10 Horror Movie Performances That Proved EVERYONE Wrong
Redefining horror and powerhouse acting at the same time.
Legitimately scaring an audience is no easy feat.
While directors may achieve cheap thrills with jump scares and gory special effects, leaving a truly indelible impression on the audience is the hallmark of a good horror film. Images and sounds that jump into a person's mind after they've turned off the lights and are standing alone in the dark, making them hurry up the stairs just that little bit faster.
As with all good films, horror films that live long in the memory require a strong performance from the actors involved. However, in the cutthroat industry that is Hollywood, films are often written off long before their release for any number of reasons.
Maybe the star of this flick's last five films have been complete disasters, a blatant attempt at a cash grab. Maybe the lead character is just utterly unbelievable as a character in a scary film. Maybe the film is even in, God forbid, black and white.
Put aside these misgivings and give these films a chance as they are a case study in proving writers, studios and even the audience dead wrong about what it means to make a great horror.
10. Katie Featherston - Paranormal Activity
Horror movies have to have a big budget, right?
Surely a massive budget is necessary for the special visual effects required in this day and age to properly simulate ghostly activity in order to actually get audiences scared?
How can a horror movie even get off the ground to begin with, without the involvement of a big name star to drum up hype for the picture? One would be wise to take an evening to watch 2007's Paranormal Activity before they get too attached to the aforementioned principles, but they would be advised to keep the lights on.
Filmed on a budget of just $15,000, Paranormal Activity and the performance of unknown actress Katie Featherston utterly redefined the horror genre. Shot in the style of a home movie, the film manages to milk every ounce of tension physically possible out of every scene. The style of shooting meant that everyone who saw the movie suddenly imagined the bone chilling events taking place on camera within their own home, which added a new layer of dread to the genre.
Featherston, a complete unknown at the time of production, masterfully portrays the identically named Katie; a woman haunted by a demon since childhood who ultimately succumbs to the grip of her tormentor.
Paranormal Activity is a case study that highlights that horror films do not require an enormous budget, outrageous special effects or a front news worthy star to scare the living daylights out of audiences.
9. Anthony Perkins - Psycho
1510878There is arguably no more iconic scene in the horror genre than the shower sequence in Alfred Hitchcock's 1960 masterpiece Psycho, which sees Marion Crane stabbed to death in the shower by a terrifying unseen assailant.
But how close did the world come to not even seeing it?
Unbelievably, 'extremely', is the answer.
Executives at Paramount Pictures rejected the initial premise for a film based on Robert Bloch's novel, and even refused to provide legendary director Hitchcock with the necessary funding to commence filming Pyscho. Hitchcock literally bore the financial risk of the picture to get it made, in spite of heavy opposition from the studio.
The rest of course, is history. While contemporary reviews of the film at the time were mixed, Pyscho has gone on to become a immortal outing of the horror genre. Much of that praise rests on the shoulders of Anthony Perkins, who provides an incomparable performance as cross dressing, irreparably disturbed hotel owner Norman Bates.
The terrifying performance of Perkins has established Pyscho as an unquestionable staple of the horror genre in a film that could be argued to be the godfather of all subsequent slasher films. Ultimately, Hitchcock's direction and Perkin's indelible performance as Bates proved the Paramount executives and the whole world wrong.
8. Jane Levy - Evil Dead
When the remake of Evil Dead was announced for 2013, the yawn from horror fans was almost audible.
While the original version of Sam Raimi's franchise had developed a cult following, the franchise had not produced an outing since 1992. There was a sense that the notoriously bloody horror series had seen its heyday come and go. Even original iconic protagonist, Bruce Campbell's Ash Williams, had been confirmed as not returning.
This lack of excitement clearly did not go down well with director Fede Alvarez, who went to work on what was marketed as "The Most Terrifying Film You Will Ever Experience", casting Jane Levy as central protagonist Mia Allen. A recovering drug addict, Mia becomes possessed by a demon as her friends attempt to ween her off drugs in a remote forest cabin.
To say that Levy is terrifying while possessed by the demon is quite possibly the understatement of the century. Levy's face contorts into a hideous demonic mask, rasping out the vilest obscenities as she attempts to murder her closest friends in the most sadistic, gory fashion imaginable.
