10 High Budget Horror Movies With Terrible CGI
Use your imagination or this is going to be an expensive disaster.
For better or worse, CGI is now an integral part of cinematic industry.
The advancement of technology to produce onscreen results that would not be physically possible otherwise, appeared perfectly suited for the horror genre in particular. As so many events within horror films are supernatural - and therefore physically impossible in real life - the importance of the ability to use computers to generate a nightmarish demon, monstrous animal or even a convincingly gory death sequence cannot be overstated.
The double-edged nature of this status quo, however, is that many horror outings have lazily slumped into a pattern of over-reliance on these eye-popping effects; emphasis on the quality of the story, acting and overall tone of the movie appears to take a back-seat over a visually convincing monster, who often only appears for short chunks of the film.
What morphs into an even more egregious crime against cinema, is when said visual effects fall depressingly flat onscreen. Excuses can be made when the film is an independent production on a budget of less than six figures, as the prospect that the movie's digital illusions are being engineered by a member of the crew with a laptop and some computer know-how is not overly entrenched within the realms of fantasy.
In rarer cases, when the film is a multi-million pound production that debuts an example of woeful CGI, fans are left scratching their hands as to how such enormous financial backing could lead to such dismal results.
10. Jaws 3-D
The third installment within the Jaws franchise holds the unenviable accolade of owning some of the worst CGI in cinematic history. Armed with $9 million, Steven Spielberg's 1975 epic original was an absolute triumph for the genre. While the animatronic shark may be unconvincing to contemporary fans, audiences who watched the film when it was first released were legitimately afraid to go swimming again afterwards.
Sadly, any advice to emphasize practical effects over computer imagery for Jaws 3-D clearly fell on deaf ears. Gone is the aura of ominous menace, replaced with shoddy graphics that do not come close to mimicking the success of Spielberg's robotic predator. The CGI sharks are poorly defined and brought to life in blocky, disjointed fashion; appearing as something vaguely resembling a shark crudely moulded out of grey clay. The embarrassingly sub-par climactic scene in which the shark explodes is so dreadfully animated that it is likely the same effect could have been achieved using a blank screen featuring only the word "BOOM".
Jaws 3-D sought to exploit the revival of 3-D technology at the time but the end result was a visual abomination. The fact that it possessed a budget of $18 million is absolutely comical when one considers just how unrealistic the film's digital efforts are. While Jaws was selected for the prestigious honor of preservation with the US National Film Registry as "culturally, historically or aesthetically significant", the only lasting legacy Jaws 3-D leaves behind is a disastrous case study in the dangers of low-grade CGI and franchise exploitation.
9. Deep Blue Sea
Deep Blue Sea is a triumphantly unashamed disaster of a movie, which is likely why the flick featuring genetically-enhanced sharks is so universally adored by horror fans.
The film is just as ludicrously ridiculous as it sounds; the sharks have larger brains as a result of the misguided work of scientists conducting Alzheimer's-related research. Said super sharks gleefully rampage through a damaged underwater facility, chomping through the unfortunate humans left trapped inside in the usual spurts of crimson gore.
Viewers do a double take when they see Pulp Fiction alum Samuel L. Jackson, appear on-screen as Russell Franklin, an executive sent in to assess the facility. The automatic assumption was that one of cinema's more notable badasses would take the reins and send these motherf*cking sharks in this motherf*cking facility packing, but viewers were proved sorely mistaken in one of the more dismal examples of CGI within the genre. Franklin meets his demise as he is devoured, mid-inspirational speech, by a creature more closely resembling Bruce from Finding Nemo than a genetically engineered apex predator.
The depressing thing is, the scenes that utilize animatronic sharks look absolutely sensational, especially when one considers the time that the movie was released. Regrettably, a large portion of the tension built up by these scenes quickly dissolves when one of the substandard cartoonish versions of the sharks pops up onscreen. While Deep Blue Sea remains a sleeper classic of the genre, it is hard not to wistfully imagine what might have been had the computer generated scenes reflected the film's budget of roughly $70 million.
8. Anaconda
While Anaconda maintains cult classic status amongst horror fans, it is not so beloved amongst those who need passable visual effects in order to enjoy a movie. The film follows a crazed snake hunter in pursuit of the titular titanic anaconda, who weasels his way onto a boat cruising down the Amazon River much to the misfortune of his fellow passengers.
Much like Deep Blue Sea, the sequences within Anaconda that make use of animatronic animal antagonists are absolutely spectacular, particularly when one takes into account the fact that the film was released in 1997. The film made use of two 40-foot-long robotic anacondas that weighed roughly a ton - essentially the serpentine equivalent of the titular shark in Jaws.
Anaconda's thin plot and flimsily constructed characters do not give the film much leeway to trip over its own feet, but do so it does whenever CGI is required. The sad reality is, due to the dangers of an extremely heavy robot flailing around maniacally, most of the picture's action shots are completely reliant on computer-enhanced imagery and fall dismally flat onscreen as a result. The sequences involving the snake wrapped around J-Lo and Ice Cube are particularly wince-worthy.
