10 Horror Movie Remakes Better Than You Remember

Underrated horror movie remakes you need to see. My Bloody Valentine, Fright Night & more!

Night of the Living Dead 1990
Columbia Pictures

Movie remakes in general get a bad rap, but while there have been plenty of high-profile stinkers, there have been a lot of great ones too, especially in the world of horror.

The likes of Evil Dead and The Ring proved that directors can put their own spin on established material, while others such as The Thing and The Fly are now more well known (and more loved) than the original movies they were based on.

Still, for every success that slips through the cracks to be accepted by fans and critics, so many others are written off before they even have a chance to prove themselves. Thankfully, hindsight is a huge part of horror, and in this genre initially-disregarded flops can later be heralded as unmissable classics not appreciated in their time.

Now, that's not to say the following flicks are on the level of, say, The Exorcist, but they do all hold up much better than their initial reception suggests. They all have something going for them, and absolutely deserve to be revisited now that the dust has had time to settle.

10. The Hills Have Eyes (2006)

The Hills Have Eyes
Fox Searchlight Pictures

Alexandre Aja made a name for himself in the early 2000s, embraced as a member of the New French Extremity movement thanks to his hugely popular slasher film, High Tension.

Unsurprisingly, Hollywood were quick to snap him up, and he was given the chance to remake Wes Craven's The Hills Have Eyes, a fun-going movie about a vacationing family who find themselves under siege by a family of mutated humans.

Now, there's nothing at all about this remake that's subtle. It's absolutely relentless in terms of its violence and Aja goes nuts pushing the gruesome set-pieces as far as they can go.

Hell, the only thing Aja wasn't allowed to do was put a cat in a blender with some milk - a 'kitten shake' he called it - and have one of the mutants drink it. This is the kind of movie and director we're dealing with here.

Still, this first remake is far better crafted than its abysmal sequel, which retroactively gave both of these modern takes a bad name. It's gory, it's thrilling, and more than lives up to the exploitation legacy of its original counterpart.


9. Fright Night (2011)

Colin Farrell Fright Night
Disney

The original Fright Night is 80s cheese through and through. Like so many horror movies of its time, the vampire movie about a teen who's convinced an undead being has moved in next door, plays out kind of like an incredibly gory Saturday morning cartoon.

Thankfully, the 2011 version didn't try to throw out the humour inherent to the original version, and sticks close to the spirit that made it such a cult hit.

It also helps that the remake had the money to splash out on an all-star cast that bring the required charisma to the flick. Compelling performances from Colin Farrell, David Tennant, Christopher Mintz-Plasse, Toni Collette and the late, great Anton Yelchin hold the movie together, and elevate the material at every step.

It sadly didn't set the box office alight in 2011, but doesn't deserve to be thrown in with so many other lifeless remakes from the same period.


8. Night Of The Living Dead (1990)

Night of the Living Dead 1990
Columbia Pictures

One of the biggest criticisms when it comes to horror remakes is that they're 'unnecessary', and 1990's Night of the Living Dead is easily the most unnecessary movie on this list, sticking incredibly close to George A. Romero's seminal work.

However, the few changes it does make are well accomplished. For one, it addresses a clear criticism of the original, that being the character of Barbara. In the 60s version she spends much of the film catatonic and is largely a hindrance, and at worst quite an annoying presence. The Barbara of the remake though benefits from much stronger characterisation, and functions as a more active figure in the plot.

The gore is also upped, thanks in no small part to the lifting of rating restrictions in the decades since the original, and the fact that Tom Savini - the special effects guru who worked on Romero's Dawn and Day sequels - actually helmed this remake.

It's by no means a replacement for (or even an improvement on) the original, but it's a blindside better than some of the other Romero remakes out there.


7. Silent House (2011)

Silent House Elizabeth Olsen
Open Road Films/Universal Pictures

While she's a household name now, back in the early 2010s Elizabeth Olsen was something of an indie darling, starring in well received dramas such as Martha Marcy May Marlene and this underseen horror remake, Silent House.

Released only a year after the Uruguayan original, this American version sticks close to what came before, similarly telling the tale of a woman (Olsen) being hunted around a large family home.

It sounds like a regular home invasion flick, but the twist here is that Silent House plays out in real time, with the filmmaking engineered to make it look like all 87 minutes were captured in one continuous take.

The gimmick does wear a bit thin after a while, but it also makes for some innovative scares, and endears you to Olsen's protagonist as you're with her virtually every step of the way.

There are a few surprises in there too, and it's certainly an experiment worth appreciating.


6. The Crazies (2010)

The Crazies
Overture Films

The second George A. Romero remake on this list, The Crazies was so clearly an attempt to follow in the footsteps of another successful Romero remake, that being Dawn of the Dead '04.

Both stick to the basics of the source material, however throw away the slower, more methodical pace in favour of fast-paced action, more overtly ghoulish monsters and a Hollywood, blockbuster sheen. Hell, both even begin with a haunting late-period Johnny Cash song that ominously sets the tone.

Just because it's not the most original remake doesn't mean it's not enjoyable though. About a local Sheriff (played by the always impressive Timothy Olyphant) who attempts to get his family to safety after a mysterious virus infects his small town, The Crazies is an enjoyable ride brimming with suspense.

