10 Horror Movies Where An Actor Plays Multiple Characters

Who needs Mike Myers when you've got Mia Goth?!

X Mia Goth
A24

Acting is not an easy job. The stars of the big screen might make it look like second nature, but no matter which way you slice it, it's not easy to create a whole different person and embody them - that's why not everybody can do it. All of that goes double for horror.

While horror actors might not get the same amount of appreciation as others, it's safe to say that they are put through the wringer, as they need to be believable in life or death (mostly death) situations. Bringing a person like that to life is insanely tough, so imagine having to do it multiple times in the same movie!

Multi-roling is hardly a new phenomenon, as it's been happening in cinema for decades, with the likes of Mike Myers and Eddie Murphy making bank off of it. Still, while those guys worked hard to make you laugh, these actors brought terror on multiple fronts.

For the record, this list will NOT include actors playing characters with multiple-personality disorder. In order to qualify, they have to play completely different people with separate bodies. So, apologies for the James McAvoy fans, as Split won't be appearing here.

10. Peter Jackson - Bad Taste

Peter Jackson In Bad Taste
WingNut Films

Peter Jackson is not known for being an actor, but he does have a surprisingly decent resume of on-screen roles, including cameos in The Lord of the Rings, Hot Fuzz, King Kong, The Lovely Bones and more. But, back in his early days, he played full-on parts in his movies.

To be fair, this was mostly an effort to save money on actors, but it did give way to some amazing characters, with his funniest and most varied performance coming from his first feature-length film, Bad Taste.

In this wild and abrasive flick, Jackson takes on the roles of Derek and Robert. Derek is an agent for the Astro Investigation and Defence Service, and yes, that does spell what you think it does. This character starts as a meek fella, but after falling off a cliff thanks to an alien, his brain gets mashed, and he turns into a violent, alien-killing madman.

What's the other role he plays, you ask? Well, it's the alien that threw Derek off the cliff in the first place. Yes, this alien in a human-skin suit is a flesh-devouring extraterrestrial that even fights with Derek, which was possible thanks to precise editing tricks.

How can you tell the difference between them? Well, Derek is clean-shaven with glasses, and Robert has a beard. Who needs big-budget make-up with a trick like that?


9. Jeremy Irons - Dead Ringers

Dead Ringers 1988
20th Century Fox

Jeremy Irons is an incredibly well-respected British actor, so a challenge like playing two characters in one movie is the kind of thing he probably revels in. Sprinkle that with the talented directing hand of David Cronenberg, and you've got yourself a horror movie with some real weight to it.

Dead Ringers is a deeply visceral and compelling character study of a pair of twins known as the Mantles. These two (played by Jeremy Irons, of course) are gynaecologists, and they have a careful balance between them. On the one hand, you've got Elliott, the more confident of the two. He's suave, nihilistic and great with the ladies. On the other hand is Beverly, the shy, awkward, introverted twin.

This pair have a little operation together, wherein Elliott seduces women, and once he tires of them, Beverly steps in to fill his place. But, after Beverly falls in love with their latest conquest, things get complicated.

Irons embodies both characters so distinctively that it really feels like you're watching twins on the screen. As the story gets darker and more thematic, it becomes clear just how much work he put into the roles.


8. Winona Ryder - Bram Stoker's Dracula

Winona Ryder In Bram Stoker S Dracula
Colombia Pictures

The story of Dracula is a horrifying tale about blood-sucking monsters of the night. But, it's also the story of eternal love and reincarnation (aww). That's why this dual performance is as important as it is, even if one of the two roles is dead before the end of the prologue.

Bram Stoker's Dracula is considered one of the best depictions of the classic villain ever put to screen, and a big part of that is the solid ensemble cast. The performances from Gary Oldman, Anthony Hopkins, not Keanu Reeves and Winona Ryder helped bring this classic gothic tale to life, and Ryder worked double time.