Despite being bestowed with a colossal budget of $45 million, Anaconda is the perfect unfortunate example of a film possessing a premise far beyond the abilities of computer imagery of the time. However, the movie is still adored by fright fans worldwide and wears its notoriously shaky graphics like a badge of honor.
7. A Nightmare On Elm Street
Samuel Bayer has a lot to answer for.
A Nightmare on Elm Street is an iconic staple of the genre; Wes Craven's original holds revered status amongst fright fans and is considered to be one of the frontrunners for the title of the greatest and most influential horror outing in cinematic history.
This makes Bayer's handling of the 2010 reboot that much more egregious. Despite an enormous budget of $35 million, the remake received almost entirely negative critical reception; many cited the film's glaring lack of originality and lamenting what was seen as a missed opportunity to bring the storied franchise into the 21st century. Bayer's take on Craven's classic essentially recycled the 1984 version's plot line and kill sequences with little to nothing in the way of new material.
While critics saved most of their punches for alternative aspects of production, the 2010 offering was slated for its shoddy effect work and is infamous for possessing one of the more atrocious CGI segments in recent memory: Freddie Krueger crawling out of Nancy Holbrook's bedroom wall.
The scene in the original is legitimately unsettling as the nightmarish slasher's form bulges through the wall above Nancy's sleeping head but the remake's take is disastrously underwhelming.
It is hard to find words that do justice to quite how bad the CGI is when Krueger's head appears, as the animation resembles an offering from somebody who failed a pre-school IT project. Krueger and Nancy are on-screen together but look like they are in two different scenes, as the abysmally integrated effects effortlessly ruin one of the most legendary horror moments in history.
6. Mama
Big things were expected of Andy Muschietti's Mama before it was released in 2013. Based on a short film directed by the Argentine director, the movie had a respectable budget of $15 million and big stars on board from the get go; Academy Award winner Jessica Chastain and Nikolaj Coster-Waldau, who had gained worldwide recognition for his portrayal of Jaime Lannister on HBO global phenomenon Game of Thrones.
Sadly, while the performances of the two unquestionably talented leads were praised, Mama itself was only a moderate success amongst audiences, with fans and critics divided over the convoluted, yet simultaneously clichéd, story and characters. Another aspect of Muschietti's flick that was notably derided was the CGI featured within the supernatural horror.
The titular Mama - for some bizarre, unexplained reason - spends a large portion of her on-screen time twisting and flailing around like some kind of demented inflatable tube man throwing a tantrum, drawing more bemused sniggers than shocked intakes of breath. The facial depiction of Mama herself is particularly dreadful, and the apparition resembles some sort of animated Disney villain as opposed to the supernatural specter that Muschietti and Co. try so hard to bring to life.
It's a legitimate shame, as not withstanding the appalling CGI, Mama's premise and some of the scare mechanics utilized to build suspense within the film are genuinely exceptional. It's a crying shame that the film's woeful visuals make said suspense deflate in a manner reminiscent of somebody puncturing a whoopee cushion.
5. It & It Chapter Two
Andy Muschietti and convincing CGI work would appear to be mutually exclusive.
The Argentine is a talented director - one does not receive the praise and backing of Guillermo Del Toro without good reason - however, it is not unfair to surmise that Muschietti may be in need of alternative contacts within the CGI industry, based on several standout examples in his flagship films.
While the agonizing effects within Mama have already been mentioned, some of the more disastrous visual work within Muschietti's films pop up in his two-part take on Stephen King's It. Muschietti's interpretation of the classic horror story was positively received for the most part; while the first chapter was universally acclaimed, the glowing reviews fell off considerably for the sequel, which was criticized as overly lengthy, convoluted and reliant on the success of the original.
The original's standout ruinous CGI moment actually occurs within the opening sequence; the animation of Pennywise's teeth clamping on to Georgie is an unmitigated catastrophe. Fast forward to the sequel and another aspect of Pennywise's mouth came under fire. This time, disapproval was directed towards the depiction of the nightmarish clown's tongue, in addition to his unconvincing overall appearance.
Factor in a wave of negative reaction to the clearly rushed digital "de-aging" of the original adolescent cast members, and Muschietti's adaptation is saddled with the unfortunate tag of a film whose computer graphics failed to do the franchise's eye-watering budget of more than $100 million justice. This depressing statement gains even more credence so when one considers how incredible Pennywise looks in the scenes relying only on make up.
4. Van Helsing
Van Helsing holds prominent and cherished status in the movies-so-terrible-they're-great category. While the merits of Van Helsing have been debated upon critical reappraisal of the fantasy horror, the film's reputation for possessing some of the worst CGI ever seen remains firmly intact.
