10 Horror Movie Trailers That Lied to Everybody
We're still waiting to see the movies these trailers sold to us.
How a movie is advertised can be more important than the movie itself. The best film imaginable can bomb critically and financially if it's presented in the wrong way. For this reason, the promotions shouldn't just be exciting but ideally also accurate.
Of course, some trailers and TV spots have a habit of plugging the feature in question in a deceptive way. Although we've looked at 10 Lies Told In Recent Movie Trailers previously, now it's time to specifically delve into the realm of horror. The genre tends to have the opposite problem, spoiling everything imaginable in an attempt to get something to click with viewers.
However, a marketing team will occasionally try a different tactic, representing a horror picture in a way that doesn't resemble the finished product. This can be done by lying about the genre, over-selling a character's role in the story, or highlighting a money shot that ends up on the cutting room floor.
Just to be clear, this type of misdirection isn't always bad. The trailers for Scream, The Cabin in the Woods, and Barbarian were fairly formulaic, so it was refreshing when each of these films went in wild and unpredictable directions.
Having said that, some moviegoers may have felt conned by the trailers for the following films since they sold something very different than what we ultimately got.
10. Pride And Prejudice And Zombies
Turning Pride and Prejudice into a supernatural action-based parody should never work, at least in theory. And yet, Seth Grahame-Smith's novel Pride and Prejudice and Zombies novel was a bonafide success.
What made the book work so well was how it successfully captured the spirit of Jane Austen's love story and 19th-century romantic literature in general despite containing a bunch of flesh-eating ghouls. Seven years after its publication, a film adaptation was released.
The British promotions for this movie did a fine job at showcasing Pride and Prejudice and Zombies as a dark comedy that was still entrenched in Austen's work.
However, the same cannot be said about the international trailer, which made Grahame-Smith's adaptation look like an apocalypse thriller.
The US teaser focuses almost entirely on the action, showcasing our heroines hacking, blasting, and kung fu kicking the savage revenants. Yes, these elements feature in the movie, but not as prominently as the trailer indicated.
British viewers got what they expected, but the rest of the world was left confused by the fact Pride and Prejudice and Zombies wasn't more traditional.
9. The Monkey
In The Monkey, two brothers find their lives changed forever after they discover a drum-playing monkey toy. Every time the windup trinket completes a drum solo, somebody suffers a grisly death.
Even though Osgood Perkins' OTT horror sounds silly, the trailer gives off a very sinister vibe. As hard as it is to believe, the titular fiend is more terrifying than the monkey from Toy Story 3.
Considering it's directed by the man behind Longlegs, produced by James Wan, and adapted from Stephen King's short story, The Monkey has all the signs of a full-blown horror.
However, it's made clear during the film's prologue that The Monkey is a horror-comedy. Though the deaths are brutal, it's obvious they're played for laughs.
The Monkey looks like it's going to be similar to Wan's other work, like Saw or Malignant, but it's closer in tone with campy slashers like Happy Death Day or The Babysitter. The end result is thoroughly enjoyable, but the goofy tone may throw some people off purely because they weren't ready for it.
8. Crimson Peak
Based on Pan's Labyrinth, The Devil's Backbone, and Cabinet of Curiosities, it's obvious Guillermo del Toro has a knack for blending horror with fairytales, gothicism, folklore, and dark fantasy. As such, it was presumed Crimson Peak would follow this formula.
The beloved director's ninth feature centres around Edith, an heiress who moves into a crumbling estate with her new husband and his sister. When Edith starts being haunted by a scarlet spectre, she unearths a dark secret about her partner.
Not only does Crimson Peak have all the hallmarks of a ghost story, the trailer plays up every horror trope imaginable (including a few gratuitous spoilers). This notion is hammered in further since the trailer contains a quote from Stephen King, calling the film "terrifying".
But Crimson Peak is an odd entry in our horror list since it's technically not a horror. In fact, it barely classifies as a ghost story, playing out more like a mystery fantasy romance drama that happens to have a ghost in it.
Even though Crimson Peak is a beautiful love letter to early gothic stories, it wasn't sold that way.
7. Predators
Look, you shouldn't be too harsh on movie shots that only appear in the trailer. As the Marvel Cinematic Universe has proven, trailer-only sequences are effective at keeping plot points secret. On top of that, a change in direction during post-production may lead to several trailer shots being axed.
With that said, Predators' promotions rubbed people the wrong way since there was one image that teased a very different movie than what we saw.
Nimrod Antal's sci-fi thriller revolves around a bunch of killers who are forced to fight a group of predator aliens on their homeworld. Although previous instalments usually had the protagonist squaring off against a singular enemy, Predators cranked it up a few notches as the ensemble was supposedly waging war against a whole planet of Preds.
Based on one shot of Adrian Brody's character being targeted by 15 laser sights, it was assumed the antiheroes would battle an army of brutal beasties.
Instead, the ensemble never fights more than a couple of dreadlocked brutes at once.
Producer Robert Rodriguez confessed that the multi-laser shot was created purely for the trailer, which was manipulative and disingenuous.
6. Monsters
Gareth Edwards' theatrical debut Monsters was a critical success and went on to earn eight times its budget. Since Monsters harboured the DNA of kaiju movies, it's easy to see why the director was later chosen to kickstart the MonsterVerse and direct multiple Godzilla films.
And yet, many people were disappointed by Monsters due to its false advertising. With a title like "Monsters," it was safe to assume the sci-fi horror would prominently feature, well, monsters. With aliens glimpsed at in the trailers, that indicated these towering beasts would play a major role in the film.
