10 Great Movies (That Were Led By Terrible Performances)

Going by this lot, you don't need good acting to make a good movie.

What makes a movie great? Wonderful direction? Inventive cinematography? A crisp, razor-sharp script? Phenomenal acting? In the cases of the films gathered here, three out of four ain't bad. In fact, three out of four is the downright best they can do. You would think, of course, that a film ultimately relied on the performance of its stars - and sometimes that is true. An actor must, after all, be able to convince audiences that they are their characters. Roles like Heath Ledger's Joker and anything Daniel Day-Lewis does continue to thrive in the microcosm of the cinema-screen because they grip us at every second. So whereas the roles here were never going to win any plaudits in acting circles, the films themselves still did not suffer as a result. And while we were tempted to compile a list consisting of every great Nicolas Cage film - and believe us it was hard not to - the article delves deep into the annals of film history to present those gems with a story so endearing and visuals so enticing they were impossible not to enjoy. Here are 10 films that survived on their many other strengths rather than failing thanks to any dud performances. Bad acting doesn't always mean bad entertainment, after all...

10. Transformers (2007)

We are only on the first film and already we are dividing opinion. Michael Bay's Autobots have come under heavy scrutiny in recent times. Revenge of the Fallen and Dark of the Moon were terribly self-indulgent and overly-long, and while explosions and fireworks still lit up the screen in humongous proportions, they couldn't capture the heart of the first one. But Transformers was a great time at the cinema. Robot grudge matches levelling cities, mind-blowing special effects, and spectacular set-pieces set it apart as a staple of the popcorn action genre. Kevin Dunn is reliable in his supporting role, and John Turturro gives his only enjoyable performance of the franchise as Agent Simmons. The amount of time the film spends with Shia LaBeouf is torture. Megan Fox is poor but it wasn't her job to act - let's be honest. LaBeouf spends the running-time at top decibel, screaming "BUMBLEBEE" every other scene and dousing us in lukewarm comedic stylings. Bashing Shia might be the hot thing to do at the moment, but his performance here is the epitome of his whole career - whiny bull-crap. At least we get Cybertronians smashing seven shades out of each other!

9. The Untouchables (1987)

The Untouchables is an absolute monster of the crime genre. From the music all the way to the direction, rounded off with a terrific Robert De Niro turn as mob boss Al Capone, Brian De Palma's picture is as entertaining as it is thrilling. There isn't a dull moment in this film. The assembly of the squad and the action sequences are encapsulate the tone. We hate the bad guys and we love the good guys. It's just a shame about the acting. Not so much Sean Connery (who is Hollywood gold), but the team of feds are so unbelievable in their roles; it's almost excruciating to watch. Costner's romantic scenes with his wife are painful in their melodrama; painting a very obvious picture of idyllic home life. His delivery is wooden and lacking any depth or emotion, but as is the rule with all his performances - he is just so entertaining. It's just like that old adage "it's so bad, it's good." Audiences can't quite put their finger on why they love him so much, but they do... just as they love this modern classic.

8. Dracula (1992)

Francis Ford Coppola's handling of Bram Stoker's tale, Dracula, received many critical accolades upon its release. His aversion to computer-generated effects and decision to use old-school filmic techniques to achieve the more difficult aspects of production has allowed the film to age well. It looks like it could have been filmed in the '70s, with a touch of classic cinema running throughout. Gary Oldman is fantastic as the titular antagonist, hiring a voice coach to help drop an octave in order to perfect the Transylvanian accent. Why couldn't Keanu Reeves do the same? Don't get us wrong - he is an entertaining actor who has made some very good films (Point Break and Speed to name two), but his forte is all-American good guys saving the day - he should stay away from that awful British accent for the rest of his career. His role as Jonathan Harker may be his worst - yes, even worse than Much Ado About Nothing.

7. Avatar (2009)

There is a reason James Cameron's Avatar is the highest-grossing film of all time. Not only is it a prime example of a well-planned promotional campaign, it also makes use of groundbreaking special effects. Audiences were literally transported to Pandora and into the world of the Na'vi. Zoe Saldana is wonderful as the lead female. Sigourney Weaver is her usual fantastic self. Giovanni Ribisi slimes himself up to play the part of a sleazy company executive with his heart set on cold cash. While it looks beautiful, though, the film lacks in originality - and even more so in the lead acting department. Sam Worthington has made a string of sub-par films including the likes of Terminator Salvation and the Clash of the Titans movies. Avatar is easily his best, but his performance remains the same. He's likeable, but he lacks charisma and often comes across as uninspired. He may look amazing under the guise of motion-capture, but it does nothing to mask the blandness of his performance. It was a good thing all eyes were on the amazing cinematography, then.

6. Rocky (1976)

The underdog story to top all underdog stories, Sylvester Stallone's Oscar-winning boxing film is one of the most beloved of all time. Spawning five sequels (all bar one are surprisingly entertaining) and an endless torrent of references in pop culture, Rocky was the film that put struggling star Stallone on the map. The music and score is legendary; its montages are some of the greatest sequences in movie history. Though it is uplifting, the downside is the acting. Burgess Meredith only has one function - snarl and growl, and you'd need subtitles in order to make it through some of Stallone's more low-key scenes. That being said, Rocky still lives on in our hearts, and his performance is as much loved as it is ridiculed. Fans often imitate the accent, yelling "ADRIAN!" at the top of their lungs... but the film remains a bizarre case of bad acting, making the piece even more enjoyable. Nobody could have played the Italian Stallion like Sly did, and for that, we should be grateful.