Levy's stupendous range is further demonstrated in the latter stages of the film where she is free of the possession. Effortlessly transforming from hunter to hunted, she morphs from a snarling nightmarish creature to a traumatized, vulnerable girl willing to do anything to survive the unimaginable evil hunting her.
Outdated? Evil Dead never dies.
7. Robert Pattinson - The Lighthouse
It is 2022, so it is fair to say that many of us who have grown up watching films in color may feel a sense of trepidation when committing to watching a black and white one. According to director Robert Eggers, the black and white form in which the film is shot was to take advantage of the pallet he deemed most effective in conveying the spirit of the film.
This is not hyperbole.
The only sense of trepidation that comes while watching Egger's 2018 psychological horror that is The Lighthouse comes from the carefully maintained air of dread cultivated by Egger's elite direction and unforgettable performances from the two stars of the film.
While Willem Dafoe's performance as maniacal lighthouse keeper Wake is as excellent as audiences have come to expect from the veteran actor, the man who really shines in this bleak taut thriller is Robert Pattinson.
The actor, now established as a serious dramatic performer following critically acclaimed performances in Good Time, Tenet and The Batman, absolutely throws himself into this harrowing performance as a haunted man running away from his past.
Utterly transforming the preconceived notion that contemporary audiences require a color production to feel chills running up their spine, Pattinson's chilling turn as Ephraim and The Lighthouse in general make for absolute must see viewing.
6. Stephen Lang - Don't Breathe
On the surface, the concept of an old blind man hunting for you in his house does not appear particularly scary. He can't see you and even in the unlikely event he does catch you, isn't he too old to do anything other than hit you with his walking stick?
Viewers reading this and nodding along in their head should avoid the house in 2016's Don't Breathe at all costs. Three friends with similar notions, break into a blinded veteran's house following a tipoff about a large amount of cash. What could go wrong?
Quite literally everything, as the friends soon realize that losing his sight has not robbed the veteran of any of his deadly military skill. Played by Stephen Lang in an engrossing performance, the sightless former solider hunts the friends through the house in a deadly game of cat-and-mouse where the slightest sound could mean death.
Eyes are the window to the soul but even without his, Lang's turn as the veteran is spellbinding. The actor arguably conveys more menace than a killer who can see his victims and his almost superhuman hearing ratchets up the dread a few notches every time one of the hunted makes a minute sound. The sequences in the house are nail bitingly relentless and Lang's twisted exploration of the character as the film progresses only serves to horrify the viewer further.
A breathtaking revolutionary film that dispelled the notion that old blind men do not make for worthy horror adversaries.
5. Simon Pegg - Sean Of The Dead
Before Shaun of the Dead hit our screens in 2004; the assumption was that horror movies couldn't be funny.
Simon Pegg blasted that assumption away with his performance as reluctant zombie basher Shaun in what quickly became a cult classic, Shaun of the Dead. The gory, yet utterly hilarious zombie comedy sees waste-of-space loser Shaun finally get his act together in a desperate attempt to win back his girlfriend as the apocalypse unfolds around them.
Shaun of the Dead is absolute comedy gold from start to finish, expertly balancing jump scares with a razor sharp script and a surprisingly emotional, feel good story of personal redemption.
At the centre of this masterpiece is Pegg, who became known to mainstream audiences in an explosion of popularity following the film's release and ultimately led to two further installments in the wildly popular "Cornetto" Trilogy.
Pegg seamlessly flows between a depressing, deadbeat electronics shop worker freshly dumped by his girlfriend to a Mad Max-esque, cricket bat wielding foil to the zombie apocalypse. An absolutely flawless performance which took the stereotype that you can't laugh until your sides ache during a horror film and beat it to death with a pool cue in time to Queen's "Don't Stop Me Now".
4. John Krasinski - A Quiet Place
Does a horror film need dialogue to get pulses racing from fear?
This was the question posed by John Krasinki's groundbreaking horror epic, 2018's A Quiet Place. The film sees a family living in a world overtaken with monstrous creatures possessing impenetrable armor and supernatural hearing, meaning that even a loud footstep can result in immediate horrendous death. Not exactly the film for iconic one liners.