The Stranger Things star took on the roles of Mina Murray (the fiancé to Reeves' Johnathan Harker) and Elisabeta (Dracula's deceased wife). Elisabeta appeared briefly in the film's intro and tragically took her life, which became the catalyst for Dracula becoming a vampire in the first place.

Later, Mina appeared, and it was clear from Dracula's love for her and Winona's presence that she was a reincarnation of the titular character's beloved spouse. This turned the horror flick into a twisted sort of immortal love story, following these two unfortunate lovers, reunited after decades.


7. Cheech Marin - From Dusk Till Dawn

From Dusk Till Dawn Cheech Marin
Miramax

The secret is well and truly out on From Dusk Till Dawn, as the movie's hidden vampire twist is common knowledge now. But, one little secret gem that a few people didn't clock onto was the recurring face of a certain beloved stoner.

Cheech Marin is a frequent collaborator with Robert Rodriquez, having appeared in Desperado/Once Upon A Time In Mexico, the Spy Kids movies, Machette and Planet Terror. Still, Rodriquez really got his money's worth in this action horror flick, as Cheech played not one, not two, but three roles. Damn!

He appears early in the film as a border crossing guard and as the gangster Carlos in the film's final scenes. While these roles were decent, it was his bombastic turn as the Titty Twister's doorman - Chet Pussy - that really made an impact. The highlight of this was his wild speech about all the kinds of *ahem* lady parts they've got on the inside.

This trio of roles is a hilarious blink and you'll miss it type, as his smaller parts are so much more reserved than Chet that you'd be forgiven not for spotting them in the first place.


6. Mark Soper - Blood Rage

Tedd And Todd Simmons Blood Rage
Film Limited

It's time to talk about twins again, but these two are far less nuanced than the Mantles in Dead Ringers.

You can likely tell from the title that this is the kind of gore-infested slasher flick that will give you a good time if you're looking for some schlock-filled 80s horror. It's a wild experience that manages to be shocking and pretty funny, all at the same time.

What's it about, you ask? Well, the film follows the twins' Terry and Todd Simmons - both played by Mark Soper. Terry decapitated a teenager when they were boys and framed Todd, who was sent to a psychiatric hospital. Now, ten years later, it's Thanksgiving time, and Terry's murderous impulses are brewing again, which is only made worse by the fact that Todd has escaped the hospital.

The movie is full of goofy mishaps akin to a Shakespeare play (albeit with less class), as the pair are confused for one another and misunderstandings ensue. But, the distinction between the twins does make it evident to the audience who is who. To be fair, one is a murderer, and the other only wants to clear his name, so it's not too hard to follow.


5. Jake Gyllenhaal - Enemy

jake gyllenhaal enemy
Pathe

Jake Gyllenhaal is a widely respected actor with a bunch of critically revered performances to his name. His turns in flicks like Nightcrawler, Brokeback Mountain, Donnie Darko or Nocturnal Animals are often brought up when deciding his best performances. However, one showing that deserves way more attention than it gets is his dual role in Dennis Villeneuve's Enemy.

In this film, he plays the quiet and meek Adam, a college professor who shockingly spots a man who looks 100% like him in a movie. That doppelganger is Anthony, an actor who is a completely different specimen. He's bold, confident and aggressive; everything Adam is not. The film follows as their lives intertwine and tensions grow.

Gyllenhaal is great in this movie, as he infuses each character with nuances and subtle mannerisms that make them feel completely different but shockingly similar at the same time. This plays into the themes of the film, as the obtuse, metaphorical storytelling leaves you wondering what exactly their identical looks imply.

He deserves way more praise for this flick, as each performance is impressive enough on its own but mind-blowing when counteracting the other.


4. Lindsay Lohan - I Know Who Killed Me

i know who killed me
Sony Pictures

Ah, Lindsay Lohan, it would feel weird to make a list about actors double rolling without including her. Sure, the film that made her famous for playing two characters (The Parent Trap) is about as far removed from a horror movie as you can get. But, thankfully (?), she has delved back into doubling up.

