10 Horror Movie Characters That Didn't Deserve The Hate
It's about time the world left Wendy Torrance alone.
We've all watched movies where we positively loathed a certain character and just hoped against hope that they'd die by the end. And in the case of the horror genre, that's obviously a very distinct possibility.
But we as viewers do sometimes tend to get carried away with our hatred and lose sight of the fact that characters are still human beings, after all, who would genuinely prefer not to die.
Yet in the annals of horror history, there are a number of widely despised characters who, these days, are best remembered for precisely that - being hated with the fire of a thousand suns.
But if we dig deep into each character and consider who they really are, it seems a bit harsh to express so much indignant hatred towards them.
If you break it down, each of these 10 characters has noted reasons for the way they act, and while some of them might well be a little annoying, their behaviour isn't without explanation.
And so, these 10 horror movie characters are all absolutely "overhated" and deserve a re-evaluation from audiences - to be considered a little more kindly in future...
10. Franklin Hardesty - The Texas Chain Saw Massacre
Any list of overhated horror movie characters must surely include The Texas Chain Saw Massacre's Franklin Hardesty (Paul A. Partain) - the doomed, paraplegic brother of protagonist Sally (Marilyn Burns).
In popular discourse Franklin is simply an annoying a**hole that many were happy to see sliced up by Leatherface (Gunnar Hansen) later in the movie.
And while Franklin is indeed a cantankerous and bitter individual, he nevertheless deserves our sympathy not only for the physical hand he's been dealt - especially in such a horrific scenario - but also how socially clueless the guy is.
Franklin is evidently lacking in even the most basic social tools most of us are born with, which when combined with his disability, the boiling heat, and the group's eventual run-in with a family of cannibalistic killers, makes it tough to resent him too much.
Sure, Franklin's never going to win any Mr. Personality awards, but given that the poor guy just wanted to check that his grandfather's grave hadn't been vandalised and ended up getting cut by a deranged hitchhiker, can you really blame him for being so irascible?
9. Heather - The Blair Witch Project
One common complaint you'll hear about found footage classic The Blair Witch Project is that the main characters are "too annoying," especially the leader of the filmmaker trio, Heather (Heather Donahue).
Hell, actress Heather Donahue even received a Worst Actress Razzie award for her work on the film, which seemed positively ridiculous at the time and only more so today.
Now, Heather isn't supposed to be the most likeable of characters - she's incredibly precious about her film, for one, and perhaps doesn't always express her frustration in the healthiest way, but if you've ever gotten lost with people who aren't really doing much to help, you should be able to relate.
As for Heather being annoying? Fear makes people frantic and skittish, so it seems a little mean to ding her too much for that, especially considering her climactic, terrified monologue into the video camera.
Again, she's not super easy to warm to, but accepting the entirety of her increasingly dire situation, she deserves sympathy rather than hatred.
8. Don Harris - 28 Weeks Later
The way folks talk about 28 Weeks Later's initial protagonist Don (Robert Carlyle), you'd assume he was responsible for unleashing the planet-decimating Rage Virus in the first place.
For many, their hate for Don was cemented in the film's gut-wrenching opening sequence, where his wife Alice (Catherine McCormack) grants refuge to a terrified young boy running from a fleet of the infected.
As the infected arrive and massacre the group of survivors, Don tries to convince Alice to leave the boy to his own devices, but Alice flat-out refuses.
And so, as the infected close in on them, Don decides to abandon his wife, fleeing the overrun cottage and just barely escaping to safety.
To this very day, many continue to brand Don a feckless coward who condemned his own wife to die. And even ignoring the fact that Alice inexplicably survives the attack, what was Don really expected to do in this situation?
From Don's perspective, there was very little he could do to fend off the infected, and staying behind would've most likely resulted in all three of them dying rather than just two.
The fact of the matter is that Don makes audiences uncomfortable because he holds a mirror up to them, reminding them how they'd most likely act in a real version of this scenario, powered by their innate fight-or-flight response.
