10 Horror Movie Characters Whose Personalities Suddenly Changed In Sequels
Freddy Krueger became quite the joker in the sequels.
Few movie franchises from any genre - let alone horror - can keep going by simply doing the exact same thing over and over again. At some point, something has to change, and more often than not this ends up being a focal character.
It goes without saying that people change over time - take Luke Skywalker in the Star Wars sequel trilogy, for example. But sometimes filmmakers re-jig a character's personality in such a sudden way that it seems jarring and unconvincing.
And this is perhaps more common in horror than any other genre, where producers and filmmakers appreciate the appeal of fine-tuning their evergreen characters in the pursuit of ongoing box office bucks across eight, nine, or even ten movies.
Whether heroes, villains, or more ambiguous tweeners, these 10 horror movie characters all underwent shocking personality transplants between movies.
Perhaps they suddenly developed a sense of humour, had their IQ conveniently drop 50 points, or simply betrayed their established character from previous films.
In some cases it thoroughly pissed the fanbase off, while in others it was an inspired enough change to basically work. Either way, these personality shifts weren't subtle in the slightest...
10. Leatherface - The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2
The original Texas Chainsaw Massacre depicted its chainsaw-wielding antagonist Leatherface (Gunnar Hansen) as a terrifyingly animalistic, mostly one-dimensional blunt object - a mentally disabled man who kills as instructed to by his family.
But The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 is a considerably campier affair - effectively a not-so-thinly-veiled parody of the original movie which presents Leatherface (now played by Bill Johnson) quite differently.
In short, the sequel gives us the horny Leatherface none of us ever expected.
Here he is hopelessly enamoured with human protagonist Stretch (Caroline Williams) and even thrusts his chainsaw around as a substitute penis, because why the hell not?
Some fans argue that this is simply a case of the emotionally stunted Leatherface going through some belated personal development, but the lovesick puppy depicted here is nevertheless a far cry from the ferocious, no-nonsense Leatherface encountered in the first film.
There's no denying The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2's stature as a cult classic, even if for many who loved the original it turned Leatherface into too much of a joke.
9. Chucky - Child's Play 2
Child's Play gave the world one of the most original and popular horror movie villains of all time - murderous Good Guy doll Chucky (Brad Dourif).
Even with the premise being so inherently ridiculous, Chucky is a serious piece of work in the first film, and once he learns that he needs to transfer his soul into the first human he revealed himself to - six-year-old Andy Barclay (Alex Vincent) - he doesn't waste much time trying to complete the ritual.
Chucky fails, of course, but is resurrected for Child's Play 2, where temporary death has apparently turned him into a bit of an idiot.
Though Chucky again attempts to transfer his soul into Andy's body, the staggering lack of urgency on his part makes no sense at all, routinely diverting to kill people, screw around, and basically do anything but complete the task at hand.
This is all while Chucky is acutely aware of a ticking clock which will keep him trapped in the doll body if he doesn't soon complete the ritual. And alas, at film's end the spell fails because - shocker - Chucky's spent too long as the doll.
Considering how ruthlessly efficient Chucky was in the first film, he's comparatively stupid in the sequel, presumably because Child's Play 2 wouldn't be much of a movie if Chucky just got on with it.
8. Dr. Lawrence Gordon - Saw 3D
Ever since Dr. Lawrence Gordon (Cary Elwes) sawed off his foot and crawled out of Jigsaw's (Tobin Bell) bathroom in the original Saw, fans hoped that he might one day return to the series, perhaps even as a secret apprentice helping Jigsaw.
And for better or worse, fans finally got their wish in the seventh film, Saw 3D.
Gordon appears in a few brief scenes throughout the movie, most notably the outrageous twist ending, where it's revealed that after Gordon escaped Jigsaw's bathroom, Jiggy nursed him back to health and installed him as yet another secret apprentice.
And so, Saw 3D ends with Gordon kidnapping the villainous Detective Hoffman (Costas Mandylor) and locking him in the series' iconic bathroom to die.