The film utterly dispelled the notion however, that verbal dialogue is required for a horror film to be scary. A Quiet Place is an incredibly tense, danger fraught experience from start to finish.
The deafening silence at moments where the human urge is to scream at the top of one's lungs is indescribably eerie and the performance of the cast who convey an unfathomable amount of raw human emotion without the use of words is breathtaking.
Krasinki's direction and lead performance is absolutely enthralling. Through his facial expressions alone, the actor conveys an absurd range of emotion, perfectly capturing the essence of a desperate father trying to help his family survive this brutal new world while tortured with guilt at the loss of his son.
Even in scenes where the characters use sign language to communicate safely, the manner in which he and the rest of the cast sign, perfectly captures the emotions they are feeling. And all without one word being spoken.
3. Nicholas Cage - Mandy
It is no secret by now, that Cage will appear in quite literally any film that will offer him a contract. Such a cavalier approach to selecting professional projects have resulted in several woefully bad films. Clangers such as nonsensical Season of the Witch and straight to video disaster Running With The Devil bombed financially as well as critically.
However, anyone who would write Academy Award winning Cage off has never seen his phenomenal performances in Leaving Las Vegas and Adaptation; he is blessed with superlative range and expressive ability. Questionable career choices have not robbed Mr Cage of his unique brand of raw and wildly entertaining method acting.
This is exemplified perfectly in 2018's psychedelic horror revenge flick Mandy. Cage plays a grief stricken outsider on an implacable quest for payback against the psychotic cult that murdered his girlfriend, the titular Mandy. He received rave reviews for his performance in the blood soaked revenge romp, which critics argued played to his strengths as one of the most versatile, underrated actors of his generation.
Most importantly, Cage proved that time and all the negative critical response in the world would not stop him from producing performances which served as a showcase of his unquestionable dramatic talent.
2. Bill Skarsgard - It
The announcement that 25 year old Bill Skarsgard would play the role of terrifying monstrous clown Pennywise in the 2017 adaptation of Stephen King's It was met with a healthy dose of skepticism from those familiar with the creature that haunts the sewers of Derry, Maine.
A boyish faced actor like Skarsgard, with no major horror credits to his name, did not give off psychotic spectral clown vibes in the slightest. There were reasonable concerns over whether the Swede would be able to do justice to the latest iteration of horror's most famous petrifying clown.
Those concerns vanished within the first five minutes of Andy Muschietti's triumphant interpretation on the classic story as Pennywise emerged from the sewers. Skarsgard is spectacularly scary from start to finish; his ability to lurch from childishly creepy foreboding figure to full fledged nightmarish sewer monster is an absolute spectacle to behold.
The voice that the Swede bestows on his take on Stephen King's immortal character leaves a particularly haunting impression; coupling an sing song tone with dialogue that positively drips with ominous menace, Skarsgard ensures that audiences will continue to hear his eerily childish voice long after the film has ended.
The lesson to be learnt? Being a smiling, youthful actor does not impede one's ability to play a hellishly disturbing clown.
1. Jack Nicholson - The Shining
The Shining is unanimously agreed upon by critics to be one of the greatest horror films ever made.
Based on Stephen King's novel, Stanley Kubrick's 1980 adaptation sees Jack Torrance, portrayed by Jack Nicholson, slowly lose his grip on his sanity after accepting a job as a caretaker and moving his family into a hotel haunted by ghostly forces. Factor in the minor detail that the previous caretaker murdered his own family before taking his own life and the scene is set for a macabre showdown.
What many do not know however, is that when Kubrick pitched the idea of Nicholson, his first choice for the role of Torrance, to Stephen King, the author instantly rejected the idea out of hand. The author felt that Nicholson's previous performance in One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest meant that audiences would have a pre conceived perception of him as mentally unstable from the get go, damaging the tone of the film.
Kubrick persevered however, and thankfully so. Nicholson produced an unforgettable performance as the recovering alcoholic writer as he descends into absolutely unhinged madness. His immortal "Here's Johnny" line and demonic grin as he manically chops through a bathroom door with a fire axe has been a staple of pop culture since the film debuted.
Not too shabby for someone rejected out of hand by the man who literally wrote the story.
Watch Next
Behind The Scares: The Horror Movie Trivia Quiz