Don did the only realistic thing he could in order to survive, and we shouldn't hate him for that.
7. Barbara - Night Of The Living Dead
An oldie but a goodie now, as for the last five-plus-decades, horror fans have relished mocking Night of the Living Dead's doomed heroine Barbara (Judith O'Dea).
Barbara admittedly doesn't serve much use throughout the film and is eventually ripped out of the farmhouse by the undead horde without putting up much of a fight.
Many over the years have called her things like "useless" and "pathetic," which rather ignores the fact that Barbara is very clearly suffering from PTSD after witnessing the murder of her brother Johnny (Russell Streiner) at the hands of a zombie at the start of the movie.
Nobody's going to put Barbara on their list of plucky horror movie heroes, for sure - that honour goes instead to Ben (Duane Jones) - but considering the movie ends with everybody dying anyway, it does rather feel like she's judged a little too harshly for her inability to cope with her fraught situation.
Victim blaming much?
6. Shelly Finkelstein - Friday The 13th Part III
A lot of Friday the 13th fans simply cannot abide the goofy shenanigans of Shelly Finkelstein (Larry Zerner) - the schlubby, socially awkward prankster who has a fateful meeting with Jason Voorhees (Richard Brooker) in the series' third movie.
To many, Shelly is nothing more than a detestable, attention-seeking weirdo who typifies the "It's just a prank bro!" mentality so prevalent today - a guy who just doesn't know when to drop the joke.
Yet it's painfully apparent that Shelly is a shy teenager who desperately wants to connect with those around him, and attempts to do so through humour.
We've all met someone who tried to compensate for their crushingly low self-esteem by putting on a show for others, and so Shelly is ultimately a sympathetic dolt who didn't deserve the brutal end that Jason dealt to him with a machete.
Plus, considering the invaluable contribution Shelly inadvertently made to the Friday the 13th mythos - gifting Jason his iconic hockey mask - you shouldn't begrudge his presence too much.
5. Sam Carpenter - Scream (2022)
If social media is any indication, a lot of people really can't stand the protagonist of the fifth Scream film, Sam Carpenter (Melissa Barrera).
And while there are valid complaints about Melissa Barrera's sometimes-flat performance, a lot of the disdain seems to stem from the fact that she's not Sidney Prescott (Neve Campbell), and the filmmakers actively sought to make her quite different.
The big rub, of course, is that Sam is the daughter of one of the original Ghostface killers, Billy Loomis (Skeet Ulrich), and as the end of the movie confirms, she's seemingly inherited his aptitude for brutal murder - albeit, using her skills to slaughter one of the killers, Richie (Jack Quaid).
It's an interesting twist on the typical slasher film protagonist, but all the same, many fans were evidently frustrated that so much of the movie focused on Sam rather than her sister Tara (Jenna Ortega), who they found more likeable.
Regardless, Sam marked an interesting character departure for the series, and depending on whether or not she survives the events of the upcoming Scream VI, is a solid protagonist to take the franchise forward for a new generation, especially with Neve Campbell's future in the series in doubt.
4. Jeff Denlon - Saw III
Saw fans really, really don't like the third film's protagonist, Jeff Denlon (Angus Macfadyen), do they?
Jeff catches a lot of flak for several reasons: first off, he's slow to react when tasked with saving people from traps.
But considering the test subjects all had some involvement in the unjust court trial following his son's accidental death, he shouldn't be judged too harshly. Plus if we're being totally honest, he probably acts closer to how somebody in real life actually would in these situations.
Beyond that, Jeff is also loathed for refusing to forgive Jigsaw (Tobin Bell) in his final test, instead cutting his throat with a circular saw.
This kills Jigsaw and inadvertently triggers a bomb which also kills his wife Lynn (Bahar Soomekh), while resulting in their daughter being locked away within Jigsaw's compound.