I Know Who Killed Me is a baffling thriller that sees Lohan take on the joint roles of Aubrey Fleming and Dakota Moss. The former is a sweet and innocent girl who is kidnapped by a serial killer, and the latter is a despondent stripper who is found by a roadside and presumed to be the missing Aubrey.

Naturally, the movie tries hard to make you question whether there really are two girls or if Dakota is simply an imaginary biproduct of Aubrey's trauma. But, it lacks the subtlety and nuance to be as complex as that.

Truth be told, I Know You Killed Me is not a good film. It's derivative, poorly constructed, lacking in thrills, and Lohan does not warrant even one role, let alone two. Still, the novelty of seeing this star re-tread her past as a duo-actor in something as adult as this has a morbidly amusing hue to it.


3. Mia Goth - X

mia goth X
Little Lamb

Most people would be over the moon at getting the chance to play the final girl in a horror movie. Equally, others would kill to take on the part of the main villain. Well, for Ti West's X, Mia Goth said, "hold my beer", as she went and played BOTH!

X is a twisted flick that will quickly give you vibes of classic slashers like The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, and rightly so. It's a beautiful homage to the genre whilst still being an impressive experience in itself, and one of its biggest selling points is Mia Goth's career-making turn as both Maxine "Max" Minx and Pearl.

Max is a young adult film star looking for fame, but what she gets is a fight for her life after she and the crew of her latest movie are relentlessly attacked by their elderly hosts, one of which is the terrifying Pearl.

Casting Goth in both roles was thematically important, according to West, as the characters are reflections of each other. One is young and liberated in her sexuality; the other is older and pines for passion after years of repression. In many ways, Pearl is an embodiment of Max's future, which is why this casting was right on the money.


2. Tilda Swinton - Suspiria

Suspiria Tilda Swinton
Amazon

The 2018 remake of the classic Italian horror movie Suspiria has no right to be as good as it is. It's a movie about witches controlling a dance company, is two and a half hours long and lacks all of the colours that made the original so beloved. Despite that, it's an excellent horror experience, and a major contributing factor to that is the acting powerhouse Tilda Swinton playing three separate parts.

Saying that Swinton sinks into her roles here would be an understatement, as she utterly vanishes into two of them. The first and most obvious character is Madame Blanc, a dance choreographer who takes the lead under her wing. She's stern and frightening but surprisingly gentle for a witch.

Then, there's the far less gentle Mother Helena Markos, the deformed and vile witch who owns the company. Swinton is buried under a barrage of prosthetics here, but her performance powers through, with her creepy voice complementing the incredible make-up work.

Finally comes Dr Josef Klemperer, a tortured 82-year-old psychotherapist. Again, his German accent and incredible make-up leave you completely fooled about Swinton's involvement. This lie is even further cemented by the fact that the part is credited to a fake actor known as Lutz Ebersdorf. Maybe that counts as a fourth role too?


1. Everyone - Us

Us movie
MonkeyPaw

Well, this movie was an utterly obvious shoo-in for the top spot, as the entire gimmick of the flick has every actor pulling double duty.

For anyone unfamiliar with Jordan Peele's Us (if that's even possible), the film centres on a family who find themselves relentlessly stalked by their exact doubles. Thus, it's safe to say that there's a lot of multi-roling going on here.

Here's a list of a few of the actors who play multiple roles in this film, Lupita Nyong'o, Winston Duke, Evan Alex, Shahadi Wright Joseph, Elizabeth Moss, Anna Diop, Tim Heidecker and the list goes on.

The movie's villains are known as the Tethered, and they are (spoiler alert) genetic clones of the American populace that lack souls, turning them into hollow husks. Naturally, the need to have multiple versions of each character means the actors need to play two roles, one regular person and one Tethered.

These evil doppelgangers are given subtle visual changes to differentiate them, but don't worry; they also wear red jumpsuits. The movie is a full-on tour de force in using the same actors twice.


Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!