While on one hand it delivered the nutty twist fans had been expecting for years, the film did a frankly terrible job of providing a convincing explanation for Gordon's allegiance shift.
Given that the ending reveals that Gordon sewed the key between Michael's (Noam Jenkins) eye in Saw II, we're effectively led to believe that Gordon went from a gibbering wreck terrified for his family to a willing accomplice of Jigsaw within a matter of months.
It doesn't really track, and while you can argue that Gordon was basically brainwashed into becoming Jigsaw's aide, it's still a really tough sell overall.
7. Dr. Samuel Loomis - Halloween 5: The Revenge Of Michael Myers
Dr. Loomis (Donald Pleasence) is as much a part of the Halloween series' DNA as Michael Myers (Nick Castle) or Laurie Strode (Jamie Lee Curtis), and even as the sequels got uniformly terrible, it was fun watching Donald Pleasence's dialled-in performance as the doggedly determined Shape-hunting psychiatrist.
While it's fair to say that Loomis' seemingly never-ending quest to take Michael down drives him to increasingly unhinged places, by the time we reach Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers, he's become a manic parody of his paranoid former self.
Loomis' rather awful treatment of Jamie Lloyd (Danielle Harris) throughout the film - namely using her, a victim of trauma, as bait to lure Michael - is often raised by fans as feeling inconsistent with his established character.
Again, Loomis' descent isn't entirely out of nowhere, yet it's pushed too hard too fast in Halloween 5, where despite Pleasence's solid effort it comes off as unintentionally comical.
Watching Loomis scream at Jamie like a loon makes him feel like a totally different character from the Loomis of Halloween 4. Thankfully the sixth film at least rejigged him back into a calmer rendition of the character who felt more in line with earlier depictions.
6. Cotton Weary - Scream 3
Cotton Weary (Liev Schreiber) was a minor but significant character in the original Scream - a man who was imprisoned for the rape and murder of Sidney's (Neve Campbell) mother Maureen.
But at film's end, we learn that Cotton was in fact innocent, and in Scream 2 he has a much larger role as a principal character who ends up saving the day.
The sequel ends with Cotton killing villain Mrs. Loomis (Laurie Metcalf), making peace with Sidney, and seemingly receiving the fame he'd been craving as a wrongly convicted man.
But amid its many other problems, Scream 3 kicks off by introducing us to a Cotton whose subsequent fame and fortune has gone entirely to his head.
In the film's pre-title sequence, Cotton is now an obnoxious celebrity with his own talk show and a clear taste for every last decadent thing Hollywood has to offer.
While fame does of course change people, often for the worse, in Cotton's case he scarcely feels like the same stoic badass from Scream 2, mutated here into a soft, irritating jackass who is rather effortlessly killed by Ghostface at the end of the sequence.
You can argue that Cotton's likeability was obliterated in order to make his death a little less upsetting to fans, but why? Let us feel the pain, rather than reworking him into a grating stereotype.
5. Pinhead - Hellraiser III: Hell On Earth
The first two Hellraiser movies depict Cenobite leader Pinhead (Doug Bradley) in a more mysterious and ambiguous fashion - a terrifying figure for sure, but one who knew the virtue of cutting a fair deal.
It wasn't until Hellraiser III: Hell on Earth that the character became an out-and-out villain, and fittingly this was also the first film in the series to verbally refer to him as "Pinhead."
With the death of Pinhead's human alter-ego, military officer Elliot Spencer, in Hellraiser II, the third film gives us meaner, more overtly evil Pinhead who ventures on a killing spree and even turns some of his victims into Cenobites.
Separated from the human side of his persona, Pinhead is a card-carrying Bad Guy this time around, much to the protest of franchise creator Clive Barker, who intended for Pinhead to remain dead after Hellraiser II, and Julia Cotton (Clare Higgins) to become the franchise antagonist.
The studio had other ideas, though, wanting to reinvent Pinhead as an unquestionably full-throttle, evil antagonist.