Instead, the story centres around a photojournalist who's escorting his employer's daughter out of a quarantined zone. Yes, the extra-terrestrials are there, but they mostly serve as an unseen menace, appearing so infrequently it's difficult to remember what they look like.
To be fair, making the terrifying behemoths a background threat was a great way to maintain focus on the human characters, keeping the story gritty and relatable. Nevertheless, this decision was polarising since Monsters was advertised as a kaiju-like creature feature.
5. Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber Of Fleet Street
Despite the fact musicals have been a significant film genre since the dawn of cinema, they're not everybody's cup of tea. Unless Disney is involved, movie musicals often struggle to turn a profit.
In the last few years, studios have combatted this problem by downplaying that the films they're promoting are actually musicals. Although recent adaptations of Mean Girls and The Colour Purple got in trouble for relying on this tactic, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street pulled the same stunt way back in 2007.
Though Tim Burton's gothic slasher is based on Stephen Sondheim's stage musical, it was unclear whether it would follow suit since some trailers contained no songs. Also, Burton isn't known for sticking with the source material, so it was debatable whether this iteration was a musical after watching the trailer.
And there wasn't just some singing. Literally the first line of Sweeney Todd is sung, immediately establishing what kind of movie this is.
Anyone who went to see Sweeney Todd under the belief it was a straightforward horror found themselves befuddled when the titular hairdresser burst into song while hacking and slashing his victims.
4. Red Eye
In Wes Craven's underrated gem Red Eye, hotel manager Lisa Reisert is making her way through the airport when she has a chance encounter with a charming stranger, Jackson Ripner. When Lisa learns the two of them are sitting next to each other on the flight, it looks like they're fated to be together.
However, Jackson quickly reveals he's a terrorist who intends to assassinate a US Deputy Secretary. He orchestrated events to sit with Lisa so she can use her connections to move the Secretary to a hotel room where it'll be easier to target him. If Lisa doesn't comply, Jackson vows to have her father murdered.
Although Red Eye is a psychological thriller, the teaser suggested otherwise. In one particular shot, Jackson's eye flashes red, indicating he's some sort of demonic entity.
Jackson is eventually revealed to be a nasty piece of work, but there's nothing paranormal about him.
Fortunately, the final Red Eye trailer made the premise clearer. Unfortunately, anyone who saw Red Eye without watching that particular trailer got a very different experience than what they expected.
3. Jennifer's Body
After Megan Fox became a Hollywood star, every studio wanted to capitalise on her sex appeal - a strategy that backfired big time with Jennifer's Body.
Karyn Kusama's 2009 feature revolves around vapid cheerleader Jennifer, played by the Transformers star, who's turned into a flesh-craving succubus. Based on the marketing, Jennifer's Body was an exploitative male-gaze slasher, especially since the trailer opens with the titular character swimming in the nude.
However, instead of getting braindead horror, Jennifer's Body was a smart satire that creatively explored and dissected female empowerment, sexual harassment, adolescent angst, and male toxicity. Even though it's difficult to juggle so many subgenres and ideas, the dark comedy pulled it off without a hitch.
Unfortunately, it's difficult to sell a satirical supernatural feminist horror-comedy. As a result, Jennifer's Body was advertised as teen schlock to appeal to a broader demographic, which led to a heavy backlash.
Luckily, the misunderstood gem has been critically re-evaluated over the years, causing it to develop a cult following. Reception towards Jennifer's Body was initially harsh, but it's a little justified considering how misrepresented it was.
2. Black Christmas
1974's Black Christmas is often considered the prototype for the slasher subgenre. Due to its influence on horror, it's surprising how long it took for Bob Clark's classic to get remade. And when a reimagining of the iconic horror was announced, nobody expected it to measure up to the original.
Sadly, those concerns were spot on, as Glen Morgan's Black Christmas is derivative, plothole-riddled, forgettable, lazy, and scare-free. However, this pointless reboot is best known for its shamelessly inaccurate trailers and TV spots.
Unhappy with how the production turned out, the producers shot several trailer sequences behind the director's back that were never intended to appear in the film itself. Although this practice isn't uncommon, Black Christmas went overboard, adding an actress called Jillian Murray in the trailer... even though she wasn't in the movie!
These inserted shots included Jillian's non-existent character finding a girl under a frozen pond, Dana being sucked into a thresher, Melissa dropping an F-bomb while cocking a shotgun, and the killer crawling on the roof with a hatchet.
Unsurprisingly, Glen Morgan disowned this remake and disparaged the producers for falsely promoting his work without his consent.
1. Alien 3
As this list proves, there are plenty of trailers that have become infamous for telling porkies. However, a more accurate term for such promotions is "misleading". Trailers can be deceptive, but it's not like they fibbed about the film's premise, right?
That's exactly what Alien 3's teaser trailer did.
This cursed threequel had one of the most troubled productions in cinematic history, going through half a dozen directors and countless scripts. Hoping to maintain public interest in the delayed property, a teaser was rushed out a year before release.
That footage was under a minute long but it got people talking since it supposedly confirmed Alien 3 would see the titular critters finally make their way to Earth.
Although William Gibson's early script had the Xenomorph crash-landing on our planet, this particular story never materialised. Instead, the Alien 3 we got involved Ripley landing on a prison-like moon that was not Earth.
Even though this reviled clip came out decades ago, Alien fans are still pissed they never got to see Ripley kicking Xenomorph butt on our world.