The slower, more ambiguous nature of the original is lost here, but the popcorn fun that replaces it is always entertaining.


5. Let Me In (2010)

Let Me In
Paramount Pictures

Matt Reeves now is one of the most respected filmmakers in Hollywood. In charge of the upcoming The Batman and helming the last two Planet of the Apes movies, he's become a reliable blockbuster filmmaker, but it would be wrong to overlook the horror movies on which he honed his craft.

His most popular effort from that period is of course Cloverfield, but his remake of Let The Right One In, titled this time around as Let Me in, was also a smart, effective horror.

The movie, all about a young lad befriending a couple-hundred year-old vampire trapped in the body of a teenager, came only a few years after the original's soaring success, and thus was written off as being redundant.

And in a way, that's not untrue. Hollywood has a bad habit of remaking foreign-language movies seemingly only in order to present them to an audience without subtitles, rather than to give its own take on a story, but that doesn't make Let Me In any less impressive in its own right.

Reeves and co. made some alterations to the story as well as adapting elements from the book that were dropped for the original film version, and it all contributes to a vampire thriller that's far more original than it's given credit for.


4. My Bloody Valentine 3D (2009)

My Bloody Valentine 3D
Lionsgate

My Bloody Valentine 3D is a weird anomaly when it comes to remakes.

This reimagining was lumped in with a bunch of desperate, gimmicky 3D movies that were all the rage at the time, but it is way more effective than the likes of The Final Destination, which released the same year.

This movie was built from the ground up to maximise its B-movie, eyes-popping-out-the-screen potential and it absolutely leaves nothing on the table. The gore on display is frankly outrageous, with the kills revelling in an absurd amount of blood and viscera. In an era where mainstream releases were opting for PG-13 ratings, MBV 3D almost feels like a swan song for an entire era of button-pushing slashers.

Admittedly, the story itself is your standard fare. A miner involved in an accident goes on a killing spree in a town, only for a copycat to arise years later. There's a predictable twist thrown in for good measure, but it's all delivered with a sense of confidence and flair cheaper efforts simply can't replicate.

If you're after gory, popcorn fun, you could do much worse than this.


3. House Of Wax (2005)

House of Wax Paris Hilton
Warner Bros.

House of Wax is dumb. House of Wax is a movie where you get to see Paris Hilton impaled with a big spike and the man from Supernatural get his face peeled off. And, honestly, it's all the better for it.

The original Vincent Price horror would never really translate to the genre landscape of the early 2000s. That film, while a total hoot, is a complete camp-fest made first and foremost to exploit a 3D gimmick popular at the time.

It would have always needed extensive adapting to be taken seriously by an audience, and thankfully this remake only takes the barebones of the original story and grafts them onto something far nastier but just as fun.

Instead of Price's burned museum owner acting as the villain, here it's two twins who are kidnapping victims and turning them into the latest attractions of the titular building which, living up to its name fully, is made ENTIRELY out of wax.

It's a little slow in the first half, and it doesn't make a lick of sense, but it's a huge amount of fun if you can turn your brain off at the door.


2. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003)

Texas Chainsaw Massacre
New Line cinema

At this point, there have been more bad Texas Chainsaw Massacre movies than good ones. With the original being one of the most influential horrors of all time, everything that followed - both sequel and remake - has been held up to a ridiculously high standard, with most written off as cheap, ineffective hack jobs further driving the franchise into the ground.

While that's not entirely incorrect, the first remake, simply titled The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, is treated much more harshly than it deserves.

It's far louder, crasser and bloodier than the original, but it never mistakes bigger for being better. It pays homage to the feel of the original, especially in its grimy cinematography and effective found-footage documentary opening and ending, but it doesn't just rehash beats or lean on nostalgia in a way future instalments are guilty of.

The cast is solid as well, with lead Jessica Biel and Eric Balfour in particular giving the film a strong emotional grounding.

Andrew Bryniarski is impossibly intimidating as Leatherface too, who's more of a hulking brute here than he's ever been. The physical performance conveys so much aggression and hostility, while the human mask itself is one of the more frightening iterations in the series.

It's an effective slasher, and a highlight in the whole franchise.


1. Maniac (2012)

Maniac 2012
IFC Midnight

Maniac is built around an interesting gimmick: what if a whole slasher movie was shot from the POV of the killer? It's a trope that was everywhere in the early days of the sub-genre, so it's a surprise that it took so long to become the basis of an entire horror movie.

Thankfully, the director here makes it work, grounding the audience in the psyche of a disturbed serial killer.

Elijah Wood always fits too comfortably in killer roles - whether it's in Maniac or something like Sin City - and the former Frodo actor brings an unassuming sinister aura to the villain here, even if you only see brief flashes of his reflection.

He also nails the more vulnerable parts of his titular maniac, offering us quick glimpses of the shred of humanity left in him that ultimately goes a long way in elevating what could have been a one-dimensional slasher flick.

It's not perfect by any means, but it boasts more interesting ideas than most remakes, and in many ways adds depth and creativity to the original.


Watch Next


The Scariest Horror Movie Quiz You Need To Try!

Hellbound Hellraiser II 20
Cinemarque Entertainment BV

1. Exactly How Many Pins Are There In Pinhead's Head?

Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.