildly popular and therefore by default is no longer cool and impossible for any discerning film fan to admit they like.


1. The Blair Witch Project

The Blair Witch Project Heather
Artisan Entertainment

Almost two decades after its release, The Blair Witch Project has a lot working against it. Since 1999 the handheld, found footage thing has been done to death and it’s not really a film that holds up well under repeated viewings although the same thing could be said of many movies, horror and otherwise.

But what feels like a trite gimmick today was a breath of fresh air back in the horror landscape of the late 1990s and despite what the bravado-fuelled naysayers claim The Blair Witch Project was bloody scary – even if those its scares were simple and hinged on disembodied children’s voices and twig figures.

In a glut of found footage horrors, The Blair Witch Project may not be as unique as it once was but that doesn’t mean it isn’t still a great and ground-breaking movie. But please feel free to sh*t on its godawful sequels as much as you like.


In this post: 
Avatar
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Helen Jones hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.