10 Horror Movies Monsters That Just DIDN'T Work
Fighting an evil snowman or a demon lamp sounds stupid... and it is.
Even though the Predator looks amazing, its initial appearance was ridiculous, forcing the crew to cobble together a new design in mid-production. This last-minute change-up demonstrates how even the best in the business may struggle to craft a monster that's striking, unique, and above all, terrifying.
However, there are many reasons why movie monsters don't always turn out the way they're supposed to. If the filmmakers can't agree on what the creature should look like, it could end up with a generic design. Even if the special effects team has the perfect blueprint in mind, things could be compromised by money or technology. After all, the crew can't bring their vision to life if they're working with subpar prosthetics or a shoddy costume.
If an animatronic is being used, it could be difficult to operate, making the monster's movements janky or stilted. If the beast is brought to life with CGI, the visuals need to be 100%, or the audience isn't going to buy it for a second.
Although the following ten movie monsters come in all shapes and sizes, none of them were as scary as they were supposed to be.
10. The Offspring - Alien: Romulus
Ridley Scott's Prometheus and Alien: Covenant were intended to usher in a new era for the Alien franchise. Unfortunately, the masses weren't onboard with the changes to the xenomorph lore. (Also, the revelation that humanity was created by an ancient race called the Engineers felt disconnected from the sci-fi brand.)
With that said, Fede Alvarez's Alien: Romulus seemed promising based on the promotions and early buzz. Sure, the sidequel had a couple of problems (especially uncanny valley Ian Holm), but it felt like a worthy instalment in the Alien saga. Until the last ten minutes...
Just when it seems like things are winding down, heroine Rain finds herself being hunted by an alien-xenomorph hybrid called the Offspring.
Though it's not uncommon for an Alien movie to have an additional climax, the Offspring doesn't gel with the tone. It's unmistakably modelled off an Engineer, so it feels like Ridley Scott (who was producer) crowbarred the hybrid in to force a connection with Prometheus.
Although the Offspring itself is unnerving, Alien: Romulus was functioning just fine without it, making this creature feel unnecessary.
9. Jack-O - Jack-O
Adorning households with jack-o-lanterns has been a time-honoured custom during Halloween for over a century. As a result, it was only a matter of time before a Halloween slasher centred around a grinning pumpkin monster came to fruition.
Which brings us to 1995's Jack-O. In this supernatural slice-a-thon, the townsfolk of Oakmoor Crossing find themselves being tormented by a pumpkinhead scarecrow wielding a scythe.
Sadly, Jack-O is an absolute mess, thanks to its sluggish pacing, dodgy action, and shoddy dialogue. It also contains a terribly distracting cameo from John Carradine - who'd been dead seven years before this film was released - as a wizard.
Of course, Jack-O's biggest problem is the titular villain. Thanks to the atrocious lighting, it's sometimes difficult to tell that Jack-O has a pumpkinhead. Due to his generic design and blank expression, there's nothing intimidating about this paranormal foe. Heck, the jack-o-lanterns from the Goosebumps series were scarier, and that was a kids' show.
The kills are equally uncreative, with the camera regularly cutting away before Jack-O plunges his scythe into his victims.
Though viewers probably weren't expecting a fruit-based monster to be nerve-wracking, this was embarrassing to watch.
8. The Spiders - The Giant Spider Invasion
Movies like Them! popularised the idea of humanity fighting off gigantic creepy-crawlies. In creature features like these, miniatures, puppets, and trick photography are used to make the tiny insects look enormous.
However, a different approach was taken for The Giant Spider Invasion. To bring the colossal arachnids to life, spider costumes were placed over Volkswagen Beetles, which were then driven around by stunt drivers. The limbs of the spiders were operated from within the vehicle to give the impression that it's crawling around.
Now, it goes without saying that this thinking-outside-the-box idea didn't work out. Rather than looking like gargantuan monsters, the spiders resemble fluffy parade floats. Sometimes, the spiders are moving around when none of their legs are touching the ground, so it's obvious there's an automobile inside piloting them.