Adopting a "throw everything at the wall and something might stick" approach to filmmaking, Van Helsing manages to cram every literary monster you can think of into a 131-minute run for Hugh Jackman to scowl menacingly at/engage in witty repartee with, before firing off bolts from a medieval crossbow-machine gun combination in their direction. It's a ridiculous romp of a film and a thoroughly enjoyable one - unless one happens to be a passionate CGI enthusiast.
Van Helsing was shot on a whopping budget of approximately $165 million, which almost beggars belief when some of the effects within the film look like they cost less than $165. Of particular note are the werewolf sequences, with Jackman's transformation from human to lycanthrope in the film's climactic fight with Dracula - where his skin literally falls off - being notably hard to watch with a straight face. Most viewers had cracked long before, when Van Helsing battles a calamitously animated version of Mr Hyde in the film's introduction.
Think 1990s era arcade game characters bashing each other and you're not too far off the onscreen result. Considering the film essentially revolves around characters that require CGI to do them justice, one wonders what on earth the budget for the latter was spent on.
3. The Thing
John Carpenter's 1982 sci-fi horror bonanza, The Thing, has been lauded as one of the most significant and well made horror films ever produced. This was likely a key factor in studio executives giving the 2011 picture an enviable war chest, but regrettably, both the budget and the soulless manner in which the producers gut the remains of Carpenter's iconic original, makes the CGI on display within the prequel/remake even more unforgivable.
Simply put, the digital efforts within 2011's The Thing are atrocious. It speaks volumes to the quality of the work on offer when fans lament the demise of 1980s-era practical effects in relation to a movie released in the 21st century. The animation is absolutely woeful; there is not one instance across a nearly two-hour stretch of film where a CGI monstrosity looks even vaguely realistic or convincing. One scene in which the creature absorbs an unfortunate victim literally has to been seen with one's own eyes for one to believe that such a sequence featured in a film that cost nearly $40 million.
The Thing even lacks the redemptive qualities often found in horror movies with terrible CGI, combining a measly, hole-riddled plot with the fact that the movie is too proud to embrace the more ridiculous tropes of its premise. Much like Samuel Bayer's transgressions in A Nightmare on Elm Street, the butchering of such a staple of the genre is a cardinal sin amongst die hard fans.
Embellishing a tired remake with sub-par CGI? Just the icing on a particularly abysmal cake.
2. The Ring 2
Deer oh deer.
One of the more infamous uses of disastrously deplorable CGI within a horror movie ambled on to screens when The Ring 2 hit cinemas worldwide in 2005.
The original outing of The Ring was a smash-hit, grossing nearly $250 million worldwide and garnering positive feedback from critics and audiences alike. The wildfire success of the first installment led to a sequel being green-lit and given a massive budget of $50 million.
Which makes the scene featuring the now notorious herd of malevolent deer that terrorize Rachel and Aidan Keller while out on the road even more embarrassing. For starters, producers could have picked anything. It could have been wolves or bears, but deer? It is hard to imagine a less frightening animal.
Particularly when they are depicted on-screen as they are in The Ring 2. The CGI is a laggy, cartoonish mess, with the deer appearing so blurry it is like they were drawn onto whatever screen the unfortunate viewer is watching on with a marker. The sequences where the deer kick things up a notch, pursuing and battering the car, is more reminiscent of a sketch from Looney Tunes as opposed to a terrifying chase. The animation is legitimately so bad that it's hard to suppress one's laughter.
It is simply baffling as to how such a high budget film could stumble on the animation of something as simple as a deer. "Don't stop", Aidan continually mumbles throughout the sequence. "Please make it stop", the agonized audience howl back.
1. The Mummy Returns
While The Mummy and the wave of sequels and spin-offs that followed that original may arguably be classed more within the fantasy sub-genre as opposed to a fully fledged horror franchise, what cannot be questioned is just how bad the CGI is within the second installment: The Mummy Returns, boasting a jaw dropping budget of $100 million.
After (temporarily) dispatching Imhotep, Rick O'Connell and Co. find themselves confronted with an even bigger and badder supernatural villain this time around: the Scorpion King, played by none other than Dwayne Johnson himself. Having spent 5,000 years trapped following a Faustian deal with Anubis, the great warrior is now half human and half scorpion as he takes on Rick and Imhotep in the film's climactic showdown.
One would imagine that the on-screen depiction of such a creature would be a terrifying visage, but the CGI team struggle to even make the Scorpion King resemble Johnson. It's like watching a film with a PlayStation 2 character crudely embedded over the original take. Not that this isn't all thoroughly enjoyable; Johnson roars and flails before being dispatched in a puff of smoke, in a suitably ludicrous conclusion to another fun Ancient Egyptian romp.
The bizarre thing about how bad the CGI work on the Scorpion King is, is that a large portion of the visual effects within The Mummy Returns are excellent; the pygmies and the army of Anubis are absolutely superb considering the film was released back in 2001! That being said, the less said about Imhotep's face appearing in a tidal wave pursuing the airborne group, the better.
Watch Next
Can You Guess The Movie From Its Bad CGI?