5. Titanic (1997)

Personally, Titanic is something of an enigma. Before Avatar came along, it was the highest-grossing film ever. It won eleven Oscars, beating out the likes of L.A Confidential and As Good As It Gets for Best Picture. All this for two and a half hours of boredom and a really cool scene at the end? Of all the heart-wrenching true-life tales of the Titanic, James Cameron opted for the fictional stylings of a poor boy falling in love with a rich girl. We could have bought into it if the acting had been better. Leonardo DiCaprio is like wine. His talent increases as he gets older, but there is a reason he wasn't nominated for Best Actor here. His performance as Jack is just so sickly and sappy - not to mention unbelievable. His lines feel forced and artificial, and while there are snippets of the man he was to become in later years, he is overshadowed in every scene by the likes of Kate Winslet and even Billy Zane. He may have stolen the every girl's heart in Titanic, but this is one act that was just too hard to swallow. Thankfully, the film is saved by the breathtaking sequence in which the ship hits the iceberg and tragically sinks; particularly poignant due to the fact it is a real historic tragedy.

4. Harry Potter (2001-2011)

J.K Rowling's seven-part series of books has sold more copies than the King James Bibles. It was inevitable they were going to be adapted into a film series. Continuing from its success, we got a theme park, three other books based on the Harry Potter canon, and another film is currently in the works. The breadth of British acting talent that appears throughout the movie adaptations is bafflingly good: Gary Oldman, Michael Gambon, Alan Rickman and Ralph Fiennes in the same films? Not to mention Kenneth Branagh, Maggie Smith and Richard Harris... we'll have as much as that as possible, Warner Bros.. The child actors, on the other hand - in particular Daniel Radcliffe - are excruciating to watch at times. It is forgivable due to their age during the original flick, perhaps, but scenes like "he was their friend!" in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban are... well, almost laughable. Luckily, all three of the main stars have gone on to improve their acting talents and delivered better and more mature performances as the series progressed.

3. Gran Torino (2008)

Let us start by saying Clint Eastwood is a legend. Simply put, he's one of the most influential and famous faces in Hollywood. His career spans over fifty years and he has acting and directing credits like The Good, The Bad and The Ugly, Million Dollar Baby and Unforgiven to his name. His performance as cantankerous army veteran, Walt Kowalski, is hilariously mean-spirited and racist; funny in the way old people are funny when they throw political correctness out the window. Clint is his usual reliable self, turning up the manliness and injecting his gruff, no-nonsense persona into the character. The supporting cast are not so ideal. The Hmong actors, particularly Sue and Thao, are terrible. There is no getting away from the fact they're propped up by Eastwood's performance and the direction he takes the film. The story may be one about change and equality... and the ending may be one of the most heartbreaking things we've seen, but we had to sit through nearly two hours of bad acting to get there. Without Eastwood, this film would have been insufferable. His keen directorial vision guides Gran Torino to the status of a wonderful modern masterclass in filmmaking, papering over the faltering work of the rookie support.

2. The Matrix (1999)

Oh, Keanu, we wondered when we'd be seeing you again. When The Matrix was released way back in 1999, it set the bar for what modern science-fiction cinema could be. Highly original with mind-bending special effects (not to mention a deep-seated social commentary), it was unlike anything anybody had seen before. Featuring strong support from Hugo Weaving as Agent Smith and Laurence Fishburne as Morpheus, the film found the perfect balance between drama, dialogue and action and cemented itself as the pinnacle of sci-fi entertainment. And who better to play a man essentially a robot than the master of the emotionless expression himself? Keanu Reeves stars as Neo, a computer hacker who has the potential to save the world from mind-controlling machines. As usual he is wooden and stoic, without a hint of human feeling etched across his face. But somehow this works - he plays the character as subtly as every other role he appears in - and looks a complete badass in shades. A rare example of a bad performance actually making sense in the context of the film?

1. Star Wars (1977)

Star Wars. The film that was everybody's childhood in one way or another. If you were lucky, you grew up with the original trilogy, basking in the glory of three of the greatest fantasy films put to celluloid. If you were like me, you grew up with the prequel trilogy and... well, it just wasn't the same. Despite George Lucas tearing apart what he created those many years ago, both share one thing in common - terrible lead performances. Whether it was Mark Hamill as Luke Skywalker or Hayden Christensen as Anakin, the protagonists have both been dull, uninspiring, generic and every other term you could think of. For that reason, fans have gotten behind supporting characters like Han Solo, Boba Fett and Yoda, who exude tons of personality despite being frequently out of the spotlight. The films are still so entertaining (well, the originals at least). They captured the hearts of every child in Western civilisation and the franchise still continues to grow and expand today. George Lucas may not have been the best writer or director, but it was the concept alone that saved Star Wars. Lightsabers? Darth Vader? The Force? We loved every minute of it. So much so, in fact, that we probably didn't realise how bad Mark Hamill's acting was. What do you think? Are there any other films that were great despite terrible performances? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

I love all things imaginative, from the page to the screen, and nurture a soft spot for Donald Sutherland and Daniel Bryan.