But again let's not forget what Jeff has been through: the guy lost his son in a drink driving accident and has quite understandably been stewing in a depressed rage about it ever since.
Did that trauma really make him worthy of being one of Jigsaw's test subjects in the first place? Ehhh.
More than almost any other Saw victim, Jeff is relatable precisely because he's a flawed person who won't let go of his anger in a totally believable, realistic way.
3. Juno Kaplan - The Descent
Neil Marshall's The Descent features one of the most widely-loathed characters in contemporary horror - Juno Kaplan (Natalie Mendoza).
First off, there's no denying that Juno does some pretty awful things in the movie - namely having an affair with protagonist Sarah's (Shauna Macdonald) husband and then leading the group of cavers, including Sarah, to an unknown, more dangerous cave system than the one they had planned.
But for starters, Sarah's husband shoulders 50% of the blame here, and if we're totally honest, Juno is also suffering through grief herself, even if for a forbidden lover.
Secondly, there was no way that Juno could've foreseen they'd end up terrorised by grotesque creatures within the unknown cave system.
Juno is a person who does a bad thing and then has a number of unfortunate incidents lumped in with it - not merely taking the group to a different cave, but also accidentally mortally wounding Beth (Alex Reid), who sneaks up on her without announcing herself.
Juno's absolutely a f**k-up, but a believably flawed person who proves infinitely more interesting than Sarah, and absolutely didn't deserve to be left in the cave to die at the end of the movie. Unlike Sarah, Juno never actively intended to hurt anyone.
2. Wendy Torrance - The Shining
There is simply no horror movie character more unfairly maligned than The Shining's heroine Wendy Torrance (Shelley Duvall).
For the better part of 40 years, there have been those tirelessly committed to the idea that Wendy is a meek, annoying character who didn't "deserve" to live - with some even wishing she'd met the end of husband Jack's (Jack Nicholson) axe.
Even the novel's original author Stephen King - who famously loathes Stanley Kubrick's film adaptation - called Wendy "a screaming dishrag," and reflects the attitude from many viewers that she's simply too "pathetic" to live.
That's without even getting into Shelley Duvall's performance, which received a Razzie nomination at the time, yet was recently revoked due to Kubrick's infamously abusive treatment of Duvall on set.
Yet Duvall's performance isn't even bad at all - it's a phenomenally grounded and devastatingly believable look at the corrosive effects of abuse.
Wendy, certainly not a person of strong personality, is clearly a victim of domestic abuse - whether merely emotional or also physical - and The Shining is ultimately about her journey to reclaim her agency by defending her son Danny (Danny Lloyd) from his now-murderous father.
Appreciating the context of Wendy's existence within the film, it's much tougher to dislike her, regardless of what you make of Duvall's work.
1. Samuel Vanek - The Babadook
Now, yours truly has even written about how gosh-darn annoying The Babadook's child protagonist, six-year-old Samuel (Noah Wiseman), is, but does that mean he's deserving of so much white-hot, full-throated hate?
Director Jennifer Kent makes the ill-behaved Sam loud and obnoxious entirely on purpose, to help the audience sympathise with his exhausted, put-upon mother Amelia (Essie Davis).
The film simply wouldn't work as well as it does without Kent establishing so persuasively that Sam is a stamina-draining force in his mother's life, cemented by the iconic, much-memed line she shouts at her son - "Why can’t you just be normal!?"
While the sheer sensory assault of Sam's bleating might genuinely make you less inclined to watch The Babadook on a regular basis - and honestly, who could blame you? - should we really be directing so much hate towards a young boy who is clearly traumatised and terrified by his experiences?
The kid was involved in a car accident while his mother was in labour with him - an accident which killed his father, no less - and spends the movie being terrorised by the titular entity.
Sam clearly loves his mother no matter that he can sense her resentment of him. And so, as annoying as he undeniably is, maybe we should give him a break?