The spider design itself can be cool (especially their creepy mandibles), but it's impossible to take it seriously watching these monsters driving after their prey.
Though the puppetry from old-school B-movies like Them! may be dated by today's standards, it's a work of art compared to The Giant Spider Invasion's laughable effects.
7. The Darkness - House On Haunted Hill (1999)
In the House on Haunted Hill remake, eccentric millionaire Stephen Price invites a group of strangers to an abandoned psychiatric hospital, promising a fortune to anyone who survives until morning. However, the group soon realise the residence harbours a paranormal force called the Darkness, which intends to trap their souls in the building forever.
Rather than attacking the guests outright, the Darkness creates hallucinations, warps reality, or possesses people to do its bidding. Not only does this approach make the Darkness more mysterious, but it also builds anticipation for its inevitable reveal.
Sure enough, the Darkness emerges from the shadows during the third act and directly pursues the ensemble. The Darkness resembles a swirling cloud of faces, each representing the mistreated victims of the psychiatric hospital. Despite sounding like a disturbing idea, the Darkness is more akin to an ink blot than a living nightmare. The lighting and compositing don’t blend convincingly with the live-action footage, making the special effects stand out in a distracting way.
Although it's commendable how the visual effects crew tried to give the Darkness a unique design, the end result isn't great.
6. Jack Frost - Jack Frost
In this Christmas-themed slasher, serial killer Jack Frost is on his way to be executed when he's accidentally transformed into a mutant snowman. (Oscar-worthy writing right there.)
With a premise like that, nobody should be expecting Jack Frost to be anything special. And yet, Jack Frost isn't even entertainingly awful. The snowman suit is bulky and immobile, making Jack seem more like a person in a costume than a convincing creature, especially when the suit's seams are visible. One-liners are said with no passion, and the wacky kills are let down by sloppy editing and cinematography.
Not only that, the poster and front cover for the film are blatantly misleading, since the design for Jack Frost is far more menacing on those. If Jack Frost looked like his poster counterpart, the movie would've been more entertaining. Instead, we got a snowman that's less believable than the one Michael Keaton played in the other Jack Frost flick.
Rather than learning from the experience, the poster for the equally awful sequel, Jack Frost 2: Revenge of the Mutant Killer Snowman, shows two designs for the sentient snowman, both of which bear no resemblance to the one in the film.
5. Mama - Mama
In Andy Muschietti's folk horror Mama, two girls are abandoned in the forest by their unstable father, where they're fostered by a spirit called Mama. When the girls are found and adopted by their uncle, Mama becomes consumed with jealousy, urging her to haunt the family.
As can be observed in the IT franchise, Muschietti has a talent for focusing on slow-burn tension and atmosphere. Although there are jump scares, they're executed well, thanks to Muschietti's clever filmmaking techniques.
For the most part, the camera cuts away just as Mama is about to be seen, perpetuating her mystique. Mama is so unsettling that she would've functioned as an overarching villain even if she never physically appeared. So, when Mama makes her presence known in the third act, the intrigue and mystery behind her instantly dissolves, since she comes across as a generic monster.
On top of that, the CGI for Mama is so poor that it feels like the special effects team ran out of time working on her. Even though the final confrontation is meant to be haunting, Mama's incomplete rendering is deeply distracting.
4. Godmonster - Godmonster Of Indian Flats
When a beast has earned the label "godmonster," you expect it to look epic. But the titular fiend from Godmonster of Indian Flats is anything but.
In this horror western, a doctor incubates a mutated sheep embryo, causing it to transform into a man-eating abomination.
Despite the fact that sheep aren't particularly scary, this idea could work. For example, the murderous farm animals in Black Sheep are genuinely unsettling at times, even though that's a horror-comedy.