4. Mick Taylor - Wolf Creek 2
As this list has made clear by now, it's not uncommon for horror movie antagonists to have their personalities significantly altered for the sequels for any number of reasons.
And perhaps one of the less-discussed examples is Wolf Creek's psychopathic Australian serial killer Mick Taylor (John Jarratt).
In the first film Mick at least presents an initial facade of charm and likeability - a larger-than-life Aussie Bloke whose sadistic tendencies are suppressed beneath the surface until he decides to act.
But Wolf Creek 2 opted to shed any and all character subtlety, reworking Mick into a more outlandish character who makes considerably less effort - that is, no effort at all - to conceal his ill intent.
Mick basically gets the Freddy Krueger treatment in the sequel - a villain we'll be getting to shortly - the more "realistic" psychopath of the original film replaced with a more humourous, quip-happy maniac.
This is in line with the sequel's decidedly kitschier tone compared to its predecessor, ditching grim seriousness for something more "amusing," even if it results in a blatant character transplant for ol' Mick.
3. Freddy Krueger - A Nightmare On Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors
Perhaps no major horror icon has undergone as blatant a character change as A Nightmare on Elm Street's Freddy Krueger (Robert Englund).
The first two Elm Street films were considerably darker than the rest of the series even with their inherently heightened premise, Krueger being a sadistic serial killer first while buffeted with occasional flecks of savage black comedy.
But starting with A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors, Freddy was not-so-subtly retooled into a campier, more wise-cracking antagonist, cemented by Freddy's infamous quip while killing Jennifer (Penelope Sudrow) - "Welcome to prime time, bitch!"
Dream Warriors, a generally fun and creative film, really only got the ball rolling, as the subsequent sequels increasingly turned Freddy into a goofy, cornball caricature of his former self.
By the time he's eating the souls of teenage boys off of pizzas, it's fair to say that Freddy has strayed far from his original terrifying persona.
Robert Englund still gives it his all of course, but in the pursuit of bigger box office success the producers reworked Freddy into a sillier, less imposing character.
2. Jill Valentine - Resident Evil: Afterlife
The second of Paul W.S. Anderson's Resident Evil movies, Resident Evil: Apocalypse, introduced fan favourite video game character Jill Valentine, as played with appealing moxie by Sienna Guillory.
After this, however, the character inexplicably sat out the third movie, before reappearing at the tail-end of the fourth, Resident Evil: Afterlife.
Yet this was far from the Jill we'd met prior: beyond sporting a drastically different look with dyed blonde hair, a purple sneaking suit, and a mind control device attached to her chest, Jill was now a bad guy, spearheading the impending assault on Alice (Milla Jovovich) and the assembled heroes.
Obviously to anyone familiar with the games it wasn't terribly surprising to see Jill make a sudden, involuntary heel turn, given that this is precisely what she did in the fifth game, but for anyone only watching the movies, it surely felt like a huge, albeit enforced, 180 for the character.
Of course the next movie in the series, Resident Evil: Retribution, eventually had Jill's mind control removed, after which she re-teamed with Alice to battle the undead horde.
1. Ash Williams - Army Of Darkness
To casual fans of the Evil Dead franchise, Ash Williams (Bruce Campbell) is best remembered for being a quip-spitting badass, even though this aspect of his character didn't fully crystallise until the third film, Army of Darkness.
Rather, in the original Evil Dead Ash is a pretty straight-laced reluctant protagonist - a totally ordinary dude who is understandably terrified at the situation unfolding before him.
Evil Dead II gave us a more charismatic, larger-than-life Ash for sure, before Army of Darkness saw him reach the full height of his zany powers, dropping one-liners left and right ("This is my boomstick!") while touting a more arrogant, cynical, and embittered personality.
Hell, even director Sam Raimi himself called out Ash's sudden persona shift on Army of Darkness' DVD commentary, noting that Ash was acting out of character compared to how he was presented in the first two movies.
And yet Army of Darkness is so much damn fun, in large part due to Campbell's magnetic performance, that it's tough to care all that much.