Having said that, the godmonster is beyond ridiculous. The costume itself is so cheap, it's clearly made from foam rubber. Rather than looking like a creature that leaves people quaking in their boots, the godmonster looks like a guy wearing a deteriorating Snuffleupagus outfit.
Instead of using subtle angles or the cover of darkness to hide the fact that the godmonster is a man in a costume, most of the scenes are in broad daylight.
It's also funny how this creature repeatedly sneaks up on its victims on a clear blue sky despite being 8ft tall.
What's worse is the godmonster doesn't appear in its final form for over an hour, making its reveal more anticlimactic.
3. The Beast Of Gevaudan - Brotherhood Of The Wolf
Brotherhood of the Wolf follows Gregoire the knight, who's tasked with investigating the Beast of Gevaudan, an enigmatic creature that's slaughtered French civilians.
For the most part, the Beast of Gevaudan is built up masterfully. In the first 90 minutes, it's never seen clearly, with the camera instead lingering on the reaction of the Beast's horrified victims just as they meet their maker. There are shots of the Beast hurling its prey into the air with astounding force, indicating its unmatched strength and ferocity.
However, Gregoire ultimately learns the Beast isn't a supernatural creature at all, but a lion wearing elaborate spiked armour. Not only that, a secret society has conditioned the wild cat to slaughter their enemies so that they can seize control of the country.
Although it could be disappointing to learn the Beast of Gevaudan isn't a beast at all, that's not the issue. The issue is the Beast... looks terrible. Even though its design is creative, the Beast never looks like it's there due to the unconvincing CGI.
Using CGI was a baffling decision considering it's established that the Beast is an ordinary animal. If the filmmakers used an animatronic, a real lion, or a mix of the two, the Beast could've been legitimately soul-stirring.
2. The Brass Floor Lamp - Amityville 4: The Evil Escapes
In this pointless sequel, Alice Leacock is gifted with a brass floor lamp, oblivious that a demon from the haunted Amityville house resides within.
The lamp has a gaggle of superpowers, including mind control, hallucinations, telekinesis, and infecting people with Tetanus (which is weirdly specific). It can also control electrical appliances in the house, turning on the garbage disposal or melting the phone to terrorise the Leacocks.
Not only is Amityville 4's entire concept preposterous, but it's made funnier by the fact that everybody takes it seriously. A priest speaks about the malevolent lamp with such sincerity, it's like he's talking about the Devil himself. A demon face sometimes appears on the bulb, which is likely to trigger unintentional giggling. Although it's meant to be upsetting when the lamp cooks the family's parrot in a toaster oven, viewers will be trying to figure out how the evil ornament stuffed the poor bird into the mini-cooker in the first place.
When something creepy happens, it's usually accompanied by a close-up of the wicked bulb with eerie music playing in the background. Every single time this happens, it's hard to believe Amityville 4: The Evil Escapes isn't a parody.
1. The Mangler - The Dark
The reason why a movie monster doesn't work normally boils down to a simple reason, like it had a dumb design or a cheap costume.
However, the backstory behind The Dark's big bad is more fascinating than anything in the film itself. Co-directed by Bud Cardos and (shockingly) Tobe Hooper, the sci-fi thriller follows Detective Derek Rydall, who's investigating a serial killer called the Mangler. In the original script, the Mangler was an abused man who snapped when his house burned down, driving him to murder.
Just as shooting was finishing, the producers urged the filmmakers to turn the Mangler into an extra-terrestrial, hoping to capitalise on the sci-fi craze at the time. There was little money for reshoots, so Cardos improvised by having the Mangler shoot lasers from his eyes and use telekinesis in the final scene.
In hindsight, it's obvious this plot development was last-minute, since the entire movie plays out like a realistic drama, only to reveal in the 11th hour that the supposedly grounded villain was from space. And just to add further confusion, the Mangler looks like a zombie.
Basically, the reason why this monster doesn't work is because there's no reason why the Mangler was a